Benoît surely has a difficult task ahead of him. He needs to make a decision, that not only needs to suit him and his abilities, but must also be able to fit his teaching style. Benoît’s background and motivation is going to be very important in making this decision. A big part of the choice is going to be how comfortable he is in using an LMS system to achieve his goals.
His experience is limited, he used WebCT to disseminate notes, which is a very simplistic use or the platform. He has also coded a website but again this is not very challenging and doesn’t necessarily apply to LMS.
Having support will be very important for him, however it doesn’t necessarily need to come from the help desk, which is slow anyway. Lots of people in his faculty are using Moodle over WebCT despite its lack of support. It would be key for Benoît to ask his colleagues about their choice, reasoning, and decision. Particularly he should find colleagues from similar backgrounds with little experience and really discuss how they are adapting and if they might be willing to help him should the need arise.
He needs to make this decision carefully it should be about understanding enough about the system to be able to use it to achieve what he wants in teaching so that the system itself doesn’t dictate the way he teaches. After talking with colleagues it would be helpful for him to try each system and get a feel for them before making his final decision.
Q: After discussing and sampling both systems, which one do you feel more comfortable with/ excited by?
This question is important because regardless of his decision, he is going to have to spend a significant amount of time learning to use it, creating a course on it and he will need to have a passion for what he is doing to motivate himself to finish.
Benoît has said that he could spend an five hours a week working on the course to go live the next semester. I really don’t feel able to say if this is enough without knowing more details. How long is left until the next semester? Is he simply going to be transferring existing materials? Or developing new parts to the course? How was his course organized before? Test based courses would be easier to transfer. How quickly does he adapt to using new technology? Is he good at working productively or does he become distracted? I think he needs to start transferring the course, being sure to ask these question, and see how long it takes him to accomplish the first couple of units, then a progress check could be used to see if he is on track for finishing in the set time.
Hi Amber,
I think you raise a great point. Benoit must do some research up front to determine which platform better suits his needs. I would take it back 1 step further and say the he first needs to figure out what his needs are. I’m sure both platforms have pros and cons but without knowing his own preferences how can he really make the judgement call?
I agree that we need more information to assess the timeline. I think the questions you posed are important. I especially like: Is he simply going to be transferring existing materials? Or developing new parts to the course? The answer to that question will greatly impact the timeline.
Hi Amber,
I think your question hit a key area, in finding the system he is the most excited about. It’s funny I was thinking mostly from a technical and strategic point of view, but I completely neglected to think about the excitement aspect.
You are of course right, the excitement factor is not something to be ignored, especially since he’s going to need a lot more time to develop his course than he thinks. It will also help him to find activities and select media to augment his course material.
Jason
Hi Amber,
I agree that finding the right fit is an important consideration when selecting LMS. Choosing the option that best meets the outcomes of the course, with the student learning goals in mind, is the logical place to start. But finding a suitable option that fits the teaching style of the instructor, as you mentioned, is crucial as well. Without the right fit, the motivational factor becomes an issue, and the effectiveness of the LMS suffers as a result.
I sometimes wish that, as educators, we’re given more opportunities to select based on interest and best fit, rather than having decisions handed down from administrators without considering all of the factors.
– Allen.