Month: June 2022

How climate-friendly is your food at UBC? According to recent studies, labels encourage more sustainable food choices and change how we eat. 

This first UBC Climate-Friendly Food System Label research project was carried out in three main phases from Summer 2021 to May 2022, where the research teams tested different icon iterations’ impact on the UBC community behaviour.

Phase 1: The 3 tiered colour system (red, yellow, green) has been tested in the first phase (August to September 2021) at Mercante pizzeria on the UBC Vancouver campus as a first icon to indicate the climate-friendliness of a meal (Graphic design by Helen Eady, Creative Co).

Phase 2: A traffic-light system has been developed for the second phase (October to January 2022) and added on some menu items at Mercante pizzeria and Open Kitchen managed by Food Services to measure the impact of a label on food choice student behaviour. Here is the poster that has been developed as complementary information to inform UBC Community on this label (Graphic design by Helen Eady, Creative Co).

Phase 3: A single happy planet icon (Graphic design by Mallory Lupick) focusing only on a positive message has been selected through 3 side-by-side concept mock-ups to represent the UBC Climate-Friendly Food System Label from February to June 2022. Two UBC dining halls located in campus residences participated in the study. One was the treatment location, while the other was a control site.

A food meal labelled with the happy planet icon means that this food menu item has at least a 50% lower environmental footprint per 100 grams than other items.

This project shows how people from different backgrounds and expertise can work together towards the same goal, promoting the Climate-Friendly Food Systems at UBC.

In light of the climate emergency, for most of those consulted, as well as the observed sales results, most of the UBC community wants to be more informed about the environmental impact of our food choices. 

A simple, easy-to-understand label icon showing colour range seems to be the right direction on UBC’s campus as a next step to expand the Climate-Friendly Food System (CFFS) Label.

Student perspective

Background and interests

Yu Luo works under the supervision of Dr Jiaying Zhao, he is a PhD candidate in the Department of Psychology at UBC. His research focuses on applying behavioural insights to address environmental issues (e.g., plastic pollution and climate change)

Yu Luo plans to continue collaborating with academic, industry, and government partners to conduct research on mitigating environmental issues.

He learned about the Climate-Friendly Food System (CFFS) Label project from his supervisor, Jiaying, since I have led many environmental projects in his lab.

The CFFS label project aligned with the topic of his PhD dissertation. His dissertation focuses on how to use Behavioural interventions to tackle environmental issues. Implementing CFFS labels to change consumers’ food choices on campus perfectly matched his dissertation.

“This project gave me a great opportunity to test out behavioral interventions in a real-world context and the findings of this project can contribute to solving a real challenge at UBC as I led the field experiments and online surveys in Phases 1 and 2 of the project,” said Yu Luo.

In phase 1 and phase 2, findings showed that the majority of the survey’s participants supported the implementation of the CFFS Label on the UBC campus, and the results showed that adding a label to a menu item shifted participants’ food choices from high GHG emission food to low GHG emission food.

CFFS Label Impact

According to Yu Luo: “If we implement the CFFS label at all food services locations on campus, we will see a large reduction in GHG emissions from food systems at UBC. Ideally, I hope that we can implement the CFFS Label in all restaurants at UBC, even at private food providers on campus that are not part of UBC Food Services.

The SEEDS team and all our partners were very supportive throughout the project. They helped us find the key contact person for a specific request, implement the CFFS Label at various locations, and extract the sales data that we needed. It was fantastic to work with a team in which everyone shares the same vision and works toward the same goal“.

Finally, Yu Luo concludes with the following benefits he gets from this SEEDS research community-based collaboration:

“With this SEEDS opportunity, I had a chance to work with a large team. It helped me gain communication and team skills. Importantly, this project gave me an opportunity to test out behavioral interventions outside a laboratory context“.

CFFS Label Next Steps

The team behind the CFFS Labels is looking for your feedback! From February to April 2023, the team will collect survey responses on the new CFFS label seen below:

The survey link (found here) is open now, and in March 2023, a focus group will be organized to gather more opinions to ensure the icon speaks to the UBC community. For more information, visit Climate-Friendly Food Labels for the latest update on the CFFS Labels.

This innovative multi-actor project was made possible thanks to the skills, passion, and commitment of the students and faculty members through a strong collaboration with Food Services supported by the Climate-Friendly Food System Action Team, working over the past years to develop, pilot and evaluate UBC’s first Climate-Friendly Food System (CFFS) Label in food outlets across UBC campus.

UBC aims to operate a climate-friendly, just and accessible food system which means reducing our GHG food systems footprint through food production, procurement, provision, consumption, waste and recovery.

Thanks to a novel methodology developed by on of the Research team, they were able to assess greenhouse (GHG) emissions, nitrogen, and water footprint associated with UBC’s food dining halls 1655 recipes during the pilot to evaluate and inform the “climate-friendliness” of food.

Why it is crucial to create a Climate-Friendly Food System at UBC?

From a global perspective, food systems are an enormous driver of climate change and contribute to more than one-third of global GHG emissions equivalent to around 34% of emission.

Based on UBC’s overall emissions (Scope 1, 2, and 3), food emissions represent 21% of UBC’s overall emissions for 2019, accounting for over 29,000 tCO2e per year.  Based on UBC’s extended impact (scope 3 emissions), food emissions represent 31% of these emissions and are the second-highest after commuting. It is anticipated that food emissions may become UBC’s largest emissions category as other sources of UBC GHGs emissions reduce.

In an effort to tackle this, UBC’s Climate Action Plan 2030 has set a target to achieve a 50% reduction in food systems emissions by 2030 (on a 2019 baseline).

How do we determine what foods are climate-friendly?

The GHG emissions, nitrogen, and water footprints of each menu item are calculated by summing up the weight of every raw ingredient multiplied by their respective footprint factors. Ingredient footprint factors are determined according to their category in the Cool Food Calculator, which provides data on the amount of GHGs emitted during the food item’s life cycle (production, distribution, processing but excluding cooking emissions and associated food waste). Following UBC’s Climate Action Plan reduction goals for food systems, the Climate-Friendly Food Label was assigned to menu items whose composite footprint is 50% of the baseline in 2019.

The nitrogen footprint factors were provided by the Food label toolkit from Allision Leach (2016), and the water footprint factors are publicly available (Poore & Nemecek (2018)). The nitrogen and water footprint factors were recalculated for each food category in the GHG emissions factors list to maintain consistency and improve calculation efficiency.

This project has been led by the SEEDS Sustainability Program, which catalyzes student-led applied research and interdisciplinary partnerships to advance climate action at UBC. This project is in partnership with UBC Food Services, UBC’s Climate-Friendly Food System (CFFS) Action Team, Vancouver School of Economics (UBC Faculty of Arts), Department of Statistics (UBC Faculty of Science), Department of Psychology and the Institute for Resources, Environment and Sustainability.

Student perspectives

Silvia Huang supervised by Juan Diego Martinez have done outstanding work and most of the heavy lifting to build the framework and assessment methodology that allow the data team to evaluate UBC Food Services menu ingredients to attribute a Climate-Friendly impact score on it.

Silvia and Juan played integral roles in advancing the CFFS Label.

Silvia Huang’s perspective

Graduated from UBC with a bachelor’s degree in Economics and Statistics, in autumn 2022, Silvia will begin a master’s degree in analytics at the University of Chicago next September.

Silvia aims to pursue a career in data science and analytics to find and execute solutions to overcome challenges brought by the increasingly digital world.

She was enrolled in the UBC Science Co-op program and chose the Climate-Friendly Food System (CFFS) Label project as her first co-op job.

This project’s goal aligns with her own interest in using data to make a social impact. She was ecstatic to be in charge of building a data analysis framework from the ground up, which was a huge challenge that greatly improved her problem-solving and teamwork abilities.

Silvia work for the CFFS Label project as a data analyst. Her main responsibility has been to build an evaluation framework that can automate the evaluation process and perform life cycle analysis for large-scale recipes’ data.

The Climate-Friendly Food System (CFFS) Label impact according to Silvia

“The CFFS Label is a simple and effective method of indicating the climate-friendliness of meals that students buy on a daily basis. Students would be able to learn more about the food they eat and make more climate-friendly meal choices if we could provide more information behind the CFFS Label, such as the CFFS attributes data and their impact on climate.”

Her goal for the CFFS Label was to create a standardized method of menu item assessment and labeling criteria that can be used by universities and institutions across North America. According to Silvia:

“The most interesting aspect of working with SEEDS Sustainability Program is learning how people from different backgrounds and expertise can work together towards the same goal, promoting the Climate-Friendly Food Systems at UBC. Therefore, I learned to approach problems from different angles and come up with different solutions. This also poses some challenges, such as how to solve problems while meeting the needs of each team member and client.”

Aside from the interpersonal skills Silvia quickly developed, working with SEEDS Sustainability Program allows her to see things from a bigger picture that does not only focus on what she does but also from the perspective of a large team.

More information: Climate-Friendly Food Labels | UBC Sustainability

More questions about the project? Please send an email to seeds.info@ubc.ca