Category Archives: Uncategorized

Assignment 3:2

Find three examples of names that need to be spoken aloud in order to catch the allusion. Discuss the examples as well as the reading technique that requires you to read aloud in order to make connections. Why does King want us to read aloud?

 

There are many positives that come with reading a story aloud. It breaks that barrier of intimacy you have when reading in your head. I find that even when alone, reading something aloud feels as though I’m in front of an audience. It is a slight shift in the reality of reading, you have a different connection to the story you are taking on. With this being said, it may encourage you to immerse yourself, and be a part of the story, which is what King may have been inviting us, the readers, to do. There were a couple names that needed to be spoken aloud in order to catch their allusions, but the three I gravitated towards were, Dr. Joseph Hovaugh, Polly Hantos, and Sally Jo Weha. 

Perhaps the most obvious of the bunch, is Dr. Joseph Hovaugh. Admittedly I did not make this connection right away. It struck a chord with me upon reading it on the page, but it wasn’t until I read the name out loud that I realized the obvious allusion to the Bible. I learned that “Jehovah is God’s unique name in the Bible” (Who is Jehovah.)

In addition to Dr. Joseph Hovaugh, two other names I noticed were both Polly Hantos, and Sally Jo Weha. It is to my understanding that Polly Hantos is supposed to be alluding to Pocahontas. This is a character that has been adapted into the Disney universe. If I’m being honest, the film Pocahontas was a favourite of mine. There was something about the aesthetic of the film, paired with the soundtrack that made it so alluring to me. Thinking back on this film, it got me thinking of how effectively did Disney portray the young Indigenous luminary? The third name that stood out to me was Sally Jo Weha, which again, to my understanding, was an allusion to Sacagawea.

King has done this masterfully as it is not as simple as just reading the names aloud to clearly reveal their hidden identities. The reader must skip syllables, or even squeeze others together to uncover this language King has created for the reader. As I mentioned in the opening paragraph, the act of reading aloud to oneself, provides a “distinct stimulus of self-recognition” (Hendricks.) As Sophie Hardach puts it, nowadays “Reading out loud is largely reserved for bedtime stories and performances” (Hardach, 2020.) Perhaps this is another reason King is encouraging us to read aloud. Perhaps he is wanting this to be more than a standard reading experience, but more of a “performance” we are taking part in only to ourselves.

 

Works Cited

 

Stebbins, S. J. (2010, August). Pocahontas: Her life and legend. Retrieved from https://www.nps.gov/jame/learn/historyculture/pocahontas-her-life-and-legend.htm

Hardach, S. (2020, September 17). Why you should read this out loud. Retrieved from https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200917-the-surprising-power-of-reading-aloud

Hendricks, D. (2020, October 06). The little-known truths about reading aloud. Retrieved from https://www.scilearn.com/little-known-truths-about-reading-aloud/

“Who Is Jehovah?” Jehovah’s Witnessjw.org/en/bible-teachings/questions/who-is-jehovah/. Accessed 18 Mar. 2021

Interesting thoughts on believability …

On the other hand, stories must rely on a literary canon, history, culture, etc., to uphold their believability.”

Hmmmm, so, you are implying stories depend on textuality to “uphold believability “This is a thought that I’d like to examine.  Why would the idea that textuality brings believability to a story –be so?  It is true that western cultures predominantly preach the believability and reliability of the written word over the spoken word, for all sorts of interesting reasons that we will explore through-out this course. However, there are cultures for which the spoken word carries far more weight in terms of believability because the spoken word has a witness. And, interestingly, in western cultures there is an exception to this notion found in our court rooms. Spoken testimony under special circumstances, the court room for example, is considered highly believable.

Thanks for the thought- provoking idea that the spoken word relies on the written word to uphold believability. Thinking about why this seems ‘logical’ or even ‘common sense’ is important in the process of unlearning and learning to listen. We are, all of us, dominated by one narrative or another, but we are able to ‘step into the intersections’ and see where the ‘other’ narratives lead and equally able to learn new ways of seeing and believing in the world.

Your concluding statement is equally thought provoking:

“Yet as one is hard-pressed to give up one form for the other, this duality serves no larger purpose, both forms work together and to separate one from the other seems counterproductive in terms of simple communication.”

I would say along with others, the purpose served was a colonizing purpose: to subjugate a people. We will discuss this further, for now I simply want to point out one of many colonizing strategies that we will examine in literature and the stories we tell ourselves.

Unit Three Reflections:

https://newsmaven.io/indiancountrytoday/news/

Any film/ documentary enthusiast – Check this film out: https://www.nfb.ca/film/circle-of-the-sun/

. The point about this National Film Board film, if you have time to watch it, is how the outside narrator contradicts the visuals. As he speaks about a necessarily vanishing ceremony, that no longer includes young people – the final shots are of young people, hundreds of them, participating in the dance. It is really quite an ignorant film, but in 1975 – that was the narrative. Note how there are two voices, the Blackfoot man who returns to the Sundance and is filmed while in contemplative stances as his story is a ‘voice-over, and the ‘outside narrator – the film-maker is invisible as he ‘explains’ the significance of the story. It is as if the film-maker couldn’t see what he was filming. He was carried away by his ‘poetic’ vision of the story of the Vanishing Indian, he was blinded to the reality on the other side of his lens. Remarkable. As he tells a story of a dying ceremony, the truth is he is filming a ceremony on the brink of revival – and what a remarkable revival. This film is actually a good example of the kinds of story-telling about First Nations, Metis and Inuit that prompted the outcry against cultural appropriation and the telling of their stories by outsiders in the 1970s and 1980s and became a complex theoretical issue in the wonderful ‘post-modern’ 90’s … <– that is my sense of humour Enjoy the film if you have time, it’s an interesting break from work that offers insights into the ‘way’ we tell stories …

After you watch Circle of Sun (1975) – see if you can watch the next National Film Board story about the Sun Dance ceremony (2008)
The Sacred Sundance: The Transfer of a Ceremony: https://www.nfb.ca/film/sacred_sundance/
The Sacred Sundance: The Transfer of a Ceremony

https://www.ictinc.ca/blog/indigenous-peoples-terminology-guidelines-for-usage

 

Good Wed 470! While you are all working away with your Conference teams, I am reading all your Unit three blogs with great pleasure. I hope to have evaluation sheets out to all of you by the beginning of next week – it is quite a reading and watching and following journey! Here is a good link to save: re – capitalizing Indigenous.

I realize the problem is that many of the texts we read do not bother to capitalize ‘Indigenous.’ Here is an interesting and telling experiment with your spell-correction function. Look at this sentence which I typed without using any capitals: The Canadian and European and mayan peoples, who are also indigenous, all live together in belize. My spell-correction automatically capitalizes Canadian and European, but NOT Mayan, nor Indigenous. Try typing a sentence — it has to be a sentence because a single word will be automatically corrected as if beginning a sentence – with a number of proper names of peoples, like australian, African, south American, Aztec, Indian, irish ….. very interesting to see which peoples automatically get a capital letter at the beginning of the word that describes their ethnicity, one more: Mongolian. hmmmmm.

Grammar is a POWERFUL tool of oppression 

This is so because language is at the heart of how we know ourselves.

Midterm Evaluations

Before I begin a discussion on the evaluation process, I want to ask you to consider what is wrong with the following list of names:

  • Canadian
  • European
  • indigenous
  • French
  • Spanish
  • first nations
  • Montrealers
  • mohawk

Let’s talk about this list on Face Book :)

Well, well, we have reached the midway point of our studies and dialogues together and that means the time has come for me to speak up and join in with you all. Here’s how the process works:

  1. On Mar 8th – Please post a Facebook post with three links  to the three blogs you would like me to respond to – and of course assign a number of evaluative points [please see our syllabus for the breakdown of percentages].
  2.  I will read and respond to your blogs, and engage in your dialogues; this is my feedback.
  3. I will also make up an evaluative grade sheet with comments for you, which you will receive as an attachment in an email message.

I expect this process to take me a couple of week. I will alert you when I have finished the process.

I am very much looking forward reading and responding to your blogs. Enjoy.

What Do I Expect? Your website and final papers

As I am busy finishing up your evaluations for Unit Three, I can see you are all working away on your intervention websites and dialogues – excellent. I want to offer you an example from last semester of a nicely laid-out website with all the required components. You do not need to follow this example – you can be more creative if you are so inspired.

DIGITAL MEDIA: DIVERSIFYING THE CANADIAN LITERARY LANDSCAPE

This is how my evaluations will work:

  • Website design & completness / 10
  • Bibliography: / 10
  • Dialogue page:/  10

It works like this. I grade the website out of 30 points. So, say your group gets 25/30 and there are 4 people in the group. I assign you as a group 4 x 25 = 100 points. Then, as a group you distribute those points and let me know who gets what with an email to erika.paterson@ubc.ca  – as a group you agree on the distribution. IF, I do not hear from you I will assume you want to distribute the grade evenlly. The purpose of grading this way is if someone is sick and can not do their fair share – only that person loses points. Alternatively, if someone has stayed up all night to complete the work in place of your sick partner, that person gets extra points. Only you as a group can determine who has contributed what – and who deserves what points. I can not do that fairly. As well, it is a good lesson on how to collaborate when it really counts. Hope this is clear enough, thanks.

So, what do I expect with your final papers?

  • I hope to be enlightened and entertained by the connections you have made through the course of our studies
  • I expect that you will cite from our blogs and research websites
  • If you choose to write a reflective essay focused on one of the choices I have offered, I expect to learn about how our course of studies has impacted you — as a scholar and a citizen
  • If you choose to write a literary essay addressing one of the three questions I have for you, I expect a high level of insight and critical thinking that demonstrates a rich knowledge and appreciation for King’s narrative techniques and the overall ethos of this remarkable novel. I expect you to quote passages and be specific with your examples
  • If you choose to write a research paper based on your team’s research, I expect to read a paper that introduces the established state of knowledge concerning your area of research, and a well formulated discussion that will enlighten me with scholarly evidence and critical thinking that demonstrates your position and concludes with a statement on the limitations of your research and suggestions for future research.

Here is a good tip for you, review the list of course objectives and try to specifically demonstrate your new understandings in context with our objectives. You can borrow my language if you want.

Through this course of studies students will:

  • Gain perspectives and develop a dialogue on the historical and critical process of developing a Canadian literary canon
  • Develop an understanding of the relations between nation building and literature.
  • Discuss, research, and write about the intersections and departures between literary narratives and oral stories.
  • Develop reading strategies for recognizing allusions and symbolic knowledge other than Western.
  • Learn to recognize and challenge colonizing narratives and representations
  • Gain some expertise in story telling.
  • Cultivate the ability to create knowledge through social relationships
  • Developing expertise with collaborating in online spaces, writing for online spaces and presenting for an online conference.
  • Come to some conclusions on the state of literature in Canada today and offer up ideas for the future.

The objectives of this course are to strengthen your critical and literary skills and to enrich your understanding of the complex historical and contemporary relationships between literature and storytelling. This includes an understanding of the historical relations between nation building, canonization and colonization. This course requires that students have a willingness to develop a critical awareness and sensitivity to the tensions created by racism in Canada in the past and the present.

Upon completion of this course students will be able to discuss the historical and critical processes involved in developing a Canadian literary canon and explain the relations between canon building and nation building in a context that includes First Nations participation and agency in this process. Students will have developed reading strategies for recognizing and understanding allusions and symbolic knowledge other than Western.

The end goals for this course are to be able to recognize colonizing narratives and representations, to be able to discuss, research, and write about the intersections and departures between literature and story, and to speculate on the future of literature in Canada in consideration of new media technologies.

I expect you to enjoy writing this paper with the knowledge that I enjoy learning from/with you 🙂

Thank you all.

 

Reading List

Here is a list of the books you will not find online, nor in the course pac, so you will have to purchase  or borrow:

Chamberlin, Edward. If This is Your Land, Where are Your Stories? Finding Common Ground. Toronto: AA. Knopf. 2003. Print.

Frye, NorthropThe Bush Garden; Essays on the Canadian Imagination. 2011 Toronto: Anansi. Print.

King, ThomasThe Truth About Stories: A Native Narrative. Peterbough:Anansi Press. 2003. Print.

– – Green Grass Running Water. Toronto:  Harper Collins, 1993. Print.

Robinson, HarryLiving by Stories: a Journey of Landscape and Memory. Compiled and edited by Wendy Wickwire. Vancouver: Talon Books2005. (1-30)