Death Note manga, anime, film(s)

For years I have been teaching graphic novels in ELL 2 and 3 classes. I think it is also suitable for grade 8s.

One of my favourites is Death Note.  It is probably one of the most popular graphic novels in Asia. It has been translated into 7 languages including English.

I use it to talk about concepts of vigilantism, due process, and weapons of mass destruction in contemporary society. I also tie it into Japanese value struggles between the pursuit of justice, the generation gap, and anti-war passive responses since World War II. Many articles in the English version of Japan Times about these issues.

Death Note

Manga series


Death Note (Japanese: デスノート Hepburn: Desu Nōto) is a Japanese manga series written by Tsugumi Ohba and illustrated by Takeshi Obata. The story follows Light Yagami, a high school student who stumbles across a mysterious otherworldly notebook: the “Death Note”, which belonged to the Shinigami Ryuk, and grants its user the power to kill anyone whose name and face he knows. The series centers around Light’s subsequent attempts to use the Death Note to change the world into a utopian society without crime and the subsequent efforts of L, a reclusive international criminal profiler, to apprehend him and end his reign of terror.

I honestly only get to teach the first five anime episodes, the part 1 TV series movie, and the first three of the revised Live action TV series. The plots differ in each so there is a great opportunity to teach alternative story lines and contrast/compare plots.

I have a whole slew of activities which you can preview on my website

http://scharlescoderre.com/curriculum

These include the legends of Grim Reapers across various cultures and a look at the Faustian choice stories starring the Devil (which essentially is at the core of Death Note). You can also pull in anti bullying issue and strategies as one theme extension.

Many students get highly engaged with Death Note and will finish the entire set of novels, TV series, and movies on their own time. Just remind them not to stay up all night, to do their other homework, and to get outside because these novels are highly addictive.

There is a recent USA version on Netflix starring Willam Defoe as the Death God Ryuk.  That adaptation has the associated controversy of “white washing” (though L is black) and not using Asian actors. I find it the weakest of all versions because of poor acting. The newer version of the updated Japanese TV series is also on Netflix.

Posted in Uncategorized | 3 Comments

Jacob’s Ladder (film) and Occurence at Owl Creek Bridge (short story)

These films/stories below – with the theme of life just before/after death are good to show in a class of rowdy self assured (even cocky students) who seem very disengaged.  However, if the class has many students (even one) with anxiety or who are easily triggered and you want a Halloween theme. Teach Death Note instead 🙂

Jacob’s Ladder is probably one of the most psychologically scary movies made in the last 30 years. I show the PG grade 10-11 students in October before Halloween. I also tie it into Remembrance Day. Preview carefully because you may not want to show all parts.  In fact the R rated version is very disturbing in some parts and I wouldn’t show it to secondary students. (This is not a slasher movie or torture porn though.)

Jacob’s Ladder stars Tim Robbins as a Vietnam war vet recovering after being hospitalized back in the USA.  He finds out that demons are following him through the streets. He finds some measure of protection from his chiropractor who symbolizes his guardian angel.

Wikipedia description:

Jacob’s Ladder (1990 film)

1990 film by Adrian Lyne


Jacob’s Ladder is a 1990 American psychological horror film directed by Adrian Lyne, produced by Alan Marshall, written by Bruce Joel Rubin and starring Tim Robbins, Elizabeth Peña, and Danny Aiello. The film’s protagonist, Jacob, is a Vietnam veteran whose experiences prior to and during the war result in strange, fragmentary flashbacks and bizarre hallucinations that continue to haunt him. As his ordeal worsens, Jacob desperately attempts to figure out the truth.

Reviews:

Jacob’s Ladder – Review and summary – Roger Egbert

https://www.google.ca/url?q=https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/jacobs-ladder-1990&sa=U&ved=0ahUKEwjC1u2JqaTcAhVtIDQIHWiIBqYQFgg7MA8&usg=AOvVaw02ksYYw_QztxZ-iAJW6mZX

 

An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge

Short story by Ambrose Bierce


An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” (1890) is a short story by the American writer and Civil War veteran Ambrose Bierce.[1]Regarded as “one of the most famous and frequently anthologized stories in American literature”,[2]it was originally published by The San Francisco Examiner on July 13, 1890, and was first collected in Bierce’s book Tales of Soldiers and Civilians (1891). The story, which is set during the American Civil War, is known for its irregular time sequence and twist ending. Bierce’s abandonment of strict linear narration in favor of the internal mind of the protagonist is an early example of the stream of consciousness narrative mode.[3]

I haven’t seen it but there is also a short film version.

Other films you could pair it with are Lost Boys and Flatliners (the originals). Also  whole slew of what-happens-when/after-you-die articles.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Film – Empire of the Sun (Spielberg)

Wikipedia description:

Empire of the Sun (film)

1987 American coming of age war film by Steven Spielberg


Empire of the Sun is a 1987 American epic coming-of-age war film based on J. G. Ballard‘s semi-autobiographical novel of the same name. It was directed by Steven Spielberg and stars John Malkovich, Miranda Richardson, Nigel Havers, and Christian Bale. The film tells the story of Jamie “Jim” Graham, a young boy who goes from living in a wealthy British family in Shanghai, to becoming a prisoner of war in a Japanese internment camp, during World War II.

————————

I find this film useful to teach in ELL Socials Level 3.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Children’s Book ban in Surrey – a history

Children’s book banning – especially of LGBT text – has a unique and landmark history in BC.  It involved a school board with a fundamental Christian chair, a gay teacher couple, and the Supreme Court of Canada.  The lasting legacy is subtle now but still deeply profound. Though historical record now, I feel this history is vital for all BC Teachers to be aware of (wow, if I must say so myself eh 🙂

Here is a summary by the BCTF and below are more links.

Surrey book banning case

“In 1997… three children’s books (Belinda’s Bouquet, Asha’s Mums, and One Dad, Two Dads, Brown Dads, Blue Dads) were submitted to the Surrey School Board for approval for use in Kindergarten and Grade 1 as resources for the personal planning curriculum. The books feature children who have two moms or two dads. The board refused to allow the books to be used …because parents complained that their religious beliefs would be offended.”
-Murray Corren, honourary lifetime member, in Teacher  May/June 2002.

In the ensuing six-year battle, James Chamberlain, the teacher originally requesting board approval, along with Murray, his partner Peter Corren, Surrey parent Dianne Willcott, and lawyer Joe Arvey asserted that “the ban imposed by the board breached the School Act, which requires that public schools be conducted on “strictly secular” principles, precluding the board’s decision’s being “significantly influenced by religious considerations.” (Corren, 2002)

“Teacher-librarians and the BCTF proved to be outstanding allies in this fight against censorship over the years. BCTF locals and teachers gave generously to the fundraising campaign for us as the petitioners in this precedent setting case. Courageous Kindergarten and Grade 1 teachers in different school districts read these books in their classrooms and were instrumental in filing affidavits in the courts that resulted in an eventual win by a decisive seven-to-two margin at the Supreme Court of Canada.”
-James Chamberlain

Globe and Mail article 2002

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/school-board-bans-books-showing-gay-families/article22733504

xtra.ca article 2003

https://www.dailyxtra.com/surrey-reconsiders-book-ban-43901

Excerpt:

Like Justice Saunders before her, Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin found the school board violated the secular nature of BC’s School Act when it based its decision on religious concerns.

The board used the wrong criteria to evaluate those books, McLachlin ruled. It should have judged the books using the same curriculum-based criteria it applies to all other potential books.

Trustees are supposed to evaluate proposed books based on the contribution they could make to students’ learning, the quality of their storytelling, their nice illustrations, their use of good grammar and other such considerations-not the fact that they mention same-sex families.

“The board was not permitted to reject the books simply because certain parents found the relationships depicted in them controversial or objectionable,” McLachlin ruled.

Nor was she swayed by the trustees’ argument that five-year-olds are too young to hear about same-sex families. “Tolerance is always age appropriate,” McLachlin wrote, before she, too, sent the decision back to the school board for reconsideration.

———————————

On June 13 2003 the Surrey School board voted again, in spite of Supreme Court ruling to ban the books a second time

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/school-board-bans-books-showing-gay-families/article22733504/

Excerpt:

 

In arguing against the books this time, the dissenting board members said the grammar, continuity and various non-sexual messages the books portray do not fit the board’s criteria for appropriate learning aids.

Ms Polak said her board has accepted the Supreme Court’s ruling and is only concerned with how the topic of same-sex parents will be addressed.

“Frankly these books don’t do a very good job of it,” she said.

“You select the best of the best, especially in regards to a topic that is full of a lot of controversy and that people are really concerned about and you have to make sure you do that in the right way.”

A spokeswoman for the conservative lobby group Focus on the Family was satisfied with the decision and said it’s time to move on.

“Certainly there are more pressing needs in the school district then focusing on one or two learning resources,” said Anne Marie White.

But James Chamberlain, a gay teacher who first brought the books forward seven years ago and spearheaded the legal fight to overturn the initial ban, said he wasn’t buying the board’s new reasoning.

No other book in Surrey would pass the board’s criteria, he said. The books depict children living with same-sex parents but contain no mention of sex.

While not surprised by the vote, Mr. Chamberlain said the board is “grasping at straws” and used criteria that had not been brought up in six years of litigation.

He particularly questioned the board’s reason for banning Belinda’s Bouquet on the basis that the dieting issues the book discusses are not suitable for young children.

“That’s like saying Jack and the Beanstalk will encourage children to engage in theft, or Goldilocks and the Three Bears to engage in breaking and entering,” said Mr. Chamberlain. “It’s just a ludicrous argument.”

Mr. Chamberlain said he may go back to court to have the new ban overturned.

————————-

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/school-board-rejects-books-with-gay-parents-for-bad-grammar-1.392499

The board came to the same conclusion Thursday night, but for different reasons this time.

“This story has problems with punctuation and grammar throughout. The spelling of ‘favourite’ is inconsistent, switching from the Canadian to the American,” said board chair Mary Polak about Asha’s Mums.

The board also criticized the book’s depiction of men.

Belinda’s Bouquet was rejected because it raised the subject of dieting.

“To discuss the issue of dieting as it relates to body image is risky at this age, and I think clumsily handled in this story,” said Polak.

The board rejected One Dad, Two Dads, Brown Dad, Blue Dads because it said it made fun of skin colours and dealt too much with sexual orientation for its intended audience of kindergarteners.

James Chamberlain, a kindergarten teacher who tried to bring Asha’s Mums into his class six years ago, says he wasn’t surprised by the board’s ruling, but says the reasons are weak.

“The board is grasping at straws, dreaming up criteria six years after the fact,” he said.

————————

So as far as I know that is how it ended up. The books were ultimately banned for other reasons, but from 2002 no school Board could ban a book based on LGBT content or moral objections from parents that are not consistent with secular schools. Chair Mary Polacco became a BC Liberal MLA (Langley) and has been elected three times since 2005., James Chamberlain  went on to form Gay and Lesbian Educators (GALE) BC to support queer educators and students.

This Supreme Court ruling might be used to challenge the new Ontario Ford’s government rescinding their new sex Ed curriculum based mainly on these historic arguments. (Offending the conservative religious objections of parent groups).

This is one of many academic papers that came out of the Surrey Book Ban case:

BANNING BOOKS, BURNING BRIDGES: RECOGNIZING STUDENT FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION RIGHTS IN CANADIAN CLASSROOMS

https://ojs.library.dal.ca/djls/article/viewFile/4219/3860

Abstract:

In Canada, books and magazines are regularly intercepted at the border and are consistently removed from libraries, schools and bookstores. The banning of books is a controversial topic that involves issues of cen- sorship and freedom of expression rights. The Supreme Court of Cana- da recently examined the issue in Chamberlain v. Surrey School District No. 36, where it was found that the School Board acted unreasonably in banning several books depicting same sex couples. The Court, however, did not consider the freedom of expression rights of students in reaching their decision. Despite this recent opportunity to comment on a studentʼ’s right to information, Canadian jurisprudence remains silent on the is- sue of student freedom of expression rights in the banning of books from schools. Using Chamberlain as a backdrop, this paper will argue that a liberal interpretation of studentʼ’s freedom of expression rights by the courts would provide much needed guidance for educators in making curriculum selections. The recognition of such rights would place the interests of the students first in pedagogical decision-making, enhance democratic functions within schools, and encourage a rights discourse to shape the classroom environment.

 

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

interdisciplinary picture books

I remember in a Writer’s Craft course in grade 11, we wrote poems, and then passed them along to an art class to have them illustrate our work. They were not given any context or insight about the poems, so their illustrations reflected how they read/connected to them personally. I remember writing a very dramatic sonnet called “Wicked White Walls” and thought I was so deep and reflective. Our teacher compiled everything together and had a book printed and bound for our entire class. (As an (almost) educator, I look back at this now and can appreciate all of this extra time and effort so much more than I did at the time as a student. Yay for passionate educators.)  I think creating a picture book in this same manner would be a really interesting project. Has anyone had any success doing something like this, or with interdisciplinary connections in general??

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Silent Book Collection

This was the project that Dr. Shoemaker mentioned! It was started as a response to the waves of refugees from Africa and the Middle East arriving in the Italian island. This is a great tool or even an idea for activities/projects for classes that may have many ELL students!

 

http://www.ibby.org/awards-activities/activities/silent-books/?L=0#

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Virginia Wolf by Kyo Maclear

This was one of the books Dr. Shoemaker brought in and I was blown away! Everything from the writing style, images, and underlying themes really caught my attention. I highly recommend checking it out if you haven’t already! I believe this is a great book to bring in during a mental health unit or to just simply teach patience and understanding. 

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Dr. Kathy Shoemaker and Visual Literacy

I enjoyed Dr. Shoemaker’s presentation and agreed with her points about the importance of visual literacy. In fact, I learnt how to close read text by close reading images first. I believe this is the case for many people, but many do not realize this. It was not until I took a first year literature course when I was introduced to actively “reading” images and then transferring these same skills to text. I can definitely see myself bringing in picture books/graphic novels into my future classes!

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Picture Book

For anyone wanting to explore some more picture books, this is one that I was just introduced to in my Indigenous Ed class, and I would definitely recommend it! It explores the theme of reclaiming language.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

The Dictionary of Obscure Sorrows

The Dictionary of Obscure Sorrows is this beautiful project that y’all should check out. The creator aims to capture very real human experiences within a made-up word. A few of the words have been made into stunning videos as well – I’ve attached a personal favourite, check it out!

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment