
As everyone has heard already, the second last Harry Potter movie is out now. I walked into the theatre somewhat ambivalently. I hadn’t encountered anything Harry Potter or fantasy related for a couple years now. All my textbooks and readings dealt with real-life social and political issues.
But watching the movie reminded me why Harry Potter, and fantasy, is so important to us.
First, there certainly is that “escape with us” aspect (also happens to be Cineplex’s motto). This can be taken to the extreme: like those people who were triggered into committing suicide or developing depression over the fact that the world in Avatar was only fantasy.
But there can still be a healthy attachment to the unreal, I think. Having this unreal world nurtures imagination and creativity, and encourages us to look at things differently.
More importantly though, it is a means for conveying messages. In a fantasy land, you don’t take the physical seriously. Yet the messages transcend the physical differences between the fantasy world and our own. Meaning is not contingent upon the physical.
What I’m saying is that, Harry Potter brought to our generation what the ancient stories, like the Bible, often could not. The common discourse around these holy texts is about physical nature, not meaning. People ridicule prophets, and place velocirapter heads on portraits of Jesus because they fancy themselves witty for critiquing the literal translations of the Bible. On the other side of the debate, people actually reject evolution as an evil conspiracy. In other words, the issues have become physical in nature: did evolution actually occur, did Jesus actually come alive again? (admittedly, the Christian case has always a little bit more contingent on physical world because of the whole resurrection ordeal, but there are some Christians who have a metaphorical interpretation.)
But with Harry Potter, no one is arguing that Harry Potter actually exists. Alright, so some of us were a little disappointed when we didn’t get a letter inviting us to Hogwarts at age 11, but I think it’s safe to say that most people don’t focus on the fantasy vs. reality issue, but the messages. The books taught us values of courage, friendship, love, and goodness. They helped us grapple with questions of death, jealousy, fear, and sacrifice. Harry Potter has left an indelible stain on my generation.
I often joke about how, when my generation grows up to be in power a few decades from now, we will be living our childhood dreams: inventing broomsticks, playing real quidditch, inventing a Sorting Hat. But what I really wonder is if the messages in the books will remain with us. I think if the churches, synagogues, temples and mosques want to affect people’s way of life, they should focus less on the physical details, and more on the meaning. Fantasy can effectively convey messages because everyone knows it isn’t reality. But when you, religion, are focused on proving the physical aspects, the meanings are lost. It all becomes a question of science, and quite frankly, you’re not good at it.
Wait, how did I start talking about Harry Potter and up talking about religion? Typical of me!