Author Archives: Shuichiro Takeda

Module #2-5: Stereotypes of Indigenous Peoples

Since the discussion topic was about stereotypes, I researched Indigenous peoples and stereotypes a little further. I found some amusing stereotypes, but many negative one too that were not funny at all. I assume (or hope) that non-Indigenous people would not entirely believe them, but the negative stereotypes are deep-rooted and may affect how Indigenous people are viewed in some respects.

Native Appropriations is a forum that discusses representations of Native peoples, including stereotypes and cultural appropriation. In a recent post they discussed racist Halloween costumes. I totally understand that wearing Indian costumes can be perceived as racist but racism may not be always the reason for choosing Indian costumes; sometimes people dress for something they love and respect, so one cannot over generalize. If children want to choose a costume simply because s/he likes it, how should adults react?

Creative Spirits, the website that introduces contemporary Aboriginal culture in Australia, discusses many stereotypes and prejudices about ‘Aboriginal Australia’. At the same time, they introduce ‘good’ stereotypes as well as typical ones; for example, the Tourism Australia website uses the common stereotype of ‘Australia = friendly Aboriginal people’ to promote the tourism in Australia. It is important for students to learn about the negative aspects of Aboriginal history, but at the same time, teachers should focus on Indigenous peoples’ strength and beliefs to reveal their positive aspects. It may not be the best solution for rooting out negative stereotypes, but perhaps positive stereotypes can help overcome negative ones.

Module #2-4: Network in Indigenous Communities

One of the difficulties that Indigenous peoples may face is networking. Even though the Internet is developed and people can easily connect with one other, it does not mean all people know how to network with other communities. Actually it can be quite hard to connect with people; I knew there should be a Japanese community in Quebec City when I first moved here, but it took me several months to meet the first Japanese person!

The Circle on Philanthropy and Aboriginal Peoples in Canada is an open network to promote giving, sharing, and philanthropy in Indigenous communities across Canada. They connect with and support the empowerment of Indigenous communities and individuals in building a stronger, healthier future. They strive to strengthen the Indigenous right to self-determination as one of their goals through  workshops, meetings, newsletters, and so on.

In 2006, an Indigenous entrepreneur started NationTalk as a newswire and listing service that aggregated information relevant to the Indigenous communities in Canada. Their services rapidly grew across Canada and now it is the great way to reach out to the Indigenous communities, with more than 15,000 daily newsletter subscribers and over 2 million page impressions a year through its website. NationTalk allows the creation of websites with local information on jobs, with advertisements, and news for communities as small as a village.

Networking can help Indigenous people strengthen their relationships with others, with numerous benefits for all concerned. It can also be a good source of new perspectives and ideas, expand opportunities for business or valuable knowledge, open doors to the exchange of valuable suggestions, and provide guidance.

Module #2-3: Films and Documentaries

Recently I have seen a few documentaries about Indigenous peoples both on TV and in the theater. One is called Kind Hearted Woman, about a native woman in North Dakota who struggles with poverty, career, drug and alcohol abuse, and her own identity. It was very powerful and I had so many questions such as “what prevents her from leaving the community?” or “why is it so hard for her to overcome her problems?” because of my ignorance about Indigenous peoples and, probably, my stereotypes about them. Then I watched Nanook of the North last week and now I curiously started searching for more Indigenous films.

First Nations Films was created in 1998 and distributes award-winning educational documentary films for, by and about Indigenous peoples in Canada. Many movies are listed in their catalogue with trailers. Movies feature various topics, such as native women, suicide in the community, Indigenous peoples’ historical relationship with the Provincial and Canadian governments in settling the land question in Canada, etc. National Film Board of Canada features many Indigenous documentaries and animations on its website as well. The best feature of this website is that we can watch many full-length feature films about Aboriginal Peoples.

Coincidentally, imagineNATIVE, Toronto’s 14th annual showcase of the latest work by indigenous filmmakers and artists, will be held October 16th through 20th. Every fall imagineNATIVE presents a selection of distinctive Indigenous works from around the world in conjunction with a variety of cultural & social events. Because we are apt to have incorrect impressions or stereotypes about Indigenous peoples, it is helpful for us to see films and documentaries on them to dispel stereotypical notions about them. Through diverse media presentations we can arrive at a greater understanding of Indigenous peoples and cultures.

Module #2-2: Foundations for Indigenous Literacy in Australia

  • Over 50% of Indigenous families in very remote areas speak their Indigenous language
  • Only 40% of Aboriginal children remain school until year 12
  • Only 1 in 5 kids in a Northern Territory remote community can read at an acceptable level
  • Less than 36% of people in a remote community have access to a library and books

These are the facts in Australia as indicated on the Indigenous Literacy Foundation (ILF) website. In Australia there are a few large foundations and organizations making efforts to close the gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous young people with regards to literacy and numeracy. The ILF is one of the largest; they work to provide access to books and literacy resources to over 200 remote Indigenous communities, and have already donated nearly AUS$494,000 (CAN$485,000) and 100,000 books in 2013. The Australian Numeracy and Literacy Foundation (ANLF) is another big foundation working to improve Indigenous literacy. Their Wall of Hands Project raised AUS$320,000 in donations to improve language, literacy, and numeracy standards in Australia.

About a week ago, OOdals, a new UK-based Amazon-like online store selling Books and Movies, announced that they will donate 10% of all their profits to support Australian literacy charities (article), including ILF and ANLF.

Literacy is one of the most important tools for improving Indigenous life, especially among young learners. It is not only about literacy in English but also literacy in their native language because language is a vital part of their culture. Therefore, it is absolutely crucial to improve literacy in their own language as well as in English. Their language and culture cannot fade with this generation.

Module #2-1: One Laptop per Child

One Laptop per Child (OLPC), an ambitious project begun in 2006, aims to build an inexpensive laptop (XO) to be sold in the developing world and make it available to children in those countries. By 2009 about 2,000 XO laptops were delivered to three schools in indigenous communities in Australia (article) and students were able to begin to close the education gap, according to their blog posted in 2011. In 2010, twelve First Nation schools in Canada announced the use of the XO laptop in their classrooms.

But the OLPC project has also come under criticism. In 2012, some articles pointed out that the project was a failure because the  XO laptop costs twice the originally intended price. And then in July of this year OLPC announced a very different product—a $150 Android-based tablet, not only for kids in developing nations, but also for sale in Wal-Mart in the US. It seems like the OLPC project is now a little lost but still hoping to find the best way to pursue their original goals.

This OLPC project not only affords Indigenous children an equal opportunity to learn, but also provides methods to facilitate their learning. It enables children to surmount the first and perhaps greatest obstacle to their educational experience.

But it is not enough to just spend a lot of money providing XO laptops or tablets; the project would also be viewed as a big success if were to improve local infrastructure, update software, provide technical support over the long term, and so forth.

I assume that many people knew from the beginning that just providing laptops would not be enough to improve the educational situation. OLPC cannot, unfortunately, fix everything; they are mainly responsible for developing/providing affordable laptops, not for the improvement of local infrastructure. That should be someone else’s responsibility (e.g., government, other NGO groups, etc.).

Statement Connecting Weblog to Research Interests

For my project, I am interested in the factors behind the dropout rates of Indigenous learners. Lately more Indigenous students have better education opportunities, but I still find articles about high dropout rates of Indigenous students in North America. Some marginalized students may be facing geographical problems or infrastructure difficulties, or there may exist other reasons. In terms of education, Indigenous peoples’ situation may be improved by the Internet—it has made it possible for them to access material and join the class discussion no matter where they live.

Since schools at every level will have more Indigenous students in the future, it is crucial for both educators and learners to understand the factors that encourage students to remain in the course or cause them decide to leave. I would like to propose a research project analyzing the reasons Indigenous learners drop out—my research findings will help educators obtain a clearer picture on how school education should be conducted in order to retain students over the long term and how technology can be used to further that goal.

I haven’t narrowed down my research questions yet. The broad topic about dropout rates for Indigenous students may already been studied by other researchers so I want to develop a distinct approach for my study. I need a little more time to think about it.

References:

Balla, J. (2012). Identity and Knowledge in Indigenous Young Children’s Experiences in Canada. Childhood Education, 88 (5), 286-291.

Biddle, N. & Cameron, T. (2012). Potential Factors Influencing Indigenous Education Participation and Achievement. National Centre for Vocational Education Research (NCVER).

Jones, B. A. (1992). Collaboration: The Case for Indigenous Community-Based Organization Support of Dropout Prevention Programming and Implementation. The Journal of Negro education, 61 (4), 496-508.

Kutay, C., Mooney, J., Riley, L. & Howard-Wagner, D. (2012). Experiencing Indigenous Knowledge Online as a Community Narrative. Australian Journal of Indigenous Education, 41 (1), 47-59.

Mangana, J. & Trendleb, B. (2010). Cancellation of indigenous Australians from the apprenticeship training contract. Education Economics, 18 (4), 377-394.

Module #1-5: Australia

According to the Australian Bureau of Statistics, there were 176,057 school students in Australia who had identified as Aboriginal at their time of enrolment in 2012. This represents an increase of 7,254 (4.3%) over the corresponding figure for 2011. These students now make up almost 5% of all school students. This figure is only for primary and secondary schools and does not take into account higher education, but I assume the number of Indigenous students enrolled in higher education should be increasing accordingly. Since indigenous communities are often located in remote areas, distance education will be key to providing a proper level of education and training for them.

In Australia, the Queensland Government formed the Indigenous Lead Centre in 2006 to ensure Indigenous peoples have access to culturally appropriate and relevant courses including distance education, course materials, and training products that enable them to fulfill their professional and personal aspirations. The Indigenous Lead Centre has also developed a variety of user-friendly e-learning resources; Internet technology like this could definitely help support students and job seekers in remote communities. However, infrastructure is the big issue among Indigenous communities and peoples. According to this article published in 2011, only 6% of residents in some remote Indigenous communities in Australia had a computer, while 80% of Australians access the Internet regularly—in some communities, as few as 2% of residents had an Internet connection. In 2011, the Australian Communications Consumer Action Network (ACCAN) started a project called Home Internet for Remote Indigenous Communities to assess the reasons for low internet take-up and use by people living in remote Indigenous communities, determine the needs of remote Indigenous communities with regard to home Internet use, and provide advice through empirical research.

Batchelor Institute of Indigenous Tertiary Education in Northern Territory, an educational institution for the tertiary education of Indigenous people of Australia, opened a new e-Learning and Research Building in 2008. This was a $2.86 million project funded by the Federal Government. Internet technology must be effectively employed to provide quality education and training to Indigenous peoples. Creating Internet access requires stable infrastructure, and an Internet development budget funding is essential to making the project come to life. It is not an easy process!

Module #1-4: First Nations Councils in Canada

First Nations communities are often marginalized and have poor access to services in areas such as youth, employment, and so on. They also face a number of challenges regarding access to educational technology related to their marginalized social positioning. Therefore, to battle against this issue it is crucial for First Nations people to take advantage of technology, especially the Internet, to get connected to one other and rebuild a sense of community. First Nations councils in Canada aim to improve and better reflect the culture, education, and other needs of the First Nations.

The First Nations Education Council (FNEC) was created in 1985 with the mission to achieve full jurisdiction over education of all First Nations children and their communities in the Nations of Quebec. Their philosophy is that only First Nations people can develop an education system that is based on First Nations values. The FNEC supports, promotes and safeguards the lifelong education and the unique cultural identity of First Nations. FNEC priorities include installing fiber optics in all FNEC-member communities, supporting the funding of vocational training programs, compelling the federal government to adopt a new funding formula for First Nations schools to put an end to their chronic underfunding, and so forth.

In September 2013, in Saskatchewan, the 12 First Nations of the Prince Albert Grand Council (PAGC) announced that each of them plan to develop their own education acts, aiming to better reflect the culture and needs of the First Nations, according to this article. The acts will recognize First Nations culture, language, academic achievement, and First Nations jurisdiction over education—asserting their indigenous right and authority over their children’s education.

Module #1-3: Endangered Languages

Wendake is the Huron-Wendat reserve located 15 minutes from downtown Quebec City. It is one of the Seven Nations of The Iroquois Confederacy—a historic confederation of First Nations living in and around the Saint Lawrence River valley at the start of the eighteenth century. I have been to this small town once. There are buildings such as the Huron-Wendat Museum, the Traditional Huron site “ONHOÜA CHETEK8E“, several souvenir shops, and many tourists as well. It was fun learning about their history and culture, but the most interesting part of my visit was their language. I saw many signs written in Wyandot—even traffic signs.

Wyandot is one of the Iroquoian languages. This website give some background on the Iroquoian language. Unfortunately, Wyandot essentially died out as a spoken language nearly a century ago; however, there are attempts at revitalization such as the village school in Wendake, which offers adult and children’s classes in the language.

Not only Wyandot, but also many indigenous languages have been struggling to stay alive. According to this article, only 545 Canadians claim Mohawk, which has the largest number of speakers of the Northern Iroquoian languages, as their mother tongue according to 2011 census data. Language and identity are closely connected and intertwined; it is so difficult to imagine losing a part of our identity. Even if the language manages to be somehow revived, it would soon be endangered again if there are not enough people dedicated to protecting it from extinction. Conversation can be recorded and preserved as an archive for future generations, but losing languages and its speakers are very regrettable.

Module #1-2: The Ainu in Japan

When I was a student in Japan, there was little taught about the Indigenous peoples of Japan in any school. I believe that the situation has not changed much, unfortunately. Since I still don’t know much about them, I began researching to obtain basic knowledge about one of the two Indigenous peoples, the Ainu. The Ainu live mainly in Hokkaido, a northern region of Japan, and in part of Russia. There are about 25,000 Ainu living in Japan according to official population estimates (the unofficial number is upwards of 200,000 people).

In the mid-to-late 19th century Japanese settlers took over the indigenous land. The Ainu were forced to assimilate under pressure from various laws and the Japanese government banned their cultural traditions. The government’s assimilation policy resulted in many Ainu being ignorant of their own culture and history. For that reason the Ainu language is now considered endangered. The Ainu people also hope their living and educational standards can be upgraded. According to the Ainu Association of Hokkaido, 38.3 percent of the Ainu in Hokkaido are on welfare, compared with the local average of 24.6 percent. Moreover, only 17.4 percent of the Ainu receive a college education while 38.5 percent of the locals do.

Surprisingly, the Japanese government did not recognize the ethnic Ainu as Japan’s indigenous people until 2008; it must have been a major challenge for a country long proud of being ethnically homogeneous.

Probably because of this recognition, the description of the Ainu has significantly increased in the textbooks used for primary schools in 2010. Needless to say it was a big step forward since school education about them is important to raising awareness of the Ainu among the population at large. However, teacher knowledge is essential to teaching the contents of the textbook properly and the improvement of teacher training is crucial.

In 2010, the documentary film TOKYO Ainu was released. I believe there were few documentaries featuring the Ainu made before this one. This film features the Ainu living in Tokyo and its surrounding areas actively promoting their traditional culture. The promotional footage is available here on YouTube. For more information about the Ainu, the Ainu Museum website is also a useful resource for learning about Ainu history and culture.