Feb 16 2011
Watch The Romantics?
The Good: The supporting cast! Malin Akerman and Adam Brody are pretty hilarious. Dianna Agron is adorable as Anna Paquin’s little sister and their sisterly chemistry is actually quite believable. Candice Bergen as Anna Paquin and Dianna Agron’s overbearing mom was perfect. The chemistry between the supporting cast actually made this film quite bearable. It distracted me from how much I didn’t really like Josh Duhamel, Katie Holmes, or Anna Paquin.
The Bad: The use of indie music. Okay, we get it. It’s an indie flick and you’re trying to use indie music to make it seem cool and hipster. It’s fucking lame. It kinda seemed like it was trying too hard to be 500 Days of Summer and it just wasn’t even close.
The Ugly: Josh Duhamel, Katie Holmes, and Anna Paquin. The movie is supposed to be centered around the love triangle between these three, but somehow it also manages to make me hate them. Josh Duhamel is not believable as a college literature graduate who can quote Shelley and while it’s clear that he still loves Katie Holmes’ character continues to stay with Anna Paquin even though the chemistry is clearly lacking. Katie Holmes just can’t seem to get out of that “girl next door” character. Whether people liked or hated you as Joey Potter, you’ve got to move on, girl! Take a different role and stop playing these characters that allow you to shoot puppy dog eyes at the camera in an attempt to make the audience feel pity for you. It’s not working for you anymore! Anna Paquin, who I love in True Blood, was just not likeable at ALL in this movie. Maybe it was how her character was written. I can probably see that. But as a supposed lead, she didn’t get enough screen time. Had the audience gotten to know her better we may have understood why Josh Duhamel was constantly at odds with trying to pick between her and Katie Holmes. He states that it’s because of her practicality, but if we don’t see that translated in her actions, then we don’t really believe it.
Overall, I didn’t have great expectations for the film. It was just something at the video store that I thought I would try. I expected to like Agron, Akerman and Brody and to hate Duhamel and Holmes so I guess my expectations were on the money.
Here’s hoping someone makes a romantic comedy that doesn’t suck extremely soon!
2.5/5