Cultural appropriation, indigenous knowledge and libraries

As a librarian, I have at times been responsible for collecting print and electronic resources about indigenous issues, and also for collecting resources that support aboriginal students in a range of college programs. In addition, libraries sometimes have collections of artifacts, acting as small museums or archives. In light of this, I would like to learn more about issues of cultural appropriation and indigenous knowledge as they relate to libraries in Canada.

What issues do librarians need to be aware of as they wield their power to select, classify, and store materials? The parallels between the organizing/standardizing imperative of Western colonial domination and the organizing, classifying, and standardization of knowledge in libraries is interesting. What are the limitations of print and published materials in representing indigenous knowledge? It would also be interesting to look at anxiety induced by physical library spaces (fear of acting inappropriately, of not knowing where to begin), and how this anxiety may be more intense for aboriginal students.

Sources will include academic literature on cultural appropriation of indigenous knowledge, and library literature about services and collections for aboriginal people. I recognize that I will need to be careful not to make generalizations about aboriginal culture and assume that one solution fits all circumstances.

A first reference:

Haig-Brown, C. (2010). Indigenous thought, appropriation, and non-aboriginal people. Canadian Journal of Education, 33(4), 925-950. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com.ezproxy.library.ubc.ca/docview/848717095?accountid=14656

Research Interest: Treaty Essential Learnings SK

This barcode allows you to follow the Office of Treaty Commissioner with your smartphone. The picture is also linked to the Office of the Treaty Commissioner website. http://www.otc.ca/

The Treaty Essential Learnings is an initiative in Saskatchewan to teach all students, K-12, about treaties 4, 5, 6, 8, and 10 which cover our province. It has been in development since 2008 and teachers throughout the province now have resource kits to help teach about treaties. The resources available are well put together however it would be beneficial for teachers and students to have as many resources at their fingertips as possible. At this moment, teachers have been finding their own supplemental resources. I would like to put together a website that would gather as many online resources as possible the support the TELs as well as about First Nations culture in general. I envision it for both teachers and students with short synopsis’s of each one and/or recommendations on how to use the resource.

 

I am interested in this topic because I am a grade four teacher in Saskatchewan with little experience of First Nations culture. I have been teaching the TELs for the past few years with the resources available however I have always felt I could do a better job.

Research Interest: Identity, the Arts, and New Media Technologies

Through the use of this blog, I would like to gain a greater understanding of contemporary Aboriginal cultural identity, specifically in a Canadian context. I feel that the arts provide a valuable lens from which to explore this topic, as art forms such as music, dance, carving, and textiles have long played a pivotal role in First Nations culture. The arts provided artists and communities with ways of preserving traditions, history and affirming a shared sense of tribal identity, something that was adversely affected by the federal laws that restricted or prohibited traditional practices, and of course the residential school system that separated children from their families over several generations.

As First Nations communities attempt to heal the scars of these traumatic experiences, I’m curious to know what role the arts are playing in revitalizing Aboriginal cultural traditions and strengthening a sense of purpose and identity in the twenty-first century. In addition to revitalizing traditional art forms, new technologies such as video, audio recording and digital art software provide First Nations artists with an opportunity to create new works of art that merge tradition with modernity. The integration of new technologies, re-interpretations of traditional art forms and the influence of media produced by non-aboriginal artists, however, presents new challenges and questions about the meaning, purpose and sanctity of Aboriginal art that I feel is worth exploring.

 

Technology and loss of identity

The benefits of technology are easily noticed.  The Web and other technological devices do allow indigenious people an opportunity to explore and investigate their culture.  People can often find traditional skills that may have otherwise been lost. However there has been a much research done on the overuse of technology.

Therefore, I wish to explore the drawbacks or negative side-effects of this over technological use on indigenious people.  This topic may seem broad in scope. How do we judge what is overuse of technology?  Which negative aspects of techuse do I wish to explore:  the medical, the environmental, or the social?  I will focus my research on the personal impact of technological use as it affects or alters one’s life.  I wish to explore if technology is taking away the self-identity, or cultural identity of indigenious people, – an identity that, without technology, would remain.

I will explore articles and sites on technology versus self-identity and cultural identity.  I will also examine data on technological use for indigenious and non-indigenious groups.

Below is a list of some sites, articles, and research that may be used along with the information from my modules.

Statement Connecting Weblog to Research Interests

For my project, I am interested in the factors behind the dropout rates of Indigenous learners. Lately more Indigenous students have better education opportunities, but I still find articles about high dropout rates of Indigenous students in North America. Some marginalized students may be facing geographical problems or infrastructure difficulties, or there may exist other reasons. In terms of education, Indigenous peoples’ situation may be improved by the Internet—it has made it possible for them to access material and join the class discussion no matter where they live.

Since schools at every level will have more Indigenous students in the future, it is crucial for both educators and learners to understand the factors that encourage students to remain in the course or cause them decide to leave. I would like to propose a research project analyzing the reasons Indigenous learners drop out—my research findings will help educators obtain a clearer picture on how school education should be conducted in order to retain students over the long term and how technology can be used to further that goal.

I haven’t narrowed down my research questions yet. The broad topic about dropout rates for Indigenous students may already been studied by other researchers so I want to develop a distinct approach for my study. I need a little more time to think about it.

References:

Balla, J. (2012). Identity and Knowledge in Indigenous Young Children’s Experiences in Canada. Childhood Education, 88 (5), 286-291.

Biddle, N. & Cameron, T. (2012). Potential Factors Influencing Indigenous Education Participation and Achievement. National Centre for Vocational Education Research (NCVER).

Jones, B. A. (1992). Collaboration: The Case for Indigenous Community-Based Organization Support of Dropout Prevention Programming and Implementation. The Journal of Negro education, 61 (4), 496-508.

Kutay, C., Mooney, J., Riley, L. & Howard-Wagner, D. (2012). Experiencing Indigenous Knowledge Online as a Community Narrative. Australian Journal of Indigenous Education, 41 (1), 47-59.

Mangana, J. & Trendleb, B. (2010). Cancellation of indigenous Australians from the apprenticeship training contract. Education Economics, 18 (4), 377-394.

Residential School Impacts or The Importance of Residential School Awareness

I just now realized that my Research Statement was not posted properly on the Webblog. I apologize for this late post as I thought I posted it some time ago but must not have published the post.

My main area of interest has to do with the lasting effects of the residential School Era in Canada. The topic is very popular today as it was only in June of 2008 when the Government of Canada made a formal recognition and apology.

The Government of Canada began to play a role in the development and administration of Indian Residential Schools in 1874. It operated nearly every school as a joint venture with various religious organizations including Anglican, Presbyterian, United and Roman Catholic churches.

Indian Residential Schools recognized by Canada are those where children were placed in a residence for the purposes of education by, or under, the authority of the Government of Canada; and, where the Government of Canada was jointly responsible for the operation of the residence and care of the children resident therein.

Some 150,000 Aboriginal children were removed and separated from their families and communities to attend residential schools. There were over 130 schools located in every province and territory except Newfoundland, New Brunswick and Prince Edward Island. While most Indian Residential Schools ceased to operate by the mid-1970s, the last federally-run school closed in the late 1990s. (AADNC, 2012)

I understand that the topic of residential schools on a whole is far too broad to focus on just for this class project. I hope to stream it to something along the lines of how has the Indian Residential School Settlement Agreement changed for the better and of the impacting effects of residential schools.

There are 2 major questions that I have came up with to focus my research efforts

  1. Does money and settlements have any means of fixing the loss of identity and social problems caused by tearing families apart and in some cases torturing or murdering children?
  2. Or, I may want to focus on how the necessity of bringing residential school awareness to Canadians. If we ignore the wrongdoings of a government and societal mindset do we risk having future atrocities taking place again?

Some Preliminary resources I have found are below:

References

AADNC. (2012, March 28). Indian Residential Schools  – Key Milestones. Affaires autochtones et Développement du Nord Canada / Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada. Retrieved September 28, 2013, from http://www.aadnc-aandc.gc.ca/eng/1332939430258/1332939552554

Exhibit / Where are the Children?. (n.d.). Where are the Children? Healing the Legacy of the Residential Schools. Retrieved October 1, 2013, from http://www.wherearethechildren.ca/en/exhibit/impacts.html

Canadian Press. (n.d.). Day students seek class action for suffering at B.C. residential schools  | Globalnews.ca. Global News | Latest & Current News – Weather, Sports & Health News. Retrieved September 29, 2013, from http://globalnews.ca/news/883196/day-students-seek-class-action-for-suffering-at-b-c-residential-schools/

Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (TRC). (n.d.). Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (TRC). Retrieved September 28, 2013, from http://www.trc.ca/websites/trcinstitution/index.php?p=3

Connecting Weblog to Research

As mentioned in module 1 postings, I am interested in the residential school history in Canada. As a child growing up in New Brunswick and living close to a reserve, we had a number of native students in our school and classrooms. As a child, I didn’t like it at all and I didn’t understand why the native students were in school because it was obvious, even to a primary school child, that they really didn’t want to be there.

My education about native Canadians is very weak and I do not recall ever studying or learning about their history or culture while in school. I know only a small amount about the residential school programme in Canada and this is an area I would like to research more. I would like to look at the government’s purpose for these schools, how they operated, the curriculum taught, treatment of the students and their eventual closer and government apology for them.

Statement connecting weblog to research

Based on my background in social research as an undergraduate, I would like to explore more on the subjects of how educational technology can support social connectivity, networking, and community building in preserving and advancing First Nations culture in today’s world. The analytical framework will be based on the notion of social capital defined by Falk & Filpatrick (1999) as “the product of social interactions with the potential to contribute to the social, civic or economic well-being of a community-of-common-purpose. The interactions draw on knowledge and identity resources and simultaneously use and build stores of social capital.” Many researchers are applying this notion to the Indigenous context (e.g. see sources).

Possible topics of exploration includes:

  • Social capital in examining educational achievement, particularly in relation to social exclusion.
  • Social capital as a relevant way of measuring the impacts of ICT in Indigenous communities.
  • Social capital in the context of Indigenous economic development.

I will also seek to examine community-building projects carried out by ICT support groups such as Network BC and First Nations Technology Council, and analyze the role of social capital for measuring social and economic outcomes in rural and remote aboriginal communities.

Possible Sources:

Brough, Mark., Bond, C., Hunt, Julian., Jenkins, D., Shannon, C., & Schubert, L. (2006). Social Capital Meets Identity: Aboriginality in an Urban Setting. Journal of Sociology 42(4), 396-411.

Hunter, B. (2000). Social Exclusion, Social Capital and Indigenous Australians: Measuring the Social Costs of Unemployment. CAEPR Discussion Paper 204, Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research, The Australian National University, Canberra.  

Lahn, J. (2012). Poverty, Work and Social Networks: The Role of Social Capital for Aboriginal People in Urban Australian Locales. Urban Policy and Research, 30, 293-308.

Mignone, J., Henley, H., Brown, J., O’Neil, J., & Ross, W. (2008). Information and Communication Technology in Aboriginal Communities in Canada: Increasing Aboriginal Social Capital. Journal of Aboriginal Health, 1-84.

Mignone, J. (2009). Social Capital and Aboriginal Communities: A Critical Assessment. Journal of Aboriginal Health, 100-147.

Preservation of Culture in an Economy of Extraction – my statement to connect weblogs.

Nilesh Patel, a friend of mine from High School, filmed and directed a movie in 2006 called “Brocket 99: Rocking the Country”. The film was created to spark authentic dialogue between First Nations and non-aboriginal peoples in the hopes of tackling stereotypes and promoting increased tolerance. I recently had a chance to talk with Nilesh, who described some of his experiences of the past 10 years, making documentary movies with First Nations groups across BC and Alberta. We discussed how attitudes towards First Nations groups varies greatly depending on the region and how some First Nation groups are making strides to regain sovereignty, while others fall behind and still face oppressive resistance and hostility. Reflecting on our discussion, I think of how government in Western Canada is eagerly pursuing an “economy first, use it or lose it” agenda. I question, “Where does culture of indigenous peoples fit within an ideology of resource extraction and economic growth?” I believe economic development has put indigenous peoples at a crossroads today. The race is on to preserve traditional ways, especially language, in the face of massive global economic pressure and corporate interests.

Tar sands extraction in northern Alberta

To start my inquiry, I will look at three distinctly different regions of Western Canada and the groups of indigenous peoples that live within these regions: Duncan, BC (Cowichan Tribes); Fort McKay, Alberta (Cree, Dene, and Metis); and Inuvik, Northwest Territory (Inuvialuit, Gwich’in, and Metis). I will examine the industry that exists within these areas and how economics has affected and continues to affect these First Nations peoples. I will then study how these indigenous groups are using technology to help retain and pass on what is vital to their way of life. Lastly, I will look at how these First Nations groups are utilizing the internet as a space to promote culture and identity.

Mel Burgess.

Statement Connecting Blog to Research

Possible Title: Teaching the Teacher: a Look at How Canadian Schools Portray its Indigenous Population

Issues surrounding Canada’s indigenous population have long intrigued me. My undergraduate studies raised questions about the role of the mainstream population in threatening indigenous culture, through displacement and residential schooling.

As we read through the course readings and I gain more knowledge, I am interested in studying possible supports that could alleviate the historical tensions between indigenous and mainstream populations.

More specifically, I am interested in exploring what role Canada’s school system can play in reviving and inspiriting its nation’s indigenous culture. As an educator, I am eager to extend my knowledge of the teaching methods available to promote a positive, accurate portrayal of Canadian indigeneity, in the hopes that improved education will lead to improved relations between the two cultures.

My research will be founded on Marker’s seven suggestions for the classroom, as well as the writings of Mohawk leader Lamb, who describes the ideal relationship between the two populations. Chad Solomon, a member of the First Nations, is currently actualizing some of Marker and Lamb’s recommendations. His educational program “Rabbit and Bear Paws,” uses humour and interactive puppetry to teach native traditional stories to indigenous and mainstream populations alike.

 

List of resources:

http://rabbitandbearpaws.com/presentations

http://www.bimose.ca/

http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/aiq/summary/v027/27.1lambe.html

https://circle.ubc.ca/bitstream/handle/2429/44152/Balfe_W_Letting_Go_LLED590_2013.pdf?sequence=1 (Section 4, pages 37-47)