Open Source Ratings System

There is a mix of scholarly discussion and excitement associated with open source software. I think all of us are struggling with understanding how to move ahead with the constant changes that take place. As well – we’re definitely torn between intriguing new functionality and stability.

In the “institutional” scheme of things — faculty have already spoken – software has to work!

Sometimes it feels like the Gartner Group hype cycle roller coaster — “peak of inflated expectations”, “plateau of productivity” or… ?

Enter the new Business Readiness Ratings initiative – a collaborative effort to develop out standards for determining how ready software is for deployment. From their website:

Business Readiness Ratings (BRR) is being proposed as a new standard model for rating open source software. It is intended to enable the entire community (enterprise adopters and developers) to rate software in an open and standardized way. BRR is a community initiative that is being sponsored by Carnegie Mellon West Center for Open Source Investigation, O’Reilly CodeZoo, SpikeSource and Intel.

I am definitely on board with developing out a consistent ratings system, and this looks like an excellent step in the right direction.

I particularly like how, in addition to suggesting the use of technical categories (usability, scalability, etc.), they have also included people-oriented categories

– adoption, community, and professionalism –

that begin to capture collegial components.

I hope the other members of OLT will be reading the White Paper within the next few days (there may be a quiz later…)

PS… I saw the link for the new “Business Readiness Rating” project first in the New York Times article:
Rating System Will Evaluate Free Software

This entry was posted in UBC Strategic Efforts. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Open Source Ratings System

  1. Scott Leslie says:

    Michelle, thanks for pointing to the BRR work, it is interesting in part because of who is developing it and that they have alreayd looked at some of the existing ed tech projects. They are, however, re-inventing the wheel slightly – I’d point to as an earlier attempt (that is still ongoing as far as I know) to develop a Maturity Model for Open Source. But maybe it’s more a question of introducing the two projects to one another in the hope of getting one set of indicators with strong backing. Cheers, Scott

  2. mitch says:

    You can “learn mor about BRR during the presentation on Maturity of Open Source Affinity Groups”! 😮

    See, another reason for an OLTer to go to OSCON. 😉

    /studies diligently for the quiz.

Comments are closed.