Review: “Spatial and temporal aspects of alcohol-related crime in a college town”

Brower, A. M., & Carroll, L. (2007). Spatial and temporal aspects of alcohol-related crime in a college town. Journal of American College Health, 55(5), 267-75.

This paper addressing the relationship between drinking and student crime in Madison (Wisconsin), making two major arguments:

  1. More serious crimes occur at the intersection between high density student areas and high density drinking outlets.
  2. Non-student residents living near students submit noise complaints at around midnight when they are going to sleep and student parties are still continuing.

Methodology:

The methodology was very basic – effectively mapping reported crimes by time onto a basemap in ArcGIS.

Results:

  1.  There was a peak in serious crimes  when bars closed downtown, which was identified as a high density cluster for drinking and crime incidents.
  2. Noise complaints, as expected, were highest between 9pm and midnight. 

Although the paper lead to genuine zero-tolerance policies by the University and the city, the authors underestimated the statistical potential of GIS, as they presented it as a merely descriptive tool. As such we assigned the paper a mark of 5/10.

Class 8: Use of GIS in Fire Departments

The Calgary Fire Department (CFD) actively use GIS analysis for the following:

  • Risk Analysis
  • Response Mapping
  • Decision Making
  • Spatial Planning
  • Apparatus Deployment
  • Station Relocation

To collect the risk data the team use basic on-paper mapping techniques to classify areas by risk as a function of concentration and distribution. Another form of analysis they use is the identification of proximity loss where incidents are a function of structures in close proximity to one another. This analysis lead to the identification of roads that are too narrow for fire trucks and where the buildings have a high fire risk due to proximity.

By mapping out the locations of oil and gas stations and hydrants, the team have a better understanding of where to situate apparatus and fire stations. Furthermore it is possible to apply a temporal element by analysing the distribution of historical fire incidents. Call and drive fire and medical response times were also mapped out across the city. Fire location analysis can be used alongside potential explanatory variables like population growth and annex lands, and number of firefighters likely to arrive on scene.

These analyses together can help in the proposal of new fire station locations to ensure service provisions to communities based on need from growth and the results of the gap analysis. Indeed, this was implemented to created a new station in northwest Calgary that fulfilled a number of locational requirements.

Review: Spatial Access to Health Care in Costa Rica (Kevin Hu)

Rosero-Bixby, L. (2004). Spatial access to health care in Costa Rica and its equity: a GIS-based study. Social Science & Medicine58(7), 1271-1284.

Kevin presented a paper that used GIS analysis to investigate differential access to health care in Costa Rice. The data consisted of census data and health care provision data, with missing data acquired through the use of telephone interviews. The author also conducted random field visits to hospitals and did some groundtruthing for the GPS coordinates.

The author built a model to simulate distance to the nearest healthcare facility, mapping proximity to outpatient facilities. The smallest distances were clustered around San Jose but were otherwise very sparsely distributed. The model also accounted for visitor’s satisfaction and the choices they make when selecting between healthcare facilities.

The results indicated that 12-14% of the population of Costa Rica were underserved. On a temporal scale, inequity declined by up to 30% as a result of reforms in 1995 and 1996, although this number has been steadily increasing in recent years.

Overall, Kevin gave this paper a 9/10 because the models were well designed and the data was carefully validated. However, some decisions (i.e. cut-off values in the models) appeared to be selected arbitrarily.

Review : “Using geographically weighted regression for environmental justice analysis: Cumulative cancer risks from air toxics in Florida”

Gilbert, A., & Chakraborty, J. (2011). Using geographically weighted regression for environmental justice analysis: Cumulative cancer risks from air toxics in Florida. Social Science Research, 40(1), 273-286.

This paper draws on previous literature about inequality in health geography to investigate the risk of cancer risk  from ambient exposure to air pollutants between different socioeconomic groups across Florida, focusing on the following 2 research questions:

  1. Are cumulative lifetime cancer risks from ambient exposure to multiple sources of hazardous air pollutants distributed inequitably with respect to race/ethnicity and socioeconomic status across Florida?
  2. How does the direction and significance of statistical relationships between cumulative lifetime cancer risk and race/ethnicity or socioeconomic status vary across the state of Florida?

Methodology:

Using modelled cumulative air cancer risk and socio-economic factors such as racial structure of communities, the authors conducted two forms of regression analysis. Ordinary Least Squares was used to acquire a global fit and Geographically Weighted Regression was used to determine whether the difference in the fit between the explanatory variables and the overall cancer risk changed differed across the state.

Results:

  1. There is a positive and significant relationship between the proportion of Black, Hispanic and Asian residents and overall cancer risk and a negative and significant relationship between population density and number of people below the poverty line and overall cancer risk.

2.  In comparison to the OLS model, the GWR model fit the data disproportionately across the           map, with hotspots in urban centres like Miami. 

This paper makes a convincing case for GWR and the authors use GIS software to produce clear and legible maps, but more care could have gone into the selection of model data. The authors elaborate on the theoretical element of GWR but this soon becomes repetitive. As such, this paper has been given a rating of 7/10.

Lab 4: CrimeStats

In this lab, the Crimestats analysis software was used to analyse the spatial and temporal distribution of a number of crimes between January 2005 – March 2006 in Ottawa (ON): vehicle theft, breaking and entry (residential), breaking and entry (commercial). A Moran’s Correlograms (below) shows that the spatial autocorrelation of breaking and entry (residential) incidents is highest of the crimes, followed by Vehicle thefts and break and entry (commercial) incidents. Additionally, these all appear to share spatial autocorrelation with the population variable.

The Nearest Neighbour Analysis Index (below) indicate that the crime with the highest level of spatial clustering is breaking and entering (commercial), while the lowest is breaking and entering (residential). This is unsurprising considering the presence of commercial hubs in urban areas.

1st, 2nd and 3rd order nearest neighbour risk-adjusted spatial clustering results (below) represent ‘clusters’ within ‘clusters’ of crimes and accounts for population distribution. Thus, the map indicates areas at particular risk of residential breaking and entry crimes, given the population. The areas at risk are in the central downtown area and in other distinct pockets in suburbs and satellite towns.

While we also produced single dual kernel density analysis maps, I found the dual kernel density map to be the most useful as it shows the relative density of breaking and entering (residential) crimes in Ottawa while accounting for population density. The map indicates higher risk in localised pockets downtown in and particular suburbs away from the city centre, with low z-scores likely representing more sparsely populated parts of Ottawa.

Lab 3: Geographically Weighted Regression

The spatial nature of some datasets (for example, Census data) allows us to investigate the extent to which these associates vary in strength and direction across space. The aim of this lab was to model child social skills against a model Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR) model composed of a set of statistically selected independent variables related to the child and to their neighbourhood. Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR) is a spatially resolved statistical form of regression that allows the value of the dependent variable to vary between locations based on the assumption that so too do the values of the independent variables, as the relationship between phenomena are not fixed across space.

Gender as a predictor of social skills in children

Gender appears to have a notably varied effect on children’s social skills across the cities. In the West End and Mount Pleasant, being a female predicts lower social skills, in comparison to areas of South Vancouver and Hastings where it appears to have a positive impact. The relationship between language skills and social skills is positive across the city, though notably less pronounced in parts of South Vancouver (i.e. South Granville, Shaughnessy and Cambie) where the standard deviation reaches a low of 0.31. Finally, the relationship between parent’s income and social skills is lowest in areas of East Vancouver (i.e. Main and Victoria) with a standard deviation of -1.8, higher in Renfrew (standard deviation of 2.5), though the map indicates a relatively weak relationship between the two variables in comparison to the gender and language skills. The r2 values from the model output were plotted as point data and overlaid onto the raster coefficient maps – the highest fit of the models to the data are clustered in central East Vancouver and lowest in areas such as UBC and South Vancouver.

Grouping Analysis:

The ArcGIS grouping tool was used to categorise neighbourhoods of the city with shared characteristics as determined by GWR. This provides a more nuanced view of differences in childhoods across the city than simply ‘east vs west’. This analysis generated the following groups, which were choropleth mapped :

The legend categories 1-4 are detailed below:

  1. UBC, Mount Pleasant, West End, Marpole

This area has the lowest % of families that spend 30 or more hours on childcare per week, the lowest number of families >4 and the lowest number of neighbourhood immigrants.

  1. Stanley Park area, Strathcona

This area has the highest number of neighbourhood immigrants.

  1. East Vancouver

This area the highest number of low parent families, the highest % if families that spend 30 or more hours on childcare and the lowest average income.

  1. Kitsilano, Dunbar

This area has the highest income, the highest number of families >4, and the lowest number of lone parent households.

 

 

Class 7: GIS & Crime

Instead of merely a function of temporal and socioeconomic aspects as a predictor of criminal activity, crime can also be considered as a geographical phenomena. Environmental criminology incorporates the idea that crime is influenced by our lived environment.

Crime Geography Theory

  • Routine activity theory: individuals with a motivation to commit a crime, a suitable target, and the absence of a capable guardian. 

Routine activities occur in space, as do ‘nodes’ of activity (places of residence, school, work and leisure facilities. Furthermore, transportation effects the location of a crime which is especially visible when you compare between ‘walking cultures’ and ‘car cultures’.

  • Rational choice theory: criminal activities are a result of the individual making what they believe to be a rational and prudent decision to commit a crime.

What are the rewards against the chances of getting caught? The individual might conduct a cost benefit analysis, and the risk might not be homogenous across space.

  • Crime pattern theory: criminal activities are tied into people’s everyday activities

Crimes occur where the daily activities of victims and potential criminals intersect.

Spatial Crime Analysis Types

Geographical profiling is a tool that has been used to exploit the geographic nature of serial criminal offenders to predict the probably location of the next offence. This analysis can incorporate whether the criminal is a commuter (they travel to commit a crime) or marauder (they commit crimes in their own neighbourhood).

Crime Analysis Applications

  • Intelligence analysis investigates organised criminal activity with the aim to link people with events and property via social network analysis.
  • Criminal investigative analysis is the (largely retrospective) study of serial criminal activities with analysis alongside physical, socioeconomics, psychological and spatial variables.
  • Tactical crime analysis incorporates recent criminal incidents and potential criminal activity to investigate trends in criminal activities and identify key suspects.
  • Administrative crime analysis looks at the findings of crime analysis research in the context of legality, politics and practical considerations.

Class 6: GIS in health geography

Epidemiology is, broadly, the investigation of health or disease conditions, causes and distributions. It is the study of health and population. There are a number of mechanisms by which GIS analysts can aid this branch of medicine:

Spatial epidemiology is about describing and analysing disease risk in relation to space. It has been developed in recent years as a function of geo-referenced health data availability, in addition to advancement of the capabilities of GIS and statistical technology. Small area analysis is preferred because of particular correlating relationships between social and environmental variables and health outcomes (i.e. Geographical correlation studies). Important internal details would be lost using a large-scale analysis framework. An issue with small-scale studies is spatial misalignment whereby data might be available in two different spatial units (i.e. polling districts vs dissemination areas), in addition to uncertainty resulting from changing qualities of population datasets, and metrics which are difficult to measure such as population movement. Best practises in spatial epidemiology include allowing for spatial heterogeneity, using well defined population groups, use consistent data (i.e. from surveys) and allow for both latency times and population movement.

Environmental hazards can also be analysed using GIS. This involves investigating the influence of environmental variances (such as the spraying of DDT) on health risk in particular areas, considering the differential exposures of communities to harmful substances or diseases. Historical data can be incorporated to build on our understanding of the spatial distribution of environmental hazards.

The modelling of health services can take a number of forms. For example, models of public accessibility to health services can be constructed to calculate the extent to which individual communities can easily seek out medical care.

Identifying health inequalities is a particularly valuable outcome of health GIS analysis. Many studies have outlined higher levels of risk of smoking-related disease to individuals in lower socio-economic groups. Furthermore, communities often exhibit inequity in accessibility of healthcare services.

Disease classifications are challenging because they may be the result of multiple causal agents and can have different manifestations among different population subgroups.

Lab 2: Exploring Fragstats

In Lab 2, we used the Fragstats software to analyse land use change around Edmonton between 1966 and 1976. The below maps show the land use maps in the entire study areas for each of the two years, using land use data downloaded from Canada Land Use Monitoring Program (CLUMP) data for Edmonton from the Geogratis website:

1966 Land Use in Edmonton

1976 Land Use in Edmonton

The Fragstats analysis revealed a number of noteworthy changes. One major trend is the decrease in cropland extent as land within this decade was converted to urban land, unimproved pasture, productive forest and mining. Urban areas increased in extent over this decade – both in the city of Edmonton and in smaller settlements, mostly located along the North Saskatchewan river, as can be seen in the map below:

Increased Urban Expansion in Edmonton 1966-1976

Additionally, productive woodland has increased at the expense of unimproved pasture to the northwest and southeast of Edmonton, as can be seen in the map below:

Increased Urban Expansion in Edmonton 1966-1976

Based on the analysis in this report, I believe the following recommendations would be beneficial in increasing our understanding of the described phenomena:

  • Further analysis should be pursued to investigate potential correlations between the change in landscape metrics between 1966 and 1976. Multiple regression could determine the extent to which predictor variables such as population change and socioeconomic factors.
  • A greenbelt system could be installed to prevent further exponential urban expansion into agricultural land. Furthermore, increasing collaboration with the local government and stakeholders could mitigate future conflict surrounding issues of food sustainability, industrialisation and access to outdoor recreation.
  • Further research could be pursued on the increased prevalence of forest edges and the possibility of increased vulnerability to invasive species.

 

Class 5: What is health geography?

Why? There is an inherent connection between Geography and health, as our health is to some extent associated with the natural and built environments in which we work, live, and travel. An example of this is the link between location and the quality of water supplies. Therefore, we can exploit GIS to analyse spatially resolved health data.

Medical geography is the topical intersection between health phenomena and geographical methods. Health geographers, in comparison, perceive flaws in the biomedical viewpoint of medical geography as this perspective does not incorporate much social theory. Today we have a “post-medical” perspective of health geography. Some commentators suggested there were, in fact, five strands of health geography:

  1. Spatial patterning of disease and health (patterns of disease, views diseases as “facts” and understands related processes as ecology)
  2. Spatial patterning of service provision (patterns of health service facilities and utilisation, considers equity, demand and efficiency, diseases as “facts” and people as “optimisers”)
  3. Humanistic approaches to medical geography (looks at perception of health by laypeople in comparison to experts, illness is viewed as a social construct)
  4. Structuralist / materialist / critical approaches to medical geography (investigates the inequalities in health taking into consideration the structure of the social, political and economic system in place)
  5. Cultural approaches to medical geography (considers therapeutic landscapes and health promotion and reframing health in positive terms, culturally sensitive health practises)