Categories
Uncategorized

First Sunday reflection; “Lima the Ironic”, and more

Since reading The Lettered City, Rama’s notion of a rigid order within the colonizer’s city planning has been stuck in my mind. So much so, that, in this past week’s numerous expeditions throughout Lima, I have been attempting to find this alleged ‘orderliness’; as of now I have found everything but. In a rather wonderful way, this city is the most chaotic and disorderly place I have seen in my life. The foot traffic is all over the place; vehicles swerve and gap one another while pigeons fly to and fro. The streets are filled with vendors of food, art, and massages; their stands are plastered against a background of rising towers that look incredibly out of place in and of themselves. This may be solely my interpretation, but the whole scene offers no semblance of ‘order’, and I love it. I believe this irony serves, at the very least, as some form of a ‘fuck you’ to the colonial powers that attempted to mold a perfectly orderly Lima. Indeed, I wondered whether this disorderliness that Lima has adopted was due to some failure by the Spanish or simply a symptom of something like a massive increase in population, or pressure over the centuries to grow in ways that reflected growth around the world. However, as I type this, I’ve realized that this question is not a simple “either/or” because Lima responding the pressures of Western modernity in the first place is rooted within its colonial past. Instead, I think the answer relates to our first discussion about the inability of a simulation to create something ‘real’. I believe that the Spanish failed in their goal of an orderly utopia due to the inevitability of reality. Of course, this questions whether Lima’s disorderliness is a ‘fuck you’, but I am choosing to interpret it as so because it makes me happy. Further,

By jshoudy

I'm entering my third year as a student at UBC, majoring in socio-cultural anthropology.

2 replies on “First Sunday reflection; “Lima the Ironic”, and more”

Hi darling! Loved how you used the readings to ground your observations of the city. Yes, it is indeed ironic that the supposedly ordered utopia of Lima is actually quite disordered in our experience galavanting around the city. I think a potential reason for this was that the ideal plan of the city for a specific moment in time. The city was not built with the intention of growth and the diverse people it would eventually hold. Thus, the rigid city plan was difficult to adapt to to the changing Lima and led the different parts of the city to fit together without harmony.

“This may be solely my interpretation, but the whole scene offers no semblance of ‘order’, and I love it.” It is also true that in chaos we could find a certain regularity, which is not exactly “order.” I think we agree that “order” as a geometrization of spaces, crowds, and emotions can only constantly fail. But it implies that there may be another organization that does not imply absolute chaos… as in the large Latin American cities. And I love it too.

Leave a Reply to Daniel Orizaga Doguim Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Spam prevention powered by Akismet