Although performance evaluation metrics do not deal with consumers directly, they have a major impact on employees. Take for example Suzanne’s blog post, which details Wells Fargos firing 30 employees because they were taking shortcuts in order to meet goals, displaying how dangerous and powerful metrics can be.
To my surprise, a corporation as successful as Microsoft also had their own share of performance evaluation issues. The multi-billion dollar corporation used to run a metric called stack ranking, which forced mangers to rank
employees as top, average, and poor performers. The metric established a competitive culture rather than the collaborative and innovative culture that Microsoft was intending for. It is easy to see how this metric caused issues such as absenteeism, motivation, and higher employee turnover. On the bright side, CEO of Microsoft Steve Ballmer recognized this flaw and implemented a new system which encourages teamwork and employee growth.
Although on the surface it might be easy to simply blame the employees, just like what Wells Fargos did, it is important to note that most people’s actions are motivated by the situations in which they are forced into.
Resources:
http://www.theverge.com/2013/11/12/5094864/microsoft-kills-stack-ranking-internal-structure