The moral imperative of shopping?

Well, I really enjoyed my Xmas presents and I’ve got nothing against “stuff.”

In fact, if we had more equitable distribution of the economic pie everybody could not only have what they need but could enjoy more pleasures.

But, the Boxing Day editorial in the Vancouver Sun illustrates the absurdy of consumerism/capitalism run amok.
buy-nothing-day.jpg

While Canadians are queuing up at Future Shop to save 50 bucks on a PSP (10 per store) this morning, The Sun was telling its readers the post-Xmas retail rush is about more than saving a few bucks, rather holiday shopping is moral imperative.

“Break out that credit card and support humanity,” the editors tell us.

While I’m sure The Sun would label me one of those “righteous voices of high-mindedness” that tend to speak over “the profits and pleasures inherent in closing out the year by successfully stalking a terrific bargain,” but do they really think that readers are going to believe their BS that shopping is about making the difference between a “shiny new bike” or a “couple of used CDs” or a turkey dinner instead of weiners and beans for the low paid, temporary, otherwise unemployed retail workers in the lower mainland???

The Sun says, “What you spend on Christmas gifts and Boxing Day sales will flow benefits to people whom you don’t know, will never meet and yet will be grateful for those benefits although they’ll likely never thank you.” Well, that’s probably true, but people raking in the benefits are not retail workers but corporations like the Pacific Newspaper Group who reap huge profits from all those sale ads, banks that issue Visas and Mastercards, and retail conglomerates like Wal-Mart, HBC, Federated, etc.

Makes me want to join the Buy Nothing Day crowd.

A multicultural xmas

91655-32056.jpg
Today’s Vancouver Sun published an article by religion and ethics writer Douglas Todd on the “multicultural Christmas” celebrations at Sir Richard McBride Elementary and how students there “balance” their own ethnicity with diverse (sometimes new) cultural traditions.

McBride, on Vancouver’s eastside, is my son’s school and his good buddy Codie Schultheis has some insightful comments on Christmas celebrations in public schools.

When I asked Codie Schultheis, 11, one of the few dozen white students at McBride, what he thought of some secularists’ argument that neither Christmas nor Christian symbols should be allowed in any way in public schools, he looked perplexed.

“I don’t get offended when the school celebrates Divali [the Hindu-Sikh festival],” retorted the Grade 6 student, who added his family is not particularly religious.

“I love Christmas. I just try to be happy when it’s around. I don’t know, people who say we shouldn’t have Christmas in the school here should go to a school in China. I bet they wouldn’t stop celebrating Chinese New Year there because some Canadians were in the school.”

Saturday » December 24 » 2005
Vancouver Sun
A multicultural Christmas
CELEBRATIONS I Sir Richard McBride students balance ethnicity with new traditions

Douglas Todd
Vancouver Sun

Saturday, December 24, 2005

CREDIT: Bill Keay, Vancouver Sun
On the gym wall at Sir Richard McBride elementary school on East 29th Avenue is a sign that encourages students to respect each other, regardless of their cultural backgrounds.
More Columns By This Writer
:: Speaking openly about Christmas
:: A shortage of the gift of life
:: Interview with a (converted) vampire-and-sex writer
:: Iraqi conflict a sectarian civil war
:: Mystery writers fill a spiritual gap left by churches
:: Religious rules challenged
:: Hazing the ultimate in grisly initiation rites
:: Innovation includes an interspiritual initiative
‘Tis the season of Christmas trees and Santa Claus expectations inside the old, red brick walls of Sir Richard McBride elementary on East 29th Avenue in Vancouver.

‘Tis also the season of Silent Night and sparing a thought for the hungry; of children growing excited about big family dinners, multicoloured lights and piles of gifts.

Just as when I was a kid at Richard McBride in the early 1960s.

Or not.

There are a few differences.

One is that, when I was at McBride, nearly every student was white — with the exception of two Chinese children (one of whom I had a crush on in Grade 2. Vice versa, I like to think.)

Now, the stately three-storey heritage school, built in 1911 and named in honour of a B.C. premier from the early 1900s, is attended by students who speak at least 22 languages in their homes — most of them Asian.

McBride is on the untidy front lines of Canada’s immigration, language and multicultural policies. Even though four out of five of McBride’s 440 students were born in Canada, the vast majority enter kindergarten as English-as-a-second-language students.

Their most common first language is some form of Chinese, spoken in the homes of 172 McBride children.

That’s followed by Tagalog, from the Philippines, which is the language used in 66 McBride students’ homes. Then comes English (60 homes) Vietnamese (58 homes) Punjabi (33 homes) and Tamil (10 homes).

There are also children whose home languages are Urdu, Japanese, Thai, Persian, Portuguese, Spanish, German, Cambodian, or something else.

McBride — located in the middle of a pleasantly jumbled middle-class neighbourhood between Fraser and Knight streets, where small, well-kept heritage homes frequently butt against blocky new houses and unkempt ones — has become one of those urban Canadian public schools that have turned into social laboratories.

McBride has become a living test case, where all the theorizing about multiculturalism by Canadian and international policy makers, cultural scholars, economists, religious leaders, multiculturalism and the politically correct actually comes to a head.

Is it working?

I went to find out how Christmas is marked at McBride compared with when I was a student, thinking it would be a way to check if Canadian-style multiculturalism is proving effective on the ground, or deteriorating into a grand failure.

Could a public school that mixes large cohorts of Sikh, Hindu, Christian, Muslim, Buddhist, agnostic, ancestor-revering and atheist kids pull off living and learning together, without many people somehow ending up irritated or offended?

Christmas is one of those times that can get up people’s noses as too commercial, too sentimental, too emotionally demanding, too invasive or too Christian.

But I found a lot of Christmas energy flowing at McBride.

My first discovery was that neither I nor the teachers could uncover a single student who didn’t have a Christmas tree at home.

And, despite their mostly Asian ethnic origins, almost every student I interviewed said they would receive at least some gifts, and have some sort of extended family dinner on Christmas Day. When turkey is on the table, they said, it will likely be served with rice, steamed vegetables or curry dishes.

The widespread embracing of elements of Canadian-style Christmas at McBride suggested to me that it’s becoming a secular spiritual festival appreciated by far more than European-rooted Christians.

Most of the predominantly Asian-Canadian students at McBride seemed as intoxicated as I remember most white kids were in my days at the school; giddy at all the good, Christmassy things suddenly flowing their way.

“There’s just a different atmosphere at Christmas,” said Benjamin Pan, 12, whose non-religious parents immigrated from China.

“There’s the Christmas trees and the lights and the food and the gifts, which all make you feel happier.”

Standing near one of the two decorated Christmas trees in McBride’s hallways, under which were piled hundreds of cans for the Vancouver Food Bank, Pan said he liked at Christmas how “there’s all the kindness and giving to less fortunate people, which should be part of any religion.”

I don’t really have bad memories of my early years at McBride (I left after Grade 3 for North Vancouver), nor do I recall anyone expressing racist beliefs, but the rows of desks were, of course, perfectly straight in my day. The wall colours were more dour.

And I do remember on days that poured rain we were forced to stay for recess inside McBride’s high-ceilinged basement. Some teacher with a British accent would stop our noisiness by forcing us to line up against the basement wall for the entire 15 minutes. If we dared moved, he’d rifle a volleyball at us. That was Grade 1.

Nor are the maps of the world at Sir Richard McBride any longer dominated by the colour pink, marking the British Empire, as they were for my generation — and especially when my mother, aunt and uncle attended the school during the Second World War.

God Save the King and then God Save the Queen were also sung at McBride in those days, and the British-based Canadian Red Ensign was honoured as the nation’s flag.

Since then, of course, in the name of secularism and multiculturalism the singing of God Save the Queen has disappeared from McBride, Bible readings are gone — and the Lord’s Prayer is no longer recited each morning.

I can remember earnestly repeating the Christian prayer sitting at our desks. Even though I was from a non-religious family, I took it seriously, and certainly didn’t protest it. But I also had little notion of what it was about.

Yet, despite the understandable removal of explicit British and religious ritual from Canadian public schools, vestiges of traditional Christmas, with its sacred underpinnings, are still allowed in 2005 to have their moment at Sir Richard McBride.

When I asked Codie Schultheis, 11, one of the few dozen white students at McBride, what he thought of some secularists’ argument that neither Christmas nor Christian symbols should be allowed in any way in public schools, he looked perplexed.

“I don’t get offended when the school celebrates Divali [the Hindu-Sikh festival],” retorted the Grade 6 student, who added his family is not particularly religious.

“I love Christmas. I just try to be happy when it’s around. I don’t know, people who say we shouldn’t have Christmas in the school here should go to a school in China. I bet they wouldn’t stop celebrating Chinese New Year there because some Canadians were in the school.”

Even though I was raised an atheist, I could relate to the way many of McBride’s current students, including those who aren’t religious, were exuberant about the approach of Christmas.

As my friends and I did in the early 1960s, most of the McBride pupils talked about trying to believe in the magic of Santa Claus and his present-giving as long as they could.

And like my fun-loving mom, who seemed to like all the Christmas fuss as much as my brother and I did, many have parents who get a kick out of the holiday. Twelve-year-old Nathan Dong said his extended family always buys joke gifts, like “a pair of pink shoes for my uncle, who’s the biggest, buffest guy in our family.”

Then again, one thing that’s new at McBride, compared with my era, is that when the season comes, the multiracial school also pulls out the stops to celebrate at least two other major cultural festivals — Chinese New Year and Divali.

Chinese New Year, with its emphasis on cosmic good fortune, arrives at McBride in January with gusto. Dragon dancers, Chinese lanterns and Chinese games are brought in. And parents, some of whom run restaurants, serve a Chinese lunch, says principal Sandra Phillips, who has been at McBride for five years.

For Divali, which is a celebration of spiritual light, many girls come to school in October dressed in saris and perform Indian dances at a special assembly. The school’s Sikh and Hindu parents also bring sweets and prepare a feast of Indian food, says Phillips, the most multiculturally enthusiastic and least uptight principal I’ve ever met.

In contrast to many school trustees across North America, Grade 7 student Benjamin Pan didn’t think Christmas, Christianity, Hinduism, Sikhism, Judaism, Chinese folk traditions or any other faith should be barred from public schools.

“We should recognize all religions, and not just smear them together,” Pan said.

To further help bring an awareness of diversity into the schools, Phillips says Remembrance Day assemblies at McBride are often devoted to appreciating families’ historical roots.

As well as following a wide variety of religions, some parents of McBride students are refugees who have escaped war. Many parents, struggling with English, work two jobs, which makes it hard for them to become involved in school life — where the majority of teachers are white, although there are a number with Indo-Canadian, Chinese and Japanese roots.

At Remembrance Day ceremonies, children often wear traditional ethnic costumes, pepper a map of the world with pins showing their own or their parents’ country of origin, and talk about why their parents chose to move to Canada.

To round out the multicultural approach at McBride, Phillips has strived to keep the school’s eclectic ethnic and religious mix of kids held together by some shared values.

Wall posters, for instance, extol the global virtues of “optimism,” “curiosity,” “perseverance” and “honesty.”

Another hall sign champions tolerance by forbidding homosexual slurs, including “You’re so gay.” The poster says such bullying is as bad as racism.

More ecumenical ethics are captured in the lyrics of a song by B.C.’s Holly Arntzen, Soar Like an Eagle, which Arntzen and the principal recently adapted to become McBride’s anthem.

The words to Soar Like an Eagle, which are posted in the school gymnasium, call on McBride students to celebrate their differences at the same time they reach for a common goal — to respect and care for one another.

NO MORE SCROOGE

At McBride, in line with these pluralistic times, what we used to call the annual Christmas concert now goes by the more open-ended title, Winter Concert.”

There is no longer a theatrical production about the birth of Jesus Christ, like the one at McBride in the late 1950s in which my older brother played one of the bearded wise men. Nor did the students perform Charles Dickens’ British classic, A Christmas Carol, in which my uncle played Scrooge in the 1940s.

But McBride’s kaleidoscopic concert would have been a tough event to sit through for a secular purist; someone who wants to erase all aspects of spirituality from the public square.

Multiculturalism manifested itself at the annual McBride concert in ways that make the head swim — as cultures bumped up against each other on stage in confusing, endearing, often amusing ways.

Here are some scenes from McBride’s Winter Concert:

A dark-skinned boy from the ESL kindergarten class, with his black hair tied in a Sikh head-knot, joined his class in holding a green paper Christmas tree in front of his body. He and his classmates then formed the shape of an evergreen and recited, in palpitating English, The Straight Green Tree.

A tall, ethnic-Asian boy dressed up as a roly-poly Santa Claus to help perform songs like Must Be Santa and I’m Getting Nothin’ for Christmas, sometimes accompanied by Asian children wearing green elf hats and gigantic beige elf ears.

A Chinese boy sang a sweet solo rendition of It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas.

Two lively Jewish songs were performed, The Dreidl and Hanukkah Tonight (whose lyrics, projected overhead, referred to a “miracle divine”) — even though McBride’s teachers don’t think there’s a Jewish child at the school.

Despite the directions of the Vancouver school board and many others across the continent, the Sikh, Hindu and non-religious kids sang some sacred Christmas carols, including Noel, Noel and Ding Dong Merrily on High (which mentions heaven, angels and steeple bells).

As in my day at McBride, Silent Night was sung.

With its reference to the “holy night” in which Jesus Christ was wondrously born to a virgin mother, the classic carol sounded tender coming from the lips of the diverse singers. One of them, Mahdia Merzed, a Muslim, later said she found Silent Night “sad” but she liked it.

Finally, children from scores of different backgrounds crammed together on stage to sing a rousing rendition of Shine a Light for Peace. For a moment it sounded like a concert from Live 8, the concert series in the G-8 countries and South Africa this year in advance of the G-8 conference in Scotland.

The starry eyed kids were having a ball, enjoying the limelight, their parents’ chaotic camera work and their own often-impressive performances — as well as the sense that Christmas freedom was in the air.

Many of the parents, grandparents and relatives who watched the afternoon concert had taken precious hours away from their jobs. With toddlers in tow, many flowed in and out of the gymnasium with casual, sometimes distracted, abandon.

But many also looked proud and said later they were pleased.

“The children did a beautiful job,” said Selva Kanbiah, a Hindu cabinetmaker from Sri Lanka, who said he had no trouble with the sacred songs tinged with Christian and Jewish themes.

“I think about my children and enjoy what they enjoy. My children like it, so I have to celebrate it. We live here now.”

Bill Dong, a Chinese-Canadian, welcomed the traditional Christmas elements in McBride’s Winter Concert.

“We adhere to the North American tolerant way,” he said. “We respect every culture and religion, but also take everything with a grain of salt.”

When the Winter Concert was over, McBride’s music teacher, Lisa Reimer, who almost single-handedly directed the children through the 90-minute event, looked tired but satisfied.

The number-one reason Reimer says she’s determined to include sacred choral music in the Winter Concert is her conviction such carols are of far higher quality than most of the “cheesy” secular tunes usually trotted out at Christmas.

“I use Silent Night because vocally it’s a really great teaching piece. It seems to be quite magical for kids. They take it really seriously.”

Reimer, 30, says the other reasons she includes a few Christian-rooted carols are that a large proportion of the students seem to be Christian — and, for those who are not, it’s a good thing to learn aspects of the Christian story.

“You don’t have to believe it.”

The Jewish songs are added to the Winter Concert mix, added Reimer, because they have a strong beat, creative melodies and tell some Jewish history.

“It’s a way of honouring Jewish people. The students will meet Jewish people in their lives, so it’s a way of celebrating diversity.”

Reimer, who doesn’t attend any religious institution, says in her five years of teaching music she’s slowly learned to be more “tolerant” of bringing religion-rooted songs into public schools.

Even though the Vancouver school board “technically” disallows sacred music in the classroom, Reimer says, she would go to the Supreme Court of Canada to fight for the right to teach sacred music. So would a lot of other teachers.

There is a lot of crummy winter-oriented music currently being written in the U.S. for public schools that want to avoid bringing religious songs into the classroom, says Reimer, who leads her own acclaimed children’s choir, called Zing!

“Unfortunately some music teachers are choosing the U.S. material because it’s safe and it’s secular and it’s about snow. It’s really scary,” she said.

“It’s a lot better to honour good quality music that happens to be sacred. That teaches us a lot more about diversity than trying to ignore religion.”

SOME TAX THINGY

Sakshi Bali, 8, is Sikh. Her parents are from the Kashmir region of India. With a huge smile, she says she loves Christmas, but her favourite religious holiday is the five days of Divali.

Still, Bali can capably recite the basic elements of the Christian Christmas story about Jesus’s birth in a stable — far better than I could at her age.

“Jesus had to be born in Bethlehem because there was some sort of tax thingy,” Bali said, noting she’d learned some of the story in class, but also elsewhere.

“The wise men visited the stable and people say Jesus had a halo around his head. I sort of like the story of Jesus — except for the end, when he dies.”

It’s almost impossible to keep track of the dizzying variety of cultural-spiritual beliefs held by students at McBride.

But the dozen or so children I met at Sir Richard McBride seemed comfortable with celebrating what have become the near-universal aspects of Christian-rooted Christmas, like Santa Claus and Christmas trees.

All four Grade 3s that I interviewed, including Shawn Thai, 8, whose non-religious parents are from Vietnam, said they receive gifts at Christmas and have family dinners — some modest, some huge, with up to 40 people attending.

At the same time, the students seemed genuinely interested in each others’ faiths and beliefs, including when world religions are taught in class.

“It’s cool. It’s interesting,” said Sakshi Bali.

“When someone’s against religion, I get bothered,” added her chipper Grade 3 friend, Kayashai Jenkins, 8, whose mom is from the Philippines and dad is from New Jersey.

Jenkins sometimes attends Catholic mass. While many of the Chinese and Vietnamese students at McBride don’t explicitly practise any faith, except perhaps Asian folk religion and ancestor reverence, most of the Filipino children are Catholic.

Thaddeus Salvo and Justine Felizarta, both 11, are Canadian-Filipino Catholics for whom Christmas is a big deal. They firmly believe in the virgin birth of Jesus, that he came to Earth so they could be saved and that Christmas is a time when angels are especially active in the world.

“There are angels in this neighbourhood,” said Felizarta. “Sometimes I feel them following me, as my guardians.”

Salvo’s family follows many Christmas traditions, including midnight mass. They also write the names of family members on Christmas tree ornaments and recite prayers for the loved ones. As well, the family often stays up late on Christmas Eve playing the Filipino card game Tongix.

A couple of the non-religious ethnic Chinese children I met at McBride were more lukewarm about Christmas, saying that, even though they may have a Christmas tree and family meal, the holiday wasn’t that big a deal in their home.

But none of the children wanted to get rid of Christmas, arguing that no one in their right mind wants to turn down its presents.

“I mean, what kid doesn’t like getting clothes or chocolates?” said Wendy Chan, 12, whose parents are from China.

Neha Vershaya, a Grade 7 student who is Hindu, said her family becomes quite involved in this festive season.

Her family marks Christmas by decorating a tree, putting a singing Santa Claus figurine in their window and having a big Indian food feast.

The Hindu family also trades Christmas gifts with their next-door neighbours — who are Chinese.

The funny thing was almost every student I talked to, including those who could be classified as atheists, like me in my youth, had struggled in one way or another with whether to remain convinced by Santa’s magic.

Many, like Nathan Dong, 12, described the day they caught their parents in the act of playing Santa. Or they joked that at least they acted like they believed in Santa because they didn’t want to pass on his presents.

The Grade 3s were most cautious about answering whether they still believed in Santa Claus, knowing the subject can be controversial at their age — except, that is for Mahdia Merzed, 8, who was born in Afghanistan.

When Merzed, whose family is Muslim, boldly declared — several times — she has never believed in Santa Claus, it caused eight-year-old Sakshi Bali, a Sikh, to laugh.

Bali then urged Merzed not to declare her lack of belief in Santa around really young and more impressionable children.

You’ve got to be tolerant of other people’s beliefs, the Grade 3s eventually agreed — whether it’s a conviction Santa can fly through the sky with reindeer, or something much more adult.

OLD STRICTNESS HAS GONE

If such a thing can be measured across time, the students I met and watched at Sir Richard McBride almost seemed happier, more relaxed, than we did when we attended McBride 40 years ago. The school’s atmosphere seems more fluid.

That old British-style strictness is gone.

As my relatives remember, despite the ferocity of battle during the Second World War in Europe and East Asia, there wasn’t really much fervent jingoism expressed at the school during those days. But there may have been an unspoken belief among some of the teachers through much of the 1900s that one of the purposes of McBride was to advance British civilization.

It could have been worse. The British heritage did bring Canada, and especially B.C., a lot of good things, like parliamentary democracy and a commitment to individual freedom, basic equality and justice.

But, like a lot of nationalistic cultures of the 20th century, the British ethos may have also given the old McBride a severity and uniformity.

This experimental multicultural era at McBride seems more unpredictable, and more exciting.

And the beauty of the kind of multiculturalism that seems to be happening at Sir Richard McBride at Christmas and throughout the year is that it’s not just about acceptance of differences. At its worst, that could lead to a sense of anything goes, to a kind of cultural chaos and fragmentation.

I expect the approach the principal, teachers and most students at McBride are now taking would gladden the hearts and minds of some of the world’s more notable multicultural theorists, including Princeton University’s Jeffrey Stout, University of B.C.’s Philip Resnick and McGill University’s Charles Taylor.

These philosophers, in their own way, say that multiculturalism, including religious pluralism, can’t truly be successful if people of different backgrounds aren’t willing to agree on at least some common ethics.

That doesn’t mean everyone in Canada, old timer or newcomer, has to celebrate Christmas, which extols universal moral values such as kindness, fellowship and concern for the poor. But it may not hurt.

Without some overarching values, the philosophers say we’ll end up with nations divided into self-ghettoized, ethno-religious enclaves. We won’t have multiculturalism, but something much more vapid — serial monoculturalism.

What are some moral principles to which we can all adhere, despite our different ethnicities and religions?

Scholars name some of those values as tolerance, responsible citizenship, individual freedom and democracy.

McBride’s principal, Sandra Phillips, wonders if all those terms can’t be summed up in the phrase, “mutual respect.”

This cluster of ethical principles sound much like the ideals highlighted in the school’s theme song, Soar Like an Eagle.

Every student is expected to memorize the lyrics of the rousing anthem, which are posted in giant letters — alongside the words of O Canada — above the gym stage, where the annual Winter Concert took place.

The words of Soar Like an Eagle are there to be seen by all the students, teachers and parents who’ve somehow managed to arrive at McBride elementary from all corners of the planet:

The school’s anthem begins:

“We all have our freedom,

share a common aim

We’re all different; still we’re all the same

Come into our schoolyard, what can you see?

Children who respect each other, caring, sharing, all together.”

Then comes the chorus:

“Tell me . . . How do we get there?

Most of us can’t fly.

Soar like an eagle, have an open mind.

Rising on the updraft, sun on your wings,

You can see so many things.”

dtodd@png.canwest.com

© The Vancouver Sun 2005

Copyright © 2005 CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest MediaWorks Publications, Inc.. All rights reserved.

The Nation’s Iraq Index & Torture Tree

The December 19 issue of The Nation included a a graphic index of human costs of the Iraq War for the US military. The index compares the grim statistics of the current war with other post-WWII conflicts and disaggregates the data by race, gender, geography, etc.

Download the “Iraq Index” here. And read the short companion article here.

The December 26 issue of The Nation is devoted to an examination of the “torture debate” in the US. The lead editorial in the issue states that there is no longer any point in arguing whether US policy condones cruel, degrading and torturous treatment of prisoners.

The “Torture Tree” illustrates the politicians, policymakers, soldiers, and academics who make up the new American torture complex … which includes, by the way, Micheal Ignatieff, Professor of the Practice of Human Rights at Harvard’s Kennedy School and Liberal Party candidate for Parliament in Etobicoke–Lakeshore (Metro Toronto).

Download the “Torture Tree” here.

Carving up the economic pie

250px-Pyramid_of_Capitalist_System.gifHere’s an interesting “piece” on dividing the economic pie, written by Holly Sklar—co-author of Raise the Floor: Wages and Policies That Work for All Of Us—for ZNet.

ZNet Commentary
Carving Up Our Economic Pie
December 22, 2005
By Holly Sklar

Pie season is here. Pumpkin, apple, cherry, whatever you like. We can use edible pie charts — and some chocolate — to see how our national economic pie is being carved up more unfairly.

Let’s look first at income distribution.

Take two pies — one for 1979, the other for 2003 (using the latest IRS data).

Divide the 1979 pie into 10 equal slices. If the slices were eaten according to the distribution of income in 1979:

— The richest 1 percent of taxpayers would get one slice.– The rest of the top 20 percent would get four slices.– The other 80 percent of taxpayers would split five slices.

Now, divide the 2003 pie into 10 slices.

— The richest 1 percent would get nearly two slices.– The rest of the top 20 percent would get a little over four slices.– The other 80 percent would split four slices.

In 1979, the top 20 percent of taxpayers had about as much income as the other 80 percent combined. In 2003, the top 20 percent had 60 percent of the income, leaving just 40 percent for the rest. The richest 1 percent nearly doubled their share.

Let’s look more closely at the upward shift in income.In 1979, the bottom 40 percent of taxpayers had about 15 percent more combined income than the richest 1 percent. In 2003, the richest 1 percent had twice the income share of the bottom 40 percent.

The richest 1 percent share of reported income jumped from 9.6 percent in 1979 to 17.5 percent in 2003. The bottom 40 percent share fell from 11.3 percent to 8.8 percent.

Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist David Cay Johnston puts the growing gap between the very rich and everyone else in stark perspective. He examined the income reported on tax returns of the top 0.01 percent — about 14,000 households with at least $5.5 million in income.

From 1950 to 1970, for every additional dollar earned by those in the bottom 90 percent, those in the top 0.01 percent earned an additional $162.

From 1990 to 2002, for every additional dollar earned in the bottom 90 percent, those at the top brought in an extra $18,000.

If you are feeling financially down this holiday season, you’re not alone. Average workers have been earning less after inflation, not more. Average hourly earnings dropped 5 percent, adjusting for inflation, between 1979 and 2004 — while domestic corporate profits rose 63 percent.

The share of national income going to wages and salaries is at the lowest level since 1929 — the year that kicked off the Great Depression. The share going to after-tax corporate profits, which heavily benefit wealthy Americans through increased dividends and capital gains, is at the highest level since 1929.

Income gaps in the workplace have become increasingly outrageous, as seen in the growing gap between worker pay and CEO pay. We can demonstrate it with a pile of chocolate.

Give 1 piece of chocolate to your worker stand-in and 44 pieces to your CEO stand-in. That was the 1980 ratio of average full-time worker pay to average pay among CEOs in Business Week’s survey of major corporations.

For the equivalent 2004 ratio, give 1 piece of chocolate to the worker and 362 to the CEO.

As the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities reports, federal policy is contributing “to a further widening of income disparities between the most affluent households and other Americans.” Households with incomes over $1 million will receive an average tax cut of $103,000 this year — an increase of 5.4 percent in their after-tax income.

The congressional majority is done crying crocodile tears over Katrina and the shameful inequality it exposed.

They’re working overtime to stiff the have-nots with more budget cuts so they can keep stuffing the pockets of the haves with more tax cuts. The budget knife is dropping on Medicaid, education, child care, food assistance and more– even public health, despite loud warnings we are unprepared for bird flu and other threats.

Tell your senators and members of Congress what you think about their priorities, and make your voice count when you vote next November.

Dictionary of Republicanisms

With the help of their readers, the folks at The Nation have put together a new book A Dictionary of Republicanisms. Here’s a sample:

abstinence-only sex education n. Ignorance-only sex education [Wayne Martorelli, Lawrenceville, NJ].

alternative energy sources n. New locations to drill for gas and oil [Peter Scholz, Fort Collins, Colo.].

bankruptcy n. A punishable crime when committed by poor people but not corporations [Beth Thielen, Studio City, Calif.].

“burning bush” n. A biblical allusion to the response of the President of the United States when asked a question by a journalist who has not been paid to inquire [Bill Moyers, New York, NY].

Cheney, Dick n. The greater of two evils [Jacob McCullar, Austin, Tex.].

China n. See Wal-Mart [Rebecca Solnit, San Francisco, Calif.].

class warfare n. Any attempt to raise the minimum wage [Don Zweir, Grayslake, Ill.].

climate change n. The blessed day when the blue states are swallowed by the oceans [Ann Klopp, Princeton, NJ].

compassionate conservatism n. Poignant concern for the very wealthy [Lawrence Sandek, Twin Peaks, Calif.].

creationism n. Pseudoscience that claims George W. Bush’s resemblance to a chimpanzee is totally coincidental [Brian Sweeney, Providence, RI].

DeLay, Tom n. 1. Past tense of De Lie [Rick Rodstrom, Los Angeles, Calif.]. 2. Patronage saint [Andrew Magni, Nonatum, Mass.].

democracy n. A product so extensively exported that the domestic supply is depleted [Michael Schwartz, unknown].

dittohead n. An Oxy(contin)moron [Zydeco Boudreaux, Gretna, La.].

energy independence n. The caribou witness relocation program [Justin Rezzonico, Keene, Ohio].

extraordinary rendition n. Outsourcing torture [Milton Feldon, Laguna Woods, Calif.].

faith n. The stubborn belief that God approves of Republican moral values despite the preponderance of textual evidence to the contrary [Matthew Polly, Topeka, Kans.].

Fox News fict. Faux news [Justin Rezzonico, Keene, Ohio].

free markets n. Halliburton no-bid contracts at taxpayer expense [Sean O’Brian, Chicago, Ill.].

girly men n. Males who do not grope women inappropriately [Nick Gill, Newton, Mass.].

God n. Senior presidential adviser [Martin Richard, Belgrade, Mont.].

growth n. 1. The justification for tax cuts for the rich. 2. What happens to the national debt when Republicans cut taxes on the rich [Matthew Polly, Topeka, Kans.].

habeas corpus n. Archaic. (Lat.) Legal term no longer in use (See Patriot Act) [Josh Wanstreet, Nutter Fort, WV].

healthy forest n. No tree left behind [Dan McWilliams, Santa Barbara, Calif.].

homelandism n. A neologism for love of the Homeland Security State, as in “My Homeland, ’tis of thee, sweet security state of liberty…” [Tom Engelhardt, New York, NY].

honesty n. Lies told in simple declarative sentences–e.g., “Freedom is on the march” [Katrina vanden Heuvel, New York, NY].

House of Representatives n. Exclusive club; entry fee $1 million to $5 million (See Senate) [Adam Hochschild, San Francisco, Calif.].

laziness n. When the poor are not working [Justin Rezzonico, Keene, Ohio].

leisure time n. When the wealthy are not working [Justin Rezzonico, Keene, Ohio].

liberal(s) n. Followers of the Antichrist [Ann Wegher, Montello, Wisc.].

Miller, Zell n. The man who shot and killed Alexander Hamilton after a particularly tough interview on Hardball [Drew Dillion, Arlington, Va.].

neoconservatives n. Nerds with Napoleonic complexes [Matthew Polly, Topeka, Kans.].

9/11 n. Tragedy used to justify any administrative policy, especially if unrelated (See Deficit, Iraq War) [Dan Mason, Durham, NH].

No Child Left Behind riff. 1. v. There are always jobs in the military [Ann Klopp, Princeton, NJ]. 2. n. The rapture [Samantha Hess, Cottonwood, Ariz.].

ownership society n. A civilization where 1 percent of the population controls 90 percent of the wealth [Michael Albert, Piscataway, NJ].

Patriot Act n. 1. The pre-emptive strike on American freedoms to prevent the terrorists from destroying them first. 2. The elimination of one of the reasons why they hate us [Michael Thomas, Socorro, NM].

pro-life adj. Valuing human life up until birth [Kevin Weaver, San Francisco, Calif.].

Senate n. Exclusive club; entry fee $10 million to $30 million [Adam Hochschild, San Francisco, Calif.].

simplify v. To cut the taxes of Republican donors [Katrina vanden Heuvel, New York, NY].

staying the course interj. Slang. Saying and doing the same stupid thing over and over, regardless of the result [Suzanne Smith, Ann Arbor, Mich.].

stuff happens interj. Slang. Donald Rumsfeld as master historian [Sheila and Chalmers Johnson, San Diego, Calif.].

voter fraud n. A significant minority turnout [Sue Bazy, Philadelphia, Pa.].

Wal-Mart n. The nation-state, future tense [Rebecca Solnit, San Francisco, Calif.].

water n. Arsenic storage device [Joy Losee, Gainesville, Ga.].

woman n. 1. Person who can be trusted to bear a child but can’t be trusted to decide whether or not she wishes to have thechild. 2. Person who must have all decisions regarding herreproductive functions made by men with whom she wouldn’t want to have sex in the first place [Denise Clay, Philadelphia, Pa.].

“I don’t think y’all can contest any of the sentences”

image_2042491.jpgFederal appeals court judges in Georgia gave a hostile reception Thursday to a lower court decision that ordered Cobb County to scrape off evolution disclaimer stickers from almost 35,000 science textbooks.

Judge Ed Carnes, who dominated the questioning, said the three-sentence disclaimer seemed to him to be “literally accurate.”

Carnes told the lawyer representing parents who filed suit against the stickers that since the US Supreme Court has previously referred to evolution as a theory that “I don’t think y’all can contest any of the sentences.”

Earlier this year, U.S. District Judge Clarence Cooper found that the stickers, which say evolution is a “theory, not a fact,” improperly endorsed religion.

In a 44-page decision released in January, Cooper agreed. He acknowledged that the disclaimers had a secular purpose, and avoided religious reference. But, he continued, “the sticker communicates to those who oppose evolution for religious reasons that they are favored members of the political community, while the sticker sends a message to those who believe in evolution that they are political outsiders.”

The Cobb school board adopted the 33-word stickers on March 28, 2002, amid a storm of protest from parents who disagreed with a new science curriculum that allowed evolution instruction. Since 1995, the board had curtailed the teaching of evolution, leading some teachers to rip sections on evolution from science textbooks.

The disclaimers were placed inside the front pages of Cobb science textbooks in the fall of 2002. The stickers read: “This textbook contains material on evolution. Evolution is a theory, not a fact, regarding the origin of living things. This material should be approached with an open mind, studied carefully and critically considered.”

A recent Washington Post profile of Cobb County traced its evolution from an ultra-conservative backwater into a 650,000 Metro Atlanta suburb where there people actually raise questions about governments that require warning stickers on science textbooks that contain science and laws requiring citizens to own a gun.

Of course, this is the county infamous as a key location in the rebirth of the Ku Klux Klan and where Leo Frank was lynched in 1915; it was also ground zero for the Newt Gingrich’s “Republican Revolution” of 1994. Cobb is certainly one of the most “liberal unfriendly” places in the USA, as I know from teaching high school in next door Fulton County.

Cobb County schools have not yet required that U.S. history textbooks carry a disclaimer sticker that reads: “This textbook contains material on democracy. Democracy is used as synonym for capitalism in this book and the material should be approached with an open mind, studied carefully and critically considered.”

Bush’s propaganda war on Americans and Iraqis

Here are three good articles on Bush Administration’s propaganda war aimed at Americans and Iraqis:

Meet John Rendon, Bush’s general in the propaganda war, courtesy of Rolling Stone: The Man Who Sold the War

And

The New York Times (Sunday, December 11) ran a long story on Bush administration’s propaganda war in Iraq, which is run by the military. The story by Jeff Gerth, describes how a military media center in Fayetteville, NC prepares a daily mix of music and pro-US news for newspapers and magazines in Iraq. The Fourth Psychological Operations Group at Fort Bragg supplies “good news” articles written by US soldiers, which the Lincoln Group, a Pentagon contractor, then pays Iraqi media outlets to run!

And

Also in Sunday’s paper Frank Rich continues to attack the Bush administation’s homefront propapanda war, arguing that “since we don’t get honest information from this White House, we must instead, as the Soviets once did, decode our rulers’ fictions to discern what’s really happening.”

Keep reading for Rich’s full column
It Takes a Potemkin Village

By FRANK RICH

12/11/05 “New York Times” — — WHEN a government substitutes propaganda for governing, the Potemkin village is all. Since we don’t get honest information from this White House, we must instead, as the Soviets once did, decode our rulers’ fictions to discern what’s really happening. What we’re seeing now is the wheels coming off: As the administration’s stagecraft becomes more baroque, its credibility tanks further both at home and abroad. The propaganda techniques may be echt Goebbels, but they increasingly come off as pure Ali G.

The latest desperate shifts in White House showmanship say at least as much about our progress (or lack of same) in Iraq over the past 32 months as reports from the ground. When President Bush announced the end of “major combat operations” in May 2003, his Imagineers felt the need for only a single elegant banner declaring “Mission Accomplished.” Cut to Nov. 30, 2005: the latest White House bumper sticker, “Plan for Victory,” multiplied by Orwellian mitosis over nearly every square inch of the rather “Queer Eye” stage set from which Mr. Bush delivered his oration at the Naval Academy.

And to no avail. Despite the insistently redundant graphics – and despite the repetition of the word “victory” 15 times in the speech itself – Americans believed “Plan for Victory” far less than they once did “Mission Accomplished.” The first New York Times-CBS News Poll since the Naval Academy pep talk, released last Thursday, found that only 25 percent of Americans say the president has “a clear plan for victory in Iraq.” Tom Cruise and evolution still have larger constituencies in America than that.

Mr. Bush’s “Plan for Victory” speech was, of course, the usual unadulterated nonsense. Its overarching theme – “We will never accept anything less than complete victory” – was being contradicted even as he spoke by rampant reports of Pentagon plans for stepped-up troop withdrawals between next week’s Iraqi elections and the more important (for endangered Republicans) American Election Day of 2006. The specifics were phony, too: Once again inflating the readiness of Iraqi troops, Mr. Bush claimed that the recent assault on Tal Afar “was primarily led by Iraqi security forces” – a fairy tale immediately unmasked by Michael Ware, a Time reporter embedded in that battle’s front lines, as “completely wrong.” No less an authority than the office of Iraq’s prime minister, Ibrahim al-Jaafari, promptly released a 59-page report documenting his own military’s inadequate leadership, equipment and training.

But this variety of Bush balderdash is such old news that everyone except that ga-ga 25 percent instantaneously tunes it out. We routinely assume that the subtext (i.e., the omissions and deliberate factual errors) of his speeches and scripted town meetings will be more revealing than the texts themselves. What raised the “Plan for Victory” show to new heights of disinformation was the subsequent revelation that the administration’s main stated motive for the address – the release of a 35-page document laying out a “National Strategy for Victory in Iraq” – was as much a theatrical prop as the stunt turkey the president posed with during his one furtive visit to Baghdad two Thanksgivings ago.

As breathlessly heralded by Scott McClellan, this glossy brochure was “an unclassified version” of the strategy in place since the war’s inception in “early 2003.” But Scott Shane of The New York Times told another story. Through a few keystrokes, the electronic version of the document at whitehouse.gov could be manipulated to reveal text “usually hidden from public view.” What turned up was the name of the document’s originating author: Peter Feaver, a Duke political scientist who started advising the National Security Council only this June. Dr. Feaver is an expert on public opinion about war, not war itself. Thus we now know that what Mr. McClellan billed as a 2003 strategy for military victory is in fact a P.R. strategy in place for no more than six months. That solves the mystery of why Lt. Gen. Martin Dempsey of the Army, who is in charge of training Iraqi troops, told reporters that he had never seen this “National Strategy” before its public release last month.

In a perfect storm of revelations, the “Plan for Victory” speech fell on the same day that The Los Angeles Times exposed new doings on another front in the White House propaganda war. An obscure Defense Department contractor, the Lincoln Group, was caught paying off Iraqi journalists to run upbeat news articles secretly written by American Army personnel and translated into Arabic (at a time when American troops in harm’s way are desperate for Arabic translators of their own). One of the papers running the fake news is Al Mutamar, the Baghdad daily run by associates of Ahmad Chalabi. So now we know that at least one P.R. plan, if not a plan for victory, has been consistent since early 2003. As Mr. Chalabi helped feed spurious accounts of Saddam’s W.M.D. to American newspapers to gin up the war, so his minions now help disseminate happy talk to his own country’s press to further the illusion that the war is being won.

The Lincoln Group’s articles (e.g., “The Sands Are Blowing Toward a Democratic Iraq”) are not without their laughs – for us, if not for the Iraqis, whose intelligence is insulted and whose democratic aspirations are betrayed by them. But the texts are no more revealing than those of Mr. Bush’s speeches. Look instead at the cover-up that has followed the Los Angeles Times revelations. The administration and its frontmen at once started stonewalling from a single script. Mr. McClellan, Pentagon spokesmen, Senator John Warner and Donald Rumsfeld all give the identical answer to the many press queries. We don’t have the facts, they say, even as they maintain that the Lincoln Group articles themselves are factual.

The Pentagon earmarks more than $100 million in taxpayers’ money for various Lincoln Group operations, and it can’t get any facts? Though the 30-year-old prime mover in the shadowy outfit, one Christian Bailey, fled from Andrea Mitchell of NBC News when she pursued him on camera in Washington, certain facts are proving not at all elusive.

Ms. Mitchell and other reporters have learned that Mr. Bailey has had at least four companies since 2002, most of them interlocking, short-lived and under phantom names. Government Executive magazine also discovered that Mr. Bailey “was a founder and active participant in Lead21,” a Republican “fund-raising and networking operation” – which has since scrubbed his name from its Web site – and that he and a partner in his ventures once listed a business address identical to their Washington residence. This curious tale, with its trail of cash payoffs, trading in commercial Iraqi real estate and murky bidding procedures for lucrative U.S. government contracts, could have been lifted from “Syriana” or “Glengarry Glen Ross.” While Mr. Rumsfeld and Mr. McClellan valiantly continue their search for “the facts,” what we know so far can safely be filed under the general heading of “Lay, DeLay and Abramoff.”

The more we learn about such sleaze in the propaganda war, the more we see it’s failing for the same reason as the real war: incompetence. Much as the disastrous Bremer regime botched the occupation of Iraq with bad decisions made by its array of administration cronies and relatives (among them Ari Fleischer’s brother), so the White House doesn’t exactly get the biggest bang for the bucks it shells out to cronies for fake news.

Until he was unmasked as an administration shill, Armstrong Williams was less known for journalism than for striking a deal to dismiss a messy sexual-harassment suit against him in 1999. When an Army commander had troops sign 500 identical good-news form letters to local newspapers throughout America in 2003, the fraud was so transparent it was almost instantly debunked. The fictional scenarios concocted for Jessica Lynch and Pat Tillman also unraveled quickly, as did last weekend’s Pentagon account of 10 marines killed outside Falluja on a “routine foot patrol.” As the NBC correspondent Jim Miklaszewski told Don Imus last week, he received calls within hours from the fallen’s loved ones about how the marines had been slaughtered after being recklessly sent to an unprotected site for a promotion ceremony.

Though the White House doesn’t know that its jig is up, everyone else does. Americans see that New Orleans is in as sorry shape today as it was under Brownie three months ago. The bipartisan 9/11 commissioners confirm that homeland security remains a pork pit. Condi Rice’s daily clarifications of her clarifications about American torture policies are contradicted by new reports of horrors before her latest circumlocutions leave her mouth. And the president’s latest Iraq speeches – most recently about the “success” stories of Najaf and Mosul – still don’t stand up to the most rudimentary fact checking.

This is why the most revealing poll number in the Times/CBS survey released last week was Mr. Bush’s approval rating for the one area where things are going relatively well, the economy: 38 percent, only 2 points higher than his rating on Iraq. It’s a measure of the national cynicism bequeathed by the Bush culture that seeing anything, even falling prices at the pump, is no longer believing.

Copyright 2005The New York Times Company

(In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. Information Clearing House has no affiliation whatsoever with the originator of this article nor is Information Clearing House endorsed or sponsored by the originator.)

Overcoming Obstacles to Progress

The Washington Post sought an analysis of the ninth-grade hurdle to student progress from Walter Haney, professor at the Lynch School of Education and director of the Ford Foundation-funded Education Pipeline project in the Center for the Study of Testing, Evaluation and Public Policy at Boston College:

Overcoming Obstacles to Progress:

Thirty years ago, only about 4 percent of students had to repeat ninth grade. Now, it is about 12 percent. In such states as Florida, South Carolina and New York, the ninth-grade hurdle, or bulge, is even worse, with more than 20 percent more students enrolled in ninth grade than were in eighth grade the previous year.

What is causing the grade 9 hurdle, what are its consequences, and what can be done?Historically the ninth-grade bulge has been associated with three waves of education reform. First, the so-called minimum-competency testing movement in the late 1970s and then the push for more academic requirements in the late 1980s. . . . A greater increase occurred in the 1990s with the rise of the so-called “standards-based reform” and “high stakes-testing” movements. The grade 9 hurdle is also associated with a structural change in how students typically reach high school. The movement from junior high schools to middle schools shifted a grade 7 bulge to grade 9, which is now the critical choke point in the education pipeline.

The consequences have been severe. A majority of students (as high as 80 percent) who are ordered to repeat grade 9 will not stay in school through graduation. This has led to a falling graduation rate in the last decade or so. According to a new report from the National Center for Education Statistics, the graduation rate nationally for the classes of 2002 and 2003 was less than 75 percent, and even lower in such states as South Carolina, Georgia, New York and Mississippi, where it hovered at about 60 percent.

Even more troubling than such appallingly low graduation rates – far lower than the graduation rate of 90% set out as a national education goal in 1994 – is this: Under the pressure of high stakes testing to raise grade 10 test averages, high school administrators in some states (such as New York, Alabama and Texas), have actually been pushing at-risk students out of school.

What can be done? Making high schools smaller and less impersonal and connecting schoolwork with students’ lives outside of school is one approach. Probably more important would be changes in policies — specifically providing schools with tangible incentives for keeping children in school and abandoning high-stakes testing used to make important decisions about students and schools based on test results in isolation. After all, test results can never cover all the broad goals of public education — academic, social and vocational.

Rates of keeping kids in school represent a more powerful measure for the simple reason that they reflect a host of factors affecting student progress, including performance in courses, attendance and citizenship, together with scores on standardized tests.

© 2005 The Washington Post Company

The police state in CT high schools: Say #!%* and Pay $$$, Hartford Tells High School Students

The New York Times: reports that Hartford, CT public high schools have “authorized police officers assigned to two of the city’s public high schools to begin issuing tickets to students who hurl expletives. The fine: $103.

“The officers have issued about 60 tickets to students at Bulkeley and Hartford High Schools in what several experts think is the first such effort in the country. There are already signs that the new approach may be working, some teachers and principals said. Fights have decreased, classrooms are calmer and there is less cursing in the corridors.”

The tickets accuse students of creating “a public distrubance” and require them to appear in Superior Court.

Hmm, sounds like Singapore, or percursor to the thought police … wonder if they teach 1984 in the English classes in Hartford?

Meanwhile in Ohio, an appeals court has upheld a law intended to limit the parties held by students at Bowling Green State University. Well…aye zigga zumba zumba.

Bono and Jesse Helms … buddies??

Bono & Jesse Helms.jpg
Apparently it’s true. U2’s Bono, the crusader against debt and AIDS in Africa, whose close personal friends include Canadian PM Paul Martin is also hanging with the racist, right-wing Jesse Helms, former US senator from North Carolina.

According to the Rock and Rap Confidential listserv, Jesse and Bono were enjoying each other’s company prior to U2’s gig in Raleigh.

“Before U2 opened to a raucous crowd of 17,000 at the city’s new downtown arena, Bono had dinner with right-wing Republican Senator JesseHelms.

“He (Bono) called us a couple of weeks ago and said he wanted to see his old friend the senator,” said John Dodd, president of the Jesse Helms Center, who accompanied Helms and other family members to Monday’s meeting.

Since they were introduced several years ago, the Republican Helms and Bono have become close allies in the fight against the AIDS epidemic in Africa.

Helms, who is 84 and suffers from a number of serious health problems, arrived backstage before the show and was joined by Bono for a casual meal. On the menu: grilled chicken, roast beef and salmon.

“It was nothing fancy,” Dodd said. “They ate in the cafeteria with the roadies and the rest of the crew.”

The two men talked for a few minutes about their work and what they have been able to accomplish and what still needs to be done, Dodd said.

Bono briefed the senator on DATA _ or Debt, AIDS, Trade in Africa _ a nonprofit organization he helped found in 2002 with other activists to increase awareness of the crises in Africa.

Did Helms stay for the concert?

“No, he didn’t,” Dodd said. “He has been to a U2 show before, but he was tired after traveling back from Raleigh earlier in the day.”