Categories
ETEC 565- Learning Technologies Selection: Design and Application Module 4- Social Media

The Wisdom of the Crowd

Blogs: the good, the bad and the ugly…

In my search to find more information about the pros and cons of blogging I stumbled upon the article by Gerry McGovern “Blogs and blogging: advantages and disadvantages” and he points out that a myriad of the revolutions we have seen in the last few decades have had to do with writing and ‘blogging’ is no exception! From emailing to webpages to texting we have certainly changed the way we communicate. He calls bloggers ‘people with attitude’ and says that there is ‘a book inside everybody’. Who let this ‘book’ out? Blogs did! With blogs, we are now exposed to a myriad of perspectives and are bombarded with information.

The good….

• enable knowledge building, creates a community

• enable a forum for feedback, interaction with peers and teachers

• develops talent, keeps students informed

• fosters confidence and enables think time before response must be written

• encourage a ‘best effort’ by students due to peer scrutiny

• exposure to other viewpoints and opinions

• enables parents to see what their children are ‘learning’ about

• makes it ‘real’ for students since their work is out their for everyone and anyone to review

The bad….

• blabla bla- blog writing isn’t always quality or pertinent to the topic

• exposes learners to critism, exclusion of classmates, popularity contests continue online

• safety concerns- stranger danger!

• easy to start but hard to maintain! –organization!

• Time-consuming

• Inability for so many of us to ‘K.I.S.S.’

The ugly….

How does a blog cater for those learners who are more visual learners? (I say that all students need to write sometimes and the blog that you use with your students can encapsulate that required writing time! Students need literacy practice whether they like it or not!)

How do we keep parents onside? Keep them informed, give responsibility to students (student-parent-teacher contracts) etc.

And a variety of other ideas that have already been discussed at length!

Categories
ETEC 565- Learning Technologies Selection: Design and Application Module 4- Social Media

Public or Private learning spaces? A Case Study

The Situation:
Noelene teaches Grade 9 English at a private high school in the Sea-to-Sky corridor (along BC’s Sea-to-Sky Highway 99, between Squamish and Pemberton, including Whistler). Getting her students to inculcate the practice of writing is challenging: bringing blogs into her curriculum seems like a great way to integrate purposeful learning activities with those many students already enjoy.

After doing some research she decides to use LiveJournal as the delivery platform for an activity she calls No, really: something kewl I discovered online this week. Noelene has created a community on LiveJournal called Something Kewl. Students must post once a week to the community, describing something noteworthy found online. Students need to set up their own blog on LJ (as it’s called) in order to post to the community.

Students have the option of posting a draft version of their entry to their own blog, in order to receive formative feedback from Noelene. In each term a student earns up to 10 marks for their entries, so long as they are substantial and well-edited; anyone whose entire 10 entries are free of surface errors gets a bonus of 5 points. Each Friday the class reviews that week’s entries, which are posted no later than Wednesday night.

The students love doing the activity, and she can see their writing improving. However two parents expressed concern about the activity because: 1.) it’s public, and 2.) strangers have been commenting in their children’s personal LJs.
How might Noelene address the concerns raised by the parents in a way that does not negatively impact the activity for the students? Are there justifications for having students work in public spaces on the web?

————————————————————————————————————
Proactive or Protective?
The first thing I would advise her to do (as did kathie) would be to have a Parent-Teacher night and/or prepare an explatory newsletter and/or post information on the class/school website/blog/wiki….

1. I would advise parents to read:
http://mashable.com/2010/05/13/parenting-social-media/
2. I would demonstrate the pros/cons of the activity
3. I would clearly identify the need for the students to be aware of cyber ‘stranger danger’ and explain strategies that will be employed to minimize this
4. Remind them that to be a 21st century learner, new teaching and learning strategies and tools will be employed
5. Provide an alternative task that parents are more comfortable with

I think if the parents are communicated with and feel informed they will be more relaxed and hopefully involved.

Spam prevention powered by Akismet