I did my video project analyzing masculinity presented in the western archetype of the cowboy. I went with a fairly broad approach to explain the origins of the hyper-masculine and individualistic qualities and their effect/reflection in today’s North American society.
The video assignment was a lot of fun but also quite difficult. It’s a totally different mode of presenting information and PowToon is a bit temperamental. I’d started off in iMovie but it didn’t allow for the amount of text/layout flexibility that I wanted (and I hate using Powerpoint for movies) so I switched over to PowToon despite many people in the class having trouble with it. However, once you get used to its controls it’s fairly user friendly… I just couldn’t work out how to include video clips without pauses which limited my presentation somewhat… I’d meant to include some modern day clips of the cowboy imagery in action like in the Doritos commercial here. Regardless I think the video was successful without it, just forced me to change the content to focus more on movies and history than exact examples. The same can be said for its audio function which limited the video to the song’s 3:10ish duration. The rest of the tools are fine though and allow for lots of little details like the appearance of images and figures at various times. I quite enjoyed making the video and playing around with getting the sound to line up with image or word popups.
I think videos allow for both the condensation of certain information and the expansion of others; they also allow for concepts to be supported by images and sound which is not often found within papers or other media types. The only issue is perhaps timing and effort, especially when doing videos with text that has to be paced or with a voice over that has to be lined up with the content. Without effort into the details as much as the content the video is not as successful – as seen by videos that lacked audio or had issues with their pace in class. For me, this effected how I approached the project, with a focus on getting basic information out as clearly as possible without too much garbled text or speedy voice over.
Overall, I really enjoyed doing a video project as it’s rarely done in classes. It’s an interesting way of doing a paper and presenting research which really helps you think about what to include and what can be omitted through the use of other mediums.