[Updated 5 November 2026]
This page gives the full instructions for the Annotated Bibliography (20%). For a summary, see the Assessment page. The assignment has two stages: a checkpoint due by the end of Friday, November 13, and the final bibliography due by the end of Friday, December 4. Both are submitted through Canvas.
Checkpoint
The checkpoint is due by the end of Friday, November 13.
What to submit:
- Your research question. Start from one of the course’s weekly topics, or from any other aspect of Hong Kong’s history that interests you, and pose your own “how” or “why” question that is more specific than our weekly focus questions. See “What makes a good research question?” below.
- Your AI-generated candidate list. Ask an AI tool for 8–10 academic studies (journal articles, book chapters, monographs, or dissertations) related to your question, and submit the list exactly as the tool gave it to you.
- The entire conversation with the AI tool, not just your prompts. Include the AI’s responses and any follow-up questions you asked, either as a share link or as copied-and-pasted text, along with a brief note on which AI tool you used and how. If you used more than one tool or session, include each one. Please do not edit or trim the conversation. Disclosure is required whenever AI is used in this course.
What makes a good research question? Aim for a question that is genuine, historical, significant, and appropriate in scope. A genuine question is one whose answer you do not already know. If a quick search could settle it, it is a factual lookup, not a research question. A historical question asks about change or continuity over time: how or why something came about, shifted, or persisted. A significant question is one you can explain in a sentence or two as worth investigating, perhaps because it helps us understand a larger development in Hong Kong’s past. A question of appropriate scope is neither too broad (no handful of sources could answer it) nor too narrow (there is too little scholarship to find sources on it). Your first draft of a question will probably be too broad, so try narrowing it by adding a specific group, place, or time period.
For example, the focus question for Week 8, “In what ways was Hong Kong reconfigured by the influx of immigrants?” is a good question for class discussion but too broad for a short bibliography. “How did Shanghai industrialists who moved to Hong Kong after 1949 shape the territory’s textile industry?” is something you could actually investigate.
You can (and probably should) refine your question as you read, so treat the question you submit at the checkpoint as a starting point, not a commitment. If your question changes substantially, see “Changing your question” below for what to do.
What to expect:
- The checkpoint is checked for completion, not graded for quality. Its purpose is to make sure you are on a reasonable track before you invest time in the harder work.
- You do not need to verify the sources yet. That is the next stage: you will check every source against the UBC Library catalog and select the 5 most pertinent ones. Some of what the AI suggests may turn out to be inaccurate or even nonexistent, and discovering that is part of the exercise. Please don’t quietly correct the list before submitting it.
- The final bibliography (5 verified sources, annotations, a comparative paragraph, and a verification note) is due Friday, December 4.
Final bibliography
The final bibliography is due by the end of Friday, December 4, through Canvas. Late submissions lose 4/100 points per day.
What to submit:
- Your final research question, stated at the top of your bibliography. See “Changing your question” below.
- Your five sources, listed in Chicago (Notes-Bibliography) style. Check each source against the UBC Library catalog, and include only sources you’ve personally confirmed. Choose the 5 most pertinent verified sources, all locatable through the UBC Library catalog. At least 4 must be academic studies (secondary sources); up to 1 may be a primary source instead, and it need not come from the AI’s list. In general, favor journal articles and book chapters, as you probably won’t have time to read 5 book-length studies.
- An annotation for each source (about 75–100 words each): (a) its argument, (b) its evidence base, (c) one sentence on what surprised you or complicated your question. For a primary source, replace (a) and (b) with who produced it, when, and for what purpose, and say how it bears on your question. Cite specific page numbers whenever you reference a source’s argument or evidence.
- A comparative paragraph (about 250–300 words): where your 5 sources agree, disagree, or talk past each other, and how together they help answer your question.
- A verification note (about 150–200 words): how you verified your sources (what you checked, and how), and any AI-suggested sources that turned out to be fabricated, misattributed, or irrelevant. Then account for how you arrived at your final five: which came from the AI’s suggestions, which candidates you dropped and why, and where any other sources came from.
Changing your question. Begin your bibliography by stating your final research question. If it differs from the one you submitted at the checkpoint, add a sentence explaining how and why it changed. If the change was substantial, ask an AI tool for candidate sources on your new question and submit that conversation with your final bibliography, as you did for the checkpoint.
How much to read: articles and chapters in full. For monographs and dissertations, the introduction, conclusion, and one substantive chapter closely, plus the bibliography and table of contents for the rest—this is how historians size up sources efficiently.
AI use in your final bibliography. The AI conversation is for finding candidate sources. Everything after that is your own work. You must read your sources yourself (an AI summary is not a substitute for reading), and the annotations, comparative paragraph, and verification note must be your own writing. AI tools may be used to support grammar and sentence-level clarity, but not to generate the ideas, analysis, or arguments you present as your own. Please include an AI note at the end of your submission stating whether you used an AI tool in writing it and, if so, which tool and how.
