Inquiry Journal #6: Presentation Handout

My question: How can teachers encourage their students to develop a growth mindset in the classroom?

3 main points:

  • Students with a fixed mindset believe that intelligence is a fixed and inborn trait that cannot be changed, and they try to avoid learning opportunities that involve a risk in performing poorly or admitting they do not understand something. Students with a growth mindset believe that intelligence is dynamic and can develop over time, and they view challenging work as an opportunity to learn, grow, and discover new strategies.
  • Teachers should be providing praise for the thinking process and strategies a student has engaged in, rather than just focusing on the final outcomes. Teachers should also be presenting challenging tasks as fun, exciting, and useful for our brains, and let students know how their brain changes and develops as they tackle something difficult.
  • Teachers should also be working towards changing their own beliefs and mindsets about intelligence. If teachers don’t believe that their student abilities can change or improve, then they won’t be providing the students opportunities to do so.

Challenges/weaknesses:

  • Praise itself, whether it is for a student’s ability or their effort, can be viewed as problematic. Eventually, the students might only be completing a task or activity just to receive the external praise or reward, and may not actually be interested in the topic anymore.
  • In order to see results or effectiveness, I would have to follow the students’ progress over many years.

Next steps:

  • How will I implement these strategies into the classroom? What will it look like?

Inquiry Journal #5

Today I focused my inquiry research on looking for any challenges or resistance to the idea of growth mindsets in the classroom. As I started working on my Powerpoint presentation and handout, I was looking back through the requirements and remembered I had to include something about any challenges or issues that came up during my research. I came across a blog post titled “The Problem With Having a ‘Growth Mindset'” that explained how growth mindsets should not just be about the student “trying harder”, but that teachers really need to think about changing their own mindset and adjusting their own teaching practices. Should teachers be changing their practices to meet the needs of the students, or are teachers expecting their students to change to meet the needs of the teacher?

I have come across similar points during my earlier research, and I believe this is an important point that we all need to be thinking about. It’s great that we have so many expectations of our students and that all this research has been done that gives us insight into how we could unlock our students’ potential, but in order to get there, teachers need to realize that they also have to change and look at things from a new perspective. We should be trying to meet the needs of our students, and we need to be flexible and open to new ideas that will allow us to do so.

I need to think about how I will incorporate these points into my presentation. Most of it has been made already, I just have to tweak it slightly. I have my presentation next week, and I am excited to see how it goes, and to hear what kinds of questions my peers will ask me.

 

Inquiry Journal #4

Today after my one-on-one discussion, I’m feeling more confident with my inquiry topic and all of the research I have done. I feel that I have done a sufficient amount of research on growth mindset and the strategies that teachers can use in the class to promote it. It was really great to talk about my question to someone other than my group members, and I really appreciated all of the feedback and other ideas that came up during the meeting. I think I have a solid foundation to work with as I begin thinking about how I am going to present all of the research I have done for our panel presentations coming up in a few weeks.

I don’t think I will be expanding on or narrowing my question down for now. I feel that a more broader question will keep my research more open and will be easier to adapt into my practicum classroom when I begin trying to implement what I have learned into the way I speak in the classroom. If anything, the growth mindset topic has really taught me how our words have a huge impact on the students in our class, and that subtle changes in the language that we use can drastically change the way that students react.

With that being said, it is also extremely important for teachers to be able to change their mindsets towards student intelligence and abilities. A lot of the articles I have found talk about how if teachers have a fixed mindset, then there is a very high chance that their students will develop a fixed mindset. If students don’t feel that their teacher believes in their ability to improve, then they won’t feel motivated to do so. Teachers and students need to work together to move towards a growth mindset, and the classroom needs to become a positive and supportive community that helps students reach their highest potential.

Inquiry Journal #3

Over the past couple weeks, I have mentioned how the research I have done for my inquiry question so far has led me to articles that explain why fostering a growth mindset in the classroom is important and how it is beneficial for students, but I was struggling a bit to find resources that could give some insight into how teachers could go about doing so. Today during our personal research time in our inquiry class, I did it!

I found some great articles that explained how teachers could go about creating a culture of risk taking in their classroom. The language teachers use in the classroom is important, and the praise and encouragement teachers provide to students can have an impact on their attitudes in tackling challenges. Teachers should portray challenging tasks as fun and exciting, and they should be praising the students’ process and thinking strategies, and the effort they have put into solving the problem. I’m really excited that I was able to find these articles and I can’t wait to see what else I can find. I might have to keep altering my search terms to make sure I pull up new results in these databases. I also don’t think I will end up altering my question yet. Fostering a growth mindset in the classroom involves in all kinds of aspects of classroom management, and I’m interested to see how learning about all these strategies and methods will (or will not) impact my question in the coming weeks.

We also had a really good group discussion today. Julie was explaining how her question began to change a bit, and she described how she’s thinking of focusing on self-reliance/self-confidence/self-regulation. It was then May’s turn, and she explained what she has been doing with her question, telling us all about what she has found with regards to communication in the classroom. This then led to our discussion about how we should be talking to our students. I have been told that teachers shouldn’t be saying things such as “I want you to…” or “I need you to…” as this would imply to the students that they are completing tasks for us, the teachers, and not for themselves. Instead, we should be saying things like “Your job is to…” which puts the responsibility onto the student so that they would be internally motivated to complete the task. But then we wondered, what is the balance between that? We want to be able to build students’ responsibility and “letting them go”, yet we also need to establish our leadership/authority in the classroom if needed. What is the best way to communicate in our classrooms?

Overall, today was a wonderfully thought-provoking day. Excited to see what else will come our way this term!

Inquiry Journal #2

Today during our group discussion, we had a quick discussion about how we were feeling a bit flustered with our questions. After thinking about our inquiry questions over the last week, we talked about if we should be thinking about narrowing our question’s focus or if we should expand and make it even more broad than it is currently. This accurately describes how I’m currently feeling about my inquiry. There are so many pathways I think would be really interesting to try to explore but I know that I will have to eventually settle and focus on one aspect of my question.

May offered some great insight into some of the research she has been doing for her inquiry question, which is very similar to my own. She explained to us how she has found a lot of literature that looks at language, and the impact of how we talk to students in the classroom can have a big impact on their behaviour and attitudes towards learning. For example, addressing the students as “scientists” during a science lesson/activity can help the students become more engaged or excited about doing science. You’re letting the students know that you expect them to be thinking and behaving like mature scientists, and the students will want to be able to live up to these expectations. I thought this was really interesting to learn, and I wonder how the students in my practicum class would react to something like this.

This then led me to ask questions to the group about the importance of body language in the classroom, and how my actions in the classroom would have an impact on student motivation and self-confidence (and mindsets).

So my main question about my question is still focused on HOW can I achieve this in the classroom? A lot of the articles I’ve found talk about how important it is to increase students’ motivation, to keep them determined and persistent when facing problems, but I haven’t found anything that explains how we can do this… This should be my main focus for research over the next week, and hopefully my next journal entry will have more of a relieved tone since I will hopefully know where I will be going.

Inquiry Journal #1

What’s the difference between listening to a story and actually taking part in the story?

This was the question that was posed to us at the end of our inquiry class today. During class, we had been completing a variety of engaging activities during a read aloud, with each activity connecting back to the story and the message that the story was conveying. I thought these activities were really fun to do and they kept me focused on the story and I was eager to find out what would happen next.

The difference between just listening to story compared to taking on an active role and actually engaging with the story is that you become so much more invested in the characters and the events that take place. Putting yourself in the shoes of the character, and trying to understand what could be going through their minds when they have to make a decision, makes them seem that much more real, which makes them easier to connect to. Making personal connections to the characters and their situation is really important for understanding and engagement.

These kinds of activities that put you in the story also make listening to a read aloud less dull, as students are able to get up out of their seats and think about situations in the story in a different way.

Overall, I thought class was lots of fun today! Going forward, I would like to see if I could incorporate these kinds of activities into my practicum class and observe my students’ reactions. I think it would be really fun to implement as well.

And some quick updates on my inquiry question:

  • The question (as of today): How can teachers encourage students to develop a growth mindset in the classroom?
  • I’ve looked up a bunch of different journal articles relating to the concept of growth mindsets, and I’m also thinking of looking into Carol Dweck’s TED talks or other videos/interviews of her.
  • A lot of the articles have been about how hard work, determination, persistence and self-confidence are important when trying to cultivate growth mindsets in the classroom. My question right now is, how do we get there?? What if a student doesn’t have high self-confidence? How can I help them realize they do have the abilities they think they lack?
  • Also, I have been wondering if there was any way I could squeeze music education into my inquiry question. With my CFE being with the VSO, and the fact that we have a music class this term (which I am thoroughly enjoying), my love for music has been reignited and I wonder if music education has any effect on a student’s perception of their skills and abilities. Something to look into as I keep researching, I think…

That’s all for now! 🙂

Sketching: Mini Inquiry

Last class (October 11), we did a mini inquiry task on a natural object that we had a connection with. We had read the article “Learning Through Sketching” by D. McNamara, and we got to experience the different kinds of sketching methods that were described.

My shell is from a family vacation when our cruise stopped at a port in Mexico. I believe this port was Mazatlan. I thought this shell had a really nice design and colour scheme, with both horizontal lines and vertical lines. This shell is very smooth, so I think it had been on shore and has been buffered by the waves for quite some time.

I wonder what kind of shell it is exactly, and what kind of creature had lived inside of it. Did that creature leave the shell because it outgrew it, or was it forcibly removed from the safety of its habitat?

The shell is significant to me because I love learning about marine life and I have always been fascinated with learning about our natural world. We originally collected some shells and other trinkets to give away as souvenirs and gifts to family and friends, but I liked this shell so much I kept it for myself. 🙂

First Post!

Here we go, the first week of my teacher education journey! It’s been a bit overwhelming and I have been bombarded with tons of information, but I am so excited to finally get going. Everyone I’ve met has been so warm and welcoming and I can’t wait to get to work with my KIPP cohort!

I can’t wait to see where this journey will take me, and how I will grow and learn as an educator over the next year. Bring it on, BEd!!

Spam prevention powered by Akismet