At last, I have finished Marcel Proust’s Combray. Forty-nine pages felt like a lifetime, and I attribute this to there being sentences that went on for longer than this blog post. Apparently, using periods wasn’t common practice in early 20th century France and semicolons were all the rage. I did enjoy it though I think, once I got though it all.
The hilarity of Swann being basically a kind of villain in the narrator’s eyes because he was a guest, and guests prevented the narrator’s mother from kissing him goodbye just might have made the whole thing worth it. Poor boy. His love for his mother was certainly endearing but it did break my heart a bit when his sadness was seen as nervous condition. The only good that came from that was that it allowed the narrator to “cry without sin” which isn’t much considering his sobs the night his mama slept beside him “never really stopped” it’s just that he could only hear them when “life became quieter around [him]”. Honestly, I think it was the descriptions of his sorrows that made me stick around because the conversations the adults were having were, sorry-not-sorry, often quite dull. The fact that this also a semi auto-biographical recounting of Proust’s own childhood also piqued my interest.
It was funny to me though that Swann is actually part of high society and dines with princesses etc and the narrator’s great-aunt and whole family think he is middle-class and send him running around doing chores basically. The whole family was rather amusing honestly. I also thought the structure of the story, while confusing at first was clever as it played out how a memory would. The more we learn, the more is remembered and revealed. I also learned a lot of words from this one: benumbed (deprived of physical or emotional feeling), ignominious (deserving of public disgrace), demimonde (people at the fringes of high society) and cocotte, (an oven or a fashionable prostitute).
And of course, the infamous madeleine scene. I had similar experience once, when I ran out of body lotion and put on some random leftover one I had, and bam, suddenly it was summer before senior year. I’m disappointed that my experience didn’t involve “render[ing] the vicissitudes of life unimportant to me” or made me “cease to feel mediocre, contingent, mortal,” though, but I’m happy that was the case for Proust I guess. In any case I now at least know what vicissitudes (changes in unpleasant circumstances) are. Poor boy honestly, so much suffering just for a goodnight kiss.
4 replies on “Combray (or, Memories of a Mommy’s Boy)”
Hi Sofia! I am in the same boat as you –my vocabulary expanded through this book for sure. I don’t know though, while he really craved for the attention for his mother, I don’t think this necessarily meant he was a mommy’s boy. I think he was just starved for regular attention from his mother.
Hi, Sofia. You are so funny that you call him poor boy. Indeed, I had the super similar experience as Proust when I was a kid. At night parents will stay in the living room to watch movies while I was forced to stay in my room. Super dark, and I always thought monsters will come to me and eat me so I would cry out loud then my mom could open the door and save me from the darkness.
Hi Sofia! The lengthy sentences are definitely a Proust thing.
I agree with you that the social aspect of the novel, Swann being part of the high society, while the narrator’s family belongs to the middle class, could be an aspect to take into consideration and analyse it even more.
I’m glad that your vocabulary grew!
Good job! Please share these ideas on class, they will definitely be interesting to your classmates.
See you tomorrow,
Julián.
Hi Sofia !!
The lengthy sentences were definitely testing my thought retaining capacity, cause wdym we’re still on line 1 for like a paragraph??? Also the words omg, I was filling them with guesses based on context and the fact you looked them up is commendable. Now I know what they mean with absolute certainity [my guesses were so wrong haha]! Moreover, you’re highkey making me want to make a lil cute dictionary for fun in this class.
The Madeline experience was so surreal! I get whiffs of certain smells [which for the life of me, I can’t remember atm] and a memory associated with it too! But for some reason I can never pinpoint what time/place/people are causing the reminiscing feeling. Like an itch on your hand you can’t scratch, the memory just brushes past consciousness and goes poof for a while.