Friendship Among the Intellectuals

Commentary: Friendship Among the Intellectuals, By Joseph Epstein

ìIt is painful to consider,î wrote Samuel Johnson about friendship, ìthat there is no human possession of which the duration is less certain.î

Too true. Some friendships die on their own, of simple inanition, having been quietly allowed to lapse by the unacknowledged agreement of both parties. Others break down because time has altered old friends, given them different interests, values, points of view. In still others, only one party works at the friendship, while the other belongs to what Truman Capote called (in a letter to the critic Newton Arvin, his ex-lover) ìsome odd psychological type . . . that only writes when he is written to.î And then of course there are the friendships that end when one friend betrays or is felt to betray the other, or fails to come through in a crisis, or finds himself violently disputing the other on matters of profoundest principle.

These days, such principled disagreements tend often to involve ideas, and to be endemic among supposedly educated people and especially among intellectuals. The ideas themselves are as likely as not to involve politics. Even more than differences over religion, political disputes seem to ignite ugly emotions and get things to the yelling stage quickly. That may well be why, in 18th-century clubs and coffeehouses, politics was often prohibited as a subject for discussion.

Harvard Study Finds That Students at Private High Schools Have a Clear Edge

The Chronicle: Harvard Study Finds That Students at Private High Schools Have a Clear Edge

Researchers at Harvard University say private high schools give their students an advantage over those who attend public schools. The new findings, presented in a report released today, challenge a recent study by the U.S. Department of Education, which did not find as many statistically significant differences between the effect of private and public schools on student achievement.

The Harvard study found a private-school advantage in 11 of 12 comparisons of students at public and private high schools. In eighth-grade mathematics, for instance, the new study found a private-school advantage of three to seven points on test scores; in reading, the advantage ranged from nine to 13 points.

Judge Orders Ohio State to Pay $2-Million to Coach It Fired for Rule Breaking

Journal News: Former Ohio State coach awarded $2.2 million for wrongful firing

Ohio State must pay former basketball coach Jim O’Brien about $2.2 million plus interest for wrongly firing him for giving a recruit $6,000, a judge ruled Wednesday. The award in the Ohio Court of Claims ends two years of controversy at Ohio State, which was handed NCAA sanctions for the money given to the recruit in addition to losing the lawsuit brought by O’Brien. O’Brien, 56, who coached the Buckeyes for seven years including a trip to the Final Four in 1999, was fired in June 2004 after revealing to then-athletic director Andy Geiger that he had given the money to Serbian prospect Aleksandar Radojevic. He had sought $3.6 million in his lawsuit.

Florida: Student newspaper bought out by local daily

The Ledger: Capital city daily buys Florida State student newspaper

The Tallahassee Democrat, a Gannett-owned daily, has bought the student-run newspaper at Florida State University, one of the first moves by a major publisher into the college newspaper market, an analyst said Wednesday.

Veteran newspaper analyst John Morton of Silver Spring, Md., said the purchase represents the first of its kind in the industry.

“I’m not aware of other daily newspapers having done anything like this,” said Morton. “It’s expanding its grasp of the local print market.”

The acquisition shows the newspaper is trying to reach college-age students in a more effective way and profitable manner, Morton said.

The independently run FSView & Florida Flambeau will continue to be managed by students, but published by the Tallahassee Democrat. Jennifer Irwin, the student newspaper’s general manager, will add the title of publisher.

University Staffs Grew Faster Than Civilian Labor Force Over Recent Decade, Study Finds

The Chronicle: University Staffs Grew Faster Than Civilian Labor Force Over Recent Decade, Study Finds

The increase in the total number of staff members working at American institutions of higher education outpaced the growth of the civilian labor force during a recent 10-year period, according to a report released on Tuesday by the U.S. Department of Education.

Unions line up to oppose ban on gay marriage, civil unions

Duluth News Tribune: Unions line up to oppose ban on gay marriage, civil unions

Labor unions are joining forces to fight a proposed ban on gay marriage and civil unions in what could become a powerful force in the Nov. 7 referendum.

The groups, representing employees ranging from teachers to prison workers, say they are worried the amendment will take away their ability to bargain for benefits such as health insurance for the domestic partners of gay and straight employees.

They are making donations, organizing volunteers and educating their members as part of their attempts to make Wisconsin the first state to defeat a constitutional ban on gay marriage.

AFSCME, which represents 44,000 public service and health care workers in Wisconsin, became the latest to join the cause on Monday with a strong denunciation of the ban from its political arm and a vow to get its message out.

Web site reveals professors’ grading

The Sacramento Bee: Web site reveals professors’ grading

Web sites that allow college students to anonymously evaluate their professors — slamming them as buffoons or rating them as ”hot” — have grown in popularity in recent years.

Now, a unique site called PickProf, which also posts the numbers of A’s through F’s given out in individual classes, is breaking into the California market of more than 2.3 million public university and college students.

The for-profit company prevailed recently in a public-records lawsuit against the University of California-Davis that was seen as a test case in California. (The school initially refused to hand over the letter-grade information, then backed down and paid PickProf $15,000 in legal fees.)

Now the company is seeking the distribution of grades at other University of California schools, the California State University system and the state’s community colleges — to the ire of faculty members who say students will shop for easy classes.

The Daily Bruin: Class ratings may go public

The results of the university-distributed professor evaluations could potentially be made available to students within the upcoming academic year.

The numerical data from the end-of-quarter professor evaluations are at the center of a proposal currently in the works by Marwa Kaisey, president of the Undergraduate Students Association Council.

According to the Daily Bruin archives, professor evaluations were available in booklets published by the Office of Instructional Development until 1995. The booklets were discontinued because of high printing costs.

Teachers union raps Quinnipiac for disbanding faculty union

Boston Globe: Teachers union raps Quinnipiac for disbanding faculty union

-A national teachers union has rebuked Quinnipiac University for abolishing a faculty union.

At its convention in Boston last weekend, the American Federation of Teachers called on Quinnipiac to restore union bargaining rights. The private university won a National Labor Relations Board ruling to decertify the union earlier this year.

The NLRB granted the university’s petition to reclassify about 240 full-time faculty as managerial employees and disband the Quinnipiac Faculty Federation.

The AFT resolution censured the Hamden school for what the union called a “shameful attack on the rights of Quinnipiac faculty.” The union represented university employees for more than three decades. Its most recent contract expired July 1.

All the world’s a stage – especially classrooms, says school union

Guardian Unlimited: All the world’s a stage – especially classrooms, says school union

The drone of monotonous teachers may become a thing of the past after union leaders said that all staff should get voice training to ensure their students’ concentration never wavers.
Unemployed actors should be on hand to offer training in voice projection and classroom performance, according to Philip Parkin, the general secretary of the Professional Association of Teachers.

His remarks follow research showing that many teachers with damaged or “breathy” voices fail to hold their pupils’ attention for long periods of time.

90 Pittsburgh school employees laid off

Post-Gazette: 90 Pittsburgh school employees laid off; 79 teachers get notices; some say number less than expected

Seventy-nine teachers and 11 other employees of the Pittsburgh Public Schools have been laid off because of school closings and budget cuts.

Layoff notices were mailed Friday and Monday, Lisa Fischetti, the school district’s chief of staff, said yesterday.

Furloughed besides the teachers were three other professional employees — two librarians and a counselor represented by the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers — and eight clerical employees represented by the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees.

School officials, union leaders and employees had known for months that cuts were coming. Sherman Shrager, PFT vice president for middle schools and liaison with the district’s human resources office, said the number of affected employees was fewer than he had feared.

One university’s key to R&D – the right senator

Christian Science Monitor: One university’s key to R&D – the right senator

Like most public universities, Mississippi State wants to help improve the state economy – the nation’s poorest.

But unlike most schools, MSU is getting $37.2 million this year in special help from Congress to get the job done.

It’s a magnet for money – call it pulled “pork” – that few schools can rival. By comparison, North Carolina State University, which serves a population four times larger, got $500,000 this year.

Tuition a rising share of CUNY revenue as state share falls

New York City Independent Budget Office: Tuition a rising share of CUNY revenue as state share falls

THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK, commonly known as CUNY, is the largest
urban public university system in the country, with approximately 450,000 students. Until the
city’s fiscal crisis in the 1970s, CUNY charged no tuition. But even with the addition of tuition
revenue, CUNY has faced ongoing challenges to its operating budget. CUNY officials say these
challenges have hampered their ability to expand and improve the university’s educational
programs.

AAUP issue critique of Higher Education Commission report

From Inside Higher Ed:

The Association of American Universities has issued a thorough critique of the second draft report by the Secretary of Education’s Commission on the Future of Higher Education. Robert M. Berdahl, president of the association of 60 of the country’s leading public and private research institutions, says that the group’s members agree with much of the draft report’s overall points, but bemoan its lack of attention to higher education’s research and graduate education missions and its emphasis on preparing students for the work force. “America values higher education not only because it qualifies students for jobs but because it enriches their intellects and makes them better citizens,” the AAU document says

Dealing with PR disasters, which seem to be everywhere in higher ed

Inside Higher Ed: Dealing with disaster

A respected chair of religious studies at Elizabethtown College, in Pennsylvania, is arrested for allegedly making Internet plans to meet an undercover agent who was posing as a 12-year-old girl. A long-time dean of African-American affairs at the University of Virginia announces his retirement just days after admitting he lied to investigators regarding his “knowledge of the activities of a known drug dealer.” And a director of undergraduate studies at Eastern Oregon University is placed on paid leave after torrid allegations of rape are exposed.

All of the events occurred during the hot, hot month of July, much to the chagrin at administrators at the spotlighted institutions. While it isn’t every day that colleges and universities see top administrators or professors accused of or involved in major crimes, institutions often have to make fast-paced employment decisions that have immediate impact on individuals and reputations.

Former Texas Southern president indicted

The Houston Chronicle: Slade, 3 others indicted; A total of $1.9 million was allegedly misspent

A Harris County grand jury indicted former Texas Southern University President Priscilla Slade and three aides Tuesday on allegations of misusing school money on personal expenses.

The indictment alleges Slade, who led TSU for nearly seven years before being fired in June, failed to follow her employment contract, university policies and state laws in paying for household furnishings, landscaping and charitable donations, among other things

Federal Court Criticizes Labor Board’s Handling of Case Involving Union Drive at Private University

The Chronicle: Federal Court Criticizes Labor Board’s Handling of Case Involving Union Drive at Private University

A federal appeals court sent a case back to the National Labor Relations Board on Monday, saying the board had insufficiently explained its reasoning when it decided, in 2004, that professors at a private institution in Pittsburgh were not managers and therefore could form a union.

Inside Higher Ed: Professors: Managers or Employees?

Ever since 1980, professors at private colleges and have had a difficult time forming unions. That’s the year that the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that faculty members at Yeshiva University couldn’t unionize because they had so much power that they were managerial employees.

A federal appeals court ruling Tuesday is the latest to consider attempts by faculty unions (or would-be unions) to win the legal right to collective bargaining. The ruling — involving the faculty union at Point Park University — didn’t offer a definitive opinion on whether faculty members at the Pittsburgh institution could unionize.

Mobilizing the Campus Right

Inside Higher Ed: Mobilizing the Campus Right

We shouldn’t have to have this conference,” Roger Custer, director of the National Conservative Student Conference, said in an interview Monday after delivering the meeting’s opening address. “But these students are so isolated on campus.”

In its 28th year, the Young America’s Foundation annual college student gathering is a well-established Washington tradition — with roughly 400 attendees and a speaker list including Newt Gingrich, Robert Novak and David Brooks. Still, speakers talk with a marked sense of urgency.

There is little tolerance for the conservative viewpoint on campus, panelist after panelist agreed. The charge of a liberal slant in academe is nothing new, but the assertion found new life in each speech. The sense of victimization shone through in the organizers’ description of the conference as a place for students to “learn about conservative ideas and how to advance them in the face of liberal hostility.”

Texas Southern U. Cuts 178 Jobs to Avert a Big Budget Gap

The Chronicle: Texas Southern U. Cuts 178 Jobs to Avert a Big Budget Gap

Texas Southern University has eliminated 178 jobs in an effort to forestall a projected multimillion-dollar budget deficit. Sixty-seven nontenured faculty members are among those dismissed.

Election law and Michael Moore

The Chronicle:

The Federal Election Commission has dismissed two complaints filed against a handful of colleges that accused them of violating a ban on corporate donations to political campaigns by paying a speaker’s fee to partisan filmmaker Michael Moore in 2004.

State $till Failing CUNY

New York Post: State $till Failing CUNY

City University, once free to generations of New Yorkers, now relies more on tuition fees than on state aid to operate its 11 senior and six community colleges, according to a new study.
The study, released yesterday by the city’s Independent Budget Office, confirms what CUNY officials have said for years – that a decline in state support has hampered the university’s ability to expand.