Hello everyone! For Assignment 1:3 I have decided to answer question seven, which I will put right here for your convenience: “At the beginning of this lesson I pointed to the idea that technological advances in communication tools have been part of the impetus to rethink the divisive and hierarchical categorizing of literature and orality, and suggested that this is happening for a number of reasons. I’d like you to consider two aspects of digital literature: 1) social media tools that enable widespread publication, without publishers, and 2) Hypertext, which is the name for the text that lies beyond the text you are reading, until you click. How do you think these capabilities might be impacting literature and story?”
Storytelling and literature are inherently cultural elements. Through oral and written stories, the world of a civilization can be painted over thousands of years. As Chamberlin mentions in his book, If This is Your Land, Where are Your Stories: Finding Common Ground, colonizers often treat the indigenous people of whatever land they’re colonizing as “others.” Chamberlin defines others as “people who don’t write things down like we do, or speak like we do, or look like we do, or behave like we do,” (13). With this context in mind, it is easy to see how Indigenous stories, literature, and language have slowly been exiled from the mainstream dialects and literature of Canada. While wrong, this is the unfortunate reality of the colonization of Indigenous people in our country. Where the narrative begins to shift is with technology and the digital age. Before I dive into how technology helps keep cultures alive and mainstream, I want to mention why technology and social media are effective tools in doing so.
In the Tedx Talk by Ashley Fell entitled “Why storytelling is so powerful in the digital era,” Fell delves into the world of visual storytelling. In the modern era, our attention spans are shockingly short. Fell estimates that the average young person’s attention span is three minutes and fifty-five seconds (5:54). Because of this, we digest information at a quick pace before we move onto the next thing. This is the perfect attention span for scrolling through Instagram or Facebook. Fell goes on to talk about what an engaging story encompasses by using the “four I’s:” Interest, Instruct, Involve, Inspire. Social media is a fantastic way to garner interest from a wide range of people; most social media platforms offer image uploads that are a surefire way to grab an audience’s attention. Once that attention is grabbed, it is up to the author of the post to fulfill the other three I’s through their caption, geolocation, tags, hashtags, or any other means in which they can do so. If successfully utilized, social media can be the ultimate storytelling platform that works with, rather than against, our short attention spans.
While social media is an efficient storytelling vessel, what does this have to do with “other” groups that have had their cultural stories pushed outside of society’s view? Many Indigenous groups have kept their traditions alive, but because many Canadians have a subconscious view of Indigenous people and their culture as “other,” these traditions are often cast to the shadows. With social media as a free and fairly accessible platform to all, these traditions now have a new way to be brought to light. As a an example of this, I suggest you take a quick look at the article by HuffPost about Indigenous influencers in Canada. This article contains many examples of Indigenous people in Canada that are actively sharing stories and traditions from their cultures.
Without the need for a publisher or a professional publishing platform, these stories are able to be shared to the billions of people around the world in a way that they couldn’t have been before. Social media has given groups labeled as “other” a newfound voice to educate, enlighten, and take up space in a world that has cast them aside for hundreds of years.
Works Cited
Chamberlin, Edward. If This is Your Land, Where are Your Stories? Finding Common Ground. AA. Knopf. Toronto. 2003. Print.
Tedx Talks. “Why storytelling is so powerful in the digital era.” Online video clip. Youtube, 13 July 2017. Web. 16 Jan 2020.
Zamon, Rebecca. “Indigenous Canadians on Instagram Celebrate Their Culture Beautifully.” HuffPost, 21 June 2017. Web. 16 Jan 2020.
SarahAfful
January 21, 2020 — 9:47 am
Hi Chase! Great job. I have been struggling to use social media as a platform for true change and you explored in your post, the attention span of our generation and beyond is very short. I get the sense from your very positive conclusion, that the digital age may be a fundamental way to change the plight of Indigenous peoples in Canada. Do you believe that social media will bring about true and lasting fundamental change and healing for those that have faced attempted and real genocide in our country? May the writer of the Huffington post article be getting ahead of herself? What do you think?
ChaseThomson
January 23, 2020 — 10:10 pm
Hi Sarah! Thank you for the insightful question. I absolutely do not believe that social media will be enough to bring about true and lasting change for Indigenous people and how they are treated in Canada. I think that fundamental rights and government policies need to be put in place to reconcile for what Indigenous people have been going through for a long time. However, I do believe that social media is a positive way for the cultures of marginalized communities to be put into the mainstream. I believe this is an absolutely positive aspect of social media that should be acknowledged but not confused with the reconciliation that needs to happen at a Government level.
hauenj
January 21, 2020 — 1:47 pm
Hi Chase, Jack Hauen here. I really enjoyed your post. I’m wondering though — do you think social media is 100% a good thing for marginalized stories?
I totally agree that these platforms have provided an opportunity for “othered” voices to gain exposure. But my mind immediately went to the harrassment that many of my female, trans or racialized friends face when they share their opinions online. I think I can count the number of death threats I’ve received on one hand, and I work as a journalist. But it’s wildly common for anyone who doesn’t look like me (a cis, white straight guy).
I’m also curious whether you think platforms are doing enough to make sure that people who share their stories are protected from this hate. Again, my mind goes to Twitter, where you can basically get away with being a Nazi if you don’t swear at anyone or say certain words.
Let me know what you think!
-Jack
ChaseThomson
January 23, 2020 — 10:12 pm
Hi Jack! You raised some good points. I am a proud gay man myself and I have faced some harsh harassment online in my lifetime. I think it comes with the territory, to be honest. However, I think that if someone is proud of their culture and is able to bring it to the mainstream in a way that they couldn’t before, the haters don’t matter. You have to develop a tough skin online, as we all know, so I believe that these Indigenous content creators have been able to build those tough skins and proudly share their cultures with the world.
I believe Instagram has added a new feature where users can block certain words from being commented on their page. So for example, I could block the word “loser” from every being commented. I think this is a positive step in the right direction, but I do believe Facebook and Twitter could be doing more to prevent trolls.
grace owens
January 21, 2020 — 6:14 pm
Hi Chase!
Great to chat with you again! I thought your article this week was very insightful and I liked the positivity towards hopes for change you portrayed! Since this week is about how we communicate, I was wondering how you might think that social media affects the oral roots of Indigenous culture? Do you think that social media allows Aboriginal influencers to truly capture the essence of their culture or do you think that some of this tradition is lost to the technological void?
Social media and the integrity of what is being shared is something I always question in our digital age and I guess overall I am just curious if you think that social media could be the be all end all for vast storytelling and cultural acceptance or if it just another small gateway that’s bringing a little light to the traditional First Nations culture?
Have a great week!
Grace
ChaseThomson
January 23, 2020 — 10:14 pm
Hi Grace! Good to connect with you as well. I think integrity on social media is up to the individual user. Based on what I could see, and I know that is surface level, these Indigenous content creators are doing their best to share their cultures. Obviously, you don’t get as much as you would from partaking or witnessing these cultural acts in person, but it is a way to bring Indigenous culture to the mainstream in a way that wasn’t possible before. I think that is a very positive thing!
ChinoAngeloRodriguez
January 21, 2020 — 11:13 pm
Hi Chase,
I like how you pointed out how Indigenous culture was been exiled from the mainstream in Canada over time by settlers forcing Indigenous peoples to assimilate into Western society. It reminded me of a video (link below) I saw recently, about how Jacksonville, Florida could have been the world’s film capital instead of Hollywood. The video talks about Norman Studios in the early 1920s in Jacksonville, which was one of the first to produce films catering to and starring African-Americans. Unfortunately, these films were out of the mainstream while films that portrayed black characters in blackface were being produced in Hollywood.
This came into mind while I was reading your blog and I could not help but think how unfortunate it is that Western society has shut out traditions, stories, and literature of “other” cultures. I look forward to working with you in critically analyzing colonizing themes in Canadian literature over the term, cheers!
Chino
Video (Norman Studios at 5:20): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CipkJ_LQZZA
Norman Studios: http://normanstudios.org/
ChaseThomson
March 19, 2020 — 8:53 pm
Hi Chino,
I set my blog to auto-approve all comments and for some reason yours has just been sitting in the queue for so long! I’m so sorry that I haven’t seen it until now!! Not at all my intention, but I’m glad I finally found it.
Very interesting link, thank you for sharing!
Sorry again!
NargizaAlimova
January 21, 2020 — 11:45 pm
Hi Chase! I just want to comment on how I really do like your links, they added a lot to your blog, as I did click and watched through the Tedx Talk and found it really interesting! What I have to add to your post is on the topic of interest. You went over how our attention spans are short and it’s very easy for us to lose interest. When you mention how social media might be a great way for other cultures such as aboriginal culture, that have been suppressed to be represented, I’m wondering if you believe social media platforms are the best way? Social media while providing great forms of representation and identification is often filled with messages that get lost, commodification, and repression of certain ideas over others, such as face toning. Do you believe that social media can overcome the shallow and very clickbait-style it is to properly represent a message, that might be digested for the aesthetic but then scrolled passed? Or do you think it doesn’t have to be a holistic representation and it’s more on the idea of having a talking platform? In this case, who do you think would interested and what kind of message must one send? When I think of using the internet to explore or understand cultures, social media is generally not one of the main resources I would use. But do you believe it’s a good way to gather interest?
ChaseThomson
January 29, 2020 — 10:49 am
Hi Nargiza! Thank you for the insightful comment. I love all of these tough questions, but that’s why it’s taken me awhile to reply because I really want to digest them.
I think you are right in a sense that social media can be a very shallow place, however, I think that I can also be a powerful one. For example, NikkieTutorials coming out as trans almost 12 years into her career last week was a very powerful moment. Not an indigenous example, but still an example of a minority using social media to be seen and heard.
I think it all has to do with intent, which I’ve said a few times on this thread already. I think a lot of people have shallow intent on socials, but a lot of people really want to communicate their cultures and who they are. While someone interested in learning may not go to social media for information, it is a way to get that information to the masses—to the people who didn’t actively WANT to learn about new cultures but should; perhaps it’s making the waters of social media just a little bit deeper.
AlexandraSinclair
January 22, 2020 — 12:53 am
Hi Chase!
I really enjoyed reading how you answered question 7 of Assignment 1:3! Social media is particularly interesting to me as I study marketing here at UBC and have held a variety of digital marketing positions. Additionally, our generation is extremely consumed with the digital world and looks to it for validation whether that be professional or personal.
I have a question for you, do you think that the accessibility to ‘scrolling’ through stories and digital information will slowly deteriorate our ability to focus and apply our minds to more in depth or drawn out work? I sometimes worry that the immense accessibility that we have to quick and readily available information will allow us to develop a reliance on technology for information.
Thank you for sharing your insights on this topic and I hope you have a fantastic week!
ChaseThomson
January 29, 2020 — 10:52 am
Hello! Thank you for the comment!
I think that reliance on technology is a huge problem, especially for students. On the flip side, I think it can lead to some beautiful things. I think the link I provided in my original post is an example that social media can be used for sharing and inspiring people about your beliefs and cultures.
It’s all about a balance between living online and living in the real world. If you understand that balance, I think social media does more good than harm.
BrendaDruhall
January 22, 2020 — 12:40 pm
Hi Chase,
What a fantastic post! The contextual implications that your hyperlinks added to your post were insightful and gave me a lot to think about–especially the Huffpost Canada link. Real life voices and experiences are important contributions to any conversation, and the fact that social media is a free form of publication and communication that indigenous people can use as a vessel is important. I suppose the next question is, do you think that social media might also be a hindrance in both fully expressing traditions, and that people who aren’t indigenous can more easily culturally appropriate?
Great post, can’t wait to see more.
ChaseThomson
January 29, 2020 — 10:56 am
Hello! Thank you for the tough question—I have been considering different angles.
I think no matter what there is a risk to posting your culture online. While someone may not get the entire grasp on your cultural traditions, I think it is still better for them to be exposed to part of it. Social media allows for this exposure that people may not get otherwise.
As for the issue of appropriation, I think that just depends on the individual. People with beliefs that it isn’t a thing will continue to appropriate cultures regardless of social media, and I think the fear of them doing so shouldn’t be a reason to hide and shelter beautiful cultural traditions from the mainstream.