The people of Tsilhqot’in have voiced their opinions concerning the development of the New Prosperity Mine at Fish Lake. The issue brought up by the natives revolves around Taseko Mines Ltd.’s Fish Lake property, which has been recognized by the courts to be outside the title area of the Native’s. This statement, however, is not supported by the Tsilhqot’in people. They claim that the mine would be trespassing the tribal park boundary.
Large-scale industrial mining and clear-cut logging is not allowed in the tribal park, but smaller-scale resource activities would be suitable in order to provide employment for the natives, says Dave Williams, president of Friends of the Nemiah Valley. But will the Natives agree to this negotiation?
There are strengths and weaknesses to both sides of the argument. The Natives do not have the government backing them up for their proclamation of Taseko’s Fish Lake property lying within the tribal park boundary. For Taseko, their project has been rejected TWICE by the federal government. So why can’t both parties settle down and agree to disagree? It would be more beneficial to not up-scale the situation by instigating their projects without proper communication.
There is no definite answer stating that there can’t be an equilibrium point where both the Tsilhqot’in people and Taseko Mines Ltds.’ can agree on a decision. If they were to sit down and talk it out properly, realizing that both parties have pros and cons to their projects, then a suitable negotiation can be made that would benefit all.
Sources:
http://www.canadians.org/blog/tsilhqotin-declare-proposed-mine-site-tribal-park