Interrogation of Worth

Luiselli’s structural choices allow for an implicit criticism of the United States’ inhumanity during this crisis. By going through each question and providing anecdotes, the injustice and heartlessness of the US are strikingly apparent. Luiselli has no need to explicitly criticize these procedures, simply going through each question is enough to highlight the inefficacy of this process as a tool for determining a child’s worthiness of entering the country. The controlled structure seems to juxtapose the long and elaborate response that Luiselli writes to each question, reflecting the uselessness of the process; a child’s worth and value cannot be dwindled down into 40 questions. The process goes against everything the US, and the Western world, have agreed upon about human rights, and yet the crisis happened so blatantly and without intervention. Her detached approach to tackling this problem by laying it out in the same way the courtroom procedure would follow creates a powerful critique of the system when we see that it is impossible to answer these questions succinctly, thereby showcasing and critiquing the failures of the bureaucracy. I think that Luiselli’s choice to write about her college class’ initiative to help was a powerful way of showcasing that this should not be a problem that is ignored and normalized and that we should be doing something to stop this relentless cycle of colonial violence. The anger I felt while reading was, almost, soothed by this idea of hope and inspiration that I can do something to help. 

One thought on “Interrogation of Worth

  1. I agree with your analysis that Luiselli had no need to explicitly criticize the United States’ immigration procedures. They speak for themselves, and she is able to demonstrate this with her chosen structure. I find that to be such a powerful statement from her, where she is able to simply provide us with the information and we are able to notice the injustices on our own.
    I also found her inclusion of the student’s initiative really powerful. She is also able to include this anecdote passively, as if to say that anyone can start an organization like this, it just takes passion and commitment. Luiselli is almost like a messenger for all of these things that are happening.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *