It was a night of impossibility! The VSO presented a repertoire that seemed to be charming but contradicted each other — an unlikely combination of Mendelssohn’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream and Wagner’s Götterdämmerung, which make up the two parts of the concert. The two fellow composers, arguably the two most influential German composers of their time, contrasted sharply in their styles and ideologies. They were perceived as distinct composers, and their music also had different fates.
This concert was so unique that it stood out among other VSO concerts — both works of music performed tonight were operas — so it involved the participation of three brilliant sopranos. Tracy Cantin. The night opened with a selection from Mendelssohn’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream (Overture, Scherzo, Lied with Choir*, Allegro appassionato, Con Moto tranquillo, Wedding March, Ein Tanz von Rupeln, Finale), the two soprano, Eve-Lyn de La Haye, Robyn Driedger-Klassen accompanied the full orchestra to the front of the stage. One dressed in purple, while the other dressed in green, making me think of Delibes’s famous Flower Duet.
A Midsummer Night’s Dream started with the Overture in E Major, a romantic orchestral piece, that was written when Mendelssohn was only 17 years old. The most well-known piece was certainly the Wedding March, which we hear almost every when we attend a wedding. Even though people might not know Mendelssohn or A Midsummer Night’s Dream, they could recognize the melody immediately. Also ingrained in people’s head was another Wedding March in Lohengrin, interestingly, composed by his junior competitor Wagner. Nonetheless, both Wedding March became deeply rooted in people’s heart; once they hear about it, they feel genuine vividness, joy, and happiness.
Mendelssohn finished the composition of A Midsummer Night’s Dream Overture when he was only 17, but sixteen years later, he was commissioned by King Friedrich Wilhelm IV of Prussia to compose a full set of incidental music to be used at a German-language production in Potsdam. For this reason, the musical numbers after the Overture, including orchestral works and vocal numbers, showcase features of atmosphere music and were designed to be heard under speaking dialogues.
The vivid theme of A Midsummer Night’s Dream attributed to the fairy-tale story settings — it took place in Ancient Greece, a time when humans and legendary creatures such as fairies lived side by side — two pairs of lovers found happiness and the story closed in a spectacular wedding which concluded that joyful couples lived happily ever after. A beautiful image of joy and love that seemed to only exist in dreams — a love story that can melt the heart of the merciless.
During the intermission, the conductor Otto Tausk briefly explained the conflict between these two music geniuses (at least Wagner thought so). Once upon a time, Mendelssohn was the most famed and well-known musician in Germany, writing music that delighted and inspired people; Wagner, having admired Mendelssohn’s status in German music, sent his works to Mendelssohn and sought for the latter’s advice. It is unknown why Wagner never received a reply from Mendelssohn, but this “humiliation” prompted Wager to embark on a journey to tarnish Mendelssohn’s music — saying that Mendelssohn’s music was too light-hearted and could not be counted as great music works. Probably partly because of this “imagined” rivalry, Wagner adopted a distinct musical style that featured in leaden themes and attained inspiration from grand and magnificent epics.
Wagner’s most famous and widely admired 15-hour operatic cycle — The Ring of the Nibelunges, which drew inspiration from Norse legends — was overwhelming in musical richness and emotions. This operatic work was a legend itself. It consisted of four parts, and Götterdämmerung (Twilight of the Gods) was the concluding part of this colossal masterpiece. The three scenes: Dawn and Siegfried’s Rhine Journey, Siegfried’s Death and Funeral Music, and Brünnhilde’s Immolation together portrayed a grand mythical picture of Gods, legendary creatures, and humans on the bank of the Rhine River, and story about lust, greed, and power. With the death of Siegfried, Wagner presented a grand funeral march that stood in stark contrast with Mendelssohn’s vivacious Wedding March. The vocal scores of the last scene were delivered by soprano Tracy Cantin and her firmly magnificent voice, which resonated in the music hall.
Wagner’s music was awe-inspiring, epical, disturbing, and overwhelmingly energetic. I admire Wagner’s genius of composing magnificent music, but it is honest to admit that it would be physically unhealthy to attend his opera more than once a week. I was going to see his Parsifal in Palais Garnier in Paris, but unfortunately, it was canceled due to technical reasons. After attending this concert, I realize that if I would be able to participate in his opera again someday, I should at least spend a week or two to be more mentally prepared.
The clear difference between the two music virtuosos made their music end up in distinct directions. Wagner’s music and especially the magnificent Ring Cycle was appropriated by Nazi Germany as inspiration for the “vision of the future” of Germany — the fate of Earth and Norse Gods were used to parallel the Nazi’s Third Reich. Mendelssohn’s music, in contrast, was banned by the Nazi regime. However, Mendelssohn was the first to be performed in the liberation concert by the Berlin Philharmonic after the Second World War and the end of Nazi’s Reich. Thus, the combination of these two composers in a single concert was either a disaster or a brilliant success. The VSO had accomplished this impossible task — and delivered this concert of unique, dramatic, and thought-provoking experiences.