Dispersed, separate, and unequal (still)

In her article for The Village Voice, Anya Kamenetz describes the “Dispersed and unequal”
circumstances that displaced New Orleans students are experiencing in the Baton Rouge, LA schools. Baton Rouge is the site of one of the longest running school desegregation cases in the US.

The experiences of the students sent to Baton Rouge are a test case of [Jonathan] Kozol’s contention that racial segregation, exacerbated by testing, is the central problem in our public school system. Overt racism does not seem at work; the African-American East Baton Rouge superintendent, Charlotte Placide, is making the direct decisions about the treatment of these students, and Ms. Sherry Brock, Ms. Clara Joseph, and their respective staffs are each obviously working as hard as is humanly possible to teach their students with the tools at their disposal. Yet it is very easy to see how the continued structure of segregation is hurting the chances that something good can come from this disaster, for those who most need a second chance.

Kozol has just published a new book, The Shame of the Nation: The Restoration of Apartheid Schooling in America, which he called in a recent Salon interview “the angriest book I’ve written in my life.” He finds that Brown v. Board of Education has failed; schools are now just as segregated as they were in 1968, and black and Latino schools are still dramatically inferior and underfunded, receiving a national average of $1,000 less per student each year. [Kozol’s article “Still Separate, Still Unequal: America’s Educational Apartheid” was published in Harper’s Magazine last month.]

Kozol’s findings are support by the research of the Harvard Civil Rights Project, which published a report in 2003 titled “A Multiracial Society with Segregated Schools: Are We Losing the Dream?”.

Key finds from the Harvard Civil Rights Project Study include:

    The statistics from the 2000-2001 school year show that whites are the most segregated group in the nation’s public schools; they attend schools, on average, where eighty percent of the student body is white. The two regions where white students are more likely to attend substantially interracial schools are the South and West. Whites attending private schools are even more segregated than their public school counterparts.
    Our schools are becoming steadily more nonwhite, as the minority student enrollment approaches 40% of all U.S. public school students, nearly twice the share of minority school students during the 1960s. In the West and the South, almost half of all public school students are nonwhite.
    The most dramatic growth is seen in the increase of Latino and Asian students. Latino students are the most segregated minority group, with steadily rising segregation since federal data were first collected a third of a century ago. Latinos are segregated both by race and poverty, and a pattern of linguistic segregation is also developing. Latinos have by far the highest high school dropout rates.
    Conversely, at the aggregate level, Asians live in the nation’s most integrated communities, are the most integrated in schools and experience less linguistic segregation than Latinos.1 Asians are the nation’s most highly educated racial group; the rate of college graduation for Asians is almost double the national average and four times larger than Latinos.
    The data show the emergence of a substantial group of American schools that are virtually all non-white, which we call apartheid schools. These schools educate one-sixth of the nation’s black students and one-fourth of black students in the Northeast and Midwest. These are often schools where enormous poverty, limited resources, and social and health problems of many types are concentrated. One ninth of Latino students attend schools where 99-100% of the student body is composed of minority students.
    Paralleling housing patterns from the 2000 Census, this study shows a very rapid increase in the number of multiracial schools where at least one tenth of the students are from three different racial groups. Three-fourths of Asian students attend multiracial schools, but only 14% of white students do.
    The nation’s largest city school systems account for a shrinking share of the total enrollment and are, almost without exception, overwhelmingly nonwhite and increasingly segregated internally. These twenty-seven largest urban systems have lost the vast majority of their white enrollment whether or not they ever had significant desegregation plans, and today serve almost one-quarter of our black and Latino student population.
    The balkanization of school districts and the difficulty of creating desegregated schools within these cities show the huge consequences of the Supreme Court’s 1974 Milliken v. Bradley decision2 blocking city-suburban desegregation in metropolitan Detroit. According to one recent study, metropolitan Detroit schools were extremely segregated in 1994 and had the highest level of between-district segregation of all metro areas in the country.
    In 1967 the nation’s largest suburban systems were virtually all white. Despite a huge increase in minority students in suburban school districts, serious patterns of segregation have emerged in some sectors of suburbia as this transition takes place. Many of the most rapidly resegregating school systems since the mid-1980s are suburban. Clearly segregation and desegregation are no longer merely urban concerns, but wider metropolitan issues.
    The largest countywide school districts that contain both city and suburban schools are mostly concentrated in Southern states. These districts, with about half the enrollment of the big cities, had far more extensive and long-lasting desegregation and far more opportunity for minority students to cross both race and class barriers for their education.
    Many of the nation’s most successful plans are being dismantled by federal court decisions as the courts have been changed from being on the leading edge of desegregation activity to being its greatest obstacle. Since the Supreme Court changed desegregation law in three major decisions between 1991 and 19954, the momentum of desegregation for Black students has clearly reversed in the South, where the movement had by far its greatest success.
    During the 1990s, the proportion of black students in majority white schools has decreased by 13 percentage points, to a level lower than any year since 1968.

In his book, Kozol also argues that the inflexible testing requirements imposed by No Child Left Behind create a sense of “siege” in the poorest schools, punishing them by withholding funds and forcing teachers to teach by rote and to the test.

GAO: Bush’s Department of Ed broke law with covert propaganda

Bush administration/No Child Left Behind shill Armstrong Williams is back in the news as the US Government Accountability Office ruled on Friday that the secret payment of $240,000 he received from the US Department of Education from writing postive articles about NCLB constituted illegal covert propapanda.

The New York Timessaid the report “provided the first definitive ruling on the legality of the activities….In a blistering report, the investigators, from the Government Accountability Office, said the administration had disseminated ‘covert propaganda’ in the United States, in violation of a statutory ban.”

The US Education Department has defended its payments to Williams, saying his commentaries were “no more than the legitimate dissemination of information to the public.”

Editory & Publisher says “the GAO’s report also uncovered a previously undisclosed case in which the Education Department had commissioned a newspaper article. The article, on the “declining science literacy of students,” was distributed by the North American Precis Syndicate and appeared in numerous small newspapers around the country, according to the report in the Times. The government’s role in the writing of the article, which praised the department’s role in promoting science education, was never disclosed.”

END THE WAR! BRING THE TROOPS HOME NOW!

Here are photos from the anti-war demo this past Saturday (Sept 24) in San Diego, which was part of a US-wide anti-war protest, that drew a somewhere between 100,000 and 300,000 people in Washington, DC.

Polls continue to show that the majority of the U.S public is against the war in Iraq and want an immediate withdrawal of U.S troops. After Hurricane Katrina hit, support for Bush’s policies in Iraq dropped even more.

A recent CNN/USA Today/Gallup poll showed that two-thirds of Americans believe Bush is spending too much money in Iraq and 42 percent favor cutting spending on the war to pay for relief efforts in the devastated Gulf Coast region. Nearly 70% of Americans disapprove of how George W. Bush is handling the situation in Iraq; 60% now say it was a mistake to send US troops to Iraq; and over 60% support troop withdrawals.

The San Diego demo was held in Balboa Park and included some spirited singing, representatives/speeches from folks from a wide variety of political, religious, educational, community activist, and human rights organizations.

Over 2000 people (including babies and puppets, but not the cops)—and not a few sign toting dogs—came out for a vigorous protest against the oil war in Iraq and US foreign policies that continue to criminalize poor people along the southern US border who come to the US looking for work. The Rouge Forum had a small delegation there leafleting the crowd.

Photos from the September 24th demo in Washington, DC.

Former Education Secretary Bennett: Abort black babies to reduce crime

Well so much for civil society. Seems the new approach of Republicans in the US is to flaunt their racist beliefs.

story.bennett.jpg

Bill Bennett—a former US education secretary and national drug czar and fulltime right-wing moral crusader who has made millions of dollars from his Book of Virtues and lecturing people on morality, while blowing $8 million in high-stakes gambling—claimed that the crime rate in the USA could be reduced by aborting every black pregnancy in the country.

Bennett made the statement on his morning, drivetime radio talk show, carried on 115 stations across the US on the right-wing Salem Radio Network.

Addressing a caller’s absurd suggestion that lost revenue from aborted pregnancies over the last 30 years would be enough to preserve Social Security, Bennett said:

“If you wanted to reduce crime, if that were your sole purpose, you could abort every black baby in this country, and your crime rate would go down.”

Bennett was discussing the decline in the crime rate—apparently inspired by “the claim that legalized abortion has reduced crime rates, which was posited in the book Freakonomics (William Morrow, May 2005) by Steven D. Levitt and Stephen J. Dubner.” (Media Matters)

Listen the clip from Bennett’s radio show here.

In CNN’s coverage of this story Bennett defends his racist remarks.

Judge grants class action status for black students who say “achievement gap” is fault of schools

The St. Petersburg Times reports that a three-judge appeals panel has bolstered black students’ lawsuit that alleges they are not being properly educated.

The decision sets the stage for what will likely be one of the most important lawsuits in US education in recent years.

The big question is whether schools alone can be held accountable for inequities in achievement and disciplinary actions experienced by black students.

The strategy of the Pinellas County School District will be to argue that differences in achievement are an individual student matter— that some black students do well while others don’t and that the factors behind their performance vary.

At it’s heart, this strategy is a based on a deficit model of learning and works to protect the status quo in terms pedagogy, curriculum, and school organization. The fundamental idea is that students must adapt to schools, rather than schools taking responsibility for meeting the needs of students.

Another key issue will be how the so-called “achievement gap” is defined. For all intents and purposes the current discourse on achievement is narrowly focused on test scores. That is, as a result of NCLB, schools operate with a truncated definition of achievement success that deflects attention away from issues such as the limitations of instruments used to measure achievement; the narrowed curriculum (which is often racist and classist); and how the accepted educational practices, such as the use of high-stakes tests, leads to the under-serving and mis-serving of all students.

For more on the harmful effects of high-stakes tests see the American Evaluation Association’s Position Statement on High-Stakes Testing in K-12 Education

British Columbia: Teachers poised to strike

The British Columbia Teachers Federation—armed with an overwhelming mandate from its 42,000 members—announced plans last week for escalating job actions, culminating in an full-scale walk out by October 24.

Starting today (Sept 28) teachers will begin a modest job action aimed at inconveniencing administrators, by refusing to supervise students outside of class, except voluntary extra-curriculars, attend management meetings or complete report cards.

If there is no progress in contract talks by October 11, the teachers union will launch rotating strikes around the province, which will be followed by a full strike on October 24.

Because the Liberal government of BC has declared education an essential service, the BC Labour Relations Board will rule on what level of teaching would have to be maintained during a strike. The BCTF has not indicated if it will or will not abide by the rulings made the Labour Board.

Below are links to a number of articles from the national and local press, was well as the BCTF regarding the job actions/strikes:

The Province: Teachers take action today (Sept 28)

Why teachers are primed to strike (Sept 28)

BCTF: Teachers take a stand to restore services (Sept 28)

BCTF: BC Premier Gordon Campbell blames schools boards (Sept 28)

BCTF: A message to parents from your children’s teachers

Video message from BCTF president Jinny Sims (Sept 27)

Vancouver Sun: BCTF needs a lesson in marketplace competition (Sept 27)

Globe and Mail: B.C. teachers poised to strike (Sept 24)

Teachers vote 88.4% for strike (Sept 24)Teachers take action today
They refuse to supervise kids, write reports

Elaine O’Connor, with a file by Ian Bailey
The Province

Wednesday, September 28, 2005

B.C. teachers begin job action today by withdrawing administrative and supervisory duties.

It’s not supposed to impact students, but that’s not the case in some districts.

In districts with adequate non-union and board staff, schools are calling on principals, vice-principals and district staff to supervise students before and after school, and during recess and lunch.

But smaller districts are already overhauling their school day due to job action. Students in Fort Nelson schools, for example, will see recess eliminated, lunch hour shortened and the school day cut because the district doesn’t have the extra staff to take on supervisory duties.

“We’re a small district,” said Diana Samchuck, superintendent for the five-school, 1,177-student district.

“The fear is someone will be out on duty who is not used to doing student supervision and they’ll be thinking of their primary job task and not see something and we’ll have an accident on our hands.”

In Kelowna, the district has cancelled recess, so all students will be dismissed 15 minutes early.

In the first stage of B.C.-wide job action, teachers are refusing to supervise students outside of class, except voluntary extra-curriculars, attend management meetings or complete report cards.

Vancouver’s University Hill principal Jill Philipchuck said she, her vice-principal, and a district staffer will watch the 525 students over lunch. But it’s staff relations, not extra work, that are her big concern.

“Because teachers are not attending meetings, it makes it difficult to work as a team and to work collaboratively,” she said. “We may need to make a lot more unilateral decisions.”

The B.C. Teachers Federation continues to talk with the employer. BCTF reps met with Associate Deputy Minister of Labour Rick Connolly again yesterday to try to find common ground.

But Premier Gordon Campbell hinted that legislating teachers back to work might be the only solution.

“Legislation is always an option, and unfortunately for us in British Columbia it’s always been required since province-wide bargaining was brought in. We were hopeful the BCTF, the union and the employers would be able to come to a resolution. So far they haven’t been able to,” Campbell told The Province.

B.C. Confederation of Parent Advisory Councils past-president Terry Watson said parents are nervous.

“The first round includes items not supposed to affect students in classrooms, but they do affect who is supervising the kids. That’s a change parents are anxious about.”

Surrey’s Christina Woodworth has a six-year-old at James Ardiel Elementary and a 12-year-old at Como Lake Middle School in Coquitlam. She’s frustrated by the lack of information about school plans and concerned about interim supervision.

“You’ve got 300 kids on a school ground. They may not be able to recognize the different dangers that are out there,” she said.

eoconnor@png.canwest.com
=============================================================
From TheTyee.ca
Why Teachers Are Primed to Strike

Link Address: http://www.thetyee.ca/Views/2005/09/26/Teachersstrike
Published: 2005-09-26 23:00:00
By John Malcolmson

TheTyee.ca

Campbell government’s freeze strategy ignores widening salary gap.

BC teachers have conducted a province-wide strike vote and given their leaders a mandate to initiate job action. Planned strike action is aimed at pressuring the employer and the government to negotiate a new collective agreement. Teachers have worked without a contract since the last one expired in June of 2004.

Labour disputes tend to be messy situations. In the course of collective bargaining and the run-up to a strike situation, many issues get thrown into the mix. Within the current context, however, two “big picture” issues come to the fore.

Big issue #1: Salaries

First is the question of salary. Teachers expect to receive a “reasonable” increase in the new agreement. The employer, backed by government, is determined to hold the line on any hike for teachers. This would freeze teachers’ salaries for all of this past year and at least an additional year.

It is useful to look at the salary increase issue in the context of recent negotiation experiences and outcomes. The last collective agreement ran three years before ending in June of 2004. BC’s newly-elected liberal government imposed that agreement after contract negotiations became deadlocked. In it, teachers got 2.5 percent increases in each of three years. Consumer prices in Vancouver and BC rose at virtually the same rate over that period so real salary levels stayed near-constant.

If one goes back farther in time, a different picture emerges. A Category 5 Vancouver teacher earning the maximum salary saw her earnings grow just under 10 percent between June of 1998 and June of 2004. Prices over that period increased at a faster rate and have climbed another 1.5 percent in the past school year. What this means is that earnings lag inflation by about four percent over the last seven years. This is a significant but not enormous drop. However, what galls teachers is the fact that a salary freeze would be imposed at a time when economic growth, rising energy prices and increased federal transfers have pushed BC’s public accounts far into the black. And current forecasts have the province’s finances staying out of deficit territory over the full term of a new collective agreement.

So, if government can afford to reduce corporate taxes and put more cash in the pockets of big business, why is it loathe to pay teachers a “reasonable” salary increase? If it can put more money into roads, buildings and infrastructure, why not into supporting those who makes our public services work?

An aging teacher staff

These questions acquire a different urgency when looked at in light of the ongoing ageing of BC’s teacher population. At the start of 2003/04, almost two-thirds of our teachers were over age 45 and a full 43 percent of BC teachers were aged 50 plus. The latter group is within five years of possible retirement. Given recent layoffs of younger teachers having less seniority, that percentage is almost surely higher today.

BC’s post-secondary system does not graduate anywhere near the volume of education students to offset this impending attrition. Years of compressed funding at colleges and universities have left these institutions ill-prepared to meet the challenge of supplying enough teacher replacements to address staffing needs for the near-future.

The advancing retirement bulge means that we will have to attract and retain new BC grads here as well as compete nationally and beyond for more bodies if we are to replenish teachers’ ranks. Historically, this has been the approach BC has taken to address this need. A sizeable chunk of BC’s teachers were educated elsewhere in Canada and many internationally. They migrated here to start or continue their teaching careers.

This “strategy” may have worked in the past. However, today’s teachers are aging everywhere in Canada. School authorities and provincial ministries across the country all face a need to replace the high volume of educators expected to exit the system in the coming decade. It is a classic situation where demand will increase at a rate outstripping available supply. The winners in this kind of market scenario will be those offering, guess what — superior salaries, good pensions (which are tied to salaries) and decent career working conditions.

It is for reasons like this that the BCTF is working to focus attention on the yawning teacher salary gap between cities like Vancouver and urban centers in provinces like Alberta and Ontario. A just-published report by staff researcher Colleen Hawkey and titled “Inter-city Teacher Salary Comparisons, 2005-07” provides some startling comparisons with what teachers earn in other parts of the country.

For example, a new Category 5 teacher in Vancouver this September actually earns $329 more than her counterpart in Toronto, but after 10 years on the job, will trail the annual Toronto salary by almost $10,000. The same Vancouver teacher lags her starting colleague in Edmonton by more than $5,600, a gap which doubles in size over the next decade of movement up the experience grid.

These gaps are calculated for the current year only. They will grow in size if a salary freeze is imposed in BC. This is because teachers’ salaries are not frozen in these other jurisdictions.

If a new Alberta teacher can earn thousands more starting out in Edmonton, why make the trek to BC? Or, if a young teacher is struggling to pay the bills here in this province, why wouldn’t she take a long and hard look at a Toronto or Ottawa career that promises $300,000 more in lifetime earnings and a better pension to boot? There are surely good reasons these folks might come to or remain in BC, but we would do well remembering that nice scenery and Lotusland winters will only go so far.

Big Issue #2: Working and learning conditions

The second “big picture” issue referenced at the start concerns working conditions. In crucial respects, this is the real story of the current contract stand-off. BC has seen a wholesale deterioration in school working conditions since the last imposed settlement stripped out class size and staffing provisions.

In the past four years, salary and other cost increases have forced our school system to cannibalize itself. Since negotiating working conditions was made ultra vires and in the face of ongoing budget restrictions, class sizes have increased and thousands of teachers have been let go. Schools have become more difficult places to work and, for students, more difficult places to get an education.

This year, the province pumped an additional $150 million into school operating budgets. Judging from its strategy at the bargaining table, the Ministries of Finance, Education and Treasury Board are eager not to let much of this increase find its way into the pockets of teachers or other staff.

Back to freeze mode

School budgets are projected to re-enter freeze mode next year and remain there into 2007/08. This much was re-affirmed last week in Carole Taylor’s budget. Her speech to the legislature mentioned the word “education” only once, in the context of plans to build new relationships with First Nations.

Accompanying budget documents confirm that last spring’s forecast of a two-year school funding freeze remains the Liberal party line.

What better way to lock the freeze down than to put the clamps on a teacher salary bill which currently accounts for more than a half of all public school spending? And what better tool to free up money for other priorities, including corporate tax cuts, than to engineer a multi-year respite from rising cost pressure on the school salary front? Many parents and other members of the public may not relish the prospect of a school shutdown this fall. However, we would all do well to remember that, as messy as labour negotiations are, they provide a vital forum for raising and resolving issues necessary for our schools to adapt for the future. By short-circuiting this process, a legislated settlement blocks such adaptation. Given the issues at stake, we will all lose with that outcome.

John Malcolmson is a consulting sociologist doing research and evaluation in the fields of public education and education finance, literacy, labour relations, justice issues and social policy. He publishes the digital newsletter Finance Watch, where a version of this appeared. To subscribe, email financewatch@shaw.ca
=============================================================
Wednesday » September 28 » 2005

BCTF needs a lesson in marketplace competition

Michael Campbell
Vancouver Sun

Tuesday, September 27, 2005

You know things are a bit whacky in the ongoing teachers’ labour dispute when the lawyer for the BCTF argues in front of the Labour Relations Board that there is no evidence to suggest that lengthy disruptions or lockouts do long-term damage to education. Lawyer Diane MacDonald is quoted as telling the B.C. Labour Relations Board: “We have had job actions in the past that have been up to three months’ duration without significant impact on the student body.”

Given that my wife and many dear friends are teachers, I think it’s a safe bet to say that if I argued the same thing at home I’d get into a little hot water. Can you imagine how popular I’d be if I said to my wife: ‘Why don’t you phone in sick for a couple of weeks. After all, it won’t make any difference to the kids’ education.’ Not to get into too many personal details, but the response wouldn’t be pretty.

We find ourselves in this bizarre world where a BCTF lawyer is arguing that the federation’s own members aren’t necessary for significant periods of time when it comes to students’ education, while the Ministry of Education argues that they are. Talk about role reversal.

Given that this is the calibre of discussion, maybe I shouldn’t be surprised when I hear the BCTF argue that teachers’ wages must be competitive with Alberta. Even if the BCTF’s demand for a salary increase of 15 per cent over three years is accepted, it will put teachers with 12 years experience earning $73,298, which is about $4,700 less than their counterparts in Edmonton.

I appreciate that salaries do not make up the entire teacher compensation package — which also includes sick days, other forms of paid leave, employer pension contributions, paid vacation, dental and medical benefits. But the point is that, in this one area, the BCTF believes that being competitive is important. As BCTF head Jinny Sims says: “We certainly hope that the employer will consider the need to offer competitive salaries to attract bright graduates and to keep experienced classroom teachers in B.C.”

The B.C. Business Council couldn’t have said it better. The difference is that, for the BCTF, the importance of being competitive with other jurisdictions stops with teachers’ salaries, and certainly doesn’t extend to issues like tax rates, especially for business.

And this brain cramp is not unique to the BCTF. It seems to be a regular feature in the world view of many major unions.

Canada’s largest private-sector union, the Canadian Auto Workers, argues that special tax breaks in the form of subsidies are needed for big U.S. auto manufacturers in order to encourage investment in Canadian plants. Yet they strongly oppose corporate tax reductions in other sectors. We also have the NDP opposed to lowering business taxes, yet supporting special tax breaks for major American and Canadian film companies. Organized labour supports special tax breaks for labour-sponsored mutual funds, while opposing business tax reductions in other areas.

The intellectual inconsistency is breathtaking. The appreciation for the need to be competitive in terms of wages, tax rates and regulatory environment should not be confined to few self-serving areas. All Canadians will benefit when a broader policy approach toward competitiveness is adopted that extends past the concerns of a few special interests in business or labour.

Michael Campbell’s Money Talks radio show can be heard on CKNW 980 on Saturdays from 8:30 a.m. to 10 a.m.

© The Vancouver Sun 2005

Copyright © 2005 CanWest Interactive, a division of CanWest Global Communications Corp. All rights reserved.

=============================================================
B.C. teachers poised to strike
Union announces escalating job action; province vows to prevent class disruptions
By ROD MICKLEBURGH
Saturday, September 24, 2005 Page S1

VANCOUVER — Armed with an overwhelming strike mandate, the B.C. Teachers’ Federation unveiled plans yesterday for escalating job action by the province’s 42,000 public school teachers, culminating in an all-out walkout by Oct. 24.

The Liberal government immediately vowed to prevent any disruption of school classrooms, setting the stage for yet another bitter showdown between the long-standing adversaries.

The wide gulf between the two sides was underscored later in the day when, for the first time in the long dispute, the BCTF disclosed its salary demands.

The union is seeking annual wage increases of 4, 5 and 6 per cent over three years, a direct challenge to the government’s two-year, mandated wage freeze for all public-sector employees.

“Teachers need and deserve a reasonable salary increase,” said a BCTF bargaining bulletin, arguing that pay hikes are justified by cost-of-living increases and a widening wage gap between B.C. teachers and their counterparts in Alberta and Ontario.

Further inflaming the pending confrontation is the teachers’ determination to roll back Liberal legislation banning them from negotiating class sizes. The union won that right from the previous NDP government in return for giving up a wage increase.

Education Minister Shirley Bond said the government is committed to keep the schools running, despite the strike plans.

“Education is absolutely essential . . . and we will consider all of our options to make sure that students stay in the classroom,” Ms. Bond declared yesterday, less than an hour after BCTF president Jinny Sims announced the union’s vote and strike strategy.

She charged that the teachers union has stalled attempts to negotiate a new collective agreement so it can be in a position to strike this fall.

“I am continually disappointed by the practices that are being engaged in by the teachers,” said Ms. Bond, noting that a government-appointed fact-finder is meeting with union and school trustee negotiators.

The teachers’ strike vote was 88.4-per-cent in favour, with about 80 per cent of the union membership taking part.

“This is a historic day for teachers,” Ms. Sims said.

“We have voted yes to restore student learning conditions to where they were in 2002.

“Since then, they have deteriorated incredibly, and our bargaining rights were legislated away. . . .We know that students have always benefited when teachers take a stand.”

Starting Tuesday, teachers intend to begin modest job action aimed at inconveniencing administrators.

That would include refusing mandated supervision outside regular classroom hours and not submitting student attendance information.

If there is no progress by Oct. 11, the teachers union will launch rotating strikes around the province, followed by a full strike on Oct. 24.

Complicating the situation, however, is how far the teachers can legally withdraw their services.

Education is included under the province’s essential services legislation, so it is up to the B.C. Labour Relations Board to rule on what level of teaching would have to be maintained during a strike.

Ms. Sims was coy on whether the union would comply with LRB restrictions.

“The membership will make that decision,” she said. “The labour board has not yet made any rulings. This is our action plan and we will proceed accordingly.”

Also at the teachers news conference was Leann Buteau, a Vancouver high-school teacher working with special-needs students and the mother of a young daughter with learning disabilities.

Ms. Buteau said she voted to back strike action to improve conditions for students with learning problems. She said her high school has 50 students with difficulties, but funds for only five psycho-educational assessments a year.

Hugh Finlayson, CEO of the B.C. Public School Employers Association, said government intervention may be the only way to solve the bargaining impasse with the BCTF.

“If a dispute is intractable, if mediation doesn’t work, then you have to take action. As it sits right now, this is an intractable dispute.”
============================================================
Teachers vote 88.4% for strike
Parents brace for escalating measures

Janet Steffenhagen; With a file from Jennifer Chen
Vancouver Sun

Saturday, September 24, 2005

Teachers are seeking a 15-per-cent wage increase over three years and will begin job action in public schools next week that will affect administrators but not students, the B.C. Teachers’ Federation announced Friday.

But that limited action will escalate to rotating strikes starting Oct. 11 and a full-scale, province-wide walkout Oct. 24 if there is not significant progress at the bargaining table in the meantime, BCTF president Jinny Sims told a news conference.

She wouldn’t say where the rotating strikes would begin but promised to give parents 72-hours notice.

“It’s a historic day for teachers in British Columbia,” Sims said, noting that 80 per cent of the union’s 42,000 members participated in a strike vote this week and 88 per cent them — 27,990 — were in favour of job action. “I am proud of our members today — of their courage and their commitment.”

The BCTF said in a news release that it is seeking wage increases of four per cent in 2004 (its last contract expired in June of that year), five per cent in 2005 and six per cent in 2006.

The government has declared that teachers, like other public servants, will get nothing in 2004 or 2005.

Sims said that during the first phase of teachers’ job action, classroom instruction will continue but teachers won’t supervise students outside of class, attend meetings with management, send attendance reports to the office or communicate with principals and vice-principals. Extra-curricular activities will not be affected, Sims said.

The union originally announced that phase one job action would start Tuesday. But it took the plan to the B.C. Labour Relations Board for approval Friday night, and it was not clear when the board would grant approval, possibly delaying the start of job action until Wednesday

Education Minister Shirley Bond, responding to the union’s announcement, said her government intends to keep students in class, but she would not say whether that means there will be a back-to-work order.

“I remain committed, as does this government, to saying education is absolutely essential . . . and we’re going to make sure that students stay in classrooms.”

Sims said teachers have three goals in negotiations: the restoration of learning conditions that were in place in 2002, a “reasonable” wage increase and the return of full bargaining rights, which were curtailed in 2001 when the Liberals passed a law declaring education an essential service.

That law prohibits a withdrawal of services that would seriously disrupt the education program. The Labour Relations Board has been holding hearings — which are expected to resume Monday — to determine what level of job action is permitted before instructional services is seriously disrupted.

Sims hotly rejected a suggestion from the B.C. Public School Employers’ Association, which bargains for the province’s 60 school boards, that union requests for contract improvements and a pay hike would boost education spending by 35 per cent a year.

“That’s a totally bogus figure,” she said. “It’s a fabrication.”

The 35 per cent figure cited by the employer includes not only the three-year, 15-per-cent wage increase put forward by teachers, but also other proposals currently on the negotiation table, such as an early retirement incentive package.

Sims said earlier that an improvement in classroom conditions is the top priority, with 98 per cent of respondents to a recent union survey indicating they want learning conditions enshrined in their contract as they were in early 2002. That included class-size limits, restrictions on the number of special-needs students in any one class and a requirement that schools have a certain number of specialty teachers — such as librarians, counsellors and ESL teachers — based on student numbers.

Leann Buteau, a teacher at Gladstone secondary in Vancouver, said she voted for a strike after seeing 38 students in a History 12 class, including six with severe learning disabilities. The class has desks for 26 students and textbooks for 24. As well, there are 50 students waiting for psycho-education assessments, but only five can be assessed each year, she said.

“It was time for me to stand up and speak out for all of our students’ learning conditions. That’s why I voted yes.”

Although teachers are ready to strike, Sims said they are also prepared to bargain at any time. She described the appointment of deputy labour minister Rick Connolly as a fact-finder as “a ray of hope.” He has been asked to meet the parties, determine if a negotiated settlement is possible and report to government by Sept. 30.

Bond said she was disappointed the union did not wait for Connolly to finish his work or the labour relations board to issue its ruling on essential services before announcing strike plans.

Many parents picking up their children at Lord Roberts elementary Friday supported the teachers’ proposed strike.

The teachers’ call for higher salaries and improved conditions in schools seems fair, said Zoran Jermilov, standing with his 10-year-old daughter and six-year-old son. “For example, this school has only one telephone for the whole school,” he said.

jsteffenhagen@png.canwest.com

ACTION PLAN

If there is no major progress in bargaining, BCTF president Jinny Sims, pictured above, promised these measures Friday:

FROM This Tuesday No out-of-class student supervision. No meetings with management. No attendance reports. No communication with principals.

Tuesday Oct. 11 Rotating strikes

Monday Oct. 24 Full-scale, province-wide walkout.

WHAT IT WOULD COST

According to figures provided by the B.C. Public School Employers’ Association, the total salary paid out to the province’s 33,314 full-time and part-time teachers in 2004/05 equaled $1.977 billion.

p A four per cent increase to that total would add $79 million, bringing the teacher’s payroll to $2.056 billion in the first year of the contract.

p A five per cent increase would cost a further $103 million, for a total payroll of $2.158 billion in the second year of the contract.

p A six per cent increase would cost a further $130 million, for a total payroll of $2.288 billion in the third year of the contract.

Ran with fact box “Action Plan” and “What It Would Cost”,which has been appended to the end of the story. Also See:Editorial, Letters, C6

© The Vancouver Sun 2005

Changing bad education policy

The Forum for Education and Democracy has a nice article by Ann Cook and Phyllis Tashlik summarizing how parents, students, and educators in New York State battled and won a victory against perhaps the most committed proponent of test-driven education in the US, New York State Education commissioner Rick Mills.

While the outcome in NYS was limited to students in publicly supported alternative schools, this is a story of how organizing and political pressure can work to change bad education policies, which should give hope to others, like the folks in California who were rallying against high school exit exams over this past weekend.

Pennsylvania: Evolution lawsuit

http://insidehighered.com/news/2005/10/07/id

http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/education/2002522889_evolution27.html

http://www.latimes.com/news/education/la-na-dover26sep26,1,4383005.story?coll=la-news-learning

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/pp/05275/581245.stm

http://www.philly.com/mld/inquirer/living/education/12797106.htm

http://www.philly.com/mld/inquirer/living/education/12793013.htm
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/ArticleNews/TPStory/LAC/20051001/INTELLIGENT01/TPEducation/

Does God wear a lab coat?
The latest round in the culture wars pits Christians advocating ‘intelligent design’ against secular parents who want kids taught evolution only. Is there a middle ground? SHAWN McCARTHY surveys the view from Harrisburg, Pa.
By SHAWN MCCARTHY
Saturday, October 1, 2005 Page F3

Brown University professor Kenneth Miller proclaimed from the witness stand this week that he is a Christian Darwinist — a position that would be considered oxymoronic by more extreme partisans in the acrimonious debate over the teaching of biology in the United States.

Mr. Miller was the first witness in the case of Kitzmiller v. the Dover District School Board in Pennsylvania, the latest U.S. legal battle pitting Christian opponents of evolutionary theory against advocates of separation of church and state.

Eleven parents are suing the Dover school board for introducing the concept of “intelligent design” — which holds that the world was created by an “intelligent designer” who set evolution in motion — into biology class. The parents argue that intelligent design is a thinly disguised version of creationist theology and, as such, does not belong in a public-school science class.

But the Kitzmiller case is not just a scene from the current culture wars, sparked by the rising aggressiveness of U.S. fundamentalist Christians. It is a 21st-century instalment of the centuries-old contest between religion and science, a conflict that most famously led to the trial of Galileo Galilei by the 17th-century Inquisition.

Prominent scientists have often dismissed traditional religion as mere mythology and superstition, just as Christian leaders have denounced evolutionary biology as godless and evil.

On the stand this week, Mr. Miller sought to bridge those two solitudes, arguing that society should render unto science that which is scientific — and leave matters of faith to religion.

A Roman Catholic who co-wrote the leading biology textbook in the United States, Mr. Miller insisted there was no conflict between faith and science. “I believe not only are they compatible, but they are complementary,” he said.

He is a fervent opponent of the intelligent-design movement, the latest salvo in Christianity’s 146-year-old war on Charles Darwin’s theory that all species evolved from a single life form over billions of years through a process of natural selection.

He testified that the movement’s reliance on a supernatural designer is unscientific. But he criticized prominent Darwinists who fail to distinguish between scientific theory and philosophical speculation when they assert that the theory of evolution reveals a godless universe that is unfolding in a random manner.

“I believe God is the author of all things, seen and unseen, and that would include the laws of physics and chemistry,” he told the Federal Court.

But where Mr. Miller sees an unseen planner, other scientists perceive no plan at all, other than nature’s laws. Since it was first advanced in the mid-19th century, Darwinism has been extended beyond the realm of natural science and — through Social Darwinism — become associated with a mechanistic world view that sees man bound by laws of natural selection and survival of the fittest.

Richard Dawkins, the Oxford University zoologist and prominent evolutionary theorist, summed up this worldview in his 1986 classic, The Blind Watchmaker: Why the Evidence of Evolution Reveals a Universe without Design: “The universe we observe has precisely the properties we should expect if there is at bottom, no design, no purpose, no evil and no good, nothing but blind, pitiless indifference.”

Mr. Dawkins dismissed religion as “the big lie.”

Theistic scientists argue that thinkers like Mr. Dawkins have poisoned the well of public discourse by creating the impression among lay people that the evolutionary theory necessarily entails atheism. And in a country like the United States, where 78 per cent of poll respondents identify themselves as believers, such a perception is bound to cause problems.

“In the context of the war between evolution and creationism in the United States, the problem is perhaps less with believers who read the Bible as a literal account of creation, and more with believers who read Richard Dawkins as a literal account of evolution,” said William Grassie, executive director of the Metanexus Institute, a Philadelphia-based think-tank dedicated to bridging the worlds of religion and science.

Mr. Dawkins took his ironic title, The Blind Watchmaker, from an early version of intelligent-design theory espoused in 1802 by English cleric William Paley, who argued that, much as a watch suggests the existence of a watchmaker, the evidence of complex design in the universe indicates the existence of a designer — that is, God.

Current proponents of intelligent-design theory resurrect Mr. Paley’s watchmaker analogy by arguing that evolution fails to account for exquisitely complex organisms in nature. That complexity, they argue, reveals the existence of a designer.

The movement to promote intellectual design has its genesis in the creationist battles that have been waged throughout the United States. In a 1987 ruling in Edwards v. Aguillard, the U.S. Supreme Court prohibited the teaching of creationism — a literal biblical account of man’s origins — on the grounds that it was a sectarian religious belief.

As a result, proponents have refined their approach to offer an alternative that does not directly mention God. Mainstream scientists have overwhelmingly rejected intelligent-design theory as unsupportable and untestable.

William Behe, a biologist at Lehigh University who will testify for the school board at the Kitzmiller trial, argues that throughout nature, scientists can see examples of organism that are “irreducibly complex” and could not have been the product of evolutionary processes alone.

But for every one of the examples Mr. Behe provides, Mr. Miller suggests evidence that they are not at all “irreducible” — but comprise constituent parts that had different functions before their appearance in particular organisms.

In the intelligent-design textbook, Of Pandas and People, which the Dover board purchased and recommended students read outside the classroom, authors Percival Davis and Dean H. Kenyon argue that evolution has failed to provide answers to key questions such as the beginning of life from an inanimate world, or the differentiation of species through a slow mutation process.

Robert Pennock a professor of philosophy, science and technology at Michigan State University, testified this week that scientists continue to work on the unanswered questions of evolutionary theory — but that those gaps do not imply a supernatural answer.

The intelligent-design movement, which is largely backed by fundamentalist Christians, appeared to receive some support this summer when a Roman Catholic cardinal wrote an opinion piece in The New York Times criticizing “neo-Darwinism.”

Cardinal Christoph Schonborn, Archbishop of Vienna and lead editor of the 1992 Catholic catechism, wrote that neo-Darwinism — described as “an unguided, unplanned process of random variation and natural selection” — is incompatible with church teaching.

Mr. Miller rebutted his coreligionist, saying he was mistaken to assert that modern Darwinism is inherently atheistic because it was guided by random variation and natural selection.

“Biological evolution fits neatly into a traditional Catholic understanding of how contingent natural processes can be seen as part of God’s plan,” Mr. Miller wrote in reply to Cardinal Schonborn, “while ‘evolutionist’ philosophies that deny the Divine do not.”

Shawn McCarthy is The Globe and Mail’s New York City bureau chief.

Analysis: ‘Intelligent design’ case to undergo 2-pronged test

Sunday, October 02, 2005

By Bill Toland, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

In the parlance of the sports world, defense attorneys in the federal “intelligent design” trial will have to come from behind when testimony resumes this week.

They’ll have a tough time overcoming the first week of testimony, in which plaintiffs and former board members from Dover Area School District said the school board was motivated by religion when it changed its biology curriculum last year.

The case pits the school district against 11 plaintiffs, who believe that intelligent design — a concept that says biological complexity presents evidence of a designer — is a Trojan horse that brings God into public schools.

First Amendment professors and constitutional law attorneys following the case seem to agree. After the trial’s first week, it appeared that certain board members were motivated by religion, and not an educational purpose, when they amended the curriculum to include intelligent design.

“I would certainly say that from what I have seen thus far, I find the evidence troubling,” said Valerie Munson, an Eckert Seamans attorney who specializes in church-state issues. “The school board’s policy will probably be found to have a religious purpose, and to advance religion, in violation of the First Amendment. In other words, it [will] fail both the purpose and the effects prongs of the constitutionality test.”

But she also adds that the trial, expected to last more than five weeks, is in its early stages, and the defense team, Thomas More Law Center of Michigan, has yet to offer any evidence. “Cases are never a slam dunk,” she said. “If they were a slam dunk, they would never be going to court.”

U.S. District Judge John E. Jones III is being asked to apply the two-pronged test to this case, in which the plaintiffs claim the Dover board violated the Constitution’s establishment clause.

The first test is the “effect” test — whether the theory itself, and its appearance in the ninth-grade biology curriculum, is religious in nature. In other words, to be legal, intelligent design must neither promote nor inhibit religion.

The second test can be called the “intent” test — even if the judge does not determine that intelligent design is an inherently religious concept, he may find that the school board had the purpose of promoting religion. In legalese, the school board must have a bona fide secular purpose in teaching intelligent design.

The plaintiffs’ attorneys, including the American Civil Liberties Union and Americans United for the Separation of Church and State, must win just one of these match-ups, not both. A third prong, the “entanglement” test, is not being applied.

As with the criminal court system, the burden of proof lies not with the defense, but the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs are striking blows on both sides — using expert witnesses to argue that intelligent design isn’t science and using witnesses to show that school board members wanted to bring God into the classroom.

The expert witnesses — two biology professors and a theologian — have testified to the “effect” side of things, arguing that intelligent design, because it infers a creator from biological evidence, is biblical creationism, updated with new scientific terminology.

But the fact witnesses, testifying to the “intent” test, have provided the most compelling evidence, said Eugene Voloch, First Amendment professor at UCLA. The courts, he said, have left the door open for “intelligent design” in a perfectly crafted test case, but this isn’t such a case.

The school board, based on what he’s read, was “animated by a desire to promote the biblical account” of creation. This week, plaintiffs testified that, over a two-year period, the school board intermittently discussed God, religion and creationism, before finally changing the biology curriculum in October 2004. Board meetings were like “old-time Christian tent revivals,” a former school director testified.

“It’s conceivable that if the court was looking only at the ‘effects’ test, the board might have a shot,” Voloch said.

Marc J. Randazza, an attorney with Florida-based Weston, Garrou, DeWitt & Walters, a First Amendment law firm, agreed with his colleagues.

“The first problem I see is testimony that clearly demonstrates that the majority’s motivation was to promote the Christian [theory] of creationism. Although there has been some attempt to characterize this as promoting intelligent design as a means of offering an alternative theory to Darwinism, I can’t see a shred of honesty in this characterization.”

He said the plaintiffs also win the “effect” challenge, but not as convincingly.

(Bill Toland can be reached at btoland@post-gazette.com or 1-412-263-1889.)

October 2, 2005
In Pennsylvania, It Was Religion vs. Science, Pastor vs. Ph.D., Evolution vs. the Half-Fish

By LAURIE GOODSTEIN
HARRISBURG, Pa., Sept. 30 – When Casey Brown testified this week, she embodied the pain and division the intelligent design controversy has wrought in Dover. Mrs. Brown sat stiffly on the witness stand, her mouth as tight as her gray ponytail, recounting how she had run for school board on the same ticket as the board members now facing her from the defense table.

The board is being sued by 11 parents who say that intelligent design is creationism cloaked as science, is inherently religious and has no place in a ninth-grade biology class.

Mrs. Brown said her political alliances and friendships had become strained in the last couple of years as some board members had pressed for changing the biology curriculum to teach creationism on par with evolution. They wanted to buy an intelligent design textbook, “Of Pandas and People,” in place of the newest edition of the standard biology text.

Under cross-examination by Patrick Gillen, a soft-spoken defense lawyer, Mrs. Brown was asked whether she recalled visiting the home of a board member and admiring a carving of the Last Supper.

“The Lord’s Last Supper, yes sir,” Mrs. Brown said. “I had never seen such a beautiful carving.”

But she said she did not feel comfortable when the board member asked her if she was a born-again Christian. She also said she felt disturbed when another board member, who was among those most insistent about teaching creationism, drove her home from a meeting and asked the same question.

Suddenly, his manner changing, Mr. Gillen pounced: these were Mrs. Brown’s friends, she was in their homes, in their cars, and she found it offensive to be asked about religion?

“Yes, I do, and I still do, sir,” she said.

A bite in his voice, Mr. Gillen asked if she thought religion should not be discussed at all.

“I wouldn’t presume to discuss religion within normal circumstances,” she said, “except within my own family.”

Mrs. Brown and her husband quit the board the night members voted 6 to 3 for intelligent design.

Worlds in Conflict

The trial presents a particular challenge for the journalists from science magazines. In the courtroom hallway during a break last week, Celeste Biever, a reporter for NewScientist, was interviewing a courtroom regular, a bearded local pastor who says he considers evolution a lie.

“You want half-bird, half-fish?” she asked, drawing a dotted line on her notepad.

“Yeah, why not,” the pastor said.

Later, out of the pastor’s hearing, Ms. Biever said with fascination, “He thinks evolution is a bird turning into a fish turning into a rabbit” – one straight line of common descent, instead of a tree with common roots.

Ms. Biever was finding that she could not cover the trial the way she would a classic courtroom face-off. When you put intelligent design up against evolution, she said, “It’s not a head-on collision between two scientific arguments; it’s orthogonal,” with the opponents coming at each other from right angles.

“It’s apples and oranges,” Ms. Biever said.

Her readers do not take intelligent design seriously, she said, so she was striving for “local color.” Her readers want to know, she said, “Why is this happening here?”

“We’re not just science cheerleaders, and I don’t want to overlook any valid argument for intelligent design,” Ms. Biever said. “As far as I’m concerned, I haven’t heard one yet.”

As for the pastor, after four days of listening to science experts dismantling the case for intelligent design, he was unimpressed.

“They’re babblers,” said the pastor, the Rev. Jim Grove, who leads a 40-member independent Baptist church outside of Dover. “The more Ph.D.’s you get, it seems like the further away from God you get.”

Dover school board members were well aware they were inviting a lawsuit over church-state issues when they voted last October that biology students should hear a statement telling them that there were gaps in the theory of evolution and that intelligent design was another theory the students should examine.

But the board forged ahead, having been assured that they would have the backing of the Thomas More Law Center, a nonprofit law firm dedicated to providing legal representation to Christians, and its chief counsel, Richard Thompson.

One Side of the Culture War

In courtroom breaks Mr. Thompson occasionally sits next to board members and puts an arm around their shoulders. White-haired and dapper, he has said little in court, leaving most of the cross-examination to his two co-counselors.

But this week, he became the public face of the intelligent design movement, stepping into the ring of cameras and microphones outside the courthouse each afternoon, taking every question until, one after another, the reporters slipped away.

As a former Michigan prosecutor who tried repeatedly to convict Dr. Jack Kevorkian, Mr. Thompson is comfortable in the spotlight. He failed in his prosecution of Dr. Kevorkian and eventually lost a bid for re-election; voters told pollsters they did not share his outrage over assisted suicide.

Mr. Thompson’s major argument in defending the board is that intelligent design is not religion, but science. He is, however, absolutely open about his own religious motivations.

During the lunch break on Thursday, Mr. Thompson said he founded the law center to defend Christians who he thought were losing the culture wars. The center was initially financed by Thomas Monaghan, the founder of Domino’s Pizza. Both men are Roman Catholics.

“There are two worldviews that are in conflict,” Mr. Thompson said. “I do feel that even though Christians are 86 percent of the population, they have become second-class citizens.”

Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company

Home

Privacy Policy

Search

Corrections

XML

Help

Contact Us

Work for Us

Site Map

Back to Top

Back
Copyright ©1997-2005 PG Publishing Co., Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Political meddling in the history curriculum? Oh my!

Here’s a piece from The Boston Globe—Schools directed to expand history courses—about a new commission in New York that will examine whether the “physical and psychological terrorism” against Africans in the slave trade is being adequately taught in schools. The commission is named for the slave ship Amistad, which was commandeered by slaves who eventually won their freedom in the U.S. Supreme Court.

Easy to answer this one…NO.

The “outrage” over this “dabbling” expressed by Carl Hayden (head of the NYS Board of Regents) and Candice DeRussy, the ultra-right wing SUNY trustee is laughable as these two have been on the cutting edge of making K-16 public education in safe for coporate capitalism.

The Mysteries of NOLA: 25 Questions about the Murder of the Big Easy

From Tom Dispatch
The Mysteries of New Orleans

Twenty-five Questions about the Murder of the Big Easy

By Mike Davis and Anthony Fontenot

We recently spent a week in New Orleans and Southern Louisiana interviewing relief workers, community activists, urban planners, artists, and neighborhood folks. Even as the latest flood waters from Hurricane Rita recede, the city remains submerged in anger and frustration.

Indeed, the most toxic debris in New Orleans isn’t the sinister gray sludge that coats the streets of the historic Creole neighborhood of Treme or the Lower Ninth Ward, but all the unanswered questions that have accumulated in the wake of so much official betrayal and hypocrisy. Where outsiders see simple “incompetence” or “failure of leadership,” locals are more inclined to discern deliberate design and planned neglect — the murder, not the accidental death, of a great city.

In almost random order, here are twenty-five of the urgent questions that deeply trouble the local people we spoke with. Until a grand jury or congressional committee begins to uncover the answers, the moral (as opposed to simply physical) reconstruction of the New Orleans region will remain impossible.

1. Why did the floodwalls along the 17th Street Canal only break on the New Orleans (majority Black) side and not on the Metairie (largely white) side? Was this the result of neglect and poor maintenance by New Orleans authorities?

2. Who owned the huge barge that was catapulted through the wall of the Industrial Canal, killing hundreds in the Lower Ninth Ward — the most deadly hit-and-run accident in U.S. history?

3. All of New Orleans and St. Bernard Parish east of the Industrial Canal were drowned, except for the Almonaster-Michoud Industrial District along Chef Menteur Highway. Why was industrial land apparently protected by stronger levees than nearby residential neighborhoods?

4. Why did Mayor Ray Nagin, in defiance of his own official disaster plan, delay twelve to twenty-four hours in ordering a mandatory evacuation of the city?

5. Why did Secretary of Homeland Security Michael Chertoff not declare Katrina an “Incident of National Significance” until August 31 — thus preventing the full deployment of urgently needed federal resources?

6. Why wasn’t the nearby U.S.S. Bataan immediately sent to the aid of New Orleans? The huge amphibious-landing ship had a state-of-the-art, 600-bed hospital, water and power plants, helicopters, food supplies, and 1,200 sailors eager to join the rescue effort.

7. Similarly, why wasn’t the Baltimore-based hospital ship USS Comfort ordered to sea until August 31, or the 82nd Airborne Division deployed in New Orleans until September 5?

8. Why does Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld balk at making public his “severe weather execution order” that established the ground rules for the military response to Katrina? Did the Pentagon, as a recent report by the Congressional Research Service suggests, fail to take initiatives within already authorized powers, then attempt to transfer the blame to state and local governments?

9. Why were the more than 350 buses of the New Orleans Regional Transportation Authority — eventually flooded where they were parked — not mobilized to evacuate infirm, poor, and car-less residents?

10. What significance attaches to the fact that the chair of the Transportation Authority, appointed by Mayor Nagin, is Jimmy Reiss, the wealthy leader of the New Orleans Business Council which has long advocated a thorough redevelopment of (and cleanup of crime in) the city?

11. Under what authority did Mayor Nagin meet confidentially in Dallas with the “forty thieves” — white business leaders led by Reiss — reportedly to discuss the triaging of poorer Black areas and a corporate-led master plan for rebuilding the city?

12. Everyone knows about a famous train called “the City of New Orleans.” Why was there no evacuation by rail? Was Amtrak part of the disaster planning? If not, why not?

13. Why were patients at private hospitals like Tulane evacuated by helicopter while their counterparts at the Charity Hospital were left to suffer and die?

14. Was the failure to adequately stock food, water, potable toilets, cots, and medicine at the Louisiana Superdome a deliberate decision — as many believe — to force poorer residents to leave the city?

15. The French Quarter has one of the highest densities of restaurants in the nation. Once the acute shortages of food and water at the Superdome and the Convention Center were known, why didn’t officials requisition supplies from hotels and restaurants located just a few blocks away? (As it happened, vast quantities of food were simply left to spoil.)

16. City Hall’s emergency command center had to be abandoned early in the crisis because its generator supposedly ran out of diesel fuel. Likewise many critical-care patients died from heat or equipment failure after hospital backup generators failed. Why were supplies of diesel fuel so inadequate? Why were so many hospital generators located in basements that would obviously flood?

17. Why didn’t the Navy or Coast Guard immediately airdrop life preservers and rubber rafts in flooded districts? Why wasn’t such life-saving equipment stocked in schools and hospitals?

18. Why weren’t evacuee centers established in Audubon Park and other unflooded parts of Uptown, where locals could be employed as cleanup crews?

19. Is the Justice Department investigating the Jim Crow-like response of the suburban Gretna police who turned back hundreds of desperate New Orleans citizens trying to walk across the Mississippi River bridge — an image reminiscent of Selma in 1965? New Orleans, meanwhile, abounds in eyewitness accounts of police looting and illegal shootings: Will any of this ever be investigated?

20. Who is responsible for the suspicious fires that have swept the city? Why have so many fires occurred in blue-collar areas that have long been targets of proposed gentrification, such as the Section 8 homes on Constance Street in the Lower Garden District or the wharfs along the river in Bywater?

21. Where were FEMA’s several dozen vaunted urban search-and-rescue teams? Aside from some courageous work by Coast Guard helicopter crews, the early rescue effort was largely mounted by volunteers who towed their own boats into the city after hearing an appeal on television.

22. We found a massive Red Cross presence in Baton Rouge but none in some of the smaller Louisiana towns that have mounted the most impressive relief efforts. The poor Cajun community of Ville Platte, for instance, has at one time or another fed and housed more than 5,000 evacuees; but the Red Cross, along with FEMA, has refused almost daily appeals by local volunteers to send professional personnel and aid. Why then give money to the Red Cross?

23. Why isn’t FEMA scrambling to create a central registry of everyone evacuated from the greater New Orleans region? Will evacuees receive absentee ballots and be allowed to vote in the crucial February municipal elections that will partly decide the fate of the city?

24. As politicians talk about “disaster czars” and elite-appointed reconstruction commissions, and as architects and developers advance utopian designs for an ethnically cleansed “new urbanism” in New Orleans, where is any plan for the substantive participation of the city’s ordinary citizens in their own future?

25. Indeed, on the fortieth anniversary of the 1965 Voting Rights Act, what has happened to democracy?