Why the kids and not the parents?

This book, by far, has been my favorite read for this class.

Do you blame the nanny? I don’t.

Leila Slimani does an amazing job in crafting a narrative that fits everyone’s biases. Through Slimani’s story, to blame or not to blame the nanny is a byproduct of the reader’s own biases. What do you notice, what details strike you the most, how far your analysis of class, race, and gender dynamics can overcome the gory aspects of what happened?

Louise

Overview

We can agree that Louise was not just a nanny, she was a cleaner, a cook, interior designer, planner, teacher, and entertainer. However, she was just still paid for being a nanny, aka take care of the children. Some people could argue that no one asked her to be all of those things, that it was actually on her and her strange obsession with taking over the lives of the Masses.

Only a few times did the Masses, especially Paul, worry about “the nanny’s long hours” because he doesn’t want “her to accuse us of exploiting her one day” (p. 54). Myriam said she will fix the problem. She confronts Louise but ends up “thrilled” that Louise takes it upon herself, it is her fault. This is followed by small apologies once in a while, cheap gifts, and used clothes.

Did she have OCD?

Imagine being secluded in a strangers apartment, taking care of two children, surrounded by dirt and messyness. Imagine forcing yourself to not clean, to not organize because you are not being paid to do it. Nevertheless you are still forced to come to that space everyday. Dishes pilling up, dust, dirty clothes, the smell of trash. Would you be able to spend your entire day without taking care of the mess of a stranger without being paid for it?

Maybe, we could argue that she did not have to go that far. But, what if you were scared to not find another job? How can you prove to your employers that you are the right choice? How can you prove you are irreplaceable to secure your job that has no protections?

Maybe, we could argue that she just wanted the life of the Masses, to live a fantasy of what life could be, of motherhood, homemaking, and domesticity. For this specific point I want to argue that this is the capitalist fantasy that fits Louises’ background, a fantasy that is hard to question because it’s not 100% chosen. Instead, to an extent, it is imposed by the circumstances, by her past, her background, money, lack of proper stable housing, etc.

Contradictions and Rebellion

Throughout the book we see a weird fight between the desire and hate for this chosen/imposed fantasy. Moments of lucidity become more common as Louise becomes a “more accepted” part of the family. Like glitches in the matrix, Louise becomes more open and vulnerable to the truths she hides, the humanity in her. In the Masses’ trip to Greece, Louise is able to taste a bit of those privileges she once should have deserved just because of the color of her skin. For instance, autonomy weirdly becomes natural the moment she pushes Mila at the beach. She is annoyed, but she no longer performs, she reacts like the real parents of the child: irritation, boundaries, and selfishness.

When they go for dinner, the three of them, for the first time, Louise almost gets the courage to “tell them something — doesn’t matter what, something about her — but she doesn’t dare” (p.76) Why is she so scared? When was the last time you felt that scared to talk about yourself to someone? Is it just the fear of being unprofessional?

The more this lucidity is noticed in Louise, the more annoyed the Masses get, the more worried they are that they are giving too much to Louise. Resentful. The worry is no longer that she is doing too much, it is that they, instead might be giving her too much. The amount of work becomes normal, their gestures of appreciation, of caution, have become excessive.

Are this really gestures of appreciation? Why is increasing her paycheck not an option? They can afford a trip, an expensive watch, impulsive shopping, hosting friends at their home, but not increase Louise paycheck? Why, weirdly, it feels like they are being so nice to Louise. Did you get deceived? The Masses are giving Louise what rich people think can replace money. Social and cultural capital are the main currency. They are giving her a taste of their life, a peek into their privacy, a spot that can only be taken by people of the same class. Pity is not empathy.

Beyond class dynamics

However, we should not see Louise only as a victim either. She also is a privileged person in comparison to other people in the book. Here is where the complexity of the book and the blame becomes tricky.

“No illegal immigrants, agreed?”

She is chosen, she is different. She is not like the other nannies. Racism and Xenophobia.

Louise knows that she is special and she loves it. She knows she has an advantage, that the fantasy she chose fits her and attracts others.

She doesn’t need to pay or fake marriage for her papers, like Wafa did.

Her isolation, to an extent, is chosen. The people that are naturally around her do not fit the fantasy she belongs to.

She is respected by the friends of the Masses, she is respected in the streets, by her landlord, no one questions her capacity to do her job. She is respected by the masses, she is feared, to an extent by Myriam.

However, as we advance through the book we can see that her whiteness and her femininity are not enough to escape the misfortunes and judgements that being poor brings.

Here is where the understanding or at least a message that I think Slimani is trying to convey is that maybe these features, these privileges, are what makes Louise so dangerous in comparison to the other nannies. For Louise it is easier to accept and embrace the fantasy, but at the same time it is easier for her to understand that the fantasy is not real, that she deserves a different fantasy or that, if nothing else, she has more of a chance to force that fantasy into reality.

The unquestioned historical privileges that she embodies as a French woman, blind her from her own reality.

For Myriam a similar opposite process happens too, her historically unquestioned imposed disadvantages blind her from her own actions, from her desires to perform and achieve a different kind of fantasy.

A society of disconnection, where sorority is a threat to your own capitalist endeavors.

This is just a very superficial aim to understand some of the dynamics the Slimani carefully crafts in her book. There is so much to say about Myriam, Paul, and the kids, but this will make the blog into a paper.

To conclude, I will say: I do not think we can only blame Louise for what happened. Do you?

Comments Off on Why the kids and not the parents?

“a language playground, as diaries so frequently are” – Almeida’s That Hair

This week I struggled a lot with finishing this book. I am not sure if it is just the fact that I have been extremely sick for the last couple of days that has made my attention hard to control. Or maybe it was the fact that the book made me remember too much amidst the passing of my grandfather.

I have to admit too that this has been a more engaging and difficult book than the others that we have read for this class. I believe I have to read it a couple of times to actually grasp all the ideas Almeida is trying to transmit her readers.

My first thought when starting the novel is, what is this man doing? I am not sure if I am just not used to reading that many books with excerpts from the translators. Maybe I just always skip them. They are too distracting. I felt Eric M. B. Becker’s introduction to the Almeida’s family album completely disrupted my mind to immerse myself properly in the words of the author. I guess it is important to hear the process of what the translator went through, some of their thoughts, because, of course, to an extent, they do kind of become co-authors of the novel (in a weird way). I just felt completely disturbed, as if my own interpretations of what I was about to read were already tainted by someone else’s ideas.

Anyway, maybe it is my crazy ibuprofen sick thoughts that made me feel a bit iffy throughout the book when understanding who was the person behind the process of re-imagining the words of the author, of a foreign experience, a foreign life. Maybe I was more conscious of the process of translation. I felt sad that I had this big wall between my reading and the author’s ideas and memories. A disconnection I could only solve by reading the original.


This is also the first book that forced me to write little notes and quotes in my notebook. I felt scared of letting them go too easily. Two things for this blog:

First, of course one of the times Almeida explains the process Mila goes through when growing up through her hair: “prior to the advance of my aesthetic frustrations into a disgust that lasts the entire day, like a moral failing, a curse.” This moment in the book made it clear that the main way we understand to hate ourselves when growing up, mostly in our puberty/teenage years, is through the comments of adults, specifically grown women, women that we are supposed to trust.

Do you recall the first time you were curious about makeup? It starts as a fun game, right? Until the moment it mutates into a frustration, a cry for help. Suddenly when looking at yourself in the mirror, new monsters start popping up. Your hairy eyebrows, your new pimples, the big dark undereyes, your flat eyelashes, your crooked teeth. What once looked just like a face, a part of your body, becomes the centre of attention for main despair: how can I fix it to look more beautiful? Makeup becomes a tool for deceiving, to forget the monsters. I remember being 12 years old and feeling a horrible amount of dread when I had to get out of my house and didn’t have enough time to put on a bit of concealer, a bit of eyeliner, a bit of mascara. I felt like the most horrible person on the planet. The looks: they probably are noticing the things that I am so desperately trying to hide. I was a child! For God’s Sake!

Second, the family album. “Perhaps then it will be clear to me the way all of childhood is a childhood album, when the day arrives that this book is my oxygen and I can no longer remember what I’ve recounted in its pages.” Holy mother of God. That moment broke me. After a weird overlap of me going through my teenage diaries and family pictures I was able to salvage in my few trips back home, I understood how precious this book was. Beyond style, beyond literature, this was a piece of history, an autofiction, a family heirloom.

Pages later Almeida says: “the 20th century would come to a close in 2014, the year my grandfather died.” The book was originally published a year after. I cried. After my grandfather died I have not been able to stop writing. There is a door that opens when someone in your family passes away. It opens to questions you were previously banned to ask, a lot of silences that become so loud there is no way you can’t ignore them. I am not sure if I am making a point in this last reflection but I guess what I am trying to say is that the symbols that exist in this book just speak so loudly to the a lot of the wounds and hopes that comes when trying to understand your identity and what a monumental place (for good or for bad) your family takes when trying to unravel it.

Comments Off on “a language playground, as diaries so frequently are” – Almeida’s That Hair

“Mi historia es mi cuerpo, soy el cuerpo mío” – ITA by Mónica Albizúrez

I am embarrassed to confess this is one of the most recent central american contemporary novels written by a woman that I have read so far, after, of course, Jacinta Escudos.

This novel has forced me to think about the importance of your own intersections to match those of the writers of the books that you read. Do I carry a birth given social bias? Or as someone from such a small region in the world, a region that is accustomed to silences and where we learn to ignore our problems by ignoring the importance of literature, accessing books like Albizurez’s is so hard/inaccessible that it makes you believe that your experiences/your life are/is not book/novel-worthy?

This book might not be Nobel prize worthy, but damn, the difference that it makes to see yourself, your culture, your pains, the places that you have inhabited, the histories that you have learned in school and at home reflected in the pages of a book, being part now of the word of literature. I have to confess that this book sparked some intense visceral reactions in me, a bunch of incomprehensible emotions that the other books we have read for this class have not caused.


What is this book about? This ia a story about inherited wounds and the slow, painful labour of seeing clearly of swimming against your inherited current. Ita, a successful upper-middle class lawyer in her forties, is diagnosed with fibromyalgia, a chronic pain with no visible cause. This illness becomes a metaphor for what the novel is really about: a suffering that lives in the body but originates elsewhere, in a family history and a national history that were never spoken aloud.

Her search for the meaning of her pain leads her back to her mother, an artist who abandoned her career during Guatemala’s 36-year long armed conflict, and through her, to the silences that structured her entire upbringing. As Ita revisits her childhood, she begins to pull back the blurry curtain that kept her from seeing the realities around her: the class tensions within her own parents’ relationship, the way her family treated the domestic workers, most of them Indigenous, as part of the household yet invisible within it, and the lies she was told about a murder that her family chose to bury rather than confront.

What emerges is a portrait of generational trauma not as a single event, but as a system of omissions passed down from one generation to the next. Ita comes to understand that her privilege depended on not seeing, and that the racism and classism of Guatemalan society were not distant forces but intimate ones, present even in the most private spaces of her life. The novel questions the idea of innocence in times of war, suggesting that even a child raised in comfort is shaped by the violence that surrounds her.

Ultimately, Ita is a novel about awakening. By confronting her family’s past, Ita confronts the country’s (to an extent), and in naming what was hidden, she begins to make sense of a pain that was never only her own.


I have to acknowledge that this novel shares some of the pitfalls we identified in our discussion of Kim Thúy’s Ru. Albizúrez, like Thúy, narrates a pain that is not entirely her own, speaking from a position of relative privilege compared to those who directly suffered the civil war and genocide in Guatemala. However, I believe Albizúrez handles this tension with greater self-awareness. Rather than claiming to know her place, she makes the uncertainty of that place the subject of the novel itself: Ita is still working out whether she is an observer, a beneficiary, a perpetrator, or a victim, and the narrative never resolves that question too comfortably.

My question for this week: How does your reading experience change when a book is written not only by a woman, but by a woman who shares other parts of your identity, such as your country, region, language, social class, or generation? Do you find yourself drawn to authors whose backgrounds resemble your own, or does it not matter much to you?

Comments Off on “Mi historia es mi cuerpo, soy el cuerpo mío” – ITA by Mónica Albizúrez

Carmen Mola

Here’s a little scandal from a few years back…

A Spanish woman wins a prestigious literary prize, marketed as “Spain’s Elena Ferrante,” but she turned out to be not a woman but three men.

Spanish media noted that publicity for the books had played off the tensions between the apparent creator’s life and “her” creations.

“It hasn’t escaped anyone’s notice that the idea of a university professor and mother of three, who taught algebra classes in the morning then wrote ultra-violent, macabre novels in scraps of free time in the afternoon, made for a great marketing operation,” Spanish paper El Mundo noted in an interview with the authors.

Beatriz Gimeno, a feminist, writer, activist – and former head of one of Spain’s national equality bodies, the Women’s Institute – attacked the men for creating a female persona in their publicity for Carmen Mola books, over several years.

“Quite apart from using a female pseudonym, these guys have spent years doing interviews. It’s not just the name – it’s the fake profile that they’ve used to take in readers and journalists. They are scammers,” she said on Twitter.

Their agent’s website features a photo of a woman, looking away from the camera, on the author profile page, above a flattering comparison with Italian literary sensation Ferrante.

Last year, a regional branch of the Women’s Institute recommended one of Mola’s works as part of a selection of books by female authors including Margaret Atwood that could “help us understand the reality and the experiences of women in different periods of history and contribute to raising awareness about rights and freedoms.”

See also for instance Mina Samuels, “Betrayed by Carmen Mola: What We Lose When a Successful Female Author Turns Out to Be Three Men” (December 14, 2021):

If Elena Ferrante turns out to be many men, I will be even more disappointed. A woman’s voice created by a committee of men feels minimizing, as if women aren’t individuals, but rather a lumpy mass of stereotypes. There’s a demeaning aspect to the idea that the individuality of any one woman’s psyche (Inspector Elena Blanco, in this case) can be written by consensus. I know that the practice is commonplace in the television world, where Carmen Mola’s true trio comes from.

[. . .]

I believe that in the particular case of Carmen Mola, my freedom of choice outweighs the author’s freedom to choose their disguise. After all, what do the authors gain by changing gender? They gain credibility for their female police inspector. And, possibly, they gain readers like me, who love thrillers and want to prioritize female authors. Both of those gains are ill-gotten.

It is certainly true that in the past (and perhaps even now) women authors have gained a lot by disguising themselves as men—the right to publish a novel period, or a more appreciative audience who was not judging their writing and content based primarily on their gender and/or protection from the vitriol so often aimed at women with something substantive to say.

I acknowledge that I am wading into deep and fraught waters here by invoking and giving importance to an author’s gender. I offer my view here with deep respect for each writer’s individual voice and expression, recognizing that in other situations the use of a pseudonym may serve a higher purpose than my freedom of choice.

And to give a sense of the discourse before the “revelation,” look at María Fasce, “¿Quién es Carmen Mola?” (June 15, 2018).

Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Carmen Mola

Brutally Honest, Brutally Beautiful: Sinfonia em branco by Lisboa

It has been a few hours since I finished the book and I do not seem to know how to make justice to the book through this blog.

In comparison to Kim Thúy, I believe Lisboa makes a better work at portraying memory through generational trauma narrative. I love how she makes us jump from different points of views across different time periods (it reminds me a bit of Emiliano Monge in Justo Antes del Final). But more than being fragmented snippets (as we saw with Thuy), Lisboa weaves each memory and even each forgetting in such a beautiful visual conversation.

There is a specific scene where the sisters, Maria Inês and Clarice, are bathing their mother, where their conversation turns into a poem. Gorgeous. This scene reminded me of the moment in the movie A Separation by Asghar Farhadi, where the son is washing his dad:

Even though they are from really different contexts and stories, I believe there is space to put these two scenes in conversation with each other to talk about the ways that gender dynamics affects the ways that daughters/sons confront the last stages of a parent life, when the roles flips completely making the silences, the tensions, become so loud that are too hard to ignore.

In general, these scenes, for me, represent a decision: mercy.


I love how Lisboa, throughout the entire book, pushes the abuser to the sidelines of the narrative. Nothing really points out to the father having anything to do with the hints of trauma that we get throughout the character’s stories. At best we try to blame his absence and the rigidity of a mother not capable of loving for the difficulties their daughters have to face when they try to create their own families when they grow up. Easy to blame the mom, huh? The dad, even in his absence, takes up a secondary role in the trauma inflicted. It is not until Otacília dies, that he starts taking more of a primary role in the book, that our attention is briefly occupied by his nuisance. In general he is just that, un estorbo. Until we go back, again, to that memory: Maria Inê’s memory, a memory once ignored by us, the readers, and by Maria Inê herself.

It is fascinating how accurately the book portrays the way families conceal abusers in real life. As a reader, Lisboa forces you to reproduce the forgetting and the silences needed to be complicit with the violence, with the abuser, of course, this time, unintentionally. But unintentionally, you also become complicit in toxic family dynamics in real life. You have bits and pieces that, with, perhaps, more questions, with, perhaps, more curiosity, with, perhaps, more attention, with, perhaps, more overthinking, you might be able to piece together those snippets of memory before the narrative explicitly reveals the truth about what happened; the truth behind all those little and big decisions that the characters seem to take out of the blue, that helps people around them perceive them as “bad daughters” as “bad adults” as “crazy women,” specifically, of course, in the way Clarice is perceived after her “irrational” decisions.

Question: What’s your stance towards Otacília?

Comments Off on Brutally Honest, Brutally Beautiful: Sinfonia em branco by Lisboa

Snippets of Thoughts: Ru

I honestly do not have a lot of inspiration to write this post. I read the book, it was ok.

The book reminded me of this short video that, if you have been to Dunbar theater you might recall, where they depict a Vietnamese family leaving their country escaping the communist, followed a warm welcome by a Canadian soldier:

I honestly feel it gives hints of propaganda. Just reproduces the us and them narrative. Weird timing too, just amidst Canada having its most aggressive immigration policy reversal in decades. I do believe the book Ru provides a more balanced perspective on the events that led to them fleeing the country.

It was interesting to see a new perspective (those from the South of Vietnam, the rich, the ones who did not fear the U.S.). I guess she was privileged, then not at all, then a little bit, and then privileged again but with nuance? Of course this is extremely reductionist.

Things that caught my attention in comparison/contrast to the other books we read:

  • the generational trauma still there, but she has kind of solved the puzzle more than the other characters from the other books we have read? Is it money? Rag to riches experiences give you more perspective?

  • Motherhood is less complicated? She sounds more healed than the other characters from the other books?

  • She is probably also neurodivergent, but weirdly she doesn’t explicitly mentions it. I liked this new layer to the narrative, yet it was not that developed.

  • We never get to know any real details of the main character outside of her trauma, and her kids. We get a bit about her sexuality, a bit about the husband, her trips, her jobs, but all too faint to make a real picture of who she is. Maybe that’s the point? So a lot of women with similar experience, beyond Vietnamese, can relate to her story of overcoming migration, war, etc…?

Overall, I didn’t like the way the book is written. I felt it was too choppy? I guess my question is if you see any purpose in a book written like that? Less like a diary, but more like snippets? Maybe the author is trying to get to the idea of how memory, how stories are actually felt and lived, they are fragmented? They are just pieces, they come and go, some have continuity, others don’t, some have more purpose than others.

I guess throughout the book I got excited about some themes that popped up in some of the snippets, but the author did not develop any of those. I felt like I was on a boring roller coaster; there is no climax I guess? Maybe migration feels like that?

Apologies for the scattered thoughts, my brain decided to repeat the style of what I just read.

Comments Off on Snippets of Thoughts: Ru

A girl for sale

First impression: In an attempt to not say that I did not like the book, I will say, what the hell was that?

After a few second thoughts: okay, interesting? Maybe, I get the point?

My first question then is: Who are we blaming?

Are we blaming the poor family? The poor mother? Are we blaming the rich women? The girl herself? The new baby? The old dad (the carabiniere)? The new partner of Adalgisa (Guido)?

It is way easier to understand (at least for me) why the girl (our main character) was kind of taken away from her first family so easily. It reminds me a lot of those international adoptions in Latin America during a conflict, where rich people, usually from the Global North, easily adopt kids from Indigenous or war-torn communities. Under the cover of a “good deed,” rich people get away from the forced displacement that made a kid just go through, the usual lies, the erasure of their past, just for the kid to grow up and find out (most of the time) a tragic/terrible story that could be summarized as “kidnapping.”

But on the other hand, we could ask: what other life would this baby have lived had they weren’t taken away? Poverty? Lack of love? Death? Why are our answers always so negative? Well, because we know the reality of a lot of abandoned kids or orphans that had to face the realities of their communities after war/repression was over. But still, how can we be sure that the future of that kid would have been worse?

I believe it will be unfair to blame the biologial/poor family. Similar to how the girl at the end starts feeling guilt for rejecting some of the gifts from Adalgisa (because then she was denying these privileges to her little sister), I can see the mom thinking this same way when thinking how denying Adalgisa her own daughter would have been an act/decisions out of selfishness.

Can we blame Adalgisa (what a bi*c*)? I think we get at the end the vibes of “actually, if we are more critical of the situation, Adalgisa is just a victim of the horrible/angry/deceiving man.” I don’t buy it.

What about the assh*** of the carabiniere? What a joke that he can’t take care of the girl, why revenge Adalgisa’s affair with that little girl?

Second question: Was the secrecy necessary?

No

Third question: What does Adriana represent in the story?

Here is where the story is saved. The concept of motherhood gets distorted symbolically and textually throughout the novel, ending in maybe the idea that mothering is not an act done by someone who gives birth to you, and that it is unfair to see like that? I don’t know.

Extra general thought:

While I was trying to finish the novel yesterday, I understood why classes like this are necessary. Reading more women makes you more empathetic with other women, and with yourself if you identify as a woman. We tend to read mostly men writing (either literature or more academic writing). We could definitely pin point classes where most of our readings are just men, or even when all readings are just men. Is this the same case with other classes? No, unless they are specifically about feminism or (like this one) about women writers. I do not think enough women have read enough women, and (of course) I do not think enough men have read enough women.

Comments Off on A girl for sale

Good morning, my name is…

Hi everyone, I am joining the party a bit late. This is my introductory post.

My name is Valeria. I am in my first year of my Master’s program in Hispanic studies. I am originally from El Salvador (Kuskatan) and moved to Vancouver 8 years ago to do my undergraduate studies at UBC (Political Science and Latin American studies).

My interests (I am currently researching) are the intersections between memory, education, family, and gang-violence in the context of new authoritarianisms in Central America (specifically El Salvador). My other non-academic interests include (but are not limited to) sewing (still learning) as a part of multi-media diy projects, cooking, bike riding, swimming (still learning), and writing bad poetry.

I tend to not have that many expectations for any of my classes. I think there is a creative and surprising aspect that is taken away if you have too many expectations. However, for this particular class, what excites me is the fact that I will be forced to only read women’s writings/ideas. In an environment where we unconsciously tend to gravitate to reading only men’s authors (as it was my case in the last RMS 520 class I took, reading Bolaño and Monge), I am curious to see what different themes this space/class will force us to talk about in contrast to other courses.

Can I find more connections between all the books I am reading in this class just because the authors are all women? What do they have in common beyond that? Are the books more emotional? Are the books talking more about men? Are the books talking more about women? How do women portray men? Do they do it the same way men portray women? Is it helpful to focus on gender when reading their novels? Do I change as a reader when I read novels crafted by women?

How discussions of intersectionality or social locations can fit in this space/class?

I do have a lot of questions entering this class. I hope to answer a few once we reach the end.

I am curious to read your blogs and see what are your thoughts on these questions. If you wouldn’t mind I would love to hear some of your ideas regarding one or more of these questions in the comments. What do you think so far?

I guess the other important reflection is that it is not just any women’s writers, it is women’s writers in the 21st century. What themes are women in the 21st century talking about that other women writers in other generations were not able to name? Or how do they name it differently?

Comments Off on Good morning, my name is…

Last blog post ever.

That’s right. This is the end. But when certain things come to an end, I like to think about how it can lead to new beginnings. For me, one of those new beginnings is a growing appreciation and desire to read more Latin American literature. As a French Studies student who also did a major in French as an undergrad, this course served as my introduction to the world of Latin American literature. Of course, the course didn’t focus solely on that. After all, the theme of the course was “long books”—a topic we explored from multiple angles, including through the lens of students’ blogs, which was honestly one of my favourite parts of the course. I LOVED reading my classmates’ blog posts. I can’t say blog-writing is something I will continue, as I am a very private person. But perhaps that will change…perhaps, after being obliged to share my thoughts and ideas with others, I will learn to open up more. This can be another new beginning for me. As an undergrad, I was always one of the quietest students. When I would finally work up the courage to raise my hand, I would tremble in fear, which was usually followed by an immense worry that I would sound stupid in front of others. One aspect of this course that I appreciated was the fact that I felt a lot more comfortable and less nervous than I usually do in class. For that, I give credit to our professor Jon, as well as my wonderful classmates. As a grad student, there are many instances in which I feel inadequate. Unfortunately, I tend to compare myself to others far too often. So I want to say thank you to everyone for setting a tone and creating a classroom atmosphere that was welcoming—an environment full of open-minded individuals, from different backgrounds and fields of study, who invited thought-provoking discussion, without judgment.

So, has my opinion of long books changed since the beginning of the course? The Savage Detectives was the second longest book that I’ve read in my life (the books we read in my other courses are usually less than 300 pages). I didn’t love it, but I did like several aspects of the book (if you’re wondering what those aspects are, you can read my previous blog posts). Les guerriers de l’hiver was significantly shorter in length (459 pages) and overall, I did prefer this novel over The Savage Detectives. Norek’s novel was definitely more conventional and less experimental than Bolaño’s. However, I appreciated Bolaño’s unique (and sometimes bizarre) writing style. In fact, I’d say that I preferred his writing style more than Norek’s. But, I would say that I preferred the story of Les guerriers de l’hiver. On the other hand, Amulet was the real gem of this course. Reading the short novel put me in a bit of a trance-like state, as I embarked on a surreal journey through memories of the past and visions of the future, while constantly being reminded of the present situation of our narrator (I loved her), who faced incredible challenges as she survived through a week or so of absolute chaos. It was beautiful. And I’m looking forward to reading it all over again. I probably won’t be rereading the other two books, at least not for a while. And it’s not because they’re much longer books. I’d say that I now have a greater appreciation for longer books after taking this course. Perhaps that was one of the goals of the course? Well if it was, then it worked on me. I haven’t figured out which books I’ll be reading this summer, but I already plan on looking into books that are lengthier than those that I usually choose to read. In the past, I’ve often chosen shorter books over longer books, simply because I figured that I would be more likely to finish those books. I’m the kind of person that usually gravitates towards books that are less than 400 pages long. If I’m in a bookstore, I will pick up books that look like they’re 400 pages or less, then proceed to read the back in order to see whether it might be something I’d enjoy reading. They say that one should not judge a book by its cover (I’m also guilty of this), but I’d say that one should not judge a book by its size either. Sure, it might take a lot longer to read, especially for a slow reader like me. However, that extra time and effort might just be worth it. Not every book is worth reading. But I don’t want to miss out on those that are worth reading, simply because of their length. This course has helped me gain the patience and focus to read through longer books. And for that, I am incredibly grateful.

I hope everyone has a wonderful summer :)

Question for the class: If you were to recommend a book for me to read this summer, what would it be?

Comments Off on Last blog post ever.

I’m sorry for this but I do not know what else to write about

I am late with this. It’s been increasingly hard to do anything. Fuck depression.

I hope I do not come off trying to find pity in this post, but if I have to write something this is the only thing I have in my mind and I might as well use this obligation to write a blog post as some kind of shout to the void.

I do not know why did I think I could be a graduate student. I do not know why did I think I could be in academia. Two out of two times I’ve hit a big, painful, life threatening depressive episode at the end of a term. I’ll survive, maybe, but will I finish my masters? Increasingly I think it is not for me. Even though it seems that having an imposter syndrome is a necessary qualification for academia it seems no one does anything to address it. I’ve been told several times, by different professors that “it never goes away”, but haven’t been offered a real solution. I do not know how to write an essay. I do not know how to engage with a class. You would think that after a whole degree in literature I would feel capable to have a thought. The anxiety I’ve been trying to manage this week has made getting out of bed one of the hardest challenges. And now I have two essays in the horizon, no idea what I am going to write about, no idea how am I going to write them, wondering if I should just drop out, go back to Colombia, get in a call center and either die of burn out or depression. Since we are talking about endings that seems the one my life keeps foreshadowing to.

I have no idea how the next weeks will look like.

I am 90 words short.

Well, around 8000 words short.

How am I to survive this degree let alone the academic career that seems to be the only option left for me?

 

 

Comments Off on I’m sorry for this but I do not know what else to write about