All posts by samcfaul

Are the maps we take to be unbiased truly unbiased? – Indian Borders according to Google.co.in versus Google.com

These two maps reflect the Indian Northern Border as depicted on Google.com (the American reflection of Google Maps) and Google.co.in (the Indian reflection of Google Maps). This ambiguity is hugely important and affects huge amounts of people. What are the implications when we take maps the Google maps to be objective and true?

Sam

https://i.redditmedia.com/Y9_kGExGF1M8Rjx_KdiRQgG9aeOO8dPuUoGaR5YiSfg.png?w=750&s=7503e960fa5b2fb16d751900801cc6e2

Hans Island and the Canada-Denmark War

Here is a map of Hans Island and an interesting read below:

http://media.mnn.com/assets/images/2015/11/Nares_strait_border_(Kennedy_channel).png.838x0_q80.jpg

http://www.mnn.com/earth-matters/wilderness-resources/blogs/canada-denmark-wage-whisky-war-on-rocks

A mistake in mapping; Hans Island is divided  perfectly in half between Canada and Denmark. Both countries claim it as their own. As a contested space in the north, the control of Hans Island could mean the control of the channel in which it sits and majorly affect the inclusion of the Northwest Passage as either being included in Canada’s internal waters or as an internationally recognized free trade route. The control of this tiny island has, for a long time, been somewhat of a joke between these two countries, with the claim of it changing every number of years. Each time doing so the opposing country leaving a bottle of whiskey in its lighthouse for the new captors.

Sam

Can a series of photographs be a map?

An interesting read about how the Athabasca-Mackenzie River Basin was photographed and documented. What are the implications of this form of mapping? Could the way this area was mapped have lead to the rise of the resource exploitation of the Alberta tarsands (which this area is now known for)?

http://www.aupress.ca/books/120176/ebook/04_Finkel_et_al_2010-West_and_Beyond.pdf

Sam McFaul – Oral Mapping

Ac Ko Mok Ki – Peter Fidler

Stz’uminus – oral story map

http://www.firstvoices.com/en/Hlgaagilda-Xaayda-Kil/stories
(the exact story I presented is not located on this website as it was obtained first hand and the file is not able to be posted – alternatively other Haida – Hlg̱aagilda X̱aayda Kil – stories are provided above)

https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?ll=48.99545253486705%2C-123.7910270736084&spn=0.120051%2C0.207195&dg=feature&msa=0&mid=1E_H17pirVICYyT2wMpojCU8O0H8&z=13

_________________________________

“Colonizers produce knowledge of a territory within a specific framework that allows them to understand and ‘know’ place on their own terms. The ‘imaginary geography’ justifies possession over space by privileging the colonizer’s representations of territory.”
– Matthew Dyce

“Modernity constructs it’s other as a way of  privileging itself”
– Edward Said

“Indigenous place names are not simply geographic identifiers; they are houses for layers of information, including cultural and historical knowledge, environmental conditions, availability of resources, and Aboriginal identity”
– Müller-Wille, 1989; Thorton, 1997; Cruikshank, 1990

Sam McFaul