Assessment

Term 1

Attendance/Participation (20%)

Students are expected to attend and participate actively in our weekly sessions. But please see Support if you have to miss a class.

Research Journal (10%)

Min. 8 weekly entries (min. 350 words each) over the course of Term 1 (to be submitted through the Discussion section in Canvas). Each entry (due by the end [11:59 pm] of Mondays) should provide, whenever applicable, a considered response to the upcoming readings or, in cases when there are no assigned readings, a thoughtful reflection on one’s research progress.

Preliminary Proposal (10%)

About 1,250 words (excluding bibliography). Due by the end of September 22 (to be submitted through Turnitin; late policy: 4% per day). For the preliminary thesis proposal, students are expected to:

Identify their primary research question(s). This is not an easy task, but start by articulating as clearly as you can what it is that you are (really) puzzled by or curious about.
Explain the significance of the said question(s). There are many ways to go about this. You may start by providing a well-chosen quotation from a recent work of scholarship or by tracing your question(s) to a particular primary source.
If it isn’t already clear from the above, specify the geographic, temporal, and related parameters for the project. This is important as you would, I suspect, like to graduate in time.
Identify and discuss some (3?) potential primary sources. You may not be ready, but it is never too early to think about the kinds of sources you would like to access.

Source Analysis (20%)

About 1,750 words. Due by the end of October 24 (to be submitted through Turnitin ; late policy: 4% per day). Choose a specific primary source (or a set of primary sources) you are likely to use for your thesis and provide an in-depth analysis. For this assignment, students are expected to:

Explain as clearly as reasonable the background of the source in question. Since students will be dealing with different kinds of materials, it would be difficult to generalize what is “reasonable.” Here, try your best to identify the basics: who, when, where, how, and why. Before we even begin to analyze a source, we need to know as much as we can how it came into being.
Explain the contents of the source. Here, you will be dealing with the “what” part, and you will be explaining what the source is about, especially as it is related to your research project.
Explain the significance/relevance of the source. You may explain the general significance of the source, but it is especially important that you explain (and justify) how the source could help answer your primary research question. It may be too early, but try to be as concrete as you can.
Identify the limitations of your source. Among other dimensions, pay attention to whose voice(s) you are hearing from the source and how such voices might affect how you would approach your project.

Thesis Prospectus (40%)

About 3,500 words. Due by the end of ~~December 9~~ December 15 (to be submitted through Turnitin). For this final assignment for Term 1, your task is to draw on/bring together the work you have done so far to produce a blueprint for your thesis. Since you are likely to be at different stages in your research, the “blueprint” in question would look differently for different students. Still, here are some key elements I would like you to incorporate:

The Problem(s). Explain what you are puzzled by or what you would like to explore, preferably in the form of a question (or questions). And explain how your queries are inspired by or connected to a particular body of historical scholarship. Be specific about your “point of departure.”
The Scope. Specify and justify the parameters (temporal, geographic, thematic, etc.) of your study. Persuade your reader that the scope is appropriate for both intellectual and practical reasons.
The Sources. Identify the main source(s) for the project and explain, with concrete examples, how they could help answer your primary research question(s).
The Plan. Explain how you will proceed with your project. This might take various forms depending on the state of your research, but it would be very helpful if you could identify some concrete steps (along with a timeline). If you already have an outline of your thesis, this is where you should include it.

Term 2

Drafts (2 x 20 = 40%)

During Term 2, you’ll submit two draft sections (chapters) of your thesis for feedback and assessment. The final due dates for the draft sections are February 8 and March 15, respectively. These sections should cover two different aspects of your thesis—for example, an empirical section built around primary sources and a historiographical/contextual section based on secondary scholarship. you’ll have flexibility in your approach, as long as you clearly explain the differences between the sections.

For each draft (to be submitted through Turnitin), please include:

an up-to-date thesis abstract (~250 words)
an up-to-date table of contents for the thesis (preferably with one level beyond the chapter headings)
a brief introduction (~250 words) of the contents included in the draft, with an explanation of what the section seeks to demonstrate
the draft section (min. 3,000 words, not counting notes/bibliography)

Workshop Participation (8 x 2.5 = 20%)

You’ll take turns presenting—and critiquing each other’s draft sections—in the “Chapter in Focus” workshops. To give classmates time to read and prepare comments, presenters should submit working drafts by the end of Sunday before each workshop (for example, January 18 for Workshop 1.1). Non-presenting students are expected to participate actively by providing thoughtful feedback during the workshops.

Peer Reviews (2 x 7.5 = 15%)

You’ll serve as a formal discussant for two draft sections (one for draft #1 and one for draft #2). In addition to helping kick-start the discussion of your assigned draft, you’ll submit a written peer review (guidelines to be provided) by the end of Friday following the workshop. Your review will be shared with your classmate to help them improve their draft.

Symposium Presentation (25%)

Details to be provided.