Review of Piglia

Money to Burn is rich in scenes involving whirlwinds of chaos, relentless acts of crime, and portrayal of criminality as acts of disregard and recklessness in attaining what specific groups want or desire in society. The scene involving rape and murder are shocking to read about. Nonetheless, I appreciate that the author does not shy away from describing these incidents, because just as love and remembrance—qualities often embodied in literature—are part of the human condition, so is violence and acts of criminality. Something which I found to be significant about the narrative would lie in the portrayal of drugs in the novel, which was not only pervasive but realistic in terms of representing an aspect of criminality that contributes to the disorderliness of its nature, and as a catalyst for the destructive behaviour that they impose upon their surroundings in terms of imposing chaos upon their surrounding environment. At the same time, the drugs that they use is also a central aspect of the novel, because they contribute to understanding their perspective in the world and how they contend with the ultimate reality of their situation, which, in many cases, involves lives of alienation, solitude, and the desire for a greater source of purpose to guide the trajectory of their lives, often fraught with disorder and masked over by the nebulosity provided to them by their drugs.

The motif of disorder provided by the drug interweaves with the narrative of the novel and forms in its pattern a sense of irrefutable danger and desperation, birthed from the entrails of the human condition and mingled with the chaos of criminality. The full-blown digressions into the heist in which the criminals are involved, and their relationship with drug use, creates a cinematic image of violence that is opposed to conventional social norms. The ending, which consists in the gunman deliberately burning their robbed gains, represents how their acts of criminality have no intrinsic value in terms of truly bestowing them with happiness, or helping them gain fulfillment in life. Their crimes are merely momentary occupations in which they become inextricably entangled. Once one becomes part of such a life, one has a difficult way of departing from it; and so it becomes not merely a norm but a ritual, a pattern of obligations spreading its way out from the very centre of life, surrounded by scenes of violence, fights, recklessness.

Is Dorda an intrinsically bad person, or was he made to be this way by his environment and the psychological conditions over which he has no control?

This entry was posted in Home, Piglia. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Review of Piglia

  1. Tolu says:

    I don’t think that he was an intrinsically bad person , I do think that his environment made him bad and affected his upbringing. However, I am also of the belief that people still have choices, and can choose to continue to make bad decisions. I like the line closer to the end of the book which talks about how people would have had more empathy for them if at least they did not kill orphans and women. It would make sense if he had something against the system, but he still made choices to engage in the killing of innocent people. It’s complicated!

  2. Jiachen Cao (Miyaki) says:

    Hi, Melissa! I agree with you saying that crime for them is a ritual, a pattern of obligation with violence and fights. Robbery is their lifestyle, their way of living in the society. Even they know they will get caught, they will still stay there and do drugs and wait because they have nothing else left for them if they leave this kind of “ritual”, ” life”.

  3. Jennifer Kim says:

    Hi, I agree with Tolu! I do not believe Dorda is an intrinsically bad person. This is because the situation he was placed in, he had no control over. However, what he can control is how he lives out or makes decisions in the future. So, while there is definitely influence from the environment he is in, he also has the ability make his own choices moving forward. Thank you for sharing!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *