STUDY GREAT IDEAS, BUT TEACH TO THE TEST
New York Times “On Education” Column
July 13, 2005
by Michael Winerip
Becky Karnes, a high school English teacher, recently completed a graduate-level writing course that she loved at Grand Valley State University.
“The course taught us better ways to teach writing to kids,” said Ms. Karnes, a 16-year veteran who is finishing up her master’s degree. “It showed you ways to stretch kids’ minds. I learned so much, I had my eyes opened about how to teach writing.”
Ms. Karnes learned all sorts of exercises to get children excited about writing, get them writing daily about what they care about and then show them how they can take one of those short, personal pieces and use it as the nucleus for a sophisticated, researched essay.
“We learned how to develop good writing from the inside, starting with calling the child’s voice out,” said Ms. Karnes, who got an A in the university course. “One of the major points was, good writing is good thinking. That’s why writing formulas don’t work. Formulas don’t let kids think; they kill a lot of creativity in writing.”
And so, when Ms. Karnes returns to Allendale High School to teach English this fall, she will use the new writing techniques she learned and abandon the standard five-paragraph essay formula. Right?
“Oh, no,” said Ms. Karnes. “There’s no time to do creative writing and develop authentic voice. That would take weeks and weeks. There are three essays on the state test and we start prepping right at the start of the year. We have to teach to the state test” (the Michigan Educational Assessment Program, known as MEAP).
“MEAP is not what writing is about, but it’s what testing is about,” Ms. Karnes said. “And we know if we teach them the five-paragraph essay formula, they’ll pass that test. There’s a lot of pressure to do well on MEAP. It makes the district seem good, helps real estate values.”In Michigan, there is added pressure. If students pass the state tests,
they receive $2,500 college scholarships, and in Ms. Karnes’s
middle-class district, families need that money. “I can’t see myself
fighting against MEAP,” she said. “It would hurt my students too much.
It’s a dilemma. It may not be the best writing, but it gets them the money.”
In this fashion, the five-paragraph essay has become the law of the
land: introductory paragraph; three supporting paragraphs, each with its
own topic sentence as well as three supporting ideas; and summary paragraph.
Students lose points for writing a one-sentence paragraph.
Many English teachers have developed a standard five-paragraph form with
blanks to fill in.
Topic sentence:__________.
Literary example:_________.
Historical example:_________.
Current event:__________.
Concluding sentence:_________.
The National Council of Teachers of English has warned that standardized
state tests mandated by the federal No Child Left Behind law, as well as
the College Board’s new SAT writing sample, are actually hurting the
teaching of writing in this country. For their part, the makers of these
tests emphasize that they don’t mandate a writing formula, and they,
too, say it would be a mistake if schools taught only by the formula.
But Nancy Patterson, the Grand Valley professor who offers the popular
course for teachers here, says in the face of those tests, teachers
cling to the formula and it spreads like kudzu. “A lot, particularly the
younger ones, have been raised on the five-paragraph formula, and are
insecure about their own writing,” she said. “They drink up what we do
here, but then go back to teach to the test. It shuts them down. It
narrows the curriculum.”
“If you give kids the formula to write an essay, you’re taking away the
very thinking that a writer engages in,” she said. “Kids are less apt to
develop a writer’s thinking skills.” And it is spreading downward. In
preparation for the fourth-grade state writing test, she said, she sees
third-grade teachers pressed to use the five-paragraph formula. A
teacher in Dr. Patterson’s class described her frustration over a
practice essay test in her district asking third graders to “defend or
refute from a patriotic standpoint” whether a friend should go to a
Memorial Day parade. “For 9-year-olds?” said Dr. Patterson. “Defend or
refute?”
Dr. Patterson has her teachers write in every class – something she did
with her students during 29 years in the public schools. They draw maps
of their neighborhoods, then write a story of something that happened
there. They envision a character they’d like to create, make a paper
doll of it, then pair up with another student and together write a story
with the two characters interacting.
“You’re teaching them narrative – how to tell stories that are dear to
them,” she said. She has them read good essays that start a hundred
different ways – with a quote; a question; a simple declaration of a
problem; a run-on sentence; a word or two. There are lessons on how a
writer blows up an important moment and how to turn a personal piece of
writing into a researched essay.
Recently, Kristen Covelle, 24, has been going on interviews for English
teaching jobs. She mentions exciting things she’s learned from Dr.
Patterson. “The interview will be going great,” Ms. Covelle said, “and
then MEAP will come up. They want to know will I teach to the test,
that’s what they’re looking for. They asked how I feel about using “I”
in writing. Would there ever be a case when “I” is appropriate in an
essay. I knew the answer they want – you’re not supposed to use it. But
I couldn’t say that. I said there could be times, you just can’t close
the door. They didn’t say anything but it was definitely the low point
of the interview.”
Ms. Karnes isn’t totally against the formula. “For kids struggling, if
you can give them a formula and they fill in the blanks, some will pass
the MEAP test who wouldn’t otherwise,” she said. “But it turns into a
prison. It stops you from finding a kid’s potential.”
She loves the last month of school, when state tests are over, she said.
Last spring she did lessons on poetry and writing short stories. “I
found interests and talents in those kids I didn’t know were there,” she
said. “It would have been nice to have a whole year to build on those
things.”
Follow
