Race, income and the “test score” gap

Here are to recent articles from The New York Times that illustrate the contradictions people are confronting in efforts to close the so-called “achievement” gap.

In Wake County (Raleigh), North Carolina the schools are using an “integration by income” approach to closing what is more appropriately described as the “test score” gap. The New York Times describes this as the most successful and ambitious effort to create economically diverse public schools. (This is an approach that has also been tried in LaCrosse, WI; St. Lucie County, Fla.; San Francisco; Cambridge, Mass.; and Charlotte-Mecklenburg, NC.)

In Wake County, only 40 percent of black students in grades three through eight scored at grade level on state tests a decade ago. Last spring, 80 percent did. Hispanic students have made similar strides. Overall, 91 percent of students in those grades scored at grade level in the spring, up from 79 percent 10 years ago.

The Wake Count board of education had two motives when it decided to make economic integration a main element in the district’s strategy: board members feared that the county’s three-decade effort to integrate public schools racially would be found unconstitutional if challenged in the federal courts (which in recent years has made a habit of declaring districts under desegregation orders as now “unified”), and they took note of numerous studies that showed the academic benefits of economically diversifying schools.

[Note that the federal courts’ pattern of ending desegregation plans in urban districts across the US has resulted in the REsegreation of schools in the US to level not seen since the late 1960s. For more on this see the Harvard Civil Rights Project recent report “Schools More Separate: Consequence of a Decade of Resegregation”.]

While there has been success in Wake County, there is opposition from some quarters, most particularly white, middle class parents.

On the other hand, wealthy school districts, like the one in Princeton, NJ, are not ammune to the built in racial and class biases of standardized tests, as illustrated in an article in today’s New York Times,The Achievement Gap in Elite Schools.

What the Times article illustrates is that simply having economic integration in a school system doesn’t rectify the deleterious effects of education and assessment that relies on fundamentally racist and classist standardized tests.Below are the NYT articles on Princeton, NJ and Wake County, NC:

September 28, 2005
The Achievement Gap in Elite Schools
By SAMUEL G. FREEDMAN
PRINCETON, N.J.

AN uneasy amalgam of pride and discontent, Caroline Mitchell sat amid the balloons and beach chairs on the front lawn of Princeton High School, watching the Class of 2004 graduate. Her pride was for the seniors’ average SAT score of 1237, third-highest in the state, and their admission to elite universities like Harvard, Yale and Duke. As president of the high school alumni association and community liaison for the school district, Ms. Mitchell deserved to bask in the tradition of public-education excellence.

Discontent, though, was what she felt about Blake, her own son. He was receiving his diploma on this June afternoon only after years of struggle – the failed English class in ninth grade, the science teacher who said he was capable only of C’s, the assignment to a remedial “basic skills” class. Even at that, Ms. Mitchell realized, Blake had fared better than several friends who were nowhere to be seen in the procession of gowns and mortarboards. They were headed instead for summer school.

“I said to myself: ‘Oh, no. Please, no,’ ” Ms. Mitchell recalled. “I was so hurt. These were bright kids. This shouldn’t have been happening.”

It did not escape Ms. Mitchell’s perception that her son and most of those faltering classmates were black. They were the evidence of a prosperous, accomplished school district’s dirty little secret, a racial achievement gap that has been observed, acknowledged and left uncorrected for decades. Now that pattern just may have to change under the pressure of the federal No Child Left Behind law.

Several months after Blake graduated, Princeton High School (and thus the district as a whole) ran afoul of the statute for the first time, based on the lagging scores of African-American students on a standardized English test given to 11th graders. Last month, the school was cited for the second year in a row, this time because 37 percent of black students failed to meet standards in English, and 55 percent of blacks and 40 percent of Hispanics failed in math.

One of the standard complaints about No Child Left Behind by its critics in public education is that it punishes urban schools that are chronically underfinanced and already contending with a concentration of poor, nonwhite, bilingual and special-education pupils. Princeton could hardly be more different. It is an Ivy League town with a minority population of slightly more than 10 percent and per-student spending well above the state average. The high school sends 94 percent of its graduates to four-year colleges and offers 29 different Advanced Placement courses. Over all, 98 percent of Princeton High School students exceed the math and English standards required by No Child Left Behind.

So is the problem with the district, or is the problem with the law?

The answer seems clear to those parents – mostly black, but some white and Hispanic – who have been raising the issue of the achievement gap for years. While the Princeton community includes a slice of black bourgeoisie attached to the university or nearby corporations, most of the African-American population came here a century or more ago to serve as the butlers, maids, cooks and chauffeurs of a university and town with a nearly Southern fondness for segregation. The high school, for instance, did not integrate for nearly 20 years after its founding in 1898, and the elementary schools waited until they were compelled by state law in 1947.

As far back as the 1960’s, according to the local historical society, black students suffered from “low expectations from teachers” and a high dropout rate. In the early 1990’s, an interracial body calling itself the Robeson Group – in homage to Paul Robeson, the most famous product of black Princeton – mobilized to recruit more black teachers and help elect the first black member to the school board.

Despite such efforts, the achievement gap remained. A tracking system for math separates students in middle school. The high school, while not formally tracked, has such a demand for seats in Advanced Placement classes and honors sections that a rigid hierarchy exists in effect. Guidance counselors find their time consumed by writing recommendation letters for seniors who routinely apply to 10 or more high-end schools.

And until the No Child Left Behind law was enacted there were no concrete consequences for failing to address the resulting disparity. Which may be why a number of black parents here credit the federal law with forcing attention on the underside of public education in Princeton. It requires all districts to reveal test results and meet performance standards by various subgroups, including race.

“If you scratch the surface of this town, a lot of contradictions are going to emerge,” said Ron Plummer, a project manager for a technology company and a co-chairman of the school district’s minority education committee. “I do have some suspicions when measurements come from standardized tests alone. But if it’s going to shine a bright light on the inadequacies of the system, especially as it regards children of color, then I’m all in favor.”

In any case, there can be a tone of defensiveness, even smugness, among certain school leaders in Princeton. “We’re proud of our F,” said Lewis Goldstein, the assistant superintendent, referring to the contradiction between the district’s overall success and its standing under No Child Left Behind. “It’s as if you handed in your homework and the teacher handed it back and you got a 98 on it and an F. That’s the situation we’re in.”

TO be fair to Princeton, it is hardly the only community to include both a large number of superachieving students and a smaller but persistent number of low-income, nonwhite stragglers. Princeton, in fact, belongs to an organization of 25 similar school districts, the Minority Student Achievement Network, which includes Evanston, Ill.; Shaker Heights, Ohio; and Eugene, Ore., among others, that are working to find techniques to address the issue.

Princeton’s superintendent, Judith Wilson, has accepted the challenge of reducing the achievement gap. As a newcomer to the district – she arrived last February from the working-class, half-minority district in Woodbury, N.J., near Camden – she sounds less beholden than some of her colleagues to Princeton’s exalted sense of itself.

“If the gap can’t be narrowed in Princeton,” she said in an interview in her office last week, “then where can it be narrowed? There can’t be a question here of resources, or of community support, or of quality of staff. So if we can’t impact the students who are not born into privilege, then where can it happen?”

E-mail: sgfreedman@nytimes.com

Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company
______________________________________________

September 25, 2005
As Test Scores Jump, Raleigh Credits Integration by Income
By ALAN FINDER
RALEIGH, N.C. – Over the last decade, black and Hispanic students here in Wake County have made such dramatic strides in standardized reading and math tests that it has caught the attention of education experts around the country.

The main reason for the students’ dramatic improvement, say officials and parents in the county, which includes Raleigh and its sprawling suburbs, is that the district has made a concerted effort to integrate the schools economically.

Since 2000, school officials have used income as a prime factor in assigning students to schools, with the goal of limiting the proportion of low-income students in any school to no more than 40 percent.

The effort is the most ambitious in the country to create economically diverse public schools, and it is the most successful, according to several independent experts. La Crosse, Wis.; St. Lucie County, Fla.; San Francisco; Cambridge, Mass.; and Charlotte-Mecklenburg, N.C., have adopted economic integration plans.

In Wake County, only 40 percent of black students in grades three through eight scored at grade level on state tests a decade ago. Last spring, 80 percent did. Hispanic students have made similar strides. Overall, 91 percent of students in those grades scored at grade level in the spring, up from 79 percent 10 years ago.

School officials here have tried many tactics to improve student performance. Teachers get bonuses when their schools make significant progress in standardized tests, and the district uses sophisticated data gathering to identify, and respond to, students’ weaknesses.

Some of the strategies used in Wake County could be replicated across the country, the experts said, but they also cautioned that unusual circumstances have helped make the politically delicate task of economic integration possible here.

The school district is countywide, which makes it far easier to combine students from the city and suburbs. The county has a 30-year history of busing students for racial integration, and many parents and students are accustomed to long bus rides to distant schools. The local economy is robust, and the district is growing rapidly. And corporate leaders and newspaper editorial pages here have firmly supported economic diversity in the schools.

Some experts said the academic results in Wake County were particularly significant because they bolstered research that showed low-income students did best when they attended middle-class schools.

“Low-income students who have an opportunity to go to middle-class schools are surrounded by peers who have bigger dreams and who are more academically engaged,” said Richard D. Kahlenberg, a senior fellow at the Century Foundation who has written about economic integration in schools. “They are surrounded by parents who are more likely to be active in the school. And they are taught by teachers who more likely are highly qualified than the teachers in low-income schools.”

To achieve a balance of low- and middle-income children in every school, the Wake County school district encourages and sometimes requires students to attend schools far from home. Suburban students are drawn to magnet schools in the city. Low-income children from the city are bused to middle-class schools in the suburbs.

Some parents chafe at the length of their children’s bus rides or at what they see as social engineering. But the test results are hard to dispute, proponents of economic integration say, as is the broad appeal of the school district, which has been growing by 5,000 students a year.

“What I say to parents is, ‘Here is what you should hold me accountable for: at the end of that bus ride, are we providing a quality education for your child?’ ” Bill McNeal, the school superintendent, said.

Asked how parents respond, Mr. McNeal said, “They are coming back, and they are bringing their friends.”

Not everyone supports the strategy. Some parents deeply oppose mandatory assignments to schools. Every winter, the district, using a complicated formula, develops a list of students who will be reassigned to new schools for the following academic year, and nearly every year some parents object vehemently.

“Kids are bused all over creation, and they say it’s for economic diversity, but really it’s a proxy for race,” said Cynthia Matson, who is white and middle class. She is the president and a founder of Assignment By Choice, an advocacy group promoting parental choice.

The organization wants parents to be responsible for selecting schools, and it objects to restrictions that, in certain circumstances, make it difficult for some middle-class children to get into magnet schools.

“If a parent wants their kid bused, then let them make the choice,” Mrs. Matson said. “But don’t force parents to have their kids bused across town to go to a school that they don’t want to go to.”

Supporters of economic integration contend that the county offers parents many choices but that the school district needs the discretion to assign some children to schools to avoid large concentrations of poor children. “I believe in choice as much as anyone,” Mr. McNeal said. “However, I can’t let choice erode our ability to provide quality programs and quality teaching.”

The board of education had two motives when it decided to make economic integration a main element in the district’s strategy: board members feared that the county’s three-decade effort to integrate public schools racially would be found unconstitutional if challenged in the federal courts, and they took note of numerous studies that showed the academic benefits of economically diversifying schools.

“There is a lot of evidence that it’s just sound educational policy, sound public policy, to try to avoid concentrations of low-achieving students,” said John H. Gilbert, a professor emeritus at North Carolina State University in Raleigh who served for 16 years on the county school board and voted for the plan. “They do much better and advantaged students are not hurt by it if you follow policies that avoid concentrating low-achievement students.”

One sign of the success of the Wake County plan, Mr. Gilbert said, is that residential property values in Raleigh have remained high, as have those in the suburbs. “The economy is really saying something about the effort in the city,” he said.

About 27 percent of the county’s students are low-income, a proportion that has increased slightly in recent years. While many are black and Hispanic, about 15 percent are white. Moreover, more than 40 percent of the district’s black students are working- and middle-class, and not poor.

Wake County has used many strategies to limit the proportion of low-income students in schools to 40 percent. For example, magnet schools lure many suburban parents to the city.

Betty Trevino lives in Fuquay-Varina, a town in southern Wake County. Ms. Trevino drives her son, Eric, 5, to and from the Joyner Elementary School, where he goes to kindergarten. Students are taught in English and Spanish, and global themes are emphasized at the school, which is north of downtown Raleigh, more than 20 miles from the Trevinos’ home. With traffic, the trip takes 45 minutes each way.

“I think it works,” she said of her drive halfway across the county, “because it’s such a good school.”

Many low-income children are bused to suburban schools. While some of their parents are unhappy with the length of the rides, some also said they were happy with their child’s school.

“I think it’s ridiculous,” LaToya Mangum said of the 55 minutes that her son Gabriel, 7, spends riding a bus to the northern reaches of Wake County, where he is in second grade. On the other hand, she said, “So far, I do like the school.”

The neighborhood school has been redefined, with complex logistics and attendance maps that can resemble madly gerrymandered Congressional districts.

The Swift Creek Elementary School, in southwest Raleigh near the city line, draws most of its students from within two miles of the school, in both the city and suburbs. But students also come to Swift Creek from four widely scattered areas in low-income sections of south and southeastern Raleigh; some live 6 to 8 miles from the school, while others are as far as 12 miles away.

Ela Browder lives in Cary, an affluent, sprawling suburb, but each morning she puts her 6-year-old son, Michael, on a bus for a short ride across the city line to Swift Creek.

“We’re very happy with the school,” Ms. Browder said. “The children are very enriched by it. I think it’s the best of both worlds.”

Of the county’s 139 elementary, middle and high schools, all but 22 are within the 40 percent guideline, according to the district’s data. Some are only a few percentage points above the guideline, while others are significantly higher.

The overwhelming majority of the 120,000 children in the district go either to a local school or a school of their choice, officials said. Slightly more than 85 percent of students attend a school within five miles of home and another 12 percent or so voluntarily attend magnet or year-round schools.

Although the figures can be calculated many ways, Mr. McNeal says about 2.5 percent – or about 3,000 children – are assigned to schools for economic balance or to accommodate the district’s growth by filling new schools or easing overcrowding in existing ones. Most of those bused for economic diversity tend to be low-income, he said.

A school board election will take place in October. While the board has continued to endorse economic integration, some supporters worry that that could change one day.

“It’s not easy and it can be very contentious in the community,” said Walter C. Sherlin, who retired two years ago as an associate superintendent. “Is it worth doing? Look at 91 percent at or above grade level. Look at 139 schools, all of them successful. I think the answer is obvious.”

Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company

To debate or not to debate ID

In his commentary for Inside Higher Ed, Gerald Graff, a professor of English and Education at U Illinois, Chicago, argues that there are good pedagogical reasons for “teaching the controversy” of evolution versus so-called “intelligent design.”

[Graff coined the phrase, “teach the controversy” is his writing about the cultural wars (and he’s concerned about how the religious right has appropriated the phrase in their efforts to bring religion into science under the guise of ID).]

I think Graff makes a good case and I’m inclined to agree with him. Evolution, as Graff points out, is about has solid a scientific theory as there is, so the issue is not about “gaps” in Darwinian thinking.

There is nothing gained pedagogically by merely dismissing the creationist poseurs behind ID. And, there is plenty of room for students learn about ways of knowing, rationality/irrationality, religion and science by engaging the debate.

Graff thinks

“Scientists like Coyne and Dawkins concede that debate should indeed be central to science instruction, but they hold that such debate should be between accredited hypotheses within science, not between scientists and creationist poseurs. That’s hard to dispute, but, … I can at least imagine a classroom debate between creationism and evolution that might be just the thing to wake up the many students who now snooze through science courses. Such students might come away from such a debate with a sharper understanding of the grounds on which established science rests, something that even science majors and advanced graduate students now don’t often get from conventional science instruction.”

The point being that teaching that relies merely on reference to authority is not the way to create students who understand their world and can thinking critically about it.

Vancouver Sun: Teachers make gains in the classroom

Teachers make gains in the classroom
Although teachers have failed to get class sizes put back into their contracts, they’ve finally convinced almost everyone, including the government, that action is needed to help special needs students

Janet Steffenhagen
Vancouver Sun

September 24, 2005

B.C. teachers won a major victory in their battle for improved classroom conditions before they voted this week in favour of strike action to press their contract demands.

After years of talking, they have finally convinced almost everyone — including government — that something needs to be done about the challenges many face in teaching large classes with growing numbers of students who have special needs affecting learning and behaviour.

But their union has made zero progress in persuading its education partners or the Liberal government that the answer lies in a return to the situation that existed in 2002, when teacher contracts set the rules around class size and composition

That leaves the B.C. Teachers’ Federation, on the verge of a strike that could shut schools around the province next month, with no significant support for what it says is its number one bargaining priority.

The union insists it won’t sign a collective agreement unless it receives a written guarantee from the government that student learning conditions will be restored to 2002 levels.

Its members, who say they can’t provide quality education when they are balancing so many demands with little support, want those guarantees to be part of a new collective agreement.

They look back to 2002, when their contracts included class size caps, limits on the number of special-needs students in any one class and strict requirements and formulas to ensure every school had a certain number of specialty teachers, such as ESL teachers, special-education teachers, counsellors and librarians.

“Our working conditions and our students’ learning conditions have deteriorated incredibly since that time,” union president Jinny Sims said Friday in announcing plans for an October strike.

Not everyone accepts that.

Groups representing school trustees, principals and vice-principals and parent advisory councils acknowledge that class size, class composition and special-needs education need attention — especially in the Lower Mainland — but over all, they say the education system is better than it’s ever been.

They are sounding more positive than they have for several years because of an infusion this year of $150 million into the education system — money that government urged boards to spend on class size, special needs, school resources and libraries in recognition of concerns raised by teachers.

But the over-riding message from these groups is that decisions about student learning must be made at the local level, not at the bargaining table.

“School boards believe that the best decisions are made locally,” said Penny Tees, president of the B.C. School Trustees Association. “Schools and districts need to be responsive to their local communities.”

Both she and Tom Hierck, president of the B.C. Principals’ and Vice-Principals’ Association, say schools have never been better and they aren’t hankering for 2002.

“I think we’re doing a pretty fine job,” Hierck said. “Have we got it perfect yet? No, there’s always room for improvement. But fixed language generated either from Victoria or from union headquarters in Vancouver isn’t the recipe for success.”

School board chairs Linda McPhail of Richmond and Shawn Wilson of Surrey said they, too, think education has improved since 2002. Wilson said one reason is technology.

“Through the effective use of technology, teachers are addressing a number of important learning enhancements, including but not limited to, the gender gap, diverse learning styles, peer sharing and editing, safe and responsible interaction with students around the world and the ethical use of modern communications technology,” he said in an e-mail.

McPhail said districts have to set their own priorities because their challenges are different. For example, ESL is a major concern in Richmond, where two-thirds of the students have received or are receiving ESL assistance. Each month, Richmond receives 100 new ESL students, McPhail said.

While ESL is a shared concern in the Lower Mainland, it wouldn’t be a major issue in rural and remote districts.

Teachers argue that they know more about learning conditions in the classroom than principals or parents. And many insist the only way they can be sure their concerns are addressed in all B.C. schools is through strong contract language.

Without that language, there is a danger that promises and good intentions can be forgotten. “Principals will work around it, as they’re doing now,” said Surrey teacher Peter Bonell. “They will say one thing but mean another.”

Bonell also worries that some teachers, especially younger ones, might be afraid to speak out if learning conditions are decided through local discussions rather than through collective agreements.

“It’s happening now in the schools. A young teacher comes in, they’re worried about keeping their job and getting a permanent position. They will not kick up a fuss.”

But even the NDP has abandoned its call for the restoration of learning conditions in the teachers’ contract. Education critic John Horgan said it’s time to look for other ways to help teachers with their workload, because the government isn’t likely to budge.

Horgan backs the teachers when they talk about deteriorating classroom conditions, saying the government’s decision to relax the rules about class size and class composition is bound to lead to poorer outcomes. While students might continue to get high marks on tests, they won’t learn critical thinking skills from teachers who feel overwhelmed, he said.

“I support local autonomy for school boards, absolutely. I believe that people in communities have a better understanding of what those community needs are,” he said. “But at the same time, government has a responsibility and an obligation . . . to respond when their edicts are clearly not working on the ground.”

Education Minister Shirley Bond said she is taking action.

This year, for the first time since class-size caps were removed from the contract, the ministry will monitor class sizes in all grades in B.C. to ensure boards obey the rules that were placed in the B.C. School Act in 2002.

“I’m going to be asking school districts to report to us about their class size issues,” she said. “I want to make sure that boards are respecting the legislation . . . and if there are issues with larger class sizes in specific districts, we believe we should hold school districts accountable for that.”

Teachers should be consulted about class size and composition but not during bargaining, she said. “Parents and this government have said clearly that deciding class sizes is not simply up to the BCTF and the employer.

“Parents have a stake in that discussion [and] need to be participants. But if you [make] class size a negotiating issue, it leaves out those people who have a role to play.”

She said school planning councils, which include principals, teachers, parents and — in some cases — students, should have a key role in deciding class size and composition. Kim Howland, president of the B.C. Confederation of Parent Advisory Councils, said her members want those decisions to be made locally.

The B.C. School Act sets maximum class size numbers for primary grades, but requires only that school districts not exceed an average of 30 students in Grade 4-12 classes.

The BCTF says that “flexibility” has allowed schools to put far too many students in certain classes — especially science, English and social studies.

But Hierck said averaging allows schools to offer more opportunities than they were able to do in 2002.

For example, he said, a small school can now offer Physics 12 to a handful of students because a neighbouring school has more than 30 students in core academic courses.

Those trade-offs aren’t always recognized by those who complain about larger classes, he added.

To make those trade-offs more transparent and to ensure parents are supportive, Hierck suggested the ministry should change the law to require individual schools to meet class size averages rather than having district-wide averages. Horgan agreed that might be an improvement.

Cathie Camlie of the Learning Disabilities Association of B.C. said classroom conditions haven’t improved since 2002 for students with learning challenges, but nor were they good in 2002. S

he said the lack of attention to special-needs children in public schools is leading to the “privatization of special education,” with parents who can afford it hiring special tutors to help their children.

Her main complaint about Liberal changes to education is the de-targeting of special-education funds.

When school boards no longer received money targeted for special needs, many stopped identifying those children, she said. “That was especially true for gifted kids,” she said. “It virtually wiped out the identification of gifted kids.”

But her organization’s chief concern is the lack of training for teachers in dealing with special needs. “If anyone wants to do one thing to help kids with exceptionalities it’s teacher training,” she said, noting that a BCTF study several years ago found 40 per cent of teachers in Coquitlam and Nanaimo felt they were ill-prepared to deal with special-needs children.

Rita Irwin, associate dean of teacher education at the University of B.C., said her big regret about changes between 2002 and 2005 is the loss of art education.

“If you talk about the quality of schools when it comes to the arts, it’s definitely gone down,” she said.

“But if you’re talking to the average parent who is really concerned about numeracy and literacy, then the students are probably getting a pretty comparable [experience].”

Paul Shaker, the education dean at Simon Fraser University, who has worked in four countries and five American states, said he’s encouraged by the quality of B.C. schools. But he said there is room for improvement, especially in areas such as fine arts, special needs and ESL that tend to be cut when resources are tight.

“I don’t think the system is saturated with money by any means. Obviously there’s enough money in the system to do a very good job because a very good job is being done. But a better job could be done.”

jsteffenhagen@png.canwest.com

© The Vancouver Sun 2005

7 Deadly Absurdities of No Child Left Behind

This short piece by Gerald Bracey is one of the best overviews/critiques of the No Child Left Behind Act that I’ve seen. Highly recommededed.

You can download it as a PDF here.

Or read it below.

THE SEVEN DEADLY ABSURDITIES OF NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND

Gerald W. Bracey

Gerald W. Bracey is an Associate of the High/Scope Educational Research Foundation, Ypsilanti, Michigan and a fellow of the Education Policy Studies Laboratory at Arizona State University. His most recent book is Setting the Record Straight: Responses to Misconceptions About Public Education in the U. S.: Second Edition (Heinemann, 2004).

A recent website headline read “Revolt Against No Child Left Behind Spreads to 47 States.” It’s about time. If one considers Iraq and Katrina to be twin disasters for the Bush Administration, No Child Left Behind (NCLB) makes it a trifecta. Although the law consumes over 1100 pages, its most egregious flaws can be quickly described as The Seven Deadly Absurdities:

1. The law uses the phrase “scientifically based research” 111 times and demands that such research support any educational programs that a school or district adopts. The U. S. Department of Education judged that the reading program favored by New York City lacked such support and withheld $47 million in grants until the city caved. But there is no scientifically based research—or any research—to support the law’s mandates. No research supports NCLB’s contention that the way to improve schools is to test every child every year and to fail schools and districts that do no make the required—and wholly arbitrary–Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP). Indeed, research argues against the use of such high-stakes testing as an instrument of school reform. Tests that serve as useful monitors lose their credibility, validity and value when high stakes are attached. As researcher Donald Campbell noted many years ago, the more any quantitative social indicator is used for social decision making, the more the indicator and the users are likely become corrupted.

2. NCLB lacks research support because NCLB depends solely on punishment. As schools fail to make the arbitrary AYP, the law imposes punitive, increasingly harsh sanctions. The law follows the grand tradition of “the beatings will continue until morale improves.”

3. Even those who think punishment can motivate people would never use it as NCLB does. It punishes the entire school for the failures of the few, often the very few. If a school’s special education students fail to make AYP, the whole school fails. If a school’s English language learners fail to make AYP the whole school fails. If a mere 5% of any group fails to show up on test day, the whole school fails. NCLB requires schools to report test score data by various student categories— ethnicity, socioeconomic status, special education, etc. Most schools have 37 such categories (California has more). Schools thus have 37 opportunities to fail, only one to succeed.

4. The law demands that all students must be proficient in reading, math, and science by 2014. In his 2003 presidential address to the American Educational Research Association, testing expert Robert Linn projected it would take 61 years, 66 years, and 166 years, respectively, to get fourth-, eighth-, and twelfth-graders to the proficient level in math. Alas, Linn’s projections are wildly optimistic. They assume that each increase in percent proficient is equally easy to attain. It is obvious, though, that it is easier to make AYP the first few years than in the last few when schools will be working with children for whom all previous efforts have failed. Indeed, stories abound of schools currently targeting “bubble children”—those on the bubble near a passing score—in order to maximize their chances for making AYP.

Moreover, Linn created his projections from national results on the National Assessment of Educational Progress, not data disaggregated by ethnicity. In the 2003, though, only 5 percent of African-American eighth graders and 7 percent of Hispanics were proficient in math. Only 37 percent of whites, 43 percent of Asians, and 15 percent of Native Americans reached this plateau. A recent journal article found the 100% proficient requirement so irrational it could well be unconstitutional.

5. As a consequence of #3 and #4 above, California projects that by the deadline year of 2014, NCLB will label 99 percent of its schools “failing.” California students generally do poorly tests, but high-scoring states will experience massive failure as well. For instance, in the Third International Mathematics and Science Study, only 6 of the 41 participating countries outscored high-flying Minnesota in mathematics and only one of 41 attained a higher science score. Yet the state’s Legislative Auditor projected that by 2014, NCLB will find 80 percent of Minnesota’s schools wanting. A September, 2005 study estimated a 95% failure rate for six Great Lakes states, Ohio, Illinois, Indiana, Wisconsin, Michigan and Minnesota.

6. Any school that fails to make AYP for two consecutive years must offer all students the option to transfer to a “successful” school. Thus, if a school’s special education students or English Language Learners fail to make AYP two years in a row, the school must offer all students the “choice option” in spite of the fact that the school succeeded for the other 35 student categories.

In cities and rural areas, the choice option is a farce. To exercise choice in some rural areas entails a two-hour ride. In some parts of Alaska and Hawaii it requires airplanes. In 2004-2005, Chicago had 200,000 students eligible, but only 500 spaces for them. Although New York had more eligibles than Chicago—about 350,000—in 2003-2004, only 8,000 students chose to transfer. These 8,000, though, apparently created so much havoc in the receiving schools that principals rebelled. Responding to these principals, public schools Chancellor, Joel Klein, deliberately flouted the law, permitting only 1,000 transfers. Thus far, the Department of Education has not responded to Klein’s scofflaw defiance.

7. This is the biggie: Schools alone cannot possibly accomplish what NCLB demands. But this is what NCLB mandates. It commands schools, all by themselves, to close the achievement gap between affluent and poor, majority and minority. This is ridiculous. The gap appears before kids reach school—one study found that the three-year-olds of professional mothers used more words when interacting with their mothers than mothers on welfare used in interacting with their three-year-olds. That’s right, three year old kids in one group used more words than adults in another group. After all, if one assumes a six-hour school day and a 180-day school year, then between birth and age18 children spend only 9 percent of their lives in schools. Family and community factors such as poverty affect achievement (asthma and low birth-weight infants are epidemic in some city slums; fathers and libraries in short supply). Poor children enter school well behind their middle class peers. They learn the same amount during the school year, but they lose the gains over the summer and they fall farther and farther behind. Critics blame the schools for what happens in the months the schools are closed.

Other absurdities exist–for instance, the contention that any student not “proficient” is “left behind” promotes a false dichotomy. If the threshold for “proficient” is, say, a test score of 80, then a child who scores 79 is “left behind.” In actuality, achievement is a continuum, not a dichotomy.

Some have always viewed NCLB as yet another Bush administration Orwellian Double Speak program doing the opposite of what its name implies—like Clean Waters, Clear Skies, Healthy Forests. Behind the cover of its idealistic-sounding moniker, No Child Left Behind really intends to increase the use of vouchers, increase the privatization of public schools, transfer large sums of public funds to the private sector, reduce the size of the public sector, and weaken or destroy the teachers unions (two Democratic power bases). It is working.

Although children and their teachers lose under the law, the testing companies have benefited mightily from it. F. Peter Jovanovich of the mammoth Pearson Education looked at NCLB and said, “This reads almost like our business plan.” Then-Educational Testing Service vice president, Sharon Robinson, reportedly called the law “The Test Publishers Full Employment Act.” The law gifts testing companies over $2 billion annually.

The hot properties currently, though, are those that provide tutoring and other instruction that the law designates as “Supplementary Educational Services.” Nationally, some 1800 providers can collect as much as $2 billion dollars a year. And, while the law holds public schools accountable for making progress or not, it visits no such sanctions on these private companies. The test preparation and tutoring companies have no obligation to prove that their programs actually work and no “scientifically based research” supports the contention that they do. No one is looking at the results of the Supplementary Educational Services. U. S. Department of Education spokespeople are on record saying that they merely want to create conditions such that “the market [for providers] can be as vibrant as possible.” (In fact, such services were not a part of the original plan. That plan called for vouchers to send students to private schools. The supplemental services were added when Congress rejected the voucher provisions. If FEMA had responded as quickly to Katrina as the administration turned to vouchers as part of its Katrina repair program, Michael Brown might still head the agency).

An enduring mystery of NCLB is that prominent Democrats such as Ted Kennedy of Massachusetts and George Miller of California supported its passage. In spring, 2004, Senator Kennedy and Representative Miller received information, both by email and postal service mail, explaining the logic of the outcomes described above. Senator Kennedy did not respond. From Representative Miller’s office, a staffer emailed a single sentence: “I certainly hope not.” From such a response one must conclude that Congress is not giving NCLB the critical scrutiny it requires.

The current law mandates annual testing for all children in grades three through eight in reading and math with science to be added in 2007. It also requires testing in one high school grade, to be decided by each state. President Bush has proposed extending the testing through the high school years. Given the chaos that the current law is producing in the lower grades, Bush’s proposal constitutes the domestic equivalent of invading Iran.

Notes:

(i) Formally, Campbell’s Law states, “The more any quantitative social indicator is used for social decision making, the more subject it will be to corruption pressures, and the more apt it will be to distort and corrupt the social processes it is intended to monitor.”

(ii) The speech was published in the October 2003 Educational Researcher.

(iii) Wiley, Edward, Mathis, William and Garcia, David. “The Impact of the AYP Requirement of the Federal “No Child Left Behind” Act on Schools in the Great Lakes Region. www.asu.edu/educ/epsl/EPRU/documents/EPSL-0509-109-EPRU.pdf.

(iv) Betty Hart and Todd Risley, Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experiences of Young Children. Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes, 1995.

(v) “Alexander, Karl, Entwisle, Doris, and Olson, Linda, “Schools Achievement, and Inequality: A Seasonal Perspective. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, Summer, 2001.

(vi) Bracey, Gerald W., No Child Left Behind: Where Does the Money Go? www.asu.edu/educ/epsl/EPRU/documents/EPSL-0506-114-EPRU.pdf

(vii) Ibid.

Study faults high-stakes testing

Dallas Morning News: Authors cite low rate of improvement, effects on minority students

Study faults high-stakes testing
Authors cite low rate of improvement, effect on minorities

09:59 PM CDT on Tuesday, September 20, 2005

By TERRENCE STUTZ / The Dallas Morning News

AUSTIN – High-stakes testing in Texas and across the nation has had little impact on student achievement and is disproportionately targeting minority students – as evidenced by increased retention and dropout rates in many states – according to a study by researchers in Texas and Arizona.

The study, which examined the impact of high-stakes testing in Texas and 24 other states, found “no convincing evidence” that the pressure associated with those tests – such as threatened sanctions for low scores – produced better student achievement than would otherwise have been expected.

“A rapidly growing body of research evidence on the harmful effects of high-stakes testing, along with no reliable evidence of improved performance by students, suggests that we need a moratorium in public education on the use of high-stakes testing,” said Sharon L. Nichols of the University of Texas at San Antonio, lead author of the report.

The study, released Tuesday by the Education Policy Studies Laboratory at Arizona State University, was undertaken to gauge the impact of the federal No Child Left Behind Act. States are required under the law to administer standardized tests that are used to hold schools and school districts accountable for student achievement.

Dr. Nichols and the research team reached their conclusions by creating a so-called Pressure Rating Index that ranked states based on how much pressure they put on schools to improve test scores. Texas had the highest index – based on tougher requirements and other factors – and Kentucky had the lowest among the 25 states.

Scores of each state on the National Assessment of Educational Progress were then evaluated against the indexes to determine whether a higher level of pressure on schools produced higher scores on the national test.

“The theory of action implied by this accountability program is that the pressure of high-stakes testing will increase student achievement,” the researchers said. “But this study finds that pressure created by high-stakes testing has had almost no important influence on student academic performance.”

Among the key findings of the study, titled “High-Stakes Testing and Student Achievement: Problems for the No Child Left Behind Act,” were:

•States with greater proportions of minority students implemented accountability systems that exerted greater pressure on educators and their schools. An unintended consequence is that problems associated with high-stakes testing disproportionately affect minority students.

•Increased testing pressure is related to increased retention and dropout rates. High-stakes testing in some states has increased the number the number of students – beginning with the eighth grade – who will leave school before their senior year in high school.

•Reading scores on the NAEP – administered in grades four and eight – did not improve as a result of increased testing pressure. That finding was consistent across all ethnic groups. While there was a weak correlation between pressure and fourth-grade math scores, researchers said the connection was more likely the result of “teaching to the test.”

Dr. Nichols said Tuesday that while all states fall under the basic mandates of the No Child Left Behind Act, states have discretion in meeting the requirements – such as the minimum percentage of students that must pass the state achievement test for the school campus or district to hit annual improvement targets.

In Texas, schools must show “Adequate Yearly Progress” on the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills.

Unlike Texas, which puts most of the emphasis on TAKS scores, Kentucky considers other criteria such as teacher evaluations of students, according to Dr. Nichols.

This year, nearly 87 percent of school districts and 77 percent of campuses in Texas made adequate progress under the federal law. Both figures were down sharply from a year ago because of tougher standards that took effect in the 2004-05 school year. For example, more students had to pass the math and reading sections of the TAKS.

E-mail tstutz@dallasnews.com

Online at: http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/latestnews/stories/092105dntextesting.1294db47.html

The Legendary K.O. (aka K-otix): George Bush Doesn’t Like Black People

ko_bush.jpg Listen to “George Doesn’t Like Black People”

Watch the video here.

And here’s Black Latern’s video of the tune

And

Check out the latest patriotic posters from WhiteHouse.org: “Brownie you’re doing a heck of job” and “Let them fly coach”

Kelefa Sanneh in the The New York Times Rapping for a hometown in hurricane crisis:

September 19, 2005
Rapping for a Hometown in Hurricane Crisis
By KELEFA SANNEH

ATLANTA, Sept. 18 – “I lost my house,” said one victim of Hurricane Katrina, although this particular victim was equipped with some wildly refractive ornamentation and, more importantly, a very loud microphone. The crowd fell silent. “I lost my cars,” he continued. “But it ain’t about me.” Then, without pausing to acknowledge the absurdity, he delivered an exuberant, bare-chested ode to the shiny rims on the wheels of vehicles he no longer had.

This was, in a twisted way, one of the most moving moments of Saturday night’s concert. The victim was the New Orleans rapper (and reality-TV veteran) known variously as Young City or Chopper, an aspiring star who joined loads of established ones inside the Philips Arena for a concert called Heal the Hood, a hip-hop fund-raiser for – and, in a few cases, by – victims of Hurricane Katrina. (A New York hurricane relief benefit is to be held Monday night at 10:30 at the B. B. King Blues Club and Grill in Manhattan.) On Saturday, Atlanta’s famously competitive hip-hop stations had joined forces to promote an event that would be, as the jocks constantly reminded their listeners, historic.

And they were right. The night was organized by the tireless Mississippi rapper David Banner. He had corralled an impressive lineup of rappers, especially Southern rappers: Young Jeezy, T. I., Big Boi from OutKast and many others. The cause had everyone excited, but the “because” had everyone even more excited: the night was made possible by the extraordinary continuing success of Southern hip-hop.

No other event has ever mobilized so many rappers so quickly. Just about everyone heard Kanye West’s impassioned claim that “George Bush doesn’t care about black people.” Fewer know that some stars (like T. I. and Fat Joe) hit the radio airwaves for impromptu telethons. Others, like Paul Wall, led clothing drives. And yet others, like Eminem, wrote sizable checks. Rappers from the fertile New Orleans hip-hop scene responded particularly gracefully: Juvenile was one who lost his home, but he plays down his own story, focusing instead on those who lost much more.

Even by these standards, David Banner’s response has been extraordinarily energetic. He says he turned his tour bus into a relief truck for victims on the Gulf Coast. (“I got back to Mississippi before our government did, with food and supplies,” he says.) And since then, he has turned his charitable foundation, Heal the Hood, into a disaster-relief clearinghouse.

From all this came the idea for the Heal the Hood concert, a small benefit that ballooned into one of the year’s most important hip-hop shows. A few hours before it started, Banner was in a small hotel room, wearing flip-flops and socks with a tight tank top that turned his enormous, shoulder-to-shoulder tattoo into a crossword clue: starts with an M, ends with an PI, lots of letters in between.

David Banner has a birth name that might be even better than his stage name. He is Lavell Crump, a Mississippi native and a graduate of Southern University in Baton Rouge. He renamed himself after the “The Incredible Hulk,” and he clearly relishes playing the part of the superhero. In 2003, he released both his major-label solo debut, “Mississippi: The Album” (SRC/Universal), as well as its sequel, “MTA2: Baptized in Dirty Water” (SRC/Universal).

Those albums established him as a wildly versatile and often thrilling rapper and producer, careering from the anatomically minded club hit “Like a Pimp” to the slow-motion gospel moan, “Cadillac on 22s.” On Tuesday he is to release his far-reaching but uneven new album, “Certified” (SRC/Universal). But he’d rather talk about the Gulf Coast. “If this would have happened in New York,” he says, “water probably wouldn’t be on the ground now. And the president would have been there the next day.”

Rappers are often criticized for their perceived greed, but as Young City’s bittersweet boasts made clear, being flashy doesn’t mean forgetting where you came from; in fact, it can be a way of remembering. Not so coincidentally, the impoverished New Orleans neighborhoods that were hit so hard by Katrina are the same impoverished neighborhoods that popularized the term “bling bling,” the name of the 1998 breakthrough hit for the New Orleans rapper B. G.

On Saturday, contradictions like that were on display all night. The Atlanta rapper Young Jeezy thrilled the crowd with his addictive rhymes about life as a drug dealer. “Look, I’m tellin’ you, man/ If you get jammed up don’t mention my name,” he rapped, in a drawl thick enough to make the lines rhyme. Then he abruptly switched directions for a startling and effective hypothetical. “This could have been us in Atlanta right now, living in this building,” he said, and suddenly the arena looked very different.

The night’s program began with gospel music and ended with Nelly, a not-quite-Southerner (he’s from St. Louis), who asked, “If we don’t heal our own hoods, who will?” In between came five hours of entertaining and sometimes ragged earnestness, shamelessness and exuberance; the crowd was appreciative, if somewhat subdued.

T. I., who has one of the South’s most elegant rhyme styles, used his set to showcase his group, P$C, which makes a solid major-label debut tomorrow with “25 to Life ” (Atlantic); he also insulted his main rival, whom he didn’t name. (Let’s follow his example.) “If you can’t put nothing up for the cause, I don’t wanna hear it,” he said.

The Tennessee pioneers 8Ball & MJG showed off their tough but smooth style; Big Boi spit motor-mouthed rhymes with his Purple Ribbon crew; the emerging Atlanta group D4L came armed with gaudy, infectious rhymes and gaudier (and, let’s hope, less infectious) outfits.

And then, of course, there was David Banner himself. His set included a shirtless romp through “Gangster Walk” and a besuited (and then, by the end, shirtless) version of his sex-rap “Play,” both from the new album. And when it came time for “Like a Pimp,” he found a way to deliver a topical introduction. “Bush is giving his homeboys Halliburton the rebuilding contracts to our cities,” he said, continuing, “Bush is the biggest pimp.”

Banner also made a heartfelt plea to the evacuees. “I need y’all to be sure that you go back home,” he said, finding a new twist on his usual message of hometown pride. “They been waiting to tear our ghettos down and separate us from our land.”

Hours later, when the concert was over, Banner could still be found signing autographs and posing for pictures with a handful of the fans who remained. As he no doubt knows, the hard work is just beginning: after a concert this size, there will be lots of scrutiny of his foundation.

It’s true that this concert coincides with the release of his new album, and it’s true that the Heal the Hood campaign has given him more exposure than he has ever had. But skeptics should know this: Banner spent most of Saturday in front of microphones of one kind or another. And all day long, he resisted the temptation to advertise his new album.

Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company

Oh boy! The teacher is showing a movie in social studies today!

"Okay class, today we're going to watch a movie. It's about democracy and despotism."

"Rich, get that gum out of your mouth!"

"This film really goes with our next unit, but today was the only time I could book it from A-V. Anyway, I think you'll enjoy it and … it's relevant to current events."

"Alright, now, uh, I want you to pay attention and at the end of the film we'll have a discussion about what kind of community we live in…"

"Kevin, would you please turn out the lights. Okay Ceola, you can start the projector."

View today’s social studies movie here:Despotis1946_00000000.jpg

After you’ve watched the movie, rate your community on these four scales:

  • Respect (Shared -> Restricted)
  • Power (Shared -> Concentrated)
  • Economic Distribution (Balanced -> Slanted)
  • Information (Uncontolled/Critical Evaluation -> Controlled/Automatic Acceptance)
  • What sort of community do you live in? Is your community headed for democracy or does despotism stand a good chance?

    Bonus Question:
    How does your community train its teachers? Do you agree with the teacher educator in the movie who says:

    “Young people cannot be trusted to form their own opinons. This business about openmindedness is nonsense. It’s a waste of time to try to teach students to think for themselves. It’s our job to tell ’em.”

    Why? Or why not? (Please give examples to support your position.)

    Remember what happens in your community matters for you and everyone else.

    Sink or swim

    In an interview with Citypages August Nimtz, New Orleans native and poli sci prof at U of Minnesota, discusses how disasters can foster solidarity. And he offers this take on the US government:

    One of the biggest illusions people in this country have is the notion or belief that the government is quote-unquote “our” government. It’s only through things like [Katrina] that people realize it’s their government–of the rich, for the rich, by the rich.

    What people confuse is what should be with what is. Yes, it should be our government. It should be a government of working people. But boy, we should not confuse what is with what should be, because it’s deadly. And that lesson is burned deep into the people of New Orleans’ brains unlike any other part of the country right now, and the rest of us can learn from that.

    Wise words for this Constitutional anniversary.