Category Archives: Legal issues

Does Academic Freedom Give a Professor the Final Say on Grades?

The Chronicle: CASE IN POINT: STRONACH V. VIRGINIA STATE U. (2008)
Does Academic Freedom Give a Professor the Final Say on Grades?

Commentary

Does Academic Freedom Give a Professor the Final Say on Grades?

By LAWRENCE WHITE

Carey E. Stronach, for more than 40 years a tenured professor of physics at Virginia State University, assigned an undergraduate a final grade of D after the student had failed three classroom quizzes. The student claimed to have received A’s on two of the quizzes. He submitted faxed copies of his score sheets to Stronach, who concluded that the student had doctored his scores. The student appealed to the chairman of the physics department, who sided with the student and changed his final course grade to an A.

Judge’s Ruling in Copyright Case Lets College Off but Not Lecturer

The Chronicle News Blog: Judge’s Ruling in Copyright Case Lets College Off but Not Lecturer

It’s a case that has some copyright scholars scratching their heads. A judge exonerates a university that is accused of infringing the copyright of a company’s research report. But the judge rules that an employee of the university might be culpable of the same activity.

Fired Professor and Southern Illinois U. Settle Dispute Over Alleged Plagiarism

The Chronicle News Blog: Fired Professor and Southern Illinois U. Settle Dispute Over Alleged Plagiarism

In 2004, Chris Dussold, an assistant professor of finance, was fired by Southern Illinois University at Edwardsville for copying someone else’s teaching statement. No one would have predicted the fallout from that dismissal, or guessed that the battle would stretch on for four years.

Washington: Husband, daughter of Spokane diploma mill operator enter pleas

Seattle Times: Husband, daughter of Spokane diploma mill operator enter pleas

The husband and daughter of a woman who operated a Spokane-based diploma mill have pleaded guilty to federal charges of conspiracy to commit wire and mail fraud.

Eastern Washington U.S. Attorney James A. McDevitt says 68-year-old Steven K. Randock Sr. and 39-year-old Heidi Kae Lorhan entered pleas similar to that entered Wednesday by Dixie E. Randock.

An indictment returned in 2005 says the Randocks and others used a string of fictional online universities to sell bogus college degrees and transcripts to more than 8,200 customers around the world.

Investigators allege the operation took in $5 million.

Yale student to serve a year in prison on weapons charges

The Boston Globle: Yale student to serve a year in prison on weapons charges

NEW HAVEN, Conn.—A 22-year-old Yale student has begun serving a one-year prison term after pleading no contest to charges of reckless endangerment and the illegal possession of assault weapons.

TSU’s Slade avoids prison with plea deal

The Houston Chronicle: TSU’s Slade avoids prison with plea deal

A scandal that began in 2006 when a TSU regent complimented Priscilla Slade’s choice of home furnishings ended Wednesday with a deal that lets the ousted leader of Texas’ largest historically black university avoid prison in exchange for paying back $127,672.18.

It is only a fraction of the $500,000 in school money Slade was accused of spending, lavishly and improperly, on herself. Her first trial ended last year in a mistrial, and the former, much-beloved president was scheduled to again face judgment Friday.

Wednesday’s settlement, reached after hours of negotiations and ending with Slade apologizing, brings the saga to an end.

Woman found guilty of arson in 2001 University of Washington fire

Seattle Times: Woman found guilty of arson in 2001 University of Washington fire

U.S. attorneys say five people participated in the 2001 arson at the University of Washington’s Center for Urban Horticulture:

Briana Waters: Oakland, Calif., served as a lookout and helped rent a car for the team that set the fire. She was found guilty Thursday of two counts of arson, but jurors couldn’t agree on a verdict for three other counts. She faces at least five years in prison for each arson count.

Lacey Phillabaum: Spokane, pleaded guilty to participating in the arson in exchange for assisting in the prosecution of others involved, including Waters. She faces a prison sentence of three to five years.

Jennifer Kolar: Seattle, admitted she used a knife to cut glass so others could get into an office at the horticulture center. She also assisted the government’s prosecution and faces a sentence of five to seven years in prison.

Bill Rodgers: Considered to be one of the top organizers of the Earth Liberation Front who allegedly help set the firebombs inside the horticulture center. Rodgers, a bookstore operator in Prescott, Ariz., was taken into federal custody in December 2005, but later committed suicide in an Arizona jail.

Justin Solondz: Once lived on the Olympic Peninsula, allegedly helped assemble the fire bombs in an Olympia garage and joined Rodgers in setting the devices inside the horticulture center. Solondz is now a fugitive.

TACOMA — A 32-year-old violin teacher from California was found guilty this morning of two counts of arson for the 2001 fire at the University of Washington’s Center for Urban Horticulture.

California State University system to amend conduct code

Mercury News: California State University system to amend conduct code

SAN FRANCISCO—The California State University system has agreed to amend its student conduct code to settle a lawsuit by a conservative Christian legal group that argued that its written expectation that students be “civil” was vague and violated students’ rights.

Fresno State files appeal of award in Johnson-Klein case

Fresno Bee: Fresno State files appeal of award in Johnson-Klein case

Fresno State is appealing the multimillion-dollar judgment from the Stacy Johnson-Klein gender-discrimination trial, but it’s far from certain whether both sides will tangle again in a courtroom.

In a one-paragraph notice filed Wednesday with Fresno County Superior Court, the university said it is appealing to the 5th District Court of Appeal a jury’s $19.1 million award to Johnson-Klein in December. Judge Donald S. Black later cut that amount to $6.6 million.

Fresno State also is appealing the reduced award and Black’s ruling on Feb. 8 to order a new trial only if Johnson-Klein chose not to accept it.

New York: Cuomo widens probe of kickbacks tied to student loans

Newsday: Cuomo widens probe of kickbacks tied to student loans

The state attorney general’s office has widened the scope of its investigation into conflicts of interest in higher education, expanding its probe of kickbacks in the student loan industry to a broad range of companies doing business on college campuses across the nation.

UK: Appeal upheld for youths ‘intoxicated by terror’

Telegraph: Appeal upheld for youths ‘intoxicated by terror’

The country’s top judge has dealt a significant blow to a key plank of the Government’s anti-terrorism legislation after he overturned the convictions of five Muslim men jailed last year for downloading and sharing extremist terror-related material.

California: Former coach accepts $6.6m is sex discrimination case

Sacramento Bee: Former coach accepts $6.6m

Johnson-Klein takes reduced award, says it’s ‘right thing to do.’

Stacy Johnson-Klein said Wednesday she will accept a smaller award in her court victory over Fresno State, saying it’s time for her and the community to put a divisive trial behind them.

The former California State University, Fresno, women’s basketball coach said she consulted with family and her legal team and prayed before deciding to accept Fresno County Superior Court Judge Donald S. Black’s reduced award of $6.6 million.

New York: Appellate court backs Pace faculty

New York Teacher: Appellate court backs Pace faculty

Leaders of NYSUT’s adjunct faculty local union at Pace University feel vindicated following a federal circuit court decision that potentially means adding hundreds of members to a bargaining unit of 750 members.

The January decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals, Washington, D.C. Circuit, affirmed the National Labor Relations Board’s original certification of this bargaining unit and the inclusion of adjuncts who were not eligible to vote in the 2004 representation election.

ORU money funneled, suit claims

Tulsa World: ORU money funneled, suit claims

More than $1 billion annually was funneled through ORU, a former accountant claims.

A former Oral Roberts University accountant revised his lawsuit Thursday to allege that more than $1 billion annually was funneled through the university, possibly to regents.

“It appears that many of the former board members were actual participants in the funneling of money through the university for their own eventual personal use, and thus, the foxes were watching the hen house,” says former accountant Trent Huddleston’s lawsuit.

The money “was not used for any legitimate purpose” that Huddleston
knew, his lawsuit says.

Alabama: Former college head agrees to plea deal in system probe

AP: Former Southern Union head agrees to plea deal in system probe

Former Southern Union State Community College President Joanne Jordan has agreed to plead guilty to obstruction of justice for lying to a grand jury probing Alabama’s two-year college system, a federal prosecutor said Thursday.

U.S. Attorney Alice Martin in Birmingham said Jordan, 66, of Ashland admits giving false testimony and also has agreed to plead guilty to a state ethics charge related to the federal charge.

The federal obstruction charge could bring a penalty of no more than 10 years in prison and fines of $250,000, or both. She will enter a formal plea later.

South Carolina: CSU will pay nearly $4 million in settlement

The State: CSU will pay nearly $4 million in settlement

Charleston Southern University has agreed to pay nearly $4 million to settle allegations it helped a former economist swindle investors out of tens of millions of dollars, according to documents filed Tuesday in federal court.

Al Parish pleaded guilty in October and is awaiting sentencing on charges of fraud and lying to investigators. Prosecutors said the flamboyant economist defrauded hundreds out of more than $90 million. Parish taught economics at Charleston Southern.

Most of the $3.9 million Charleston Southern has agreed to pay is covered under the school’s insurance policy, leaving $160,000 to be paid out of cash reserves, according to the settlement. A hearing on the matter has been scheduled for this month.

Alabama: Lawmaker arrested, charged with fraud in connectin to ghost job at college

Montgomery Advertiser: Lawmaker arrested, charged with fraud

State Rep. Sue Schmitz was arrested Thursday after being indicted on federal charges of taking $177,251 in pay from a program affiliated with Alabama’s two-year colleges yet doing virtually no work.

Key Legal Win in Adjunct Union Battle

Inside Higher Ed: Key Legal Win in Adjunct Union Battle

Adjunct professors at Pace University — who have been engaged in a long fight to unionize and negotiate a contract — won a key battle on Friday when a federal appeals court rejected the New York university’s attempt to limit the size of the bargaining unit.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia upheld the actions of the National Labor Relations Board, which had ruled that the adjunct union should have as its members all instructors who met certain minimal teaching requirements (teaching three credit hours). The university had asked the court to restrict membership to those who met those requirements in at least one semester in any two of the previous three academic years — a request that would have eliminated adjuncts from union membership in their first two years working at Pace.

Judge Reinstates Lawsuit Against UC-Irvine Professor

The Chronicle News Blog: Judge Reinstates Lawsuit Against UC-Irvine Professor

The saga of a paper purporting to find that prayer doubles the success rate of fertility treatment continues. A Los Angeles Superior Court judge has reinstated a defamation lawsuit that he tossed out two months ago against a professor at the University of California at Irvine who has been the study’s main debunker.

Judge Rules in Favor of Wisconsin Roman Catholic Student Organization

The Chronicle News Blog: Judge Rules in Favor of Wisconsin Roman Catholic Student Organization

Once again a federal judge has ruled that the University of Wisconsin at Madison must provide student-activity funds to a Roman Catholic student organization — even though the money will be used for religious purposes like worship services and proselytizing.