m3 Introduced us to the concept of collaboration. We’ve all collaborated on projects with different groups of people in different settings, but I think that few of us have had the opportunity to collaborate the way we did in this class, using the variety of social media tools available to us.
I will give you my interpretation of the experience from this past week. I began the week with excitement because I was envisioning Dick Tracy watches connecting group members on the fly, wherever we were, providing quick check-ins and updates. I envisioned myself in a flying car with 3d images projected in space with a disembodied voice saying “Mr. Ferguson, your group would like to meet for a quick mash-up.” as my car flew itself in a laser-guided queue. This is the future, after all. Shouldn’t this communication stuff be all worked out by now?
Sigh, no. Briefly, I’ll say that the ooVoo video chat wasn’t compatible with some devices, Google+ Hangouts doesn’t work on the iPhone and I don’t have a webcam at work, and Skype mobile got garbled quickly the first meeting we used it on, and completely dumped me on the second meeting. We had to go to Vista group chat, and when the other three members of the group were in there, I wasn’t allowed in. I was only able to chat on the Skype mobile app with the other members in the Vista chat.
Now, it would be tempting to say that the technology is not up to snuff, it was a bad experience, etc., but it was really the opposite, and I’m not trying to be a Pollyanna. One of the most interesting and exciting experiences for me is dealing with problems as they arise. Once, when I was giving a presentation to about a hundred people consisting of faculty, students and their friends and families, one of my guest speaker’s slide presentation wouldn’t project on the screen behind us. This was the central part of the presentation. I felt strangely calm. All the nerves and fear had presented itself when I was anticipating the event before it began. Once the event started and the fiasco occurred, I was fine. I went into the room behind the panel of faculty on the elevated stage, messed with the projector, and stayed back there manually changing the slides as the speaker presented. When he referred to something on a slide, I pointed it out with my finger which showed up as a giant shadow appendage to the audience. They burst into laughter, and the tension was relieved. It was a big hit.
Mistakes happen, technical problems are always lurking. But these are just opportunities to create something new out of a situation. You have to be flexible. I apologize for waxing poetic, but there it is. Collaboration is about creating something together that you could never have created alone. In architecture design classes we always looked for the happy accidents. Sometimes we even created opportunities for them. You head down one road, and then you take your artifact from that exploration and literally turn it upside down and break chunks of it off and reassemble it. A large part of what we do as information professionals is learn how to navigate the ever-shifting landscape and dodge the grenades as they explode before us. Beauty comes out of the destruction and resurrection.
I’m just glad that the people that I’ve had the good fortune to be associated with in this class are up to the challenge and willing to negotiate the terrain with a spirit of cooperation.
2 replies on “Beauty in Destruction / Resurrection”
“A large part of what we do as information professionals is learn how to navigate the ever-shifting landscape and dodge the grenades as they explode before us. ”
That the one constant in life is change may be cliche, but to me it seems amplified at libraries, which seem to deal with changes big and small on a daily basis. Whether it’s budget cuts, organizational shuffling, or simply (rather, not so simply) integrating new technologies, every library I’ve had the privilege of working at– big, small, public, academic, special, whatever– has been in a constant state of flux. What’s going on right now in Toronto with their public libraries unfortunately seems to be the norm, having to defend our value and fight for libraries. Sometimes we have to catch those grenades and throw them back. Sorry to go off on a tangent here, but the tweets I see coming out of Toronto have me riled up tonight!
I can’t fathom how some people think that libraries should be privatized. That seems like a nail in the coffin of the institution. You can’t commodify the assets contained in libraries. This is all part of a larger pro-business anti-intellectual push that was born out of the capitalist common denominator: the commodity. A person’s labor and an eggplant have nothing in common, until you make them both commodities, then you can buy and sell them and the soul drops out. If you can do it with people, you can do it with knowledge, and every knowledge container suddenly has to be justified. It’s existence has to be tied to quantifiable returns. The people who curate the collections suddenly have to justify their existence. It’s absurd. I’m constantly amazed and saddened about how large and unrelenting this push seems to be. I’m diligently building my own collection now. Maybe the only places that will be the libraries that we want are the ones we build ourselves.