Tag Archives: critical pedagogy

Module 2 – Post 4: Place-Based Learning and knowing: critical pedagogies grounded in Indigeneity, Jay Johnson

Johnson, J. (2012). Place-based learning and knowing: Critical pedagogies grounded in indigeneity. GeoJournal. 77(6). pp. 829-836

Subsequent to the Gruenewald article documented in Post 3, Johnson draws heavily on Gruenewald’s ideation of critical pedagogy of space and seeks to further develop the concepts space, place and placelessness before firmly linking indigeneity to critical place-based pedagogy.  As far back as the enlightenment, Western traditions have sought to separate culture from nature, and as a result the ensuing culture and system of knowledge has had placelessness as a primary component.  Arguably, this disconnection from place has also lead to Western science self-stated superiority over indigenous knowledge and science that is firmly rooted, and even stored, in the places, environment and landscapes in which it was developed.  Furthermore, Johnson explains that modern (Western) society creates a “thin” layer of meaning making in places, as they are converted to resource spaces for capitalistic and colonial purposes.  But for that thin meaning to exist, it is necessary to remove the meaning that is pre-existant and often significant cultural histories and moralities.

To reconcile this transformation of place to space, Johnson seeks to impart the decolonialization and rehabitation of critical place-based learning, be in a state of continual active engagement with the places, and rediscover their indigenous stories, histories, narratives and languages associated with them.

Module 2 – Post 3: The Best of Both Worlds: A Critical Pedagogy of Place, David Gruenewald

Gruenewald, D. (2003). The best of both worlds: A critical pedagogy of place. Educational Researcher. (32)4 pp. 3-12. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3700002

In this thorough analysis of the sociological themes and call for revolutionary change from critical pedagogy, and the socio-ecological themes of place-based learning, Gruenewald draws on the research and writings of prominent theorists in each field to demonstrate that these discourses build on the concepts and strengthen the goals of the other in such a way that they can be seen as two sides to the same coin and can be reconceptualized into a critical pedagogy of place.  A major goal of his paper is to “ground place-based education in a pedagogy that is socially and ecologically critical” and wrapped in a coherent theoretical framework.

The two fundamental objectives of a critical pedagogy of place are decolonization and reinhabitation, which are mutually supportive themes mirrored in critical pedagogy and place-based learning, respectively, for the purposes of “linking school and place-based experiences to the larger landscape of cultural and ecological politics”.  As such, a critical pedagogy of place seeks to find, return to, or reclaim spaces that teach us how to live well in these local environments (reinhabitation), and identify and challenge practice and ways of thinking that exploit people and places (decolonization).