Osaka Elegy or in Japanese Naniwa Erejii was released in 1936 and directed by Mizoguchi Kenji. His melodrama genre is often the prominent theme in many of his films. Like many of his films including Sisters of the Gion he uses the actress Yamada Isuzu as his struggling heroine caught in a male-dominated, money-oriented society. The world his heroine Ayako is trapped in is a hierarchical world prioritizing men and the rich; women are powerless and have a limited number of choices to survive in a world defined by money and power. Like Umekichi and Omocha in Sisters of the Gion, Ayako is another woman pushed around helplessly in the money oriented and patriarchical society.
In the film Ayako tries to obtain 300 yen to prevent her father from going to jail for embezzlement. She first turns to her poor suitor Nishimura. When he refuses to help she has no choice but to become her boss’ mistress. She has a respectable filial cause, saving her father and later procuring money to pay for her elder brother’s university tuition, for turning into a “delinquent” woman. She even chooses to serve the rich men in the movie for money instead of pursuing her true love. Despite all the sacrifices she’s made Ayako still ends up misunderstood, condemned by society, and even by the family she chose to selflessly help. Her efforts end up being in vain, unappreciated, and criticized.
Although the Japanese city is glamorous as it is with the bright colourful neon lights we get in the first scene Ayako and her family’s house is shabby. Whenever we get a shot of her house the lighting is always terribly dark, conveying their unfortunate fate on the brim of tragedy. The dark lighting contrasted with the bright city light reflects the importance of money in the hierarchical society. Just like her dark shabby house, Ayako’s situation is also grim. Although she is smart, talented, and pretty she is trapped in the social system in which she cannot succeed either way. There is a need for women to be subservient to men or else they will be seen as delinquent and will even get kicked out of their own houses despite serving their family loyally. Ayako is stuck between fulfilling her duty as a filial daughter which requires inactivity with her boss, or fulfilling those filial duties by straying from society’s expectations of women. There are many different demands in the film that causes Ayako to fall deeper and deeper into an unsolvable mess in which whichever she acts it is the wrong move. For example if she chooses to save her father and procure money for her brother like a filial daughter would do she will become a delinquent woman condemned by society.
Ayako is trapped in the society just as she is in her small dark home with her family, her confined cubicle in the pharmaceuticals, and finally the apartment her boss buys for her. The film captures a lot of claustrophobic space representing the confined cages women during this time are trapped in. Mizoguchi often focuses on Ayako and downplays the other characters, having their backs facing the audience with only Ayako’s face visible. We focus on Ayako’s expression and get a full-blown sense of her tiny changes of emotion. Whenever there is a man in the picture they always just sit comfortably and waited to be served. The focus is always on the men when Ayako is not there with their maids or ladies staying low on the ground and being subservient.
The only close up we get in the movie is in the final scene; the close up of Ayako’s impression conveying her loneliness. She stands by the riverside with glamorous city lights and numerous pedestrians around her, however she is pondering about her unfortunate life in tears. She then runs into her former boss’ doctor who walks the separate direction without giving her any good advice, intensifying her isolation. She walks away from the glamorous city lights blending into the darkness in the background and eventually the camera is in front of her. She walks towards the camera and as she gets closer and closer we get a detailed concentrated view of her expression; determined yet defeated in a world where she is trapped like being confined in a small view of the camera. Even when she’s walking the shot makes her look stationary; just like how she has tried so hard yet still ended up nowhere.
Osaka Elegy is a film reflecting the unsuccessful life of the struggling heroine trying to survive the unfair social system in her own way. We get a strong sense of women’s agony in a social system that leaves no place for success for women in Mizoguchi’s film. Mizoguchi’s talented techniques of focusing our attention on the social issues his heroine experiences in the movie while constantly intensifying tension and drama by his long shots, his sudden transition from one scene to another makes the movie meaningful yet entertaining at the same time. All that Ayako’s done for her family and her pursuit for true love ends in vain; like all Mizoguchi’s fallen women she is left with nothing except sorrow and loneliness. The movie has the power to capture the viewer’s undivided attention during the movie and entrap them with his message after.