The Remediation of the Visual

The current generation of computer users is becoming such a visual generation of students that they even watch music.  Music videos, television, websites, and magazines are all examples of how we are becoming incredibly more reliant on pictures rather than text.  Jay David Bolter in “Chapter Four: The Breakout of the Visual” of Writing Space: Computers, Hypertext, and the Remediation of Print demonstrates how our culture is becoming more reliant on images rather than print.  However, Bolter fails to recognize the reliance on visual did not start with this current generation.

Homo Sapiens began ‘writing’ with cave drawings that communicated information through pictures.

Retrieved from: McNeill Slides 2007-2008

A more sophisticated style of ‘writing’ evolved into hieroglyphics, like the writing created by the Ancient Egyptians, which were a series of images that acted as a communication tool.  

Retrieved from:  Egyptian Figures: Hieroglyphics II Art Print

After hieroglyphics came manuscripts with their elaborate scrolls and images.

Retrieved from: Manuscripts

With the invention of the printing press, the image began to fade into text.  In today’s world, with music videos, television, websites, and magazines, there is a restoration of the visual element that had been present in human life for centuries. Therefore, the breakout of the visual is not a novel phenomenon but rather something that was replaced for a few hundred years and now reinstated.

Bolter, oddly, neglects to analyze his theory in the context of remediation in his book titled Writing Space: Computers, Hypertext, and the Remediation of Print. There is a small subheading that deals with remediation on page 68, but Bolter does not go into much detail about the remediation of the visual; he certainly does not explore the previous uses of visuals explained above.  The visuals in webpages are a remediation of the earlier uses of visuals, like the cave drawings.  They are also, as Bolter fails to note, often remediation of real life. This fact is evident when you look at websites like Google Maps where maps and ground level pictures help us find our way.  Older versions of Google Maps were remediations of the paper map,

Retrieved from: Google Maps

but now they illustrate our real life situation, as many technological developers are striving to do.

Retrieved from: Google Maps

(see also Pranav Mistry: The thrilling potential of Sixth Sense technology)

There is no longer a remediation of objects, there is a remediation of our real life. The most extreme example of this is the video game Second Life where some people question if the murder of an avatar should be tried in court.  Although Bolter tries to discuss the remediation of web design, he fails to mention the remediation of visuals of past visuals and real life.

Although there was little activity with visual modes of representation after the advent of the printing press, there was still experimentation of the visual, in print.  Tristram Shandy by Lawrence Sterne is full of images that Sterne uses to draw attention to in his novel.

Retrieved from: Visual Editions

Visual poems were also part of this ‘dark age’ of visual; where the poems could not even be read aloud because they were purely for the eyes as a visual.

Retrieved from: Poetry Ireland

As Bolter also points out, ekphrasis is also a version of visual.  J.R.R. Tolkien does this in his novel The Lord of the Rings where he describes the settings in sensual detail so that the reader can imagine the places of Frodo’s adventures.  Although it seems as though this new visual breakout is new, there is evidence of our reliance on visuals since the beginning of history.

This begs the question as to our mode of learning.  Is this a natural evolution of how we learn or a learned behavior?  Since there is so much evidence, that is to say the cave drawings, hieroglyphics, music videos, television, websites, and magazines to represent our world visually, the logical conclusion would be that the breakout of the visual is a movement towards a natural method of communicating information.

If we are to adopt the visual method of communication, what does this mean for our current mode of communication?  It seems on first assessment that pictures are vague in comparison with words, hence the saying “a picture is worth a thousand words.” Or as Kress points out “The still existing common sense is that meaning in language is clear and reliable by contrast, with image for instance, which, in that same commonsense, is not solid or clear” (Kress, 2005, p.8).  However, if you begin to analyze words and their meanings, there is evidence that words are also vague. For example, in reading a poem/song written by Canadian poet Leonard Cohen there are a variety of different meanings depending on your frame of references; the 2010 Vancouver Olympic announcer pronounced Halleluiah as a song of peace where I would term it a song of violent love.

Leonard Cohen’s Halleluiah

Also, it would be difficult to understand the meaning of an “albatross around your neck” if you have never read the Rime of the Ancient Mariner.

The Rime of the Ancient Mariner

This idea that ‘words are worth a thousand words’ are apparent in the proliferation of literary classes – classes that study words.  There are multitudes of ways of saying a particular sentence that can mean a variety of things, the passive voice being a prime example.  “The boy was murdered” in comparison to “The girl murdered the boy.” Hence, the mode of text is not necessarily more definite than the communication mode of images.  It seems as though the combination of text and visuals is the most effective method of communication, as many cell phone texters have discovered 😀

The reliance on visual information of this generation, as well as past ones, suggests humans learn well with visual information. Therefore, the movement towards a virtual real world would create an optimal learning environment.  Bolter fails to notice the remediation of images throughout history as well as the real life remediation in the virtual world, but does notice the movement towards pictures as communication. This suggests, according to Kress, that this mode of communication is not “solid or clear” (Kress, 2005, p.8); however on further examination the meanings of words can be as arbitrary as some pictures.  This means the method of communication that will display an intended meaning the clearest is the combination of text and images, as many web designers demonstrate.

References

Bolter, J. D. (2001). Writing Space: Computers, Hypertext, and the Remediation of Print. Second Edition. Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Kress, G. (2005). “Gains and Losses: New Forms of Text, Knowledge, and Learning.” Computers and Composition: 22, pp. 5-22.

This entry was posted in Commentary 3 and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to The Remediation of the Visual

  1. Cathy Jung says:

    Hi,

    I also wrote my commentary 3 on Bolter’s chapter 4. It was interesting to see the path you took with your commentary. In looking at our two commentaries, one noticeable difference that stands out is your use of visual images. I found this interesting and it made me think of the following quote from Bolter (2001) “words no longer seem to carry conviction without the reappearance as a picture of the imagery that was latent in them” (p. 54).

    Cathy

Leave a Reply