“Prisoner on the Hell Planet” and the Imagery of “Meta”

Our discussions of Maus over these last couple of weeks have raised a number of points that I have found interesting. Something particularly intriguing came up in our group discussions last week when we were exploring our first impressions of the books. It had to do with Spiegelman’s presentation of “Prisoner on the Hell Planet” in Maus I between pages 99 and 104. My group members and I were discussing the metanarrative functions of the comic within the larger comic. While examining page “100” during our discussion I noticed for the first time that Art’s hand was depicted at the bottom left holding the pages of “Prisoner”. I had read this particular part in Maus I a couple of times previously to this because I had found it a particularly interesting part of the book, but this was the first time I had noticed Art’s hand there. Some of my group members had a similar experience with these pages in Maus I and we went on to discuss the implications of the fact that we are seeing “Prisoner” through Art’s eyes.

I keep thinking about how Art’s hand is presented and how I initially missed it when reading those pages. I realized as we were discussing that I probably didn’t see it at first because my own hand was obscuring Art’s; I was holding the book in such a way that my hand was making the exact same shape as Art’s. Besides making me think about the metanarrative implications of “Prisoner on the Hell Planet”, this observation forced me to confront myself as a reader of Maus and as a participant in the “meta” functions of this scene.

The inclusion of “Prisoner on the Hell Planet” is of course an indication of metanarrative; readers see directly through Art’s eyes and onto the pages of “the comic within the comic”. My experience with discovering the picture of Art’s hand forced me to think of readers as another layer of depth in this metanarrative. We are actively engaged in consuming this story; we perform the gesture of holding the pages up to our eyes, just like Art does with “Prisoner”. We bring the narrative in and experience it. It is interesting to note that there is a picture of a hand in a similar position holding the photo in the top panel of “Prisoner” as well. This gives us three distinct layers: one hand drawn in “Prisoner”, the other inside Maus, and lastly the hand of the reader, holding and reading the physical copy of Maus. I find it fascinating how the reader participates in the building of this “meta” moment, becoming part of the layered imagery relating to the consumption and analysis of a narrative.

1 thought on ““Prisoner on the Hell Planet” and the Imagery of “Meta”

  1. cristinamelo

    I also didn’t notice Art’s hand holding the “comic within the comic” until it was pointed out in class. I found it really interesting, not only because of how it forces the reader into Art’s position in the story, but it also opened my eyes to how I had been paying 90% of my attention to the words and not looking closely enough at the actual illustrations. Once we had that discussion in class, I went back and re-read the majority of it, this time looking at details and found that it really shaped my reading experience in a different way.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *