Tag Archives: love

Week 6 – My thoughts on Françoise Sagan’s “Bonjour Tristesse”

The text Bonjour Tristesse (1954) by Françoise Sagan for me was an exciting text, to say the least, and additionally kept me engaged till the very end. The novel discusses a relationship between a wealthy father and his daughter. The main character is a girl named Cécile who is 17 years old and changing her family dynamic. The change in this family dynamic is reflected at the start of the novel, where we are introduced to the characters and the father’s mistress (Sagan, 3). However, it is essential to note that the father does consider the main character’s feelings. Though the main character does reply that her father’s mistress, “Elsa would not get in our way” (Sagan, 4). The father’s relationships change based on a given amount of time, though the main character did accept it as the father’s new lifestyle after he had lost his wife. 

Though, there is something perverse about the mentality that Cécile has when it comes to being interested in other men. Such as, when there is a mention of a university student, she states that she “much preferred my father’s friends, men of fourty, who spoke to me with courtesy and tenderness,” (Sagan, 5). The relationship that Cécile has with her father must be incredibly embedded in her due to Cécile losing her mother figure and growing up without her mother. That makes me wonder whether Cécile may lack attention from her father, and due to that, she prefers “men of fourty,” (Sagan, 5). There is also the relationship that Cécile has with Anne, her mother’s closest friend. Such as, when Cécile’s mother had passed, it was Anne who “taught me something of life,” while her father was managing his grief (Sagan, 7). Throughout the novel, we understand that Anne has intentions are not pure, as Elsa’s feeling of being threatened could show that. There is also an aspect in the novel that Cécile takes another role. Cécile also takes on the role of an adult when it comes to her father. Such as when she states that her “father must be protected. He’s nothing but a big baby,” when it comes to Anne interrupting the lives of Cécile, her father, and Elsa (Sagan, 66). The protectiveness that Cécile feels could stem from the fact that since her father has multiple partners over a short period of time, Cécile is the constant female in her father’s life. Therefore, there could be an understanding that Cécile must approve or agree to a relationship with her father and guide him to the right woman. This is also shown with Cécile’s judgments of her father’s mistresses. 

Therefore a question that I would ask is: does it seem as though Cécile lacks affection or attention from her father? If so, how does this reflect their relationship?

 

-Muskan Shukla

My thoughts on Maria Luisa Bombal’s “The Shrouded Woman”

Maria Luisa Bombal’s text “The Shrouded Woman,” written in 1947, discusses the state between life and death. The main character seems to be recounting her relationships with people in the novel who come and visit her body. The narrator recalls events related and moves on towards peace and moving to the afterlife through this process. The novel highlights the role of women in relationships and the role that gender plays in creating a societal norm for how both men and women should act in society. 

One of the themes in the novel is the power men have over women. Additionally how women tend to be controlled by these men. For example; when the narrator states that men “once in their lifetime long to make some great renunciation; [. . .] to tear to pieces a butterfly, in order to feel themselves masters of their own destiny,” (The Shrouded Woman, 166). Additionally, the narrator had reflected, “I persisted in linking my life to yours, not understanding why love should be incompatible with your career,” (The Shrouded Woman, 166). This shows that women in this scenario are somewhat dependent on men, and men can leave women without remorse. The power dynamic is shown when the narrator states that they “not for a moment [. . .] think of the consequences of all this,” with “this” being the relationship that they were in (The Shrouded Woman, 169). In the end, the woman is left with memories of her lover. Therefore, the relationship between a man and woman in this society is one where the woman is dependent on the man regarding most aspects of the relationship, especially with a woman having a more profound emotional attachment to the man. On the other hand, the man is either moved by duty or can leave when they choose to. 

Another interesting notion presented in the novel is the role of death in regards to the act of recalling previous events. It seems as though the narrator questions the role of death and questions whether “must we die in order to know?” (The Shrouded Woman, 176). In this case, the “in order to know,” is related to how the people in the narrator’s lives are honest only after she has passed (The Shrouded Woman, 176). This is another norm that is a part of society, not to be openly honest about your feelings and rather present negative feelings such as ego to repress honesty. 

The questions that I would want to ask for this week are; 

How did gender become a means to decide societal and social norms?

Why does the narrator choose the temporal context of the time between life and death to discuss topics of gender and recollection?

 

– Muskan Shukla