Tales from the corporate university: Presidential golden handshakes

Last year the Faculty Association of the University of British Columbia signed a three-year agreement that included ZERO, ZERO, and ZERO percent pay “increases.”

In addition, job security for all faculty is under attack as part-time, adjunct, and other types of contingent employment replace tenure stream positions.

University presidents, however, are exempt from these indignities.

Consider the following:

  • UBC gives a one-year leave to administrators for every five years served. UBC President, Martha Piper, recently announced she will retire in 2006, one year short of completing her second five-year term. But, she’ll keep her $700,000.00 salary for a full two years post-UBC.
  • U of Alberta president, Roderick Fraser will receive $740,000.00 while taking a two year leave leading up to retirement.
  • Carleton’s president Richard Van Loon was given a two year leave at $550,000.00 even though he will be past the mandatory retirement age of 65.
  • Janyne Hodder, a vice president at McGill U, is simultaneously collecting paychecks from McGill ($170,000.00) and Bishop’s U ($150,000.00) in a 16 month transition from her position as principal of Bishop’s.

Today, The Province newspaper summed it up in their headline: “Canadian university presidents are rolling into retirement with wheelbarrows full of cash.”

Tiger Beat question of the week: Are British bands the best at being big?

Neil McCormick of The Daily Telegraph certainly thinks so. As Coldplay readies to take over the world and with art-punkers Bloc Party–who owe a lot to Gang of Four, Joy Division, and Sonic Youth–poised to be this year’s Franz Ferdinand, McCormick has lot’s of ammo to back up his claim.

McCormick says “American pop culture may dominate the worldwide media, but when it comes to truly universal rock music, British bands are still in a league of their own, superior to their American counterparts in almost every respect.”

To prove his point McCormick starts with, ahem, Aerosmith. Well who, besides Chuck Klosterman, is going to side with Aerosmith?

(Actually, Klosterman’s <a href+”Fargo Rock City is a great read.)

In this corner, representing American rock: Aerosmith, R.E.M., Velvet Revolver, GnR, Ramones, Talking Heads, Faith No More, The Byrds, and Nine Inch Nails. In the other corner, representing Britain (with I bit of the Emerald Isle thrown in): the Kinks, Sex Pistols, U2, Rolling Stones, The Clash, Joy Division, Echo and the Bunnymen, the Smiths and Blur…Click here for the results or read on.Why British bands are the best at being big
(Filed: 16/04/2005)
The Daily Telegraph

It was announced this week that Coldplay are to take the coveted Saturday night headline spot at this year’s Glastonbury festival on June 25, the scene of their widely acknowledged crowd-swaying triumph in 2000. Earlier the same month, on June 6, Coldplay will release their third album, X&Y. The cover artwork is currently being unveiled in a street poster campaign a segment at a time. A single, Speed of Sound, will be played for the first time by radio stations on Monday.

There is enormous anticipation within the music business about Coldplay’s return to the fray. Their 2002 album, A Rush of Blood to the Head, had worldwide sales of 9.8 million, but their record company, Parlophone, predicts that the new album will beat that. There is a sense that Coldplay are poised on the edge of greatness, with the chance to become the first genuine rock superstars of the 21st century, capable of filling stadiums around the world. And what is more, they are British.

I say this not out of some misguided patriotism, but because their Britishness matters. American pop culture may dominate the worldwide media, but when it comes to truly universal rock music, British bands are still in a league of their own, superior to their American counterparts in almost every respect.

This thought occurred to me during a concert by Velvet Revolver, a high-energy, perpetually riffing outfit whose album, Contraband, last year became the fastest-selling debut ever in the US. And it is not bad, if you like your music fast, loud and shallow. Their lead guitarist, Slash, is already something of a rock legend, formerly of American stadium rockers Guns N’ Roses, a late ’80s glam-punk band of screeching hysteria and frenzied soloing who, in retrospect, look like the last gasp of dinosaur bombast before grunge and Britpop brought rock back down to earth. On stage at the mid-sized Hammersmith Apollo in west London (Velvet Revolver not being nearly as popular on this side of the Atlantic), Slash dedicated a song to “the greatest American rock group of all time”. The band he had in mind were… Aerosmith.

Is that really the best America can do? Aerosmith’s claim to such a title is fairly compelling. They are America’s longest-running rock soap opera, having played together for 35 years, notched up hits across four decades, survived drugs and debauchery on a gargantuan scale and sold tens of millions of records in the process. They have a great frontman in Steve Tyler, a gifted lead guitarist in Joe Perry, they write catchy songs and they have all the licks and all the right moves… but no art, and precious little heart. Aerosmith are essentially a showband, light entertainment with heavy guitars. They are often compared to the Rolling Stones but their debt to Britain’s own longest-running rock opera is all too evident, and all too superficial. Where is their Sympathy for the Devil? Where is their Paint It, Black? Aerosmith’s most well-known global hit is the bubblegum pop-rock of Walk This Way, in a version popularised by rappers Run-DMC.

If we are talking greatness, surely we should be searching for something richer and more vital than that? When we look at the great universal British groups, the ones whose music resonates in every corner of the globe, they have soul, spirit and art in abundance. The Stones, the Who, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, U2 (not strictly British, but an Irish band signed to a British record company with two members born in the UK) and, more recently, Oasis and Radiohead. These are bands whose success was built on musical principles of passion and substance. What is the best America can offer? Fast guitar licks, big light shows, tight trousers and blow-dried hair.

The history of rock can be viewed as a kind of cultural interplay between the US and the UK, with fantastic bands from both sides of the pond influencing and interacting with one another, often with an impact far outreaching their sales. But I don’t wish to debate the relative merits of groups such as the Byrds, the Doors, the Velvet Underground, the Ramones, Talking Heads, Faith No More and Nine Inch Nails (from the US) and the Kinks, the Sex Pistols, the Clash, Joy Division, Echo and the Bunnymen, the Smiths and Blur (from the UK). I love and admire them all. But I want to address something more wide-reaching than what most groups – no matter how distinctive and inspirational – have to offer. I am talking about universality, striking a chord that reverberates around the planet, singing the songs that make the whole world sing along, selling in multi-millions over an extended period of time. I am talking, essentially, about stadium rock.

There are some who consider the term stadium rock abusive – shameless populism with all the artistic compromises that implies. Rock is undoubtedly at its best when it has an edge – but on those occasions when bands reach the point of mass appeal while retaining musical integrity, I think we witness something truly extraordinary unfold, music that speaks to something deep within its audience, invoking a spirit of communal experience almost primeval in its power. Sometimes bigger really is better, because the intensity of the experience, rather than being diluted, is magnified.

“If you invite 60,000 people to a stadium, you had better do something that people can not only hear but can also see, and that kind of scale of ambition to produce big music in a big live context is not easy,” says U2’s manager, Paul McGuinness. With the new and creatively revamped Wembley Stadium due to open next year, giving Britain its own state-of-the-art stadium venue, there is some thought being given to the question of which acts have the pulling power to perform there. “You have to have the music, you have to have the demand, and you have to be innovative and creative about the physical circumstances of your performance,” says McGuinness. “Right now, probably only Paul McCartney, the Rolling Stones and U2 can do it. It’s a very short list.”

“There have probably been not more than 20 real big stadium acts in rock history, which is not a lot,” says Harvey Goldsmith, the legendary British concert promoter. “All the artists that break through to that level have a magic about them that is hard to describe. There are two things they need: anthemic songs and incredible stage presence. The edge of the stage is a huge barrier. In any venue, no matter what size, you’ve got to be able to hit the guys at the back. If you don’t get to them, it’s not working. To do that in a space that holds 50,000 to 70,000 people takes something really special.”

Goldsmith cites the Stones, Pink Floyd, the Who and Queen as the greatest stadium bands ever. “Queen had all the anthems, they had production values, and Freddie Mercury had soul, too, which is something that’s often overlooked. It’s a two-way process, playing live, the audience reacting to the band and the band on stage reacting to the audience, and somehow he always managed to keep that interplay going.”

We are not talking about solo artists here, which I regard as a special case. In solo terms, the US may be ahead of the UK. They can boast Elvis, Bob Dylan and Bruce Springsteen as undisputable universal greats. We have Paul, Elton and Rod. I am restricting myself to the case of the rock band, the unique chemistry conjured by a group of individuals playing guitars, bass and drums. And, to my mind, the greatest rock bands of all time are British.

The Beatles were the first stadium band, although their tiny amplifiers (designed for clubs) could not compete with the volume of screams at Shea Stadium in 1965. The Stones, the Who, Pink Floyd and Genesis all took it further, finding a way to use those vast spaces. “The British bands had great production values, they brought a lot of ideas from the art world and theatre into their shows,” says Goldsmith. “In the early days, the big American bands just went out and played. They came up as big draws on the live circuit in America and saw stadiums as an extension of that. They picked up on the production thing later and went to town on it, which is where Kiss come in.”

Kiss: a bunch of men in lurid make-up sticking their tongues out and playing heavy metal power-pop with stupid lyrics. They were the biggest-selling American rock band of the mid-’70s. In the UK, we had Led Zeppelin, a phenomenal blues and folk-based hard rock outfit whose records still resonate today. “When you become part of the mass consciousness, your currency changes – whatever your original intentions were,” says former Zeppelin vocalist Robert Plant. “I think we are now considered some stalwart of British rock, which doesn’t take into account the variety and colours created by that group. Zeppelin were never a middle of the road band, we were really quite fearsome, but we took the imagination of a lot of people with us. We were always striking out for higher ground and it was always based on musical integrity.”

British rock comes out of art schools and universities. It is music of ideas, with originality and vision often admired above musicianship. It is forged in the glare of the merciless British music press. In a small country, with a limited live circuit and almost claustrophobic media, bands have to be very strong to survive, and very brilliant to flourish. US rock, by contrast, is forged on the road. In a huge country with an enormous population, American bands tour relentlessly, learning their skills in front of live audiences. It can result in very high levels of musical ability, but it is also a recipe for creating highly accomplished, road warrior showbands who pander to the lowest common denominator. American bands tend to have a whole set of cover versions at their fingertips. British bands, on the other hand, sometimes appear to be struggling just to play their own set. But this may actually work in their favour. As The Edge, guitarist with U2, explains: “U2 are the worst bar band in the world. The reason we developed the unique style that we have is because that was the only way forward, it was the approach that suited our rather schizophrenic and uneven talents.”

In the ’80s, U2 began their ascent to becoming the greatest, most passionate and innovative stadium rock band of our times. During the same period, America gave us Bon Jovi, jumped-up bar-room rock with big hair. In the ’90s, things took on a slightly different complexion. Britain gave us Oasis and Radiohead but they were easily matched by the best America had to offer. REM had their moment at the top of the pile with albums as soulful and inventive as any in rock’s canon, although, for all their gifts, there is a quirkiness to the band that has not sustained them on the stadium frontline.

And then along came Nirvana, who, for raw passion, addictive hooks and global resonance, can surely lay some claim of their own to the title of greatest American rock band of all time. Yet their career was cut short so dramatically, their place in rock’s canon essentially comes down to one universally loved album, Nevermind, and the almost mythical impact created by Kurt Cobain’s suicide (which puts him in the elite company of Jim Morrison and Jimi Hendrix, all-time greats who never got to fulfil their potential). Instead, the most enduring American stadium band of the ’90s turned out to be funk-rock outfit the Red Hot Chilli Peppers, a band formerly given to performing naked but for strategically-placed socks.

And it is those notorious socks, perhaps, that define the gulf between the great British and American rock bands. Clearly, for the Chilli Peppers, size matters. They are about spectacle and entertainment and not much more besides. The great British bands all have something beneath the surface, something that resonates deeply with their listeners. These are bands whose greatness would not be in doubt, no matter how many people tuned in. As Plant said of Led Zeppelin, they were striking for higher ground. It is the world of difference between wearing your heart on your sleeve and knitted footwear on your member.

Information appearing on telegraph.co.uk is the copyright of Telegraph Group Limited and must not be reproduced in any medium without licence. For the full copyright statement see Copyright

Housing boom, bubble, or bomb?

Like any new Vancouverite, I responded like a deer in highlights when confronted with the housing market in the Lower Mainland. Is the current housing craze the equivalent of 17th century Tulipmania in Holland?…Some respectable Wall Street economists are starting to wonder if the current housing boom is actually a bubble about to burst.

In “Riotous Real Estate” radical urban theorist Mike Davis argues that the values that mattered in the Bush re-election last year were of the property sort, rather than moral sort. Davis believes that,

At the end of the day, American military hegemony is no longer underwritten by an equivalent global economic supremacy. The housing bubble, like the dot-com boom before it, has temporarily masked a mess of economic contradictions. As a result, the second term of George W. Bush may hold some first-class Shakespearian surprises.

Rehabilitating John Brown

brown_john.jpg

John Brown, the 19th century abolitionist, has never gotten a fair shake from history and, as far as school history textbooks go, he’s been given the brush off or treated as a madman (see James Loewen’s book Lies My Teacher Told Me).

Yesterday’s New York Times Book Review has a stellar review (by Barbara Ehrenreich) of David S. Reynold’s John Brown, Abolitionist. Reynolds presents Brown as a reasonable man of his time–embraced by leading intellectuals such as Thoreau and Emerson–rather than as a crazed anti-slavery terrorist. Accordiing to Ehrenreich, Reynolds backs up his claims with plenty of evidence.

The closing paragraph of Ehrenreich’s review raises some serious issues for social studies educators and people interested in working for the transformation of society (two barely overlapping groups in my opinion).

“How do we judge a man of such different times–and temperament–from our own? If the rule is that there must be some proportion between a violent act and its provocation, surely there could be no more monstrous provocation than slavery. In our own time, some may discern equivalent evils in continuing racial oppression, economic exploitation, environmental predation or widespread torture. To them, ”John Brown, Abolitionist,” for all its wealth of detail and scrupulous attempts at balance, has a shockingly simple message: Far better to have future generations complain about your methods than condemn you for doing nothing.”

Nationalism, patriotism, and textbooks

In recent days, China has seen the biggest public protest since the Tiananmen Square demonstrations of 1989. Thousands of people, in over a dozen cities, have participated in anti-Japan protests. China-Japan relations are now at their lowest point since diplomatic relations were established in 1972.

The protests have been fueled by a number recent actions by Japan including: its campaign to become a member of the UN Security Council; a joint statement with the US calling for a peaceful resolution of Tiawan’s future status; and the decision to drill for oil and gas in disputed waters of the East China Sea. But the main targets of Chinese anger are new Japanese history textbooks.There is a rising tide of patriotic nationalism in Japan that coincides with the rise of the political right in national politics. Japan’s schools, which have traditionally been dominated by left-leaning teachers have become the major battleground in the right’s effort promote jingoistic nationalism.

Since 1999, Japan’s flag and anthem (which was written at time when the Japanese believed the emperor was an immortal diety) have become mandatory elements of school life in Tokyo. The Globe and Mail reported yesterday that over 300 teachers in Tokyo have been punished for refusing to sing or play an musical accompaniment to the anthem in the past two years. Pacifist teachers who have resisted new flag and anthem regulations have been harrassed by parents and even received death threats.

The ruling Liberal Democratic Party is planning to reform Japan’s basic education law this year to require schools teach “love of country” to students. Politicians are working revive the status of the emperor, ditch the country’s “peace constitution” (which prohibits an offensive military); and require students memorize a constitutional preamble that would praise Japan’s history and culture and the Japanese race.

Within this context, it’s not surprising that Japanese history textbooks, which are subject to government approval, have been revised so as to help meet these nationalistic goals. And, what has fuel the recent protests in China is the whitewash of Japanese aggression that appears in the latest junior high school history textbooks.

Today, The New York Times published excerpts from various editions of Japanese history texts illustrating how Japanese World War II atrocities of sexual slavery (“comfort women”) and forced labor have vanished from school texts in the past six years.

Obviously the USA doesn’t have a monopoly on the “shut up and march” brand of history education.
________
The New York Times
April 17, 2005

In Japan’s New Texts, Lessons in Rising Nationalism
By NORIMITSU ONISHI

TOKYO — In a region where history remains unresolved, the fight over the past is often a fight over the future. Seldom does it crystallize as perfectly as it did last week, in the biggest anti-Japan protests in China since the two countries re-established relations in 1972. Oddly, to Westerners at least, the focus of Chinese fury was Japan’s approval of junior high school history textbooks that critics say whitewash Japanese aggression in Asia.

This wasn’t the only textbook tempest, and it may not be the last. Not only are Chinese authorities bracing for further protests, but just before this week’s marches, Japan objected that China’s patriotic education breeds anti-Japanese sentiments, and South Korea castigated the Japanese textbooks for allegedly trying to justify a colonialist past.

Although it may yet be decades before the three countries agree on history, they have long shared a common trait that helps explain how revisions can stir such deep emotions. Their students learn history through government-approved textbooks that are, especially with nationalism rising in all three countries, useful tools in shaping national identities. Since the textbooks require the central government’s imprimatur, they are taken as a reflection of the views of the current leaders.

“In all three countries, there is a tendency to propagandize history,” said Jee Soo Gol, a professor of history education at Kongju National University in South Korea.

The extraordinary fury at Japan stems not just from its 20th-century atrocities, but from what its neighbors describe as its increasing attempts to evade past wrongdoing. And they have a point. A look at the new textbooks and those from two previous cycles, 2002 and 1997, shows an unmistakable backpedaling on some of the most contentious points.

The most glaring example surrounds the issue of “comfort women,” the euphemism for the women, mostly Asian, who were forced into sexual servitude by Japanese authorities during World War II. In 1997, all seven textbooks included passages about them, explaining, for instance, that Japan “took away young Korean and other women as comfort women to battlefields.” In 2002, the number fell to three out of eight; this time, only two out of eight acknowledge the comfort women, and none use that term.

During the war, Tokyo dealt with a severe labor shortage by forcing hundreds of thousands of Asians to work in Japan. In 1997, the textbook published by Tokyo Shoseki and now used by 52 percent of all junior high schools stated that “700,000 people were forcibly taken to Japan between 1939 and 1945” as laborers. The 2002 edition omits any number, and says, “In order to make up for a labor shortage, Japan and Germany forcibly brought in foreign people and made them work in mines and factories.” The newest edition cuts out “forcibly” and says only, “There were Koreans and Chinese who were brought to Japan and made to work against their will.”

Nobukatsu Fujioka, the founder of the nationalist Japanese Society for History Textbook Reform, said that textbooks focusing on Japan’s alleged wartime wrongs were unhealthy for the country’s students.

“I established this association because I thought it was a serious problem that this masochistic education is making the youth lose their pride and confidence in their own country,” said Mr. Fujioka.

“The words ‘war comfort women’ disappeared from textbooks in the last 10 years,” he added. “It is a fruit of our movement that the false fact was expelled from textbooks.”

The changes are also in keeping with a strong rightward shift in Japan.

“There would be a problem if the textbooks state something that the government does not assert, or if they go beyond the bounds of what the government asserts,” Shinzo Abe, one of Japan’s most popular politicians, said recently. “It’s natural that the textbooks follow the government line.”

Given the scrutiny and Japan’s comparatively long record of democracy, the textbooks here are perhaps more balanced than others in the region. China’s textbooks, for instance, teach that Chinese resistance, not the United States, defeated Japan in the war; they say nothing of the postwar Great Leap Forward, in which some 30 million Chinese died because of Mao Zedong’s misguided agrarian policies.

In South Korea, which democratized in the late 1980’s, textbooks have improved, though certain taboos remain, such as any mention of Koreans who collaborated with Japanese colonizers.

Shin Ju Baek, an education expert at Seoul National University, said that descriptions of the colonial period used to focus only on Japanese exploitation and Korean resistance, ignoring the role of Japanese colonialism in Korea’s modernization.

“There is still an emphasis on exploitation,” Mr. Sin said. “But textbooks now include other issues, such as the consumer culture that developed during Japanese occupation. Our textbooks are getting better. But Japan is a problem – it’s going in the other direction.”

Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company

Chronicles, volume one

Just finished Chronicles, Volume One, Bob Dylan’s recently released memoir. Wasn’t sure what to expect, but I was pleasantly surprised to find Dylan writing in a fairly straightforward way. Rather than being obscure or coy about major life-events, he offers frank, detailed (but often incomplete) takes on narrow slices of his life.

Chronicles is basically a collection of riffs on the development of his artistic consciousness. The book jumps all over the place, ignoring chronology, but Dylan is a great storyteller and this comes through on nearly every page.

Once upon a time015.jpgDylan recounts a variety of episodes–breaking into the folk scene in Greenwich Village; growing up on the Iron Range of Minnesota; discovering the music of Woody Guthrie while hanging out in the Dinkytown section of Minneapolis; his calculated efforts to reject the “voice of a generation” label with albums like Self-Portrait and New Morning; and a long description of his time in New Orleans working with producer Daniel Lanois on his 1989 “comeback” album Oh Mercy. The vivid descriptions of emotional/artistic trials and triumphs in making Oh Mercy and playing Cafe Wha? and the Gaslight were my favorite bits in of the book.

He mentions hundreds of people, nearly all in a positive light. He related to Rick Nelson and Frank Sanatra Jr. as artists. (I don’t doubt the former, but I think Bob might be pulling our leg about Frank Jr. and a few other observations.)

The inspiration of Woody Guthrie is palpable, but wrestler Gorgeous George inspires the young artist too!

Dave Van Ronk is saintly and John Hammond, Joan Baez, Bono, Ramblin’ Jack Elliot, Ray Gooch (for his sofa and library), Roy Orbison, Tony Curtis, Archibald MacLeish all have roles to play, but you’ll find more about Sun Pie (an elderly black man who runs a little junk store called “King Tut’s Museum” outside Raceland, Louisiana) than you will about The Beatles, The Band, or The Dead.

Dylan has whet our appetite with Chronicles, Volume One and raised expectations for the planned second and third volumes.

Now on to Greil Marcus’ latest…Like a Rolling Stone: Bob Dylan at the Crossroads.

No direction home.jpg

Who owns culture?

Theonlyfreechoice.gif

This past Thursday, the New York Public Library held a “sold-out” forum on the question of “who owns culture?” The stars of the show were Wilco leader Jeff Tweedy and Stanford law professor Lawrence Lessing, the author of Free Culture: How Big Media Uses Technology and the Law to Lock Down Culture and Control Creativity.

The New York Times quoted Lessing as saying “freedom to remix, not just words, but culture” was critical in the development of art. At one point Lessing asked, “What does it say about our democracy when ordinary behavior is deemed criminal?”

Tweedy and his band Wilco famously streamed their album “Yankee Hotel Foxtrot” over the internet, after being dropped from their record label Warner; ironically, they were then resigned by Warner subsidiary Nonesuch after the internet release proved successful.Tweedy expressed no sympathy for artists, like cyber narcs Metallica, who complain (or pursue law suits) against downloaders. “To me, the only people who are complaining are the people who are so rich they never deserve to be paid again,” Tweedy said.

The P2P technology continues to be assaulted in US courts by greed-driven coporations. Wendy Seltzer, an attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, told Wired magazine that lawsuits against those who trade or enable the trading of copyright music files online will continue to have little effect on P2P traffic.

Seltzer also said the MGM v. Grokster case now before the U.S. Supreme Court could very well determine the future shape of copyright law as it relates to the internet.

While P2P networks remain legal in Canada, as the battle against this technology intensifies in the US, effects are sure to be felt north of the border.

The spectacularization of education

In Our Spectacular Society

Are public schools the source of hidden riches and starting points for the transformation of society or are they impoverished zones to which the construction of real education can only be opposed?

Schools are sites of an unresolved ambiguity, the source of both alienation and–at least potentially–dis-alienation. The initial challenge for anyone interested in the creation of education that serves the public interest is to negate what has become the prevailing image of a successful school and what has come to constitute “good” learning and teaching.”Accountability”–strategies that rely heavily on measuring outcomes, especially student achievement, and attaching consequences, either positive or negative, to various levels of performance–is the prime concept driving education reform in North America.

These “reform” efforts are the ironic product of unaccountable corporate/state power that has made self-interested decisions ostensibly on behalf of the public (e.g., “No Child Left Behind”) when, in fact, the public has no meaningful say in what or how decisions are made or in what can count as legitimate knowledge for their children to learn. Coordinated control of goal setting, curricula, testing, teacher education and evaluation, works to restrict not only what and who can claim the status of “real” knowledge, but also who ultimately has access to it.

There can be no freedom apart from activity and within accountability-driven education all activity, other than the pursuit of the test score, is considered irrelevant.

Where accountability-driven educational reform prevails, teaching and learning are presented as an immense accumulation of test scores. Education that was directly experienced has become mere representation–students and teachers quickly learn that what you know or you can do doesn’t matter, only the score counts. Even assuming that the demands of these reforms could be met, this kind of education can never offer a qualitatively rich life, because its foundation is quantity, banality, and standardization.

We are now in an age in which all social relations within schools are mediated by test scores. The entirety of social activity is appropriated by the spectacle for its own ends and in education, like any other aspects of everyday life, there has been a continual downgrading from being, to having, to appearing. Educational reality has been replaced by image. In the topsy-turvy world of schools, what is true has become a moment of falsehood.

Local school communities are left without the authority to bring their collective resources to bear on a matter as important as the education of their children. The people who know children best–families and teachers–must give way to tighter control over how and what they learn to people in corporate board rooms and state capitols.

In today’s “reformed” schools every moment of life, every idea, and every gesture achieves meaning only from without. Direct experience and the determination of what is taught and learned by individuals themselves has been replaced by a passive contemplation of the images of “good” schools, students, and teachers. These images have been chosen by other people and are organized in the interests of only one portion of society–affecting the real social activity of those who contemplate the images.

The real social contradiction is between those who want (or are obliged to maintain) the alienation produced by accountability-driven education and those who would abolish it. What now passes as education reform implies the continual reversing of thing and image; material reality of learning has been reduced to an abstraction.

Education, as a whole, really is a critical knowledge of everyday life. In this form education constitutes the only reality in the face of the unreality produced accountability-driven education (which now seems more real than anything authentically human).

Genuine community and genuine dialogue can exist only when each person has access to a direct experience of reality, when everyone has at his or her disposal the practical and intellectual means needed to solve problems. The question is not to determine what the students are at present but rather what they can become, for only thus is it possible to grasp what in truth they already are.

Testing in the news

Next week at the American Educaitonal Research Association meeting in Montreal, Kathleen Rhoades, a researcher at Boston College’s Center for the Study of Testing, Evaluation, and Educational Policy, will present an analysis of how news about educational testing is “framed” in the media.

Rhoades research–which was funded by the Ford Foundation–explores how reporters framed testing stories in 2001-2002. “Framing” establishes the range of discourse for a news issue–what is emphasized is judged worthy of attention and what is de-emphasized is implicitly set aside as unimportant.Rhoades found one overarching frame, labeled Accountability and three sub-frames: Market Forces, Analysis and Student Stakes.

Rhoades also found that all of these news frames advocated the use of testing as the primary means for reforming schools. Moreover, she found no news frames critical of this perspective. Thus readers were given a one-sided view of testing issues in news.

All four of these frames promote the “official” (e.g., Bush administration, NCLB, corporate) view that tests can and should be used in determining: accountability for test score performance (Accountability frame), school quality (Market frame), general educational quality and equity (Analysis frame), and student eligibility for grade promotion or graduation (Student Stakes frame).

See previous posts to this blog on testing which illustrate why the “official” view is problematic.

Guided by Robert Pollard

earwig.gif

What’s that voice in my head? Something has crawled in my ear, bored a hole in my brain, and now I’m guided by a voice. The voice is Robert Pollard’s and the real-life earwig is Guided by Voices.Admittedly, I was late to the scene. But, with the possible exception of Tommy Guerrero, the legendary Bones Brigade member and low-fi, funky, downbeat instrumentalist, I’ve listened to more GBV in the past two years than any other artist.

It started innocently, with “Teenage FBI” and “14 Cheerleader Cold Front.” Then on to “Surgical Focus,” “Things I Will Keep,” “Bulldog Skin,” “Everywhere with Helicopter,” “Motor Away,” “Hot Freaks,” “Glad Girls,” “Best of Jill Hives,” … “Watch Me Jump Start,” “My Kind of Soldier,” “To Remake the Young Flyer” … you can never get enough.

Tunes that check in at two-and-a-half minutes, vaguely bringing to mind The Cars, Cheap Trick, The Beatles or even Freddie and Dreamers; never sounding dated, even though they were created in Dayton, Ohio. And, always leave you wanting more.

Brilliant, obscure, enigmatic and addictive music. Listener beware. You will not be able to resist once Robert and the boys pull out their valuable hunting knife and bore a hole in your head.