Monthly Archives: November 2013

Rome the Eternal

Everyone goes to Rome one day; everyone goes expecting it to be just how everyone else saw it. Everyone comes back feeling a little different.

Okay, so that’s not exactly true– not everyone goes to Rome, and not everyone’s changed by it; they see some ruins, take some pictures and leave. But it’s hard when you’re there not to feel the impressions of everyone who went before you. Rome, after all, is old even by European standards. It’s the city every other city has dreamed of being; when Napoleon shaped Paris, he was thinking of Caesar, when London crafted their empire… Artists, poets, world leaders. Rome and Paris were the only two cities I knew I had to see this exchange. Every other European city would be “nice”, would be “great”, to see– only those two would affect my exchange (would make me regret if I didn’t). I went into Rome expecting to feel what I did for other cities I’ve already seen– excited by the history, fulfilled by the art, coming back to Paris thinking about the great weekend I had. I never expected how painful Rome would actually be.

It makes sense to start at the Coliseum. My friend and I walked the Appian Way, past the crumbling villas or the ones holding it together with duck-tape. It was the main highway–the road Nero strung up a couple hundred burning Christians– now mostly a quiet, leafy Mediterranean road. At the end of the road are a series of stone balconies rising up four levels topped by intricate colonnades broken only here-and-there by broken stone or punctures. If it wasn’t so instantly recognizable it could have been the beginning of a series of trendy new apartments; it might take you a second to realize it’s a stadium. But go inside, look at the broken steps where they sat, down to the passages where they kept the prisoners– listen close and you can hear the rush and the roar, the cheers and the screams.

It seems oddly fitting that Rome’s surviving legacy would be their place of death: their greatest achievement was their television, the violence a little realer than we’re used to. But all places in Ancient Rome start to feel like a graveyard after a while. It wasn’t something I realized right away; I just couldn’t shake the nagging feeling that I wasn’t as happy as I expected to be here– where was that historian’s joy? Instead it was increasingly miserable being there, and leaving the ruined area didn’t bring relief so much as it brought exhaustion. It took me half the weekend to discover why.

Rome was the first civilization I became enamored with. Grade Nine classics kept me on the edge of my seat. Maybe it was the glamour and the glory of the ancients, or maybe it’s that the lives of the Roman Emperors more closely resembled a soap opera than history. Either way, I was hooked. It brought me through a full university course on them and made me watch HBO’s Rome twice– never mind it was a second rate TV show and a pretty terrible prof. Rome was enough. So when I went to Rome I expected a culmination, for history to come alive like it did in Paris. Instead, if history comes alive in Paris, it dies in Rome. All that were left were some toothpick columns and some statues rendered faceless by the elements.

That’s not to say I was “disappointed” by Rome. In fact, having such unexpected emotions added to the beauty of the trip. There is something beautiful about the field of the forum, the kind of beauty my camera or your camera or a travel agency’s camera can’t capture. It’s a feeling. It’s a reminder: no matter how great we all think we are, this is where we’ll all end up. Is this what New York will look like? The skeleton of the Empire State crashing against the swallowing sea? Dramatic of course, but it’s impossible not to think of our own lives– of nuclear missiles, of the warming planet– when I’m confronted with something like this. Is this all any of us are good for?

And then there’s that eerie balance in this city– the symmetry and the form, as if the whole city were its own classical structure. For across the river was the watchful dome. If old Rome is death, new Rome is after-death (“new” as in “only five hundred years ago”, get it?). I’ve never seen such a ‘Catholic city’. Churches in Rome are really something else: not only is there one for every street, but each one seems filled with priceless art– here’s one with Bernini’s incredible “Ecstasy of St Theresa”, here’s another with three Caravaggios. Culture pools around the Church– each unique, each taking my breath away. On Sunday we went to watch the Pope’s address from his balcony, and hundreds of thousands of people turned up to fill the square. People screamed like they were at a rock concert, with flags of countries or posters of “we love you Papa” blowing in the wind. And this happens every Sunday? Even just the word “Papa” denotes the proximity: whereas French and English refer to Francis as the Pape or Pope, Papa seems much closer. When he said “hello my children”, and they screamed back “bonjourno papa!”, it gave me a better idea of why the church is still so central there.

So while Rome is labelled the ‘Eternal City’, I think it’s better to say that it’s the city most obsessed with eternity. Eternally searching. And where is it to be found? The Papacy would like to say at St Peter’s Basilica. It towers above everything– at night it could be a marble mountain rising above the rest. Inside, it couldn’t be called a church– a palace? a fortress? It’s cavernous, with pillars like high-rises and saints the size of giants (only looking towards heaven, never down at you). It made me think of the first church I saw this trip to Europe: the one-room chapel on the summit of Mt Croagh Patrick Ireland. Those two structures are so different I have a hard time labelling them under the same religion. St Peter’s is the center of an empire, an empire that’s lasted a millennia longer than the Romans. It also gave me a greater understanding of pre-modern Europe in general: when so much money was given– read: forced– from every corner of the continent, in order to build something much more for the glory of man than God, it becomes easy to see why Luther posted a couple reforms to that wood door. St Peter’s left me awed, but it also left me cold.

Now I don’t want to give the wrong impression of Italy or the Italian people; that would be unfair to my Italian friends. The Trastevere district, for example, gives a very different impression of Rome than what I write here: laundry hanging from balconies, amazing pizza restaurants, people singing in the streets. La Dolce Vita. I understand that many people see this side of Rome, joyfully, for what it is. But for me, Rome is the forum and the basilica; everything in between was just a mix of the two. And that question of what we’re all worth dogged me the entire time.

And then we go to the Vatican Museum. Formerly the main residence of the Popes, the opulence is astounding. It’s probably the best collection of Roman statues in the whole city (which says something). On the top floor, Raphael has painted the seven antechambers, giving visitors a dramatic history of the Church. Near the end is the original “School of Athens”– the one in which Socrates stands around his students and points at the sky. While it’s immediately recognizable on its own, it became relevant to me since a reproduction hangs over the Assemblee Nationale in Paris. What’s so fascinating is that the Assemblee depicts the painting on its own, so that Socrates pointing up at the sky symbolizes reason (a nice sentiment for the French Republic). Meanwhile, in its original form, Socrates pointing up at the sky is actually mirrored in the painting on the opposite wall, where the Pope points up at God. Therefore, in its original form Raphael equated philosophy with theology. That it’s not the same today is just a fascinating example of the way art can shift its meaning over time.

Of course nothing compared to the very next room. They do a good job– these Vatican type– building things up for you, because at the end of the hallway we walked in upon the Sistine Chapel. You know how certain pieces of art need to be truly seen to be appreciated? This one takes it to another level. I walked in and was immediately overwhelmed– everywhere I looked, incredible art. Along the walls, various artists like Botticelli have painted depictions of Jesus, while the ceiling, well, that one’s reserved for Michelangelo. It’s one thing to examine God reaching out for Adam; it’s another to see them looking down on you. In painting the fall of man from the Garden of Eden, Michelangelo isn’t concerned with the Bible– he’s concerned with human nature. And it’s all there, on the walls, as people fight for a place beside Jesus– battling it out as even Mary’s in pain. It’s a masterpiece, and it’s barely changed since the Renaissance. Suddenly humans didn’t seem so screwed anymore; if Michelangelo survived after all this time… well, who knows?

Rome wasn’t the most fun of cities: perhaps there are nightclubs somewhere in that city, but we’d get home so exhausted from travelling we didn’t bother. And when my friend assumed I would love to spend another four or five days there to get to see everything else, I quite honestly replied “no, I couldn’t handle another day here. After three days I was dried out, ready for the rest of something (now at least a little) familiar, in Paris. But no city has impacted me more in such a compact period: three days and I went through a cycle of despair and hope all at once. Rome does that to people– moving through it you see where others were just as inspired, so much so it’s almost a cliché to say so now. And it’s the first city I’ve found myself looking at the pictures I took in class, only three days later, drooling over them, like they’d happened to a different person. Rome the eternal; it’ll stick with me.

Spain the Magnificent

            Image

It’s raining in Paris. Three hours of sleep after the last minute edits and the emailing of my prof the essay– packing on the go, leaving in the dark. We’re perfect Parisians, chasing the metro. On the bus out of town already the cars are lining up, honking and swaying in the rain. My roommate is shivering; at the airport people are yelling at us.

            Blink and I’m on a mountain, the sun close and warm. Out across from me the houses spread out like intricate colored clay, everything in sync except for that grand Cathedral and its four spires striking up like beach shells. Against that there’s the Mediterranean sea, the kind of blue painters use (not the kind of blue that actually exists). And when I close my eyes there’s the chirp and the clicks of the insects, dirt as I run my hands along the rocks. Hey-oh, Barcelona.

Image

            Twelve days in Spain. Twelve days that could have been three weeks, three months, a whole year. They weren’t normal days, and this wasn’t a normal trip. The best way I could describe it was– clichéd as it is– an adventure. The word ‘adventure’ is misused and exaggerated a lot in our culture– mainly by me. I mean, look at my first blog post: I joked that almost losing my visa was an ‘adventure’. What the hell’s adventurous about sitting in front of a computer screen for forty eight hours, sweating from stress? I understand it now: Spain’s a proper ‘adventure’. Having such a busy week before it, I stepped onto that plane knowing virtually nothing about the places we were going, even the mega-popular Barcelona. Then suddenly me and four friends are renting a car and going into the heartland. For the first time during my trip in Europe, I saw incredible sights which I knew absolutely nothing about– not the history, not the thing itself. Your average North American knows next to nothing about Spain: say Spanish and we think Burritos and Sombreros. So, as we drove further inland, I felt like an explorer, seeing places no one in my family and none of my friends had seen. A part of me was at points slightly, totally irrationally, scared– proving how young I still am, how inexperienced– but then we’d see the places and it would be beyond expectation. And this is it.

            Spain is a country that can’t be generalized. There’s so much fragmented history, so many overlapping cultures, that just to drive two hours is to step into another place, another time.

Image

            Without further ado, here are some generalities about Spain: Spain has some of the friendliest people in the world. There’s a sense of community here I’ve only ever seen in Western Ireland. When a man with a leg brace was seen standing on the metro, two ladies stood up to ‘attempt’ to give him their spot. Upon making a joke in Spanish, everyone around him chuckled, and whatever he’d said made the lady beside him strike up a conversation. Language barriers didn’t prevent me from seeing that something was happening here that never would in Vancouver or Paris. Like the lady who, upon meeting us on top of the mountain near her village, made great effort to tell us all about the history of her village and the random castle perched on it, even though neither of us understood each other linguistically– employing her hands and her expressions– just so I could know about the village she loved. Spain is full of dramatic landscapes, of sandy mountains, rock towers, and orange groves; a place of amazing food– tapas! Palella!– amazing drinks– sangria! Estrella and Cerveza!– and amazing culture.

            One of the most important aspects in understanding Spain is that it’s a night culture. Spanish days are often so hot that shops close between two and five to take siestas, or just relax and have a coffee. There’s an emptiness to every city around three: Barcelona and only four or five cars would be driving, all the shop fronts shut. The flipside of that was their exhilarating nights. Streets are more packed at 9 PM than at any other point of the day: women yelling from balconies, men yelling from corner bars, children running across roads, crowded sidewalks. You know you’ve left Canada, and even France, when young children are still running around in their Halloween costumes at midnight. It’s a completely different kind of lifestyle. I’m not sure if I would enjoy it all the time– too little daylight might make one depressed– but I’ve never felt so alive at five in the morning.

            Between 1939 and 1975, Spain was under the Fascist dictator Franco, who practiced an isolationist policy which kept the country out of world politics. Much, I’m sure, has changed since then, but Spain has maintained its heritage and its roots more than I ever would have expected a country in Western Europe too. Sure, they have McDonalds and Burger King (lots of burger king!) now, but it feels like something to be taken at face value. Many Spanish people, after all, don’t speak English. Every province, every village is different.

            On that note, it’s too unfair to Spain to continue with these generalizations. Here you go, here’s Spain:  

Image

            Barcelona is one of the most popular cities in Europe, and it’s not hard to see why: with mountains, amazing beaches, beautiful architecture, interesting markets, great metro and amazing nightlife, it has everything you can want for a vacation town. But it goes so beyond that. There’s something unique about the city, something which sets it apart from other European cities; it’s more than the sum of its parts. You can see that partly in the architecture, which at first glance might look like the Imperialist style of most of western Europe, only to sneak up on you. Antoni Gaudi, the modernist architect, transformed the city. As my Barcelonan friend said, “he gave this place its soul”. His buildings have a surreal quality to them, with wavy features and sandy surfaces that make them seem plunged underwater, or winding staircases which lead nowhere or everywhere. Walking his park in the north of the city was like living in an Escher painting. They have to be seen to be believed–so idiosyncratic– much like the rest of the city. And one day his masterpiece, the looming Sagrada Familia, is going to give this city its Eiffel Tower or Statue of Liberty– probably being better, if the ground floor is any indication.

Image

            Barcelona has a way of seeping in; the more time I spent there the more I loved it. Just to walk between the narrow alleys or under the hundreds of balconies, listening to the laughing in those warm Mediterranean nights– I didn’t need to be doing anything to be having fun. Not that there’s ever a shortage of things to do; despite being a sixth the size of Madrid, there’s always new things to explore. Take our day in the Gothic Quarter. If the narrow streets, dark brick and statues of angels everywhere wasn’t cool enough, finding Roman ruins and monasteries that looked like modern skyscrapers really set this place apart. It all centered itself around the sprawling Gothic Cathedral (probably one of the only churches in the world, I’d guess, with its own swan garden). When we reached the front doors a band had assembled on the front steps, playing some very strange instruments– upside-down french horns, sideways oboes, and upright bases made for some pretty odd sounds, but the tune was beautiful. Across the plaza people danced in circles, in which anyone could join; one man leading and everyone following along, everyone understanding and welcoming. A woman in a wheelchair had been placed in the center of one so that she could be as part of the dance as everyone else. I later learned that this was the traditional form of dance in Catalonia, but I never needed a guide to tell me that what was happening here was very old and very dear to the people in that square. It was community on a level so open and so basic I was overwhelmed. I can still hear the music, that beautiful tune on those alien instruments. The next day on the aforementioned mountain I was at peace, after the insanity of Paris. I could hear myself think: did I want this? Was the insanity worth it? (Is it worth writing a blog if I’m just going to contradict myself with each post?). I don’t have that answer–yet– but it made me think.

            As we were leaving Barcelona we all felt we could have just spent our reading break there, but the car was ready and we had a big country to see. Down the coast we stopped in Valencia later that afternoon. We hadn’t heard much about the city beyond the beach, and spent most of our day there, only to discover, once it had already gotten dark, the beautiful old city and its drained moat. In the end, the spectacular part of Valencia was neither near the old town or the beach. Walking along the moat, it seemed like we were being lead to the middle of nowhere, having the place recommended by the girl at the front desk of the hostel. What could be so special about something made ten years ago in a town no one’s heard of? We passed gardens, bridges, and glass conservatories. Were any of these Valencia’s ‘big deal’? Then we saw this:

 Image

and this:

 Image

Yeah. One minute we’re in an old Spanish city, next minute we’re in Blade Runner. The building is so idiosyncratic it’s almost impossible to describe (so I photobomb you with pictures, how’s that for lazy?). There was nobody around us, not even the sound of cars, just the gurgle of the pool; nothing to make me think we were in Spain, in Europe, in anywhere really. If this place was so amazing, why didn’t it feature in every architecture book, every Lonely Planet guide? Us explorers made our first discovery.

            And it wouldn’t be the last. The very next day we were through the mountains and into Granada, the former major Arabic outpost of Spain. The town crawls up the edge of a mountain, the old city virtually unchanged in the past seven-hundred-or-so years, maintaining its tiny alleys and Arabic influence. Many of the streets sold rugs and fine trinkets, and there were probably about twice the number of hookah bars– adorned with tassels, thick with incense– to regular bars. Walking through, the town was always dwarfed by the very reason it’s a town in the first place: the Alhambra Castle. Looming high above on a larger mountain, the ancient walls glowed yellow in the night.

 Image

We went there the next day thinking we’d spend two hours– max!– there before Seville. In the end we had to drag ourselves away after four. The Alhambra, a finalist for the Seven Modern Wonders of the World, is widely considered to be the most significant Arabic structure in Europe. Today you can still visit the armory, the baths, the water stairs, the garden, and the waiting rooms of the palace. All over six hundred years old. The art inside is stunning: the inlaid patterns, the vibrant colors, and the balance to which its employed makes it different from any other place in Europe (as my Lebanese friends assert, far more like the Middle East). It was also built and perfected when Christian Europe could barely hope to keep a couple of rocks together to keep out the rain. Then suddenly they lose to the Christians and they’re erased from history. Isabella and Ferdinand engaged in what can probably be called a genocide when they forced (read: murdered) the Arabs out of the country. Now the castle stands alone, reminding us what Europeans have done such a good job at forgetting. I’ve been to many castles now, but in none have I had shivers like I did here. It was like walking through a room full of ghosts. It’s a lesson a history student can’t forget.

Image

             It was interesting to leave the least ‘Spanish-ey’ city only to immediately go to probably the most. In many ways Seville is the cultural heartland of Spain. It’s the home of Flamenco, Bullfighting, Don Juan, Carmen, and that singing barber. It’s the most idyllic place we went to in Spain: colorful mansions, cobbled streets, palm trees, and the smell of oranges everywhere you go. Its old imperialism and value for beauty makes it the most similar city to Paris, while its atmosphere made it the most peaceful. While Seville was more about the feelings than the sights, it does sport the first bullfighting arena, the third largest cathedral in the world, and this:

 Image

The Plaza de Espana, the site where the first Star Wars was filmed (oh, and a lot of important cultural stuff happened there too, I guess). The flamenco show we saw later really represents the city. In a small cellar with a smaller stage, the music was a drifting mix of Spanish guitars and pained wailing– the kind of thing that will lull you into sleep (though not in a bad way). Then the third guy, only clapping his hands up to that point, stands up and begins to dance. The fact that he was a guy, therefore not wearing the traditional red dress, added to the shock of seeing him suddenly tapping his feet at nearly inhuman speeds, arms and face clenched tight. All three were trapped in a performance of sustained passion, skimming under the surface. It certainly sets the context: a dreamy city, beautiful to look at, but there’s always something more– something that’ll bring me back. It’s that remaining drift of mystery which makes me say that Barcelona and Seville are the cities I have to come back to.

             Seville and Granada seemed far away from the rest of the world. The morning we left Seville we strolled along the river in the silence and sway of the palm trees. That afternoon Madrid screamed in: traffic jams, colossal buildings, homeless people practically jumping at you to wash your car, and the myth of central-city parking. Back to the rest of Europe.  If Seville is the heart of Spain, Madrid is the pulse– electric, eclectic. Often lambasted by tourists for having nothing to see, Madrid is the living city; ask a local about their little brother and they’ll say “oh Barcelona? It’s nice, but too touristy”. Madrid doesn’t care about amusement-park attractions; it’s far too hipster for that, and its alt-scene vibe reminded me more of Montreal than of a European city. At the same time, it’s one of the most centralized cities in the world: the shopping, business, nightlife and, yes, prostitution districts are all concentrated in a single road. It becomes so dense, and its imperial buildings so high, that for that one stretch it could be a bigger city than Paris.

Image

It also takes the nightlife aspect of Spain to a whole new level. The clubs are amazing here– probably the best I’ve been to– and you can’t truly understand this city until you see it at eight in the morning. I stumble out of the club and fog cloaks the lights– only the blue of the clocktower lights seen in the distance. But the streets are packed with groups of people my age, laughing so openly they could only be drunk, wearing cocktail dresses and ruffled suits. In the end it’s as memorable as anything I’d seen this trip; as culturally significant, only this is my culture. Madrid the modern.

              We stopped in Zaragosa the following night. Day eleven, the ugliest city in the trip, when everyone is just getting tired. That feeling of almost-over can dog you: you give up, where day eleven of a month trip is nothing. We sat in a Chinese restaurant confused and lost in translation. It played out, almost to the minute, exactly like all of my family trips: that penultimate day, thinking of your flights, when everyone’s ready to go home. So for all the notion of this being a great adventure, some things stay the same. I can’t say what made it so comforting. Maybe it was just to realize some things would always be there for me, something always familiar, even when everything’s so strange. Because Spain had changed us: we got back to Barcelona with it having dropped ten degrees and autumn being in the air. In eight days we’d gone through a whole season and saw Barcelona differently now. You can only see so many castles, go through so many different cultures, before a country starts to change you. Like this exchange in general, it’ll be a while before I realize the extent of how much I’ve really changed.

              Back to Paris, and– guess what!– it’s still raining. Good to know some things don’t change.  

Image