Someone tell the president the war is over

To my mind, Frank Rich is the best columnist writing for a major US newspaper. In this column he pretty much sums up the domestic politics of the war in Iraq, but he he does leave out one angle–the oil. (See the column below).

Also, Tom Engelhardt adds some confirming details on how out of touch W. is; how desparate military recruiters are; and the confusion in the ranks of the administration.

Someone Tell the President the War Is Over

By Frank Rich

The New York Times

Sunday 14 August 2005

Like the Japanese soldier marooned on an island for years after V-J Day, President Bush may be the last person in the country to learn that for Americans, if not Iraqis, the war in Iraq is over. “We will stay the course,” he insistently tells us from his Texas ranch. What do you mean we, white man?

A president can’t stay the course when his own citizens (let alone his own allies) won’t stay with him. The approval rate for Mr. Bush’s handling of Iraq plunged to 34 percent in last weekend’s Newsweek poll – a match for the 32 percent that approved L.B.J.’s handling of Vietnam in early March 1968. (The two presidents’ overall approval ratings have also converged: 41 percent for Johnson then, 42 percent for Bush now.) On March 31, 1968, as L.B.J.’s ratings plummeted further, he announced he wouldn’t seek re-election, commencing our long extrication from that quagmire.

But our current Texas president has even outdone his predecessor; Mr. Bush has lost not only the country but also his army. Neither bonuses nor fudged standards nor the faking of high school diplomas has solved the recruitment shortfall. Now Jake Tapper of ABC News reports that the armed forces are so eager for bodies they will flout “don’t ask, don’t tell” and hang on to gay soldiers who tell, even if they tell the press.

The president’s cable cadre is in disarray as well. At Fox News Bill O’Reilly is trashing Donald Rumsfeld for his incompetence, and Ann Coulter is chiding Mr. O’Reilly for being a defeatist. In an emblematic gesture akin to waving a white flag, Robert Novak walked off a CNN set and possibly out of a job rather than answer questions about his role in smearing the man who helped expose the administration’s prewar inflation of Saddam W.M.D.’s. (On this sinking ship, it’s hard to know which rat to root for.) As if the right-wing pundit crackup isn’t unsettling enough, Mr. Bush’s top war strategists, starting with Mr. Rumsfeld and Gen. Richard Myers, have of late tried to rebrand the war in Iraq as what the defense secretary calls “a global struggle against violent extremism.” A struggle is what you have with your landlord. When the war’s number-managers start using euphemisms for a conflict this lethal, it’s a clear sign that the battle to keep the Iraq war afloat with the American public is lost.

That battle crashed past the tipping point this month in Ohio. There’s historical symmetry in that. It was in Cincinnati on Oct. 7, 2002, that Mr. Bush gave the fateful address that sped Congressional ratification of the war just days later. The speech was a miasma of self-delusion, half-truths and hype. The president said that “we know that Iraq and Al Qaeda have had high-level contacts that go back a decade,” an exaggeration based on evidence that the Senate Intelligence Committee would later find far from conclusive. He said that Saddam “could have a nuclear weapon in less than a year” were he able to secure “an amount of highly enriched uranium a little larger than a single softball.” Our own National Intelligence Estimate of Oct. 1 quoted State Department findings that claims of Iraqi pursuit of uranium in Africa were “highly dubious.”

It was on these false premises – that Iraq was both a collaborator on 9/11 and about to inflict mushroom clouds on America – that honorable and brave young Americans were sent off to fight. Among them were the 19 marine reservists from a single suburban Cleveland battalion slaughtered in just three days at the start of this month. As they perished, another Ohio marine reservist who had served in Iraq came close to winning a Congressional election in southern Ohio. Paul Hackett, a Democrat who called the president a “chicken hawk,” received 48 percent of the vote in exactly the kind of bedrock conservative Ohio district that decided the 2004 election for Mr. Bush.

These are the tea leaves that all Republicans, not just Chuck Hagel, are reading now. Newt Gingrich called the Hackett near-victory “a wake-up call.” The resolutely pro-war New York Post editorial page begged Mr. Bush (to no avail) to “show some leadership” by showing up in Ohio to salute the fallen and their families. A Bush loyalist, Senator George Allen of Virginia, instructed the president to meet with Cindy Sheehan, the mother camping out in Crawford, as “a matter of courtesy and decency.” Or, to translate his Washingtonese, as a matter of politics. Only someone as adrift from reality as Mr. Bush would need to be told that a vacationing president can’t win a standoff with a grief-stricken parent commandeering TV cameras and the blogosphere 24/7.

Such political imperatives are rapidly bringing about the war’s end. That’s inevitable for a war of choice, not necessity, that was conceived in politics from the start. Iraq was a Bush administration id

Soccer mom takes on the record companies

None of the lawsuits brought by the recording industry against individual users of peer-to-peer technologies (like Kazaa and Limewire) have actually gone to court. Instead the RIAA has relied intimitation to get “little guys” to settle out of court.

Looks like a Westchester soccer mom isn’t giving in to boilerplate lawsuits the RIAA have used…and is ready to test the RIAA tactics in court.

Taking on record companies

By TIMOTHY O’CONNOR
THE JOURNAL NEWS
(Original Publication: August 14, 2005)

WHITE PLAINS — Patricia Santangelo is in many ways the embodiment of the suburban mom.
She is the mother of five children, ranging in age from 6 to 19. She is divorced, living in Wappingers Falls after growing up in Yorktown and Putnam County. At 42, she works as a property manager for a real estate company and is trying to get her own business off the ground.

What she is not, is someone expected to be at the center of the nearly 2-year-old war between record companies and online music file sharers.

But that’s exactly who she has become.

Santangelo was sued by several record companies in U.S. District Court in White Plains in February. The record companies said Santangelo’s home computer and Internet account were used to illegally trade copyrighted song files. The record companies say people like Santangelo are destroying the multibillion-dollar industry.

Record companies have filed about 13,300 similar federal lawsuits against Internet users across the country since September 2003. Nearly 3,000 of those lawsuits have been settled. The offending music traders have agreed to pay an average of $4,000 to $5,000 and promised not to illegally download copyrighted songs anymore.

None of the cases has gone to trial.

That may change. And it may change with a soccer mom who said she would rather pay a lawyer’s fees than give in to what she calls intimidation tactics by the record companies to get her to settle.

“I am still nervous about the whole thing,” she said. “I just got so aggravated about how threatening they were.”

The risk she is taking is that, if she loses, she may wind up paying much more than the $7,500 the record companies initially wanted from her to settle the case.

The offer came through the Recording Industry Association of America’s settlement center, which was designed to facilitate Internet users’ paying penalties to the record companies before they were sued. Santangelo said the settlement center bullied her, trying to get her to accept a settlement offer.

“I didn’t do anything wrong,” she said. “Why should I pay them?”

She never used the Kazaa program — one of the networks that facilitates file sharing — that was downloaded onto her computer, she said. She didn’t even know what it was before she was sued, she said. The Kazaa account name in the lawsuit belongs to a friend of her children’s, not to her or anyone in her house, she said.

Opponents of the record companies’ lawsuits have said they hoped someone would challenge the companies’ tactics in court rather than settle.

“If this particular woman is willing to go to trial, that’s something new,” said Jason Schultz, a staff attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital rights advocacy group that opposes the lawsuits. “The threat is so great that most people don’t even risk it.”

The record companies say the law is clear and on their side: If you download copyrighted songs on the Internet without compensating the songs’ owners, you’re stealing.

Jonathan Lamy, a spokesman for the RIAA, an umbrella group that represents the record companies, pointed to the U.S. Supreme Court’s characterization of illegal online song trading as “garden variety theft.”

“Just as we must hold accountable the businesses that encourage theft online, individuals who engage in illegal downloading must also know there are consequences to their actions,” he said in an e-mail. “The toll from online theft is devastating.”

He said the record companies have “ironclad evidence” Santangelo’s home computer and Internet account were used to illegally download music.

But whether that evidence is strong enough to stand up to judicial scrutiny still is a question two years after the first suits were filed. Few of the lawsuits have gone beyond the preliminary stages.

Santangelo’s lawyer, Morlan Ty Rogers, who works in New York City and grew up in Sleepy Hollow and Ossining, said no one has challenged the “boilerplate” language of the lawsuits, adding that the record companies don’t have enough evidence to bring their claims to court.

“Many of these lawsuits have been brought against people who are simply the names on the Internet account,” Rogers said. He said that’s not good enough to sustain a lawsuit. The companies have sued unsuspecting mothers, fathers, grandparents — people who have only grudgingly made the switch from vinyl albums to compact discs.

“It’s really surprising” no one has attacked the record companies’ basis for the lawsuits, he said, “because the record companies’ claims are actually very weak.”

Joseph Singleton, a Beverly Hills, Calif., lawyer who has defended about 15 clients in such lawsuits, said he has had clients who would have been perfect to challenge the lawsuits. But they settled because, even though they didn’t do anything wrong, a loved one may have illegally downloaded the music files. Most of his clients have settled. The record companies have dropped suits against a couple of others. Still others challenged the lawsuits but didn’t survive the hurdle of summary judgment.

“You can’t go in and simply say, ‘So what? I did it, there’s nothing wrong with it,’ ” he said. “Those people will lose.”

But, he said, record companies are suing people who made songs available to others, whether or not there is any proof they ever illegally copied a song.

“You cannot have copyright infringement if you don’t copy,” he said.

Santangelo said she feels as if the well-heeled record companies are picking on a single mother.

“Why are they going after people like me?” she asked.

A judge, and perhaps down the line a jury, may have to answer that question.

Santangelo’s lawyer, Rogers, whom she retained several weeks ago, has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, saying it fails to properly state a claim. The record companies have responded that the suit makes a valid claim against Santangelo. U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon will decide the issue.

McMahon already has had a glimpse of the case from a conference May 6, before Santangelo had a lawyer. The judge told Santangelo she should get an attorney. She told the record companies’ lawyers that the settlement center was no longer to be involved in the case.

“I would love to see a mom fighting one of these,” the judge said.

Robert Fisk: “How Can the US Ever Win, When Iraqi Children Die like This?”

Robert Fisk is one of a few truly independent journalist covering the war in Iraq. His column in today’s edition of The Independent is a powerful illustration of the obsentity that is the U.S. occupation in Iraq.

Of course the answer to Fisk’s rhetorical question is, “they cannot and they will not.”

Go to original

How Can the US Ever Win, When Iraqi Children Die like This?
By Robert Fisk
The Independent UK

Saturday 13 August 2005

There’s the wreckage of a car bomb that killed seven Americans on the corner of a neighbouring street. Close by stands the shuttered shop of a phone supplier who put pictures of Saddam on a donkey on his mobiles. He was shot three days ago, along with two other men who had committed the same sin. In the al-Jamia neighbourhood, a US Humvee was purring up the road so we gingerly backed off and took a side street. In this part of Baghdad, you avoid both the insurgents and the Americans – if you are lucky.

Yassin al-Sammerai was not. On 14 July, the second grade schoolboy had gone to spend the night with two college friends and – this being a city without electricity in the hottest month of the year – they decided to spend the night sleeping in the front garden. Let his broken 65 year-old father Selim take up the story, for he’s the one who still cannot believe his son is dead – or what the Americans told him afterwards.

“It was three-thirty in the morning and they were all asleep, Yassin and his friends Fahed and Walid Khaled. There was an American patrol outside and then suddenly, a Bradley armoured vehicle burst through the gate and wall and drove over Yassin. You know how heavy these things are. He died instantly. But the Americans didn’t know what they’d done. He was lying crushed under the vehicle for 17 minutes. Um Khaled, his friends’ mother, kept shouting in Arabic: “There is a boy under this vehicle.” According to Selim al-Sammerai, the Americans’ first reaction was to put handcuffs on the two other boys. But a Lebanese Arabic interpreter working for the Americans arrived to explain that it was all a mistake. “We don’t have anything against you,” she said. The Americans produced a laminated paper in English and Arabic entitled “Iraqi Claims Pocket Card” which tells them how to claim compensation.

The unit whose Bradley drove over Yassin is listed as “256 BCT A/156 AR, Mortars”. Under “Type of Incident”, an American had written: “Raid destroyed gate and doors.” No one told the family there had been a raid. And nowhere – but nowhere – on the form does it suggest that the “raid” destroyed the life of the football-loving Yassin al-Sammerai.

Inside Yassin’s father’s home yesterday, Selim shakes with anger and then weeps softly, wiping his eyes. “He is surely in heaven,” one of his surviving seven sons replies. And the old man looks at me and says: “He liked swimming too. ”

A former technical manager at the Baghdad University college of arts, Selim is now just a shadow. He is half bent over on his seat, his face sallow and his cheeks drawn in. This is a Sunni household in a Sunni area. This is “insurgent country” for the Americans, which is why they crash into these narrow streets at night. Several days ago, a collaborator gave away the location of a group of Sunni guerrillas and US troops surrounded the house. A two-hour gun-battle followed until an Apache helicopter came barrelling out of the darkness and dropped a bomb on the building, killing all inside.

There is much muttering around the room about the Americans and the West and I pick up on this quickly and say how grateful I am that they have let a Westerner come to their home after what has happened. Selim turns and shakes me by the hand. “You are welcome here,” he says. “Please tell people what happened to us.” Outside, my driver is watching the road; it’s the usual story. Any car with three men inside or a man with a mobile phone means “get out”. The sun bakes down. It is a Friday. “These guys take Fridays off,” the driver offers by way of confidence.

“The Americans came back with an officer two days later,” Selim al-Sammerai continues. “They offered us compensation. I refused. I lost my son, I told the officer. ‘I don’t want the money – I don’t think the money will bring back my son.’ That’s what I told the American.” There is a long silence in the room. But Selim, who is still crying, insists on speaking again.

“I told the American officer: ‘You have killed the innocent and such things will lead the people to destroy you and the people will make a revolution against you. You said you had come to liberate us from the previous regime. But you are destroying our walls and doors.'”

I suddenly realise that Selim al-Sammerai has straightened up on his seat and his voice is rising in strength. “Do you know what the American said to me? He said, ‘This is fate.’ I looked at him and I said, ‘I am very faithful in the fate of God – but not in the fate of which you speak.'”

Then one of Yassin’s brothers says that he took a photograph of the dead boy as he lay on the ground, a picture taken on his mobile phone, and he printed a picture of it and when the Americans returned on the second day they asked to see it. “They asked me why I had taken the picture and I said it was so people here could see what the Americans had done to my brother. They asked if they could borrow it and bring it back. I gave it to them but they didn’t bring it back. But I still kept the image on my mobile and I was able to print another.” And suddenly it is in my hands, an obscene and terrible snapshot of Yassin’s head crushed flat as if an elephant had stood upon it, blood pouring from what had been the back of his brains. “So now, you see,” the brother explains, “the people can still see what the Americans have done.”

In the heat, we slunk out of al-Jamia yesterday, the place of insurgents and Americans and grief and revenge. “When the car bomb blew up over there,” my driver says, “the US Humvees went on burning for three hours and the bodies were still there. The Americans took three hours to reach them. Al the people gathered round and watched.” And I look at the carbonised car that still lies on the road and realise it has now become a little icon of resistance. How, I ask myself again, can the Americans ever win?

NCLB on the silver screen

Lerone Wilson is a 23 year-old former student teacher and “No Child Left Behind” is his first film. The press releases for the film, which premiers next month in New York, claim “he film explores the triumphs and shortcomings of President Bush’s education reforms, with particular focus on the New York City schools, and Mayor Bloomberg’s education reforms. The filmmaker also returns to the Michigan schools he attended while growing up, to further document the changing landscape of public education.”

“One woman who saw the film’s trailer on my website, even called to berate me about how I was essentially a liberal propagandist.” he recalled. Wilson has since re-edited the film’s trailer, yet complaints concerning its alleged political leanings continue from liberals and conservatives alike. “I’ve seen lots of hurtful, and offensive remarks flung around surrounding this issue. But after producing this film I’ve realized it’s not out of ill will, rather because it’s an issue that so many people have a vested interest in, and care passionately about.”

One of the clips on the film’s website shows kids reading letters they’ve written to NYC Mayor Bloomberg, which clearly communicates the stresses students feel about the high-stakes tests that NCLB demands. While this clip implies that the film will take a critical look on the negative effects of high-stakes tests, the list of interviewees doesn’t bring “liberal propaganda” to mind. The policymakers interviewed for the film include reps from many of the major right-wing think tanks and other test-pushers and public school privatizers including: The Heritage Foundation, Manhattan Institute, and The Education Trust.

Apparrently Wilson thinks these right-wingers are “balanced” by representatives of the NEA and various education administration groups (e.g., American Association of School Administrators), which is unlikely.

Perhaps there are test resisters or other critical voices (e.g., FairTest, Alfie Kohn, Susan Ohanian, Deborah Meier or reps from the New York Performance Standards Consoritium in the film, but the media package doesn’t list anyone who is a major player in the resistance.

I guess we’ll have to wait and see the movie, which premiers September 25 at the Pioneer Theatre in NYC.

Patriotism lite

In a Znet commentary posted this week, Paul Street (author of Segregated Schools: Race, Class, and Educational Apartheid in the Post-Civil Rights Era) offers this take on the contradictions of the “war on terrorism” and maintenance of capitalist “normalcy”:

Still, there is a very real ongoing conflict between the hard, murderous requirements of militarism and the soft, “normalcy”-craving imperatives of American consumer capitalism, which tries to reduce democratic citizenship to the uninterrupted and often trivial pursuit, purchase, and enjoyment of commodities. The “patriotism lite” charge applies reasonably to that significant part of the American populace that is content to let predominantly working-class others fight and die in imperial campaigns for which they personally refuse to sacrifice in substantive way.

“Support Our Troops” is an often cheap slogan on the back of many suburban gas-guzzling SUV’s loaded with middle-class soccer kids and with relatively affluent Moms and Dads who would never enlist their children in a dangerous American-imperial service that relies almost entirely (as Moskos and others have shown) on the children of America’s poor and working classes. Nowhere is the slogan cheaper than in the oval office, whose Fortunate Son inhabitant George “Bring ‘Em On” Bush continues his Vietnam-era record of cheering on poorer and browner other Americans to death and destruction in deceptively sold imperial campaigns he prefers to personally sit out.

Keep reading for the full commentary:Today’s commentary:
http://www.zmag.org/sustainers/content/2005-07/30street.cfm

==================================

ZNet Commentary
Patriotism Lite August 05, 2005
By Paul Street

A United States History professor I know tells me an interesting story from late March of 2003. “How many of you,” she asked her U.S. History class that fateful month, “support the American war on Iraq.” Two-thirds of the 100 students in her lecture hall raised their hands. “Okay,” she said, “how many of you are willing to enlist in the armed forces to join the war?” One hand went up in response to the second question.

The first section of last Sunday’s New York Times contains an interesting article titled “All Quiet on the Home Front and Some Soldiers Are Asking Why.” The story’s author Thom Shanker cites a number of American military officials and academic experts on the disconnect between the United States’ officially declared commitment to waging an all-out “War on Terror” and Americans’ reluctance to sacrifice in support of that war.
Noticing the absence of any “serious talk” of “a tax increase to force Americans to cover the $5 billion a month in costs from Iraq, Afghanistan and new counterterrorism missions” and the lack of “concerted efforts like the savings bond drive or gasoline rationing that helped unite the country behind its fighting forces in wars past,” Shanker quotes an officer veteran of the Iraq occupation to chilling effect. “Nobody in America is asked to sacrifice,” this officer says, “except us.” By “us,” he means the armed forces.

Shanker also quotes the venerable military sociologist Charles Moskos, who criticizes what he calls Americans’ “patriotism lite,” whereby “the political leaders are afraid to ask the public for any real sacrifices.” This, Moskos says, “doesn’t speak too highly of the citizenry.” “It’s almost,” says a retired U.S. military official, “as if the politicians want to be able to declare war and at the same time maintain a sense of normalcy” (Thom Shanker, “All Quiet on the Home Front and Some Soldiers Are Asking Why,” New York Times, 24 July, 2005, A17)

There’s a lot missing in Shanker’s article, consistent with mainstream U.S. journalism’s general reluctance to take seriously the extent to which Americans are divided along related lines of class and power. There’s nothing about the sacrifice imposed on the many millions of poor and otherwise disadvantaged Americans who are seeing needed social programs cut to pay for the deadly, deficit-generating combination of massive “defense” (empire) expenditures with huge tax cuts for the rich. There’s nothing about the millions of Americans workers thrown out of work by the also-massive American trade deficit, which is widened by the Bush administration’s determination to privilege military expenditures over “homeland” economic vitality.
There’s nothing about the Bush administration’s determination to use the “war on terror” (curiously expanded to include the occupation of Iraq, a country that posed no terrorist or other threat to the U.S. in 2003) as cover for a radically regressive domestic policy agenda that (more than simply resisting a “tax increase” to pay for the war) grants gigantic giveaways (tax and otherwise) to the privileged few. There’s nothing, of course, about the racist, imperialist, and (curiously enough) terrorist nature of “war on terror,” amply displayed in the prisons of U.S. occupation and in the broad indifference that American government and media show towards the many innocent Arab victims of U.S. military actions in the Middle East – the de-personalized “collateral damage” of supposed American “liberation.”
There’s nothing about the difference between the arguably genuine threat posed to Americans by the actual fascist Axis of the 1940s (when Uncle Sam successfully advanced savings bond and gasoline-rationing drives to “unite the country behind its fighting forces”) and the concocted and imaginary threat posed by Iraq (one part of Bush’s laughable 2002 “State of the Union” construction – the “Axis of Evil”) in 2002 and 2003.

There’s little said about the American citizenry’s intelligent skepticism towards Bush’s invasion of Iraq and his determination to merge that invasion with a “war on terror.” To his credit, however, Shanker quotes a perceptive academic who notes that “the public” sees “the ongoing mission in Iraq…in a different light than a terrorist attack on American soil.” “The public wants very much to support the troops” in Iraq, this professor says, “but it doesn’t really believe in the mission. Most consider it a war of choice, and a majority – although a thin one – thinks it was the wrong choice.”

Such skepticism towards Bush’s war on Iraq is something different than Dr. Moskos’ “patriotism lite.” It seems more like a patriotism done right, one that speaks highly of a significant part of the citizenry. It rejects blind obedience to the deceptive rhetoric of militaristic elites who want mass consent to illegal wars in accordance with the authoritarian slogan, “My Country, Right or Wrong.”

Still, there is a very real ongoing conflict between the hard, murderous requirements of militarism and the soft, “normalcy”-craving imperatives of American consumer capitalism, which tries to reduce democratic citizenship to the uninterrupted and often trivial pursuit, purchase, and enjoyment of commodities. The “patriotism lite” charge applies reasonably to that significant part of the American populace that is content to let predominantly working-class others fight and die in imperial campaigns for which they personally refuse to sacrifice in substantive way.
“Support Our Troops” is an often cheap slogan on the back of many suburban gas-guzzling SUV’s loaded with middle-class soccer kids and with relatively affluent Moms and Dads who would never enlist their children in a dangerous American-imperial service that relies almost entirely (as Moskos and others have shown) on the children of America’s poor and working classes. Nowhere is the slogan cheaper than in the oval office, whose Fortunate Son inhabitant George “Bring ‘Em On” Bush continues his Vietnam-era record of cheering on poorer and browner other Americans to death and destruction in deceptively sold imperial campaigns he prefers to personally sit out.

Paul Street (pstreet@cul-chicago.org) is a writer and researcher in Chicago, IL. He is the author of Empire and Inequality: America and the World Since 9/11 (Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers, 2004) and Segregated Schools: Race, Class, and Educational Apartheid in the Post-Civil Rights Era (New York, NY: Routledge, 2005)

The activists’ MC: An interview with Son of Nun

From MRZine: “The activists’ MC: An interview with Son of Nun”

Most progressive-minded hip-hop fans and culturally-inclined activists have not heard of Baltimore rapper Son of Nun. After listening to the Son’s first album, “Blood and Fire,” I can only say this: they will.

Despite this being his first album, Nun — a high school teacher, activist, and organizer from Baltimore — is clearly a superb, smart lyricist who is on his way up. The fact that he is able to successfully use his skills to express intelligent, radical politics in a style that ranges from poetic to in-your-face is one reason I recommend hip-hop fans get this album.
“Blood and Fire” is united thematically by the Son’s vicious vitriol against capitalism, imperialism, war, poverty, sexism and racism. It also touches on the Son’s own personal struggles. One of the songs on the album — the antiwar head-banger, “Fight back” — was chosen from over 500 submissions to appear on a recently-released antiwar compilation alongside Sonic Youth, Jane’s Addiction, Paris, and many more. Another one of Nun’s songs, “Free Palestine,” was voted the best song of the week on NPR’s Open Mic site. Son of Nun has performed and appeared on releases with the likes of Ani DiFranco and Jurassic 5, and he frequently performs at rallies, underground clubs, activists conferences, and universities.

While the current underground political hip-hop scene is extraordinarily vibrant, most artists that fall within this scene have some weakness that leaves one a little hungry: too much posturing, weak beats, amateurish lyrical skills, misogynist and/or anti-gay lyrics. In Blood and Fire, Son of Nun avoids these pitfalls, producing one of the best underground political albums in recent years. With diverse beats, sophisticated and powerful lyrics, a mature flow, and just the right amount of swagger, Son of Nun is a rising star, and it’s only a matter of time until more people begin to notice.

I had a chance to interview Son of Nun through e-mail. To get a taste of the Son, listen to the samples below. You can purchase “Blood and Fire” at .

MP3s

Fight Back

(Lyrics to “Fight Back”:
)

One Solution

(Lyrics to “One Solution”:
)

Free Palestine

(Lyrics to “Free Palestine”:
)

Interview with Rapper Son of Nun

By Derek Seidman

Seidman: “Blood and Fire” is your first album. Clearly you use hip-hop as a way to express your politics. When did you start rapping, and why did you choose hip-hop as a way to express your political ideas?

Son of Nun: I started rapping back in 1997 when a friend asked me to jam with his band. Up to that point I’d only written poetry, so I wrote a little piece for the session and I haven’t put the mic down since. Before that I messed around a little in high school from about 1991 to 1995, trying to write rhymes that sounded like whatever I was listening to — you know, Cypress Hill, Biggie, Onyx, Mobb Deep — but I wasn’t serious about it and probably only wrote a total of three rhymes.

Towards the end of high school I started getting real frustrated with hip hop because I was starting to look at it in the context of how my consciousness around America was beginning to change, the struggles that blacks had endured, and just the overall redundancy that you couldn’t avoid noticing in mainstream hip hop itself. There used to be balance on the radio in terms of the content you’d hear from artists. But I think by the end of high school that had all pretty much vanished — and so did my interest in hip hop. I think early Wu Tang, Tribe Called Quest, and Digable Planets (Blow Out Comb) held the flame till I found out about The Roots, Labtekwon, Black Star, and Common.

Overall, I think Bob Marley, conscious dance hall reggae, and Rage against the Machine had more to do with me expressing my ideas in hip hop than hip hop did. Even though my first two tapes were Run DMC’s Raising Hell and Salt N Pepa’s Get Up (I think that’s the title), I didn’t know about KRS-ONE until he dropped “Rapture” off I Got Next, and I didn’t know about Rakim till after that — even though I had seen Juice and was into the song. I know, I know, it’s sad but it’s true.

I also got into drum n bass in college and knew it was the next level for hip hop (yeah, I said it.) Around that time some of my friends started DJ-ing and one was spinning drum n bass, so we got together and I started writing and freestyling over it. Another friend in the crew got us residencies at a couple clubs and it was on. I honed my skills and got to play with and open for some of the greats: Roni Size & Reprazent, Adam F, Diesel Boy, and others.

Then I started feeling like, drum n bass was great but most of the folks who came to the shows were just into dancing, not listening. Hip hop would obviously be the best way to get a point across musically, so now I’m paying dues all over again, this time in hip hop. It’s great, because I’m at a point where I’ve learned a lot more about it as an art form and politics through study and activism. I feel like I can bring something unique for this time instead of the same ol’ same ol’.

You said that you started getting real frustrated with where hip-hop was at. What’s your take on the state of mainstream hip-hop?

Man, that shit is weak. Thank god for the underground and hip hop overseas. Again homes, balance. It’s not the fault of the artists that the companies in control only want to invest in one sound. At one point in my life I used to be a purist and hate mainstream rap with a passion until I realized that the criminal and materialistic styles have always been there and America itself has an infatuation with gangsters (oh sorry, I mean gangstas) and materialism. How can I like Goodfellas, Casino, and Scarface and then attempt to reject the same qualities embodied in these films when they appear in hip hop by saying that mainstream hip hop isn’t really hip hop? In the underground there are hundreds if not thousands of 50 Cents — so I’d have to say that the underground isn’t truly hip hop either.

Now does that mean that I condone what the artists say and do? Hell no — sometimes I feel like I’m listening to Klan propaganda — I sure as hell don’t approve of what they do in those movies I mentioned either. Do I understand that for some of them hip hop is their ticket out of the debilitating manifestations of institutionalized racism? Of course I do. But does that mean that they can’t use the brains in their head to write songs that question why things are the way they are? I feel like when you have that much influence you can save a few spots on your album to shake shit up for real. I mean let’s be honest and rational for a moment . . . if on my album all I talk about is committing crimes against other black people, who the fuck am I threatening with my “hard ass” alpha male persona? No one in any position of power anywhere considers them threatening in any way, shape, or form that can’t be handled with a parental advisory sticker. People in power consider “gangsta rap” to be about as dangerous to them as an R-rated movie is to a minor. They’re a fucking joke to these people, not because of what they’re saying but because of the position of influence they have but predictably fail to use.

I don’t know, man. Maybe these rappers think that’s what they’re doing in the world of hip hop. Maybe they think that their style is revolutionizing the face of rap and shit will never be the same because of them and the new way they’re talking about guns, misogyny, and materialism. Maybe I’m the one who’s out of touch and missing the boat because there is no interest in politically relevant hip hop. I doubt it.

Seriously, though, when I do my lesson at school on 9/11 and drop the lyrics from Mr. Lif’s home of the brave, 90% of my students ask if they can keep the copy of the rhyme I gave them to follow along. And they listen to Three 6, and 50 Cent, and all the popular shit. And these aren’t kids of privilege, these are students in a school system that was found to be underfunded by $400 – $800 million dollars by the state of Maryland. At my school more than 90% of the kids get free or reduced lunch and the drop-out rate is greater than 70%. We had plenty of fires, fights, a stabbing, a rape, a couple lock downs because of weapons, and of course some military recruiters. These kids ARE getting left behind.

So if Lif can get props in the hood and everyone else follows that trend, then there is plenty of room for politics in the mainstream which means that companies and artists (especially established ones) share in the blame. And if you don’t think the Lif example is real, look at Jada Kiss and the success of “Why?”.

What do you feel are the main themes connecting the tracks on “Blood and Fire”? What are you trying to get across to the listener?

Struggle and skills, man. On the album struggle comes through politically and personally because those are the struggles I know, and if I’m putting out something with my name on it, it had better represent who I am and what I know in a realistic way. I wanted to make music that talked about the issues I was interested in and organizing around. I wanted to get people off their ass, contribute to a soundtrack that vindicated and emboldened those already active, and I wanted to get some shit off my chest.

Politically, the album touches on war, Palestine, racism, and capitalism — these were some of the issues I wanted to speak about. I didn’t write a blueprint for the CD or anything like that. I just selected the songs I liked the most and called it a day. Countless books have been written on each of these topics, but I guess my ego was big enough to feel that I could weigh in on the debates . . . hmmm. Seriously though, they’re much more than abstract topics for discussion, their unforgiving realities that people endure across the globe.

Is a song or a compilation going to solve all our problems? Probably not. Does music resonate with people in a way that can challenge and/or galvanize their beliefs and help move them to action? Hell yes. I’m living proof. When Bob [Marley] said, “Get up, Stand up,” I took that shit seriously.

I also think it would be a big mistake to get your set of politics from a recording artist. Political musicians, just like charismatic leaders, emerge from movements, not the other way around. I think artists can and do help inspire people to action — and once people get involved I think they should do their own research and draw their own conclusions about how their efforts can be most effective. Personally I’m a socialist and I’m a member of the International Socialist Organization.

The alienation caused by the way our society is run is unavoidable. Everyday people get up and go to jobs they hate and it crushes their souls. The best part of their day is taken from them in exchange for some ridiculous wage and when they get home they don’t feel like doing shit, let alone doing something about it and/or pursue their dreams which have often been relegated to “hobbies.” Then we have kids and bequeath to them this sorry existence with the hope that they can somehow “make it” if they just work really hard, which is crap. If hard work determined your wealth in this society people like the president would be broke as shit.

Personally, I love my job but I hate that I don’t have what I need to do it as well as I could. Not only is our school system under-funded, but teachers are, as if I need to say it, underpaid.

So if you take this dynamic created by exploitation at work, a false American dream, racism, sexism, etc., what do you think the outcome is on the personal lives of everyday people? Lots of alienation, escapism, self doubt and self blame for not having more money, friends, and beautiful women, and on and on and on you know. More specifically and personally, racism fucking hurts, man, and it’s important and empowering and therapeutic to organize and rally against it in its many forms — but it still hurts. Growing up without a father and seeing your mom bust her ass to provide for you so much that you hardly get to see her fucking hurts, and when you know the sexism, racism, and immigrant discrimination she endured in and out of the black community that hurts too.

Growing up is hard enough by itself but when you add all this other stuff to the mix that you can feel the effects of but can’t always directly identify at the time, one’s experience can be pretty rough. I wanted to add some of that to the album, to inject hip hop with an alternative to the alpha-male/super hero “I-ain’t-never-scared-or-hurt” perspective. I don’t care what anyone says, nobody’s hard all the time.

So that’s what I wanted to get across on the album.

“Fight back” is one of the best songs on your album, I think. What is the background of this song?

Thanks. I guess I’d say that the background for the song was this thinly veiled imperialist power grab sold to the American people as a pack of lies that we and the Iraqi people would have to pay for in our blood. The background was being a part of the largest pre-war antiwar movement in the history of the world, watching Bush give us the middle finger-watching the antiwar movement shrivel up and get hamstrung by the Kerry campaign — and saying fuck no! Now is precisely the time when we need to be standing up and saying no to war as loudly and clearly and often as possible.

My producer and roommate at the time (yeah, real convenient), DJ Krimson, put the beat together and we recorded the track around late spring or early summer of 2004. It sounded like it was missing something so I thought the samples would just make it all the more real. The first one of the man speaking was from an impromptu interview I did at an antiwar demo in DC before the invasion of Iraq. The second sample of the people chanting “that’s bullshit get off it, the war is for profit, war and occupation will never bring liberation, that’s bullshit. . . ” was from a DC demo after the invasion.

The timing of the song was pretty clutch, too, because we completed it just before the submission deadline for Peace Not War 2, the definitive antiwar compilation with Jurassic 5, Sonic Youth, Paris, Ani DiFranco, Lyrics Born, Jane’s Addiction, and more. I was looking for labels to release the CD and came across like two days before the deadline. I sent my song through Fedex, emailed an mp3 version of it, and crossed my fingers. A couple days later I get an email from Mudge in the UK and he’s like, “talk about cutting it close.” Turns out Fedex screwed up the delivery, so if it weren’t for the mp3. . . .

I have to say a little more about Mudge though because he put all of himself into this and the previous “Peace Not War” compilation. We got to meet up in DC and he broke it down for me — he put it all on the line and he’s giving half the loot to antiwar groups while he’s living in the red. He’s organized benefits with major artists against the war and the ‘authorities’, at the last minute, deny the permit they already approved for the show and he takes the hit. But he still does it.

Before you mentioned your students, and how they could relate to politics through hip-hop. Can you talk about this — how hip-hop can serve as a way of expressing things in a way that might be able to resonate or connect with certain people more deeply?

Man, I think it’s a matter of respecting the craft and speaking to each other in a language we already appreciate and understand. When it comes to respecting the craft I mean caring enough about hip hop to learn about how it came to be and why it looks the way it does today, as well as seeing it as a source for information that’s just as valid as any editorialist, pundit, or expert with an axe to grind. My students see it that way already because they reference hip hop songs as evidence when they’re supporting their statements. And when discussions take us into the history of hip hop everyone’s interested and engaged because we’re getting into something that’s a part of their everyday life.

I was an assistant debate coach this year and earlier this summer I taught at a debate camp that’s a part of the urban debate league which is a program designed to get inner city middle school and high school students involved in debate throughout the year. The camp is rigorous, demanding, fun, and mind-blowing. I know adults who haven’t even considered the complex concepts that these kids were wrapping their heads around and then arguing both sides of competitively. This year, as part of their evidence and argument materials, they included a compilation CD featuring the music of various political artists that’s relevant to this year’s resolution. Why? Because experience has shown them that validating hip hop and exposing students to artists who use hip hop as a political weapon is not only empowering but it can attract students to their program which does a better job at preparing them scholastically and financially for college than their schools often do.

Hip hop is music and music strikes chords within us that words alone can’t. To me, hip hop is the youth of an oppressed group saying “I’ve got something to say and I’m gonna say it the way I wanna say it, and if you don’t like it… fuck you!” That’s inherently attractive, especially to young people, and especially to young people whose experience is directly being expressed in hip hop. If you’re a young person in an oppressed minority in our society, wouldn’t an art form built around your experience, expressed by other young people like you, be attractive?

To give another example I wrote a song called “Free Palestine” which I submitted to National Public Radio’s (NPR) Open Mic website where it received a record number of votes earning it the title — best song of the week. Those votes were cast by people around the world who stand in solidarity with Palestine. Haithem El-Zabri, the owner of the , encouraged people on countless Palestine solidarity listservs (like Al-Awda) to vote and word spread to Indy Media Centers from Vancouver to Italy. I received emails of encouragement and invitations from the occupied territories and the song, lyrics, and the contest were even referenced in the Jordan Times. Now this was NPR’s Open Mic website where over the history of the program many songs had been voted for and against but for the people who voted in support of “Free Palestine” it wasn’t about my song — rather it was about their desire for justice for the people of Palestine. Expressing that through a vote, particularly on NPR, resonated deeply with all involved.

You also mentioned the underground. It’s funny, a lot of the great underground rappers — from Black Star, to Common, to The Roots — aren’t really so underground anymore. What’s the underground rap scene looking like these days, and how would you define “the underground” as opposed to mainstream hip-hip?

The underground is diverse and thank god! The underground, as far as I’m concerned, stretches from U.S. school cafeteria battles and ciphers to the Palestinian hip hop of the Philistines, Life Convicts, or Iron Sheik. For me the mainstream is heavy rotation on MTV and major radio.

Who are some of the artists you most respect?

Bob Marley (need I explain?), Burning Spear (his voice strikes dangerous chords in the soul), Fela Kuti (suffering and smiling, he’s a razor), Nina Simone (I don’t know if it gets any more real), Zap Mama (extremely creative, very empowered), Last Poets (nobody can fuck with them), Jimi Hendrix (again, no explanation necessary), James Brown (I know, but music was never the same), Saul Williams (he’s putting it down for real), The Doors (they got the guns but we got the numbers and some times you feel like music is your only friend), Cannibal Ox with el-p as the third member (listen to the cold vein, compare it to Vast’s and Vordul’s solo joints and you’ll know), Black Star, Common Sense (cuz that’s his real name), The Roots (because it was about time), Nas (yeah, I know, but his talent and creativity are undeniable), Labtekwon (Baltimore’s most prolific, skilled, and dedicated emcee), Steel Pulse (tribute to the Martyrs son), Buju Banton (changed from “Boom Bye Bye” to “Circumstances” — not that rastas aren’t homophobic), Capleton (reachin’, teachin’ the people fi sure), Rage Against The Machine (because we can do something), The Clash (when they kick in your front door, how ya gonna come?), Radiohead (their sound is tangible), Portishead (the pain in her voice is beautiful), System of a Down (their sound is as schizophrenic as U.S culture).

And many, many more. Can’t forget Public Enemy, and mf doom & mad lib on Madvillain — sick!

That’s funny that you didn’t mention Tupac Shakur. He seems to embody more than anyone this paradox of hip-hop (though maybe it’s not a paradox). On the one hand, he’s was totally righteous — militant, political, radical, rooted in the Black Panther tradition, really able to articulate the experience of post-industrial black oppression in a powerful way. On the other hand, his lyrics could also be incredibly misogynistic. What do you think of Pac?

I know I’ll probably get a lot of shit for this but I never really got into Pac. Maybe it was the freedom and confidence with which he expressed his own contradictions as a human being that I wasn’t ready to hear at the time because I wasn’t able to accept them in myself (no, not in terms of being misogynistic) or maybe I just wasn’t feeling his music, or both. It’s been a long time since I’ve listened to any of his stuff but I’m definitely open to checking it again now with some more years under my belt.

What artists have been most influential for you — on your style, and just generally?

Bob Marley, Burning Spear, Public Enemy, Rage — all of them never let me forget that injustice must be confronted and things don’t get better unless you do something about it. They also entrenched in my heart the significance of history as one of the most important tools in our arsenal, a mirror to the present.

As far as my style? Well, anyone who doesn’t say Rakim is a goddamn liar — unless your doing one of the “I’m the only one who understands what I’m saying style” styles. I’m definitely still aspiring to the awe inspiring skills (which are different from content) of hip hop’s prodigal son, Nas. Zack De La Rocha’s undeniably left his mark on my brain and Saul Williams is certainly knockin’ around in there too, and so is Mr. Lif.

What are your upcoming plans? Tours? Another album?

Man, I’m just trying to rock all the shows I can. I’ve sent kits out to clubs and college radio with no feedback, so I’m just like fuck it, I’ll make them come to me. I know what my potential is so I’m going to do it my way and create a grassroots following among the people I’m organizing with. I’m relying on people who believe in the music enough to help support it in whatever way they can, you know, from writing a review to organizing a show to having me perform at a political event. Ultimately, I want to take this around the world, and I know it’s possible, so that’s what I’m working towards. Folks can always check my website for show dates — SonOfNun.

The next album is coming along, just met a producer from the U.K. who I’m going to collaborate with on a bunch of tracks, and there are some cats around the way I’m going to work with too so. . . . I don’t want to put any dates out yet because there’s still a good amount of work that needs to be done.

Derek Seidman lives in Providence, RI. He can be reached at . Seidman is a co-editor of the radical youth journal Left Hook.

WIKIMAINIA

Several stories on wikimainia from MediaChannel.org:

WIKIMANIA
Ground Zero, at least last week, was Frankfurt, Germany, site of Wikimania, the first global gathering of the self-styled ‘wikipedians’ who collectively are well on their way to the goal of providing free online encyclopedias in every language on earth. MediaChannel.org’s Rory O’Connor was there and reports on the Big Bang of the next information revolution.

BEYOND AN ENCYCLOPEDIA: WHAT’S NEXT FOR WIKIMANIA?
In just 10 years Wikimedia has evolved into a phenomenon, spawning a worldwide community that has created a brand potentially worth hundreds of millions of dollars and a website now in the top 50 that gets more traffic than USA Today and The New York Times put together. And it all happened through the efforts of volunteers, without a bureaucratic top-down organization, staff structure or marketing budget. News Dissector Danny Schechter was at the Wikimedia Conference and reports on the Wikipedia phenomenon.

WIKIPEDIA TO TIGHTEN GRIP
Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales says the Wiki web encyclopaedia written and edited by internet users from all over the world plans to impose stricter editorial rules to prevent vandalism of its content.

Report: US high schools may not adequately prepare dropouts for unemployment

From “America’s Finest News Source” a report on the latest crisis in education:

Report: Our highs may not adequately prepare dropouts for unemployment

WASHINGTON, DC–A Department of Labor report released Monday finds that America’s high schools are not sufficiently preparing emerging dropouts for the demands of unemployment.

In a letter introducing the report, Labor Secretary Elaine Chao explained that schools routinely fail to impart dropouts with the critical lying- and sitting-around skills they need to thrive in today’s jobless market.

“Our public high schools place too much focus on preparing kids for professional careers,” Chao said. “This waste of resources leaves our dropouts, the majority of whom have no chance of ever finding a job, wholly unprepared to sleep till 1 p.m., or watch daytime television while eating ramen noodles out of an upturned Frisbee.”

According to the study, America’s weakest academic performers also drop out of high school without ever having learned to steal beer money from their housemates’ change jars or wash their hair with bar soap.

“This oversight cannot continue if our kids are to become unproductive citizens,” Chao said. “The future dregs of society are not being served.”

Despite massive cuts in recent decades, some remnants of math and science instruction continue to plague many school districts. These courses, Chao argued, waste valuable time and money.

Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings defended the nation’s public-school system.

“Educators do a lot to ensure that the most hopeless students slip through the cracks,” Spellings said. “Arbitrary rules, irregularly enforced discipline, and pointless paperwork are just the first things that come to mind.”

She added: “Easy grading encourages students to be sloppy and late handing in homework–a skill that makes future deadbeats very competitive in stonewalling landlords and bill collectors.”

Chao said educators need to think outside the classroom and give kids some real off-the-job experience.

“Increasing suspensions and expulsions is a good start,” Chao said. “Furthermore, scoliosis exams should be made more routine, so students learn to adapt to the all-underwear wardrobe typical of the non-working class.”

Chao also suggested that schools hold more blood drives, which would prepare dropouts for visits to their local blood-plasma donation centers for quick and easy cash.

Some educators say the report paints too bleak a picture of schools’ efforts to instill students with a lack of ambition.

“We are doing a terrible, terrible job,” said James Dunham, the principal of HS 445 in New York. “We literally could not be doing any worse.”

Dunham highlighted the fact that the hallways of his school are lined with vending machines that sell nothing but unhealthy snack products such as soda and potato chips, both of which acclimate students to the diet of a jobless lowlife.

Susan French, a spokesperson for the National Education Association, the nation’s largest teachers’ union, said educators are superb role models for the unemployed dropouts of tomorrow.

Said French: “Students spend seven hours a day surrounded by adults who despise their low-paying jobs. If the critics out there know a better way to discourage a young person from entering the work force, I’d like to see it.”

Busting the minimum wage myth

Ellen Dannin’s two part article in MRZine on the minumum wage is a great example of how RWTT use dubious “research” to back policies that hurt the many to help the few.
What right-wing think tanks say about the minimum wage

Anyone interested in politics should at least occasionally read what Right-Wing Think Tanks (RWTTs) are proposing, for what they advocate shows up as Administration policies. Reading the RWTTs enables us to identify and respond to the same ideas that eventually trickle out of the mouths of Administration spokespeople.

Right-Wing Think Tanks want to eliminate the minimum wage. RWTTs arguments against the minium wage often mention studies and their findings, but rarely provide sufficient information to track down and assess them. Below are some of the most common arguments made by RWTTs.

Challenging right-wing think tank’s “economics-lite”

When arguments turn to economics, most of us (a) flee, (b) fall asleep, or (c) give up and figure it’s just too hard to understand.

But you can stand your ground, even if you have never taken an economics course. What it takes is being curious and willing to ask questions and challenge claims. It also helps to know that most of the pundits of Right-Wing Think Tanks (RWTTs) who fall back on economic claims base them on economics-lite. They use a few facile and sterile ideas and stretch them to fit all situations. These ideas are mere theories (in the pejorative sense of the word), and, unlike scientific theories, they have no evidence to support them. Indeed, when put to the test, these ideas tend to be falsified. That is, the evidence does not support them (more on that below). When your common sense tells you that they seem to be over-simplifying, you are probably right, er, correct.

Bush says teach ID

In a not so surprising move George W. Bush endorses teaching religion as science

WASHINGTON — President Bush waded into the debate over evolution and ”intelligent design” yesterday, saying schools should teach both theories on the creation and complexity of life.

In a wide-ranging question-and-answer session with a small group of reporters, Bush essentially endorsed efforts by Christian conservatives to give intelligent design equal standing with the theory of evolution in the nation’s schools.