Rouge Forum Update (December 12, 2005)

RF4.jpgFrom Rich Gibson:

We continue to have so many visitors to our RougeForum.org web site that the server is shutting it down. Apologies to those visitors who have seen delays. The No Blood For Oil page is updated, however, and worth reviewing. This is one of the more widely circulated articles.

This week, though, we focus on the recent book by Robert Fisk, who is becoming to the wars in the Middle East what Wilfred Burchette was to the wars on Vietnam, one of the few sources of courage and truth. His book is The Great War for Civilization, The Conquest of the Middle East.

Much of Fisk’s work is posted on the Rouge Forum web site, and he has urged readers to use the site as a reference page.

A recent interview with Fisk by the journalist, Justin Podur, is here

During this week, a Yale professor, David Graeber, an extraordinarily well-credentialed anarchist was forced to resign, or chose to leave. We will have more on the continuing repression in the k12 and university worlds next week.

File-share plaintiff plans own defense against record industry shakedown

From The Journal News (Westchester County, NY): File-share plaintiff plans own defense

The soccer mom who has become the face of the recording industry’s lawsuits against alleged online music pirates has decided to act as her own lawyer after racking up more than $20,000 in legal fees in her ongoing fight with several record companies.

Patricia Santangelo, the 42-year-old former Yorktown resident who now lives in Wappingers Falls, was sued in February by record companies that accused her of illegally trading copyrighted songs online. The recording industry has filed more than 16,000 lawsuits against individual Internet users since launching the federal lawsuit campaign in September 2003.

Record companies charge that the trading of copyrighted songs online through such computer programs as Kazaa and Grokster is a threat to the industry’s survival. Critics have decried the lawsuit campaign as a heavy-handed bullying effort by deep-pocketed multinational corporations against ordinary people.

Santangelo had hired a New York City law firm to defend her in the case in U.S. District Court in White Plains. Santangelo said she has never traded songs online and should not be held accountable if anyone else used her computer to do so. The divorced mother of five children, ranging in age from 7 to 19, works as a property manager for a real estate company.

She said she was in church on the Easter Sunday morning in 2004 when the lawsuit charges that songs were illegally traded through her Internet account. She could have settled the lawsuit for about $7,500 several months ago but said that she decided against that because “I didn’t do anything wrong.”

She recently lost a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. After that ruling by U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon, Santangelo said, she looked at her mounting legal bills, now above $22,000, and was left with two options: settle the case or continue on as her own attorney.

“I thought about settling for a split second,” she said. “But I can’t. I can’t let it go. I have to see this through.”

More than 3,000 of the lawsuits have been settled with individual defendants agreeing to pay about $5,000 each to close the cases.

The prohibitive cost of fighting the suits makes settling an attractive option for most people, leaving the legality of the lawsuits unchallenged, said Fred von Lohmann, a staff attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital rights advocacy group that opposes the lawsuits.

“The recording industry has basically been able to run this operation like a shakedown,” he said.

A spokesman for the Recording Industry Association of America, the umbrella group that represents the record companies, said the companies are within their rights to protect their business.

“We’re working to help protect the future of music, including the ability of record labels to invest in the bands of tomorrow,” Jonathan Lamy said in an e-mail. “Downloading songs without permission is just as illegal as shoplifting, and it is every bit as wrong.”

Santangelo and the record companies are due back in court Dec. 22. That will be her first taste of lawyering. She said she was nervous about being her own attorney while untrained in the law.

“I think about it often. It’s a little scary,” Santangelo said. “But I can’t give in, no.”

Hey, you think things are bad now, just be glad you weren’t around back in the day!

dancart1841.jpg
Terrorist attacks, hurricanes, capitalist wars for oil, religion posing as science, an idiot as president…historians say it’s been worse.

Researchers at the Siena College Research Institute asked 354 U.S. history professors to compare eight “trying times” in American history and 46 percent of the respondents said that the current era was the “least trying.” Fifty-five percent said the Civil War was the toughest.

After the Civil War, historians rated the Revolutionary War and the Great Depression the most trying, followed by “Vietnam and the Cultural Revolution,” World War II, the Cold War, World War I, and the current “War on Terror.”

Western Canada Labor Battles Show Need for Solidarity

MR Zine: Western Canada Labor Battles Show Need for Solidarity

Roger Annis’s article for MR Zine describes what might be signs of a working-class social movement in Western Canada. Annis describes recent strikes—including B. C. teachers, hospital workers, telecommunications workers and meatpackers—and outlines issues that must be confronted if broader labor solidarity is to be achieved.

The Silencing of Carlos Delgado

capt.nykw111011282026.mets_delgado_nykw1110.jpg
When baseball free agent Carlos Delgado signed with the New York Mets a couple of weeks ago Mets manager Willie Randolph said: “”Carlos is a great hitter, but we liked the whole package.” But, Randolph and the Mets really weren’t interested in WHOLE package because they aren’t intersted in his politics.

At his coming out party as a Met, the media bombarded Delgado with questions about his protest of the U.S. war on Iraq. Delgado’s refusal to stand on the field during “God Bless America” the past two seasons attracted nearly as much attention as his home runs.

In 2004, when Delgado was playing for the Blue Jays he told the Toronto Star: “I think it’s the stupidest war ever. Who are you fighting against? You’re just getting ambushed now. We have more people dead now, after the war, than during the war. You’ve been looking for weapons of mass destruction. Where are they at? You’ve been looking for over a year. Can’t find them. I don’t support that. I don’t support what they do. I think it’s just stupid.”

But now that he’s been traded by the cost-cutting Florida Marlins to the Mets, the slugger said he has no problem with Randolph’s rule that Met players “stand at attention and honor the flag.”

In a web-only article for The Nation David Zirin reports on the “Silencing of Carlos Delgado” and his decision to break from his anti-militarist convictions and the path blazed by the baseball great and social justice activist Roberto Clemente.

The Silencing of Carlos Delgado

by DAVE ZIRIN

[The Nation,posted online on December 7, 2005]

Sometimes sports mirrors politics with such morbid accuracy you don’t know whether to laugh, cry or hide in the basement. Just as the Bush Administration shows its commitment to democracy by operating secret offshore gulags and buying favorable news coverage in Iraq, the New York Mets have made it clear to new player Carlos Delgado that freedom of speech stops once the blue and orange uniform–their brand–is affixed to his body.

For the last two years, Delgado chose to follow the steps of his personal hero, Roberto Clemente, the Pittsburgh Pirates great and the first Latino elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame, and use his athletic platform to speak out for social justice. Clemente blazed a trail for generations of Latino ball players by standing up for the poor of Latin America and never accepting being treated as anything less than human. Delgado’s contribution to this tradition of pride in the face of conformity was to refuse to stand for the singing of “God Bless America” during the seventh-inning stretch. This was his act of resistance to the war in Iraq. “I think it’s the stupidest war ever. Who are you fighting against? You’re just getting ambushed now,” Delgado told the Toronto Star in 2004. “We have more people dead now, after the war, than during the war. You’ve been looking for weapons of mass destruction. Where are they at? You’ve been looking for over a year. Can’t find them. I don’t support that. I don’t support what they do. I think it’s just stupid.”

Delgado’s anti-militarist convictions grew from spending time and money to help clean up the small island of Vieques in his native Puerto Rico. The US Navy had used Vieques for decades as a bombing-practice target, with disastrous results for the people and environment.

When asked by the Star if he was concerned about taking such a public stance, Delgado, then a player for the Toronto Bluejays, responded, “Sometimes, you’ve just got to break the mold. You’ve got to push it a little bit or else you can’t get anything done.”

But now, Mets’ management is pushing Delgado back into the mold. The shame of this is that despite a guaranteed contract and support in the streets, Delgado isn’t pushing back. He said at the November 28 press conference announcing his trade to the Mets from the Florida Marlins, “The Mets have a policy that everybody should stand for ‘God Bless America’ and I will be there. I will not cause any distractions to the ballclub…. Just call me Employee Number 21.” And we saw him grin and bear it when Jeff Wilpon, son of Mets CEO and owner Fred Wilpon, said, “He’s going to have his own personal views, which he’s going to keep to himself.”

If opposition to the war were a stock, Delgado bought high and is selling low. There couldn’t be a better time than now, a better place than New York City, or a better team than the Mets for Delgado to make his stand. Instead, he has to hear baby-boy Wilpon say to reporters, “Fred has asked and I’ve asked him to respect what the country wants to do.” One has to wonder what country the Wilpons are talking about. The latest polls show Bush and his war meeting with subterranean levels of support. Delgado could be an important voice in the effort to end it once and for all.

He also might have received significant organizational support from Mets General Manager Omar Minaya, the first Latino GM in Major League history, and from Willie Randolph, the first African-American manager of the Mets. Randolph even told reporters, “I’d rather have a man who’s going to stand up and say what he believes. We have a right as Americans to voice that opinion.” But Minaya merely commented curtly, with an artic chill, “This is from ownership.” But Delgado still caved.

The frustrating fallout of all this is evident in media attacks on Delgado for refusing to continue his act of protest. At first glance, it would be welcome to see, for example, Newsday’s Wallace Matthews’s writing, “Even if you disagree with his politics, Delgado’s willingness to break out of the mold corporate America loves to jam us in set him apart from the thousands of interchangeable young men who thrive athletically and financially in our sports-crazed culture…But no. One of the few pro athletes who had the guts to say no is now a yes man. And the silencing of his voice, whether you agree with it or not, is not a victory for democracy but a defeat.”

But where were the critics when the then-protesting Delgado was being booed as a visiting player in New York? And where were they when radio commentators suggested he “just shut up and play”? For those of us who amplified his views, and used his stance to speak not only about the war but also the plight of Vieques, his silence is bursting our eardrums.

Ironically, one of the parts of the press conference that was genuinely touching was Delgado’s thrill at finally being able to wear a jersey with the number 21 of his hero, the great Roberto Clemente. When it came to political principle, Clemente was a giant who never backed down in the face of bigotry: He lost his life in a 1972 plane crash as he was delivering aid to earthquake-ravaged Nicaragua. To Clemente, the Wilpons of the world were little more than mosquitos buzzing in his ears. Delgado could have been our Clemente. Instead, to use his own words, he is just Employee Number 21.

The return of American apartheid schools

br0130bs.jpg
Two years ago the Harvard Civil Rights Project issued a report titled A Multiracial Society With Segregated Schools: Are We Losing the Dream?.

That report concluded that US “public schools are becoming steadily more nonwhite, as the minority student enrollment approaches 40% of all U.S. public school students, almost twice the share of minority school students during the 1960s. Almost half of all public school students in the West and the South are minority students. The desegregation of black students, which increased continuously from the l950s to the late l980s, has now receded to levels not seen in three decades. Black students are experiencing the most rapid resegregation in the south, triggered by Supreme Court decisions in the 1990’s, and have now lost all progress recorded since the 1960’s.”

[You can download an op-ed piece I wrote in March 2003 for the Lexington Herald-Leader (KY) on the resegregation of schools here.]

In his recently published book The Shame of the Nation: The Restoration of Apartheid Schooling in America, Jonathan Kozol reiterates the findings of the HCRP report and argues that the conditions of inner-city schools in the US have deteriorated in the 15 years since the federal courts started dismantling Brown v. Board (and roughly the same period of time since Kozol wrote his acclaimed book Savage Inequalities).

The latest issue of The Nation has an article adapted from Kozol’s book. Also see the September 2005 issue of Harper’s Magazine for Kozol’s article “Still Separate, Still Unequal.”

Kansas: Police investigate assault on professor who planned course critical of intelligent design

In an apparent effort to disprove that humans are evolving, two Kansas men beat up the University of Kansas religion professor whose proposed course on the “mythology” of intelligent design sparked an uproar last month.

Inside Higher Ed: reports Professor Paul Mirecki was treated Monday for injuries during what law enforcement officials are calling an “aggravated battery” on him.

“Mirecki reported that while driving on a rural road, he pulled over when two men in a pickup truck seemed to be following him too closely. While Mirecki expected them to pass, they too pulled over, and attacked him. While he was briefly treated at a local hospital, he was able to teach at the university later in the day.

A spokeswoman for the Douglas County sheriff’s department said that “aggravated battery” means either that a beating was particularly intense or involved an object.”

Mirecki had proposed a course called “Special Topics in Religion: Intelligent Design, Creationism, and Other Religious Mythologies.” The title itself angered intelligent-design proponents, who objected to being lumped in with “other religious mythologies.”

Japan’s Top Court Turns Down Professor’s Censorship Claim

The Chronicle of Higher Education: Japan’s Top Court Turns Down Professor’s Censorship Claim

The Japanese Supreme Court on Thursday rejected an appeal by a professor at the University of the Ryukyus, in Okinawa, seeking damages against the government for censorship of a textbook that he helped write in 1993. Observers see the ruling as upholding the education ministry’s right to screen and alter textbooks.The ministry’s screening of textbooks aroused anti-Japanese rioting in China earlier this year after Japanese education officials released a list of approved textbooks that the Chinese viewed as whitewashing Japanese war crimes and injustices before and during World War II (The Chronicle, May 27).

In last week’s case, the professor, Nobuyoshi Takashima, contended that the education ministry had trampled on his freedom of speech in ordering changes to chapters in a high-school textbook on modern Japanese society in which he suggested that Japan should have paid more attention to the feelings of its Asian neighbors. A district court agreed in 1998 that some of the changes were illegal and awarded him a monetary settlement. The Tokyo High Court overturned that ruling on appeal. The Supreme Court upheld the Tokyo court’s decision.

“I have fought 13 years and the ruling is as unacceptable as it is superficial,” Mr. Takashima said after hearing the verdict. He had asked the court for $10,000 for the mental anguish he suffered as a result of giving up his project to publish the original book.

Kazushige Yamashita, director of the division in charge of textbook screenings at the education ministry, said that the ruling was reasonable because it confirmed the legitimacy and need for the screenings.

Mr. Takashima’s case is the second prolonged case involving textbook issues to come before the Supreme Court. In 1965, Saburo Ienaga, a professor from the Tokyo University of Education, the predecessor of Tsukuba University, sued the government for censoring his textbook. That case did not reach the Supreme Court until 1997, when the court ruled against Mr. Ienaga’s assertion that the ministry’s vetting system violated the Constitution. However, the court did rule illegal the ministry’s demand for Mr. Ienaga to delete a description of the biological experiments that the Japanese army conducted on Chinese people during World War II.

Japanese courts have found government-ordered changes unlawful several times, but they have never ruled that the system itself illegal.