Euthanasia: Gentle death, or killing performed in the animal’s best interests.
Reasons Why Euthanasia is Performed:
- to end suffering of an old or ill animal
- if animal is deemed unadoptable (e.g. aggressive)
- if animal has been in the shelter for an extended time (i.e. to increase turnover rate)
- if financial constraints are too great to continue caring for the animal
Two Types of Animal Shelter:
- Traditional Shelter – performs euthanasia for all or most of the reasons outlined above
- No-kill Shelter – only euthanizes animals when necessary, i.e. to end suffering of very old or ill animal
The Procedure:
- usually performed by shelter workers, but some shelters transfer animals to a veterinarian for euthanasia
- inhalant anaesthetics are suitable to euthanize small dogs, but for large dogs should only be used as sedation before injectable ananesthetic administered for euthanasia
- common drugs include pentobarbital sodium, carbon monoxide,and injectable T-61
The Controversy:
- killing healthy animals for the sake of making space for another animal might not be ethically considered “euthanasia”
- approximately 29.5% of dogs taken into traditional shelters are euthanized by the shelter–huge numbers of dogs!
- in 2015 alone, the BC SPCA rehomed 2,706 dogs–if the BC SPCA euthanized animals to promote turnover rate, maybe this number would be much lower!
- average length of stay in a traditional shelter is 1/8 the length of stay in a no-kill shelter
Essentially, is it ethical to euthanize a healthy dog just because no one has adopted it?