Oshima Nagisa’s “Cruel Story of Youth” or “Naked Youth” (in Japanese, Seishun zankoku monogatari) was released in 1960, and stars Kawazu Yusuke and Kuwano Miyuki as Kiyoshi and Makoto, two young and confused lovers in a rather cruel and strange relationship. Both a gendai-geki and shomin-geki, the film follows the two throughout an urban environment in a modern setting. The film is quite explicit for its generation—there are somewhat frequent kissing scenes, women are beaten, and sex can be seen as the main driving factor of the plot.
The film begins with the young and attractive Makoto being driven home by a wealthy man at night. When the man tries to rape her, she is rescued by Kiyoshi, a young student. The two then begin to seemingly date, though initially Kiyoshi is very cruel and aggressive, unfairly forcing Makoto into having sex. Kiyoshi quickly discards her, but again saves her when she is caught up with some men at the bar who make business out of sex. Despite Kiyoshi’s criminal lifestyle and cruel treatment of her, Makoto claims she is in love and moves in with him, to her family’s discontent. Kiyoshi and Makoto begin swindling rich men out of their money, by using Makoto as bait for the rich men that pick her up. Makoto makes herself as vulnerable-seeming as she can, and when the men try to take her into a hotel, Kiyoshi shows up to heroically save her, and also to take money from the assailants.
Sex is often in the forefront of the film. Not only is it clearly suggested many times throughout the film, the plot is built around it. The film’s first conflict is a middle-aged man trying to rape the young Makoto. Kiyoshi saves her, but the next day pushes her into the water while playing on logs, and doesn’t let her out until she agrees to have sex. Right from the start, sex is the source of all the male characters’ motivations. When Kiyoshi and Makoto’s swindling is discovered, Kiyoshi blames it on the nature of these men themselves, saying that their use of cars and money to attract girls makes them at fault. However, one could argue Kiyoshi is no different, as he uses his youth and the strength and handsomeness that it brings to appear a hero. Kiyoshi, however, cheats on Makoto continuously. It would come as no surprise, and is quite believable, that Kiyoshi may have saved Makoto with only sex in mind. To further this, the very next day after saving her, he forces her to have sex with him.
The film also presents the youth as rebellious both to their family and Japanese rules and traditions. Both Makoto and Kiyoshi are at an age they should be living with their parents, but they end up living alone together. Kiyoshi appears to not attend school at all, despite being referred to as a student. Makoto’s promiscuous, untraditional lifestyle is allowed to proceed by her father, although to his other, older daughter’s displeasure. Makoto’s older sister was never allowed such a lifestyle, but the father justifies his ways by simply saying this is a new generation, and he doesn’t want to tell Makoto what she cannot do.
Considering this, it seems Oshima may be highlighting, and perhaps criticizing, the changes brought on by the American occupation that idealized freedom, and supported the breaking down of many traditions. Kiyoshi is a young man who does whatever he wants; one could argue he is free in a sense, but perhaps too free. He seems to have no moral basis—he acts merely upon lust and greed. He does not attend school and he does not work, rather, he makes money through minor criminal activities. While he is, arguably, free, his freedom in which he womanizes and cheats other men of their money is eventually his downfall. Perhaps Oshima’s film was a warning to the Japanese youth in this great period of change and westernization.
While the film was entertaining and thought-provoking, don’t expect much suspense or dramatic build-up. It seems more like a character study than a plot-driven movie, but this does not make it boring. Oshima identifies the core themes of youth, freedom, and sex early on, so it becomes quite enjoyable to see how these ideas progress and relate or conflict with the film. Viewers wary of sex or women being hit may be slightly disturbed by some scenes, but Oshima does not use such actions merely sensationally, but rather to highlight the perhaps excessive freedom of his characters. Overall, “Cruel Story of Youth” was an enjoyable film that will cater to those interested in deconstructions of traditional societal beliefs.