Human intelligence vs. Artificial intelligence
| Human answer | AI answer (Chat GPT) | |
| 1. Who were these people, and how did/does each contribute to the development of artificial intelligence? How did/does each think “intelligence” could be identified?
|
Alan Turing (1912-1954): Alan Turing, a British mathematician, is known as foundational research of computer science. In 1950, he proposed to consider the question, “Can machine think?”(Turing, 1950). His works on the code- breaking process leads automatic computing engine. His experiments on the issue of AI known as the “Turing Test”. He was considered the father of artificial intelligence.(Editors, 2020)
John McCarthy (1927-2011): He is one of the “founding fathers” of artificial intelligence. He developed machine languages such as Lisp and ALGOL. He invented garbage collection ( automatic memory management) and time-sharing technology (servers). He commented that “human material progress is desirable and sustainable.” In 2001, he released his predict on robot’s emotions and social networking in the future. (“John McCarthy – computer scientist,”) Herb Simon (1916-2001): He is a pioneering in AI. In 1950s, he worked on AI and cognitive science. Simon’s models of decision-making influenced early AI and lead him to win Nobel prize. In the Sciences of the artificial he framed intelligence as problem solving. Simon concentrated on digging deeper to understand data.Simon was interested in how humans learn and, with Edward Feigenbaum, he developed the EPAM (Elementary Perceiver and Memorizer) theory, one of the first theories of learning to be implemented as a computer program.(“Herbert A. Simon,” ; “Herbert Simon,”) Marvin Minsky (1927-2016): As one of the pioneers of robotics and telepresence, Minsky used computational ideas to understand human thinking processes and simulated it in machines. His studies have led to practical advances in the fields of artificial intelligence, cognitive psychology, and neural networks. Minsky proposed the “community of mind” theory, which is influenced by the developmental psychology of children and insights gained from the field of artificial intelligence. He mentioned that intelligence is the result of the interaction of diverse specialists. In 2006, he introduced The Emotion Machine, which includes a framework to explain human emotions and conscious thoughts in various (“AI pioneer Marvin Minsky dies aged 88,” 2016). Timnit Gebru (1982): A computer scientist born in Ethiopia, as one of the founders of Black in AI, has made extensive efforts to promote the active participation of Black and people of color in the field of artificial intelligence. As an expert in the ethics of artificial intelligence, she tries to enhance the capabilities of AI for the improvement of society. Her studies on large language models have highlighted the risks associated with using them in understanding fundamental concepts and the potential for misuse. She mentioned that AI models could generate misinformation or mistranslation, leading to laziness in people due to the convenient use of these models (Hao, 2020). |
– Alan Turing, a pioneering computer scientist, significantly shaped the foundations of artificial intelligence. His Turing Test proposed a criterion for determining machine intelligence, emphasizing indistinguishability from human responses. Turing’s seminal work laid the groundwork for AI development, influencing how we perceive and define intelligence in computational systems.
– John McCarthy, a key figure in AI history, coining the term “artificial intelligence” in 1955, propelled the field. His influence extends to developing the Lisp programming language and founding the Stanford AI Lab. McCarthy advocated for the idea that intelligence is computational and introduced the concept of “computer as a universal machine for all cognitive processes.” – Herb Simon, a Nobel laureate and AI pioneer, emphasized cognitive psychology’s integration into artificial intelligence. His work on problem-solving algorithms and the “thinking machine” concept shaped AI’s early landscape. Simon proposed that intelligence is a product of rule-based symbol manipulation, influencing AI research and defining intelligence as a computational process. – Marvin Minsky, a trailblazer in AI, co-founded MIT’s AI Lab and developed foundational ideas in perception and learning. His contributions include the concept of neural networks and co-authoring the influential book “Perceptrons.” Minsky viewed intelligence as a collection of interacting mechanisms, inspiring diverse AI research and shaping our understanding of machine intelligence. – Timnit Gebru, a leading AI researcher, co-founded Black in AI to address diversity in the field. Her work at Google focused on ethical AI, shedding light on bias and accountability. Gebru advocates for inclusive AI development and redefines intelligence by emphasizing fairness, transparency, and social responsibility in machine learning systems. |
| 2. How do “machine (programming) languages” differ from human (natural) ones?
|
Human language, developing across centuries, functions as a tool for everyday emotional communication shaped by society. In contrast, machine language, designed by experts for efficient command execution, lacks the depth of human linguistic evolution. Human communication is rich and influenced by societal factors, while machine language focuses on specific instructions. Humans talk for many reasons, but machine language is all about clear commands, showcasing the unique roles each language has (Tsujii, 2011). Also, the human language is corrected and adjusted by the members of the society, but the machine language is improved by the computer experts according to the users’ requests.
|
Machine programming languages, like Python or C++, are artificial, designed for computers to execute specific tasks efficiently. They employ strict syntax and are devoid of ambiguity. In contrast, human natural languages, such as English or Spanish, are nuanced, context-dependent, and expressive. Machines lack innate understanding of human language subtleties, relying on precise instructions. While humans use languages for communication, conveying emotions, and abstract ideas, machines interpret languages algorithmically. Bridging this gap is a challenge in AI, with ongoing efforts to develop natural language processing capabilities for machines to comprehend and generate human-like language. |
| 3. How does “machine (artificial) intelligence” differ from the human version? | Human intelligence, marked by emotional acuity and social adeptness, could understand complex emotions and varied concepts. In contrast, artificial intelligence encounters challenges in accurately decoding complex emotions during feelings analysis (Kumar & Martin, 2023). Human intelligence is adept at multitasking and setting connections across diverse domains, unlike artificial intelligence, which, guided by predefined algorithms, often struggles with tasks beyond its specific focus that prevents innovative capacities (Lake et al., 2017). Additionally, human intelligence has inherent creativity, while artificial intelligence relies on algorithms and data, lacking the spontaneous initiative evident in human cognition. Also, human intelligence consistently displays intelligent behaviors, even during sleep (dreaming) (Horowitz et al., 2023), while turned-off machines remain silence without any analytical processes. | Machine intelligence, while powerful, differs fundamentally from human intelligence. Machines excel at data processing, pattern recognition, and executing predefined tasks with speed and precision. However, they lack human qualities such as emotional intelligence, creativity, and holistic understanding. Human intelligence encompasses complex emotions, adaptability, and nuanced decision-making shaped by experience and empathy. Machines follow algorithms, while humans navigate a vast array of cognitive processes. The challenge in artificial intelligence lies in bridging this gap, striving to imbue machines with more nuanced, adaptable, and human-like intelligence, ultimately aiming for a harmonious integration of artificial and human cognitive abilities. |
| 4. How does “machine learning” differ from human learning? | Human learning is a complex process that influenced by thoughts, emotions, and cultural factors. People learn through their feelings, experiences, and cultural contexts (Vygotsky, 1978). Artificial Intelligence learning uses specific designed programs to analyze data and follows defined algorithm regardless considering diversity of cultures and human emotions. AI learning only focuses on user satisfaction about accessibility, practicality, and cost-effectiveness. In human learning, the attitude of both the teacher and the learner influence how content is presented. However, in AI learning, there is no consideration for the attitude of the learner and some differences like as gender, age, IQ level, and language. AI learning is predefined and lacks flexibility. It could reinforce social inequalities (Zou & Schiebinger, 2018).
|
Machine learning differs from human learning in its method and scope. While human learning involves complex cognitive processes, intuition, and context awareness, machine learning relies on algorithms to identify patterns and make predictions from data. Humans can generalize knowledge across diverse scenarios, adapt to new information seamlessly, and possess common-sense reasoning. In contrast, machine learning models excel at specific tasks but lack the holistic understanding and flexibility of human cognition. Bridging these distinctions is a key challenge in advancing artificial intelligence, aiming to imbue machines with more human-like learning capabilities for enhanced adaptability and comprehension. |
| 5. And for your LAST challenge, a version of the Turing Test: how do YOUR answers to these questions differ from what a machine could generate? make sure you reference the specific differences between your answers and ChatGPT’s.
|
Both machine and human tasks begin with an internet search algorithm. The machine, utilizing advanced predefined processes, quickly produces a coherent result by searching millions of words. Conversely, human step-by-step searches evolve, guided by individual knowledge and opinions, allowing for expansion, or revisiting as needed for personalized exploration and understanding.
I will categorize the differences between these two into three categories. Regarding language, both machine and human discussions encompass the diverse applications of their respective languages. However, human responses explore the origins of language creation, emphasizing that human language evolves from thousands of years of collective experience, with a focus on socialization. In contrast, machine languages, are made by computer experts, serves specific tasks, so human communication falls a secondary priority. In terms of intelligence, human responses highlight the significance of emotion, human concepts, creativity, and dreaming. In the context of learning, human responses focus attention on the role of bidirectional communication between learners and educators, integrating explanations that take into consideration structural variations such as age and gender. Generally, human responses prioritize human behavior’s impact, while machine responses prioritize correctness, regardless of cultural diversity, emphasizing a fundamental distinction in their perspectives and considerations.
|
|
References:
AI pioneer Marvin Minsky dies aged 88. (2016). https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-35409119
Editors, B. c. (2020). Alan Turing Biography. A&E; Television Networks. https://www.biography.com/scientists/alan-turing
Hao, K. (2020). We read the paper that forced Timnit Gebru out of Google. MIT Technology Review. https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/12/04/1013294/google-ai-ethics-research-paper-forced-out-timnit-gebru
Herbert A. Simon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herbert_A._Simon
Herbert Simon. https://www.ubs.com/microsites/nobel-perspectives/en/laureates/herbert-simon.html
Horowitz, A. H., Esfahany, K., Gálvez, T. V., Maes, P., & Stickgold, R. (2023). Targeted dream incubation at sleep onset increases post-sleep creative performance. Scientific Reports, 13(1), 7319. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-31361-w
John McCarthy – computer scientist. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_McCarthy_(computer_scientist)
Kumar, H., & Martin, A. (2023). Artificial Emotional Intelligence: Conventional and deep learning approach. Expert Systems with Applications, 212, 118651. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eswa.2022.118651
Lake, B. M., Ullman, T. D., Tenenbaum, J. B., & Gershman, S. J. (2017). Building machines that learn and think like people. Behav Brain Sci, 40, e253. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0140525x16001837
Tsujii, J. i. (2011, 2011//). Computational Linguistics and Natural Language Processing. Computational Linguistics and Intelligent Text Processing, Berlin, Heidelberg.
Turing, A. (1950). Computing Machinery and Intelligence. Mind, 49, 433-460. https://redirect.cs.umbc.edu/courses/471/papers/turing.pdf
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Interaction between learning and development. Mind and Society, 79-91.
Zou, J., & Schiebinger, L. (2018). AI can be sexist and racist – it’s time to make it fair. Nature (London), 559(7714), 324-326. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-018-05707-8