The Modifiable Areal Unit Problem

The Modifiable Areal Unit Problem (MAUP) is observed whenever data is geographically-modified,either by changing the scale at which we look at the data (e.g., dissemination areas versus census tracts vs cities) or by changing how we aggregate the spatial units (e.g., grouping dissemination areas into census tracts, or grouping them into neighbourhoods). The figure below illustrates these two modifications.

Two grids of the same cells: left, aggregated by scale (cells to blocks); right, aggregated horizontally in pairs (top) and vertically in pairs (bottom), giving different groupings of the same cells (the figure shows the groupings by colour, not totals).

Drawing the lines: MAUP in Vancouver: the figure above, live, on real dissemination areas.

Note in the aggregation example how the individual cells can be grouped into clusters of two, either horizontally (top figure) or vertically (bottom figure).