Posted by: | 27th Jul, 2009

Moodling

This is not the first time I’ve created a course in an LMS. As part of my job, I do all this nitty-gritty for our new online courses in WebCT. Whilst taking this course, I completed one on the “Greek and Latin Roots of English” and am starting on a course on “Women as Visual Artists”. Thankfully, the content is the responsibility of experts in the respective fields. Several MET courses ago, I also collaborated on the creation of a course module in WebCT Vista.

So, while this wasn’t as much of a “how-to” learning experience for me, it gave me the opportunity to compare the platforms. In most ways, Moodle is more advanced and user friendly than WebCT (Vista and earlier). However, I found the lack of control over organizational pages, the hierarchical “breadcrumb” trail (why, oh why does it not track where you’ve been? back-clicking from a forum to a list of all fora is counter intuitive and less than useful), discussion forum layout, and vague explanations of tools and terminology to be frustrating.

My personal preference would be not to choose Moodle as an LMS platform if the resources were available for another, more polished and logical LMS. Nonetheless, I do know now that I’m just as capable of creating a course in Moodle as in any other LMS. I’d like to spend some decent sandbox time in D2L, Blackboard 9 and others now.

Incidentally, today I came across (via Twitter) a course delivered entirely using Wetpaint. Have a look at Alec Couros’ EDST 499K web site at http://edst499k.wetpaint.com/. I’m impressed.

David

Responses

Hi David,

I am a great fan of Wetpaint, too. I successfully ran courses on this platform. I personally think it is superior to Moodle: definitely in light of SECTIONS model. And the price is right: free and no adds for education sites.

If you do not have much time and want your course up and running right away, Wetpaint is definitely is the way to go.

Alexandra

I’ve learned a lot about Moodle in this course. I have a better understanding of what it can do, and I can see it’s a valuable resource.

But I’d still probably go with a vendor product if it’s available, based on the polish of the interface.

I can now *almost* recreate the 565 Vista course in Moodle. But I still think it looks kinda…simple. But I work at a university that has budget for an enterprise solution. Previously we used WebCT because it came out of UBC’s Comp Sci department; now that we’ve been paying for it, I wonder if we’ll stick…

I’ve just completed the course with Alek Couros at the UBCO Summer Institute. It was an eye opening experience! I’m new to online “connecting” but learned a tremendous deal and overcame my fear of the unknown.
Wetpaint is fabulous!

Hi Carin:

Good to meet you online. I was intrigued by that course – might be fun to stage it elsewhere too. Feel free to follow on twitter (cellodav).

Cheers,
David

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories

Spam prevention powered by Akismet