Hindsight is 20/20–the benefit of being behind the trends.

When I think of the future of education, I always think of a statement I hear at almost every professional development session: we are preparing students for jobs that do not exist yet. I’m sure many of you have heard the same thing. In my specific context teaching English language learners in China, an additional area of focus is introducing students to different approaches to education and learning.

My school isn’t at the cutting edge of technology, but I think that can be seen as a positive. We have the advantage of not getting caught up in trends, and the only direction go is up. I’m not going to pretend that we’ll “catch up”, so to say, but I do believe we can meet the needs of our students by taking the best past trends and incorporating it into our approach to education. We’re also lucky to be situated in the “silicon valley”of China, so there are countless opportunities to access cutting edge technology (once we’re ready!)

My vision to best prepare students for jobs that do not exist yet aligns with The New Media Consortium (2014) Horizon Report 2014 K-12 Edition solvable challenges to technology adoption: creating authentic learning opportunities (p.20). The best way, in my opinion, to foster independent, creative, critical thinking is present the learning as challenges for students to solve. Much of my current course consists of theory, short demonstrations, then hands-on practice using a single assignment for all students. This is problematic for two reasons: the assignments cannot possibly be an authentic learning opportunity for ALL students, and the software used could, quite possibly, not be used in the jobs of the future. So, I would like to see my school move toward authentic learning opportunities with open-ended requirements for what/how technology is used.

The New Media Consortium (2014) Horizon Report 2014 K-12 Edition also mentions shifting teachers’ roles to becoming mentors to students who are taking charge of their own learning (p.6). This was not a surprise to me, and I’m starting to see evidence of this even in my school which has had a typically traditional approach to education. This really is the key to my vision–as teachers, we need to step back and let the students take control.

I have been thinking about how to shift the focus to authentic learning experiences with teachers as mentors and how to help this change happen in my school. My idea is to start by shifting the focus of my IT class. I am still considering all of the details, but I would like to propose that, rather than being a stand-alone class, IT be integrated into our English and Social Studies classes. I chose these specific subjects as they are classes taught using Canadian curriculum. I see my role becoming more of a tech integration specialist. By combining the curriculums, there would be more opportunity to create authentic learning experiences. I would like to use the periods usually dedicated to IT class as a time when students could use technology while they work on projects (independently and in teams) that solve authentic problems they identify in their English and Social Studies courses. My role would shift from being a lecturer/demonstrator to mentor and coach. The benefit for the students is twofold: they can develop creative and critical thinking skills, which will, no doubt, be indispensable skills in their future careers, and it introduces them to an alternate approach to learning.

Of course, the big question is, how will I get the resources to facilitate this vision, but I think I have a solution. The maker movement is gaining traction and there are several maker spaces in Shenzhen where students can go to research and develop projects to solve various problems while using the maker space’s resources for a reasonable fee. Therefore, my school’s lack of technology may become a non-issue. Instead of spending money to purchase a lot of equipment, software, and other resources, it may make more financial sense to make use of pre-existing maker spaces–the fees paid would likely be less than purchasing a wide variety of technology and resources. We also would not be responsible for constant updates–thus softening the ill-effects of following trends

The challenges I anticipate facing upfront are largely administrative resistance. A colleague suggested that, before approaching the school administration, I try to anticipate the five issues they would have with my proposal if I presented it today, then come prepared with solutions. I think this is a good way to approach proposing a change in our approach to teaching. Another obstacle is how my colleagues will react to the change if the proposal is accepted. I find that most teachers are intimidated by technology and are reluctant to use it in their classrooms. Therefore, it may be difficult to effect large-scale change without smaller changes to test the waters and build teacher confidence. So, I’ve thought about trying to encourage a culture of sharing at my school by offering lunchtime talks/demonstrations of technology teachers could try out in their classes.

I’m optimistic and motivated, but also scared. I feel like I’m on my own on my mission to see my vision fulfilled. This brings me back to a goal from my flight path: to collaborate more. I think this will be essential as I move forward because collaboration will allow me to continue learning. It will also mean that I’m not travelling this path alone–support and guidance will be essential in evaluating how to move forward

New Media Consortium. (2014). NMC Horizon Report 2014: K-12 Edition. Retrieved from http://cdn.nmc.org/media/2014-nmc-horizon-report-k12-EN.pdf

5 comments

  1. Hi Meghan;

    It is nice to see that you have been putting a lot of thought into how best to serve your students’ needs in terms of digital literacy. I love the idea of using already-established IT centres instead of investing in a lot of money into technology yourselves.

    You must feel like the proverbial ‘lone wolf’ sometimes, but I think we all do to some degree. There is so much opportunity for change now, whenever you go out on a limb to implement something, you are bound to feel alone. Instead of looking down, just look to the side, and you’ll see all of us out on our own limbs right along side you! 😉

    Kind Regards,
    Tanya

    1. Hi Tanya.

      Thanks for the comment. I’m glad that my plan to use pre-established centres isn’t considered far-fetched. Sometimes I feel that schools are so set on being independent that they miss out on great opportunities just outside their doors.

      I must say, now that I’m nearing the end of the course, I’m really starting to feel like part of a learning community. It’s both inspiring and humbling to be surrounded by so many people from different career backgrounds with a similar, yet diverse, focus.

      –Meghan

  2. Hi Meghan,

    Great post!! You are clearly very reflective and thoughtful both about what your students’ needs are, but also about how your colleagues will be nurturing innovative pedagogies and technologies in their own spaces. Tanya is absolutely right: we are on the limbs right alongside you, and we are ‘lone nuts’ in our own sense of the word (I know this video is crazy, but it is so good and true: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fW8amMCVAJQ). This is part of why I got involved in the Twitter education community. I found people who were as isolated as I was, but doing the same things!

    I loved two quotes in your post:

    – “I would like to see my school move toward authentic learning opportunities with open-ended requirements for what/how technology is used.

    – “…they can develop creative and critical thinking skills, which will, no doubt, be indispensable skills in their future careers, and it introduces them to an alternate approach to learning.”

    Understanding that the way we do things in classrooms is not a way that is going to work for every student (especially with the futuristic and mysterious jobs line you discussed) is humbling, yet pivotal to our success in these teachings. Open-endedness in project criteria and skill development absolutely aid in making these experiences far more authentic and meaningful for students and it’s just a matter of time before your colleagues will see the benefits of these decisions you’re making. You are reflective and already thinking ahead – keep it up and find your tribe that will continue supporting you!

    Victoria

    1. Hi Victoria,

      Thanks for the thoughtful comments. I admire the community you have built on Twitter. Twitter is something I definitely need to pay more attention to. I’m not sure if Twitter will be my go-to medium, but I’m looking forward to sharing this journey to the future with others.

      I also want to thank you for all the helpful tips and advice during this course. Sometimes I felt like you were reading my mind because, I would go to Connect with a question or comment and you had often already asked it (and sometimes solved it).

      –Meghan

  3. Hi Meghan,
    I also come from a school that is not at the forefront of technology and although it is wonderful to avoid trends as you mentioned, I find that sometimes it solidifies teachers in their ways and makes them often oppose any “new” technology. Your maker space idea is a wonderful one, great way to reduce the costs and take advantage of such amazing technology. Your colleague’s advice is also very relevant, it is important, in my personal experience, to present a well prepared case and ensure, to a certain extent, that there is absolutely no reason for administration to refuse the change. I would suggest bringing up the idea to your colleagues as well, test the waters; therefore the decision does not come as a surprise or as a “top-down” directive. I would also suggest preparing for any questions and difficulties your colleagues might encounter to help reassure them and ease them into using and properly integrating your idea.
    Best of Luck
    Danielle

Leave a Reply