Epigenetics and Development
Our Goals:
- To build our own definition of “epigenetics”;
- To classify the major mechanisms of chromatin remodeling;
- To investigate how external environment/behaviour can trigger a completely different developmental fate
- To propose, and interpret some experiments that allow us to shed light on this phenomenon (in a specific case)
- What could be the underlying mechanism driving the different developmental trajectory of the organisms studied in today’s class?
DIET plays a huge role in determining whether a bee becomes a queen or a worker. It may act via signalling pathways, hormones, or DNA methylation. These things may then change gene expression that will be characteristic of either a Queen or a worker
Other options could be some kind of juvenile hormones—perhaps queen bees are pre-designated and produce hormones that prevent others from being queen and promote their own queen-growth
- a) With one or two partners, take two minutes to come up with a definition of “epigenetics”:
A non-sequence related difference in gene expression
- b) After listening to other classmates’ ideas, provide a more complete (if necessary) definition of “epigenetics”:
- important to realize that epigenetics does not necessarily have to do with GENES. Can be something in the cytoplasm; methylation, histone, etc etc
- everyone agreed epigenetic is non-sequence or base-pair related… but it doesn’t even have to do with DNA t all.
- “Inheritance of a phenotype that is not explained via DNA differences”à for example, tetraformena (a protist) can inherit the direction of mouth bristles BUT it has nothing to do with genetics! It’s the way they divide the cell during mitosis.
- a) What are different mechanisms that can affect developmental trajectory, and that could be affected/directed by an “outside factor”?
- coiling/supercoiling
- enzymes involved with histone modifications
- factors involved in mitosis
- acetylase/methylation
- different environments might sensitize or desensitize these pathways
- b) What are the mechanisms that can affect chromatin structure?
- histone variants
- ATP-dependent chromatin structure remodeling
- Post translational modifications
- DNA methylation
- What would you predict about gene expression patterns in the two distinct developmental trajectories if epigenetics is driving the phenotype?
- sex developmentà workers have reproduction shut off
- growth hormones
- telemerases
- serotonin/reward genes associated with working habits
- Researchers (Grozinger et al., 2007) actually checked… what do you notice about the gene expression patterns in individuals following each of the two developmental trajectories?
- Worker bees have upregulation of foraging-related genes and down regulation of reproductive/longevity genes
- Queen bees have the exact opposite: lots of upregulated reproductive and longevity genes but down regulation of foraging ones
- What kind of protein/factor could be a key component of the epigenetic control of developmental trajectories? How would you test your hypothesis?
- Could be CPG islands
- Could be methylationà do ChiP of different histones (H3K4,9,27)
- Could be DNA acetylationà inject larvae with DNA acetylase inhibitors
- Could be other proteinsà test whether they are necessary by injecting larvae with iRNA
- What did Kucharski and colleagues find, and what does their experiment suggest?
- Found that by inhibiting Dnmt via RNAi, you can induce Queen-like traits
- This suggests that workers had methylated DNA while queen has unmethylated DNA
- Suggests that maybe worker phenotype is “default”? Because it takes methylation of worker DNA to make a Queen phenotype.
- a) What component of the food in question is most likely to affect gene regulation?
Lipidà specifically, Royal Jelly Acid
- How does the food in question activate a transcriptionally silenced gene?
It affects the transcription of the Fas gene. The Fas gene is a positive regulator of cell division, and it is up-regulated in Royal Jelly-treated larvae
- ***optional*** Using these pieces of data that we just discussed, construct a model of how consumption of the food in question leads to each of the developmental trajectories.
Day 2: Wednesday 1 April 2015
Review:
Queen bee receives royal jelly
Royal jelly acid is a part of royal jelly
There is differential gene expression in Queen and worker bees
If you treat bee larvae with Royal Jelly acid, you can induce queen symptoms
If you knock down Dnmt using iRNA, you can cause an increase of development in queen-like phenotypes (reproductive things).
Using these pieces of data that we just discussed, you can try to construct a model of how royal jelly consumption lead to Queen bee development.
- Royal jelly acid is absorbed into the larvae through ingestion
- Due to polarity, it diffuses into cellsà likely gets digested a little
- Interacts with proteins responsible for activating Dnmt proteins
- Perhaps it interacts with receptors that activate a cascade of kinases that activate or deactivate Dnmt
- This in turn methylates DNA to shut down “Worker bee” genes
- One of these genes might be an inhibitory lncRNA (like Xist)
- Lacking lncRNA, queen-like traits will become activated
- Thus, the default is worker bee but the queen develop if Royal jelly blocks.
Other suggestions:
- jelly causes increase histone acetylation
- histone acetylation then causes queen bee genes to be more expressed
Are there other things in royal jelly that affect final phenotype?
- other than jelly acid, probably other nutrients
- nutrition and nutrient-rich diets can affect phenotypes later on; not necessarily bc of active component, but because of nutritional component.
- You could isolate royal jelly acid and feed bees nectar+acid; royal jelly – acid; assess phenotype