Module 1 – Unit 2 Discussion Posting
I would have to say that the 7 Principles spoke louder to me in this case simply because I haven’t yet been in a position to really analyze whether a form of educational technology should be used.
That said, although all of the 7 principles are clearly essential to successful undergraduate education, when it comes to learning at a distance & conducting an entire degree online, the two that bubble to the top as most critical for me are:
1. Encourages contact between faculty & students
4. Gives prompt feedback.
In my experience learning online, one of the biggest factors in stoking the motivational flame is contact & feeling of connection with the students but more importantly, the teacher. There is something to be said when you feel ‘noticed’ as a student. No one likes to feel as if they are floating in cyberspace on their own with no support. As Chickering & Gamson say, “faculty concern helps students get through rough times and keep on working”. Students want to feel like their questions are honoured and their opinions valued; that they are being seen and heard.
This is directly connected to principle #4 – Gives Prompt Feedback. Yes, this speaks to grades but at a deeper level it covers questions, voicing of uncertainty, discussion postings/threads, and new lines of thinking. Chickering & Gameson explain that, “…students need to reflect on what they have learned, what they still need to know, and how to assess themselves.” I’ve been a part of many online courses where it takes weeks for teachers to respond to questions or concerns (if they do) and part of discussion groups where analysis by other students is weak an a teacher is really needed to help augment or challenge a line of thinking in order for cognitive development to take place. This leads to students dropping out or completing courses with the same developmental ability as when they started. What’s the point in that?
In the end, there are multiple reasons for why this might be true including
a) a teacher being over booked
b) not being invested/not caring
…but perhaps there are steps that must be taken in terms of outlining expectations for teachers’ participation to ensure students have the best chance to survive and thrive in the online environment. Maybe this exists…and maybe it doesn’t – but it would be nice if it was communicated to the students.