Why schools are easy targets for ridicule

Neither an FBI investigation nor Dave Marsh’s exhaustive account inLouie Louie:The History and Mythology of the World’s Most Famous Rock ‘n Roll Song; Including the Full Details of Its Torture and Persecution at the Hands of the Kingsmen, J. Edgar Hoover’s FBI, and a Cast of Millions; and Introducing for the First Time Anywhere, the Actual Dirty Lyrics can stop the controversy from roiling on. The following was posted on the Rock and Rap Confidential listserv yesterday.

School board bans band from performing ‘Louie Louie’

May 5, 2005, 7:21 AM BENTON HARBOR, Mich. (AP) — A pop culture controversy that has simmered for decades came to a head when a middle school marching band was told not to perform “Louie Louie.” Benton Harbor Superintendent Paula Dawning cited the song’s allegedly raunchy lyrics in ordering the McCord Middle School band not to perform it in Saturday’s Grand Floral Parade, held as part of the Blossomtime Festival. In a letter sent home with McCord students, Dawning said “Louie Louie” was not appropriate for Benton Harbor students to play while representing the district — even though the marching band wasn’t going to sing it. Band members and parents complained to the Board of Education at its Tuesday meeting that it was too late to learn another song, The Herald-Palladium of St. Joseph reported. “It’s very stressful for us to try to come up with new songs for the band,” eighth-grader Laurice Martin told the board. “We’re trying to learn the songs from last year, but some of us weren’t in the band last year.” Dawning said that if a majority of parents supports their children playing the song, she will reconsider her decision. “It was not that I knew at the beginning and said nothing,” Dawning said. “I normally count on the staff to make reliable decisions. I found out because a parent called, concerned about the song being played.” “Louie Louie,” written by Richard Berry in 1956, is one of the most recorded songs in history. The best-known, most notorious version was a hit in 1963 for the Kingsmen; the FBI spent two years investigating the lyrics before declaring they not only were not obscene but also were “unintelligible at any speed.”

The Lyrics and Music of “Louie Louie”

When politics, profit, and education collide

In her new book, In Defense of Our Children: When Politics, Profits and Education Collide, Elaine Garan describes how high-stakes testing and government ditaks on curriculum materals (specifically for teaching reading) are severely damaging public education.

Garan argues that the No Child Left Behind Act is a tool for the coporate takeover of public schools that has also created serious conflicts of interests for certain educational researchers.

Garan lays bare problems with the National Reading Panel (NRP) report, with a critique that complements excellent research on the same topic by Gerald Coles. She also illustrates how the NCLB requirement that any “instructional materials” purchased with program funds must be “based on scientifically based reading research” (NCLB Sect. 1202(b)(7)(iii)) damages reading instruction.

In his review of the book in Teachers College Record, Gary Ranter concludes:

Garan has performed a valuable service by challenging the purported “scientific basis” for the commercial reading programs that the government requires states and localities to adopt to receive funding under NCLB’s Reading First initiative. And she is right to urge parents and teachers to learn more about the new NCLB “reforms,” to organize, and to advocate at the state and local levels against “corporate takeovers” of public education and “deskilling of teachers” (p. 150).

Police brutality, suppression of speech/academic freedom, & racism: Just another day at the University

The April issue of the Canadian Association of University Teachers Bulletin offers up the following tidbits on the university workplace:

Police violence & suppression of free speech
A CAUT committee is investing the allegations of threats to freedom of expression, academic freedom, and inappropriate government practices at York U. Concerns about freedom of expression at York peaked after Toronto police violently ended a peaceful student demonstration, arresting five students. Click here for video of the January 20, 2005 police attack on York U students.

Attack on academic freedom
CAUT has called on McMaster U to reverse a policy that prohibits academic staff from expressing an opinion to the media that is unrelated to their area of “academic or professional expertise.” McMaster officials say that the policy is not meant to restrict academic freedom or freedom of speech. The CAUT report points out the obvious by saying that the effect of the limitation could be precisely that.

Institutional racism
In his commentary “Institutional Racism is Alive & Kicking” Les Back, a sociology professor at the University of London, discusses how white supremacy functions in higher education.

Back makes particular mention of the new book Institutional Racism in Higher Education. Back points out that making universities more democratic and inclusive is not just about developing a more multicultural curriculum or ensuring fair, respectful treatment of minorities. It also involves confronting the “whiteness” of the university and raising issues of ethics and responsibility in intellectual life.

Heavy rotation

Well, GBV is still in heavy rotation (particularly the Hardcore UFOs box), but Pollard et al. is in serious competition with:

How do I hate thee?

The April issue of University Affairs magazine features a story on psychologist Chistopher Burris’ research on hate, which in comparison to its counterpart, love, doesn’t get much attention from researchers.

The general consensus is that hate is an emotion, but Burris argues that hate is a motive. Burris says a motive provides focus directed toward the attainment of a particular goal.

Burris offers up analysis of road rage, movie scenes (e.g., Kathy Bates’ character in the movie adaptation of Stephen King’s Misery), etc. to illustrate various subtypes of hate.

The hate motive does not have to be premeditated nor do emotional experiences inevitably lead to hate. Burris says:

“To the extent that we devalue the other, see them as somehow beneath us or totally unlike us, I believe that becomes the cognitive next step towards the process of hate. And honestly, I feel like once it comes to the point of devaluing the other, hate may be an inevitable consequence.”

All of this got me thinking, not about “big” hate, but about the everyday hate one encounters, particularly in academe. Seems to me two goals that are commonly encountered in the groves of academe are “elevating the self,” and “restoring order.” Denigration and redress, then, are the subtypes of hate all too often exhibited in the “normal” course of university work.

Below is a table from the UA article summarizing Burris’ categories of hate.

Let me count the ways: six subtypes of hate

Subtype Emotional antecedent Goal
Sadism Anticipation, excitement Pleasure
Mutiny Resentment, exasperation Assertion of autonomy
Tethering Loss, fear of abandonment “Securing” the relationship
Denigration Envy, contempt Elevating the self
Redress Anger, disgust Restoring order
Nihilism Loathing, seething rage Destruction of the other

Source: adapted from “Let me count the ways: An integrative theory of love and hate,” by J. K. Rempel, & C. T. Burris, Personal Relationships (in press).

May Day. Workers of the world awaken!

59V0460r.jpg

Workers of the world, awaken!
Rise in all your splendid might
Take the wealth that you are making,
It belongs to you by right.
No one will for bread be crying
We’ll have freedom, love and health,
When the grand red flag is flying
In the Workers’ Commonwealth
(Joe Hill)

On May 1, 1886, hundreds of thousands of North American workers mobilized to strike. In Chicago, on May 3, police shot two workers during a battle between picketers and scabs at the McCormick Harvester Works. At a protest rally in Haymarket Square the next day someone (possibly a police agent) tossed a bomb into the police ranks. Police then opened fire, indiscriminately killing four workers and wounding a hundred others.

Eight anarachist leaders were arrested, subjected to a sham trial, and sentenced to death (with three later pardoned).

International protests followed the Haymarket Massacre and in 1889 the congress of socialist parties known as the Second International called for an annual one-day strike on May 1 to demonstrate labor solidarity and working-class power.

More information on May Day can be found at:
Haymarket Archives
Lucy Parsons Project
Rouge Forum
Haymarket Monument

Union-busting liberals at Columbia U

Over a thousand teaching assistants, grad students and union members from across the US marched on Columbia University last week, demanding that Columbia, Yale and the National Labor Relations Board grant graduate teachers union recognition.

The weeklong strike by Columbia grad students prompted provost Alan Brinkley, a liberal historian, to issue a memo to deans outlining punative actions to be taken against students fighting for union recognition.

Grad students at public universities have had the right to organize since 1996. In 2000, the NLRB granted grad student employees at private universities the right to unionize. Columbia University has hired one the US’s leading union-busting law firms to fight grad student unions and succeed in having the union election ballots impounded, then last year the NLRB recended the rights of grad students at private universities to unionize.

Jennifer Washburn, author of Univerity, Inc., reports in the current issue The Nation on the latest developments at Columbia.

Power of the mix tape

In the past several months, I’ve had a couple of buddies give me cds they’ve made, several of them “mix tapes.” (I’m really into the mix of The Coup, Common, and Michael Franti, btw). Anyway, I’m a mix tape fanatic, from doing tapes for our wedding reception to a series of mix cds for The Rouge Forum. And, I’ve logged a lot of time in the past year-and-a-half listening to several of the Another Late Night mix albums (particularly the cds editions compiled by Kid Loco and Tommy Guerrero).

So the new book (out next month), The Mix Tape: The Art of Cassette Culture, edited by Sonic Youth‘s Thurston Moore, is right up my alley.

Here’s an excerpt of the book from WiredSonic Youth’s Thurston Moore on the power of the mix tape

The first time I ever heard of someone making a mix tape was in 1978. Robert Christgau, the “dean of rock critics,” was writing in The Village Voice about his favorite Clash record, which just happened to be the one he made himself: a tape of all the band’s non-LP B-sides. One aspect really struck me – Christgau said it was a tape he made to give to friends. He had made his own personalized Clash record and was handing it out as a memento of his rock-and-roll devotion.

In those days, tape decks were as essential as turntables and just as bulky. But then Sony came out with the Walkman. I suppose the record industry expected consumers to buy cassettes of the LPs, and some surely did, but hey – why not just buy blank cassettes and record tracks from LPs instead? Of course, this is what every Walkman user did, and before long there were warning stickers on records and cassettes, stating: home taping is killing music! It was a quaint forebear of today’s industry paranoia over downloading and CD burning.

Around 1980, there was a spontaneous scene of young bands recording singles of superfast hardcore punk – Minor Threat, Negative Approach, Necros, Battalion of Saints, Adolescents, Sin 34, the Meatmen, Urban Waste, Void, Crucifucks, Youth Brigade, the Mob, Gang Green. I was fanatical and bought them all as soon as they came out. I was just a dishwasher at a SoHo restaurant – not exactly raking in the dough – but I needed these sides!

I also needed to hear these records in a more time-fluid way, and it hit me that I could make a mix tape of all the best songs. So I made what I thought was the most killer hardcore tape ever. I wrote H on one side, and C on the other. That night, after my love Kim had fallen asleep, I put the tape in our stereo cassette player, dragged one of the little speakers over to the bed, and listened to it at ultralow thrash volume. I was in a state of humming bliss. This music had every cell and fiber in my body on heavy sizzle mode. It was sweet.

On a Sonic Youth tour in the mid-’80s, we decided to get a cassette player for the van. One idea was to install a dashboard unit, but that was pricey. There was a street trend in NYC of hip hop heads blasting rap mix tapes through massive boom boxes, or “ghetto blasters.” So I went into this Delancey Street store and, using the band’s limited funds, bought the biggest boom box on display: a Conion that took 16 D batteries. The Conion – we nicknamed it “the Conan” – was almost like an extra body, about the size of a small kid. My solution was to stand it on end between the two front seats, facing the back. As we drove through the Holland Tunnel and began to distance ourselves from the city, I jammed in the first of the rap compilations I’d made, and the boom box sounded superb.

We had it onstage with us when we played, and I miked it through the PA for between-song tape action. Kids gave us cassettes all across the US – some of them hopeful demos and some mix tapes, and we’d jam them all. By tour’s end, there must have been hundreds of tapes strewn about the van, with their plastic cases stomped and cracked.

These days, CD technology has displaced the cassette in the mainstream, and mix CDs have become the new cultural love letter/trading post. For those of us who think that digital delivers a harsher sound than analog, it’s a sonic nightmare dealing with the new world reality of MP3s. They’re even more compressed and harsh than CDs, and in the case of vintage grooves – be it Led Zeppelin, Bad Brains, or Pavement – sound even more detached from musical vibration.

But even if MP3 music sounds lame, as long as it’s recognizable in form, free, and shareable, it’s here to stay. It will get better as more sophisticated methods of replication emerge. For now, its clunk is glamorized by celebrity iTunes playlists. ITunes has become the Hallmark card of mix tapes – all you gotta do is sign your name to personalize it.

Once again, we’re being told that home taping (in the form of ripping and burning) is killing music. But it’s not: It simply exists as a nod to the true love and ego involved in sharing music with friends and lovers. Trying to control music sharing – by shutting down P2P sites or MP3 blogs or BitTorrent or whatever other technology comes along – is like trying to control an affair of the heart. Nothing will stop it.

Adapted from Mix Tape: The Art of Cassette Culture, edited by Thurston Moore, to be published by Universe in May.

School boards to teachers: “Shut up (about class size)”

School boards in British Columbia want teachers to shut up when it comes to talking with parents about class size. The BC Public School Employer’s Association, which is the bargaining agent for the 60 public school boards in the province, told the BC Court of Appeal this week that it is not unfair to limit teachers’ free speech rights.

The school boards are appealing an arbitrator’s decision that teachers have a constitutional right to express their views about education. Teachers’ free speech rights came to the fore in 2002 after the BC Liberal government stripped class size provisions from BC Teacher Federation contracts and teachers responded by telling parents about the impact of the elimination of class size restrictions.

Last week the BCTF reported that over 43,000 students in the province are in “over-sized” classes. In March, the BC Court of Appeal ruled that teachers have the right to grieve the legislated class size limits and averages imposed by the Liberal government of the province.

Class size is one of a handful of issues examined by educational researchers about which there is little debate. There is overwhelming evidence that smaller class size has positive effects on student achievement, especially for children living in poverty.

The Tennessee STAR (Student/Teacher Achievement Ratio) study was one of the few large-scale, randomized experiments in educational research history. The STAR study found that reduction of class size to 13-17 students produces significant and lasting improvements in reading and math achievement, with greater benefits for students who started in small classes early in their school careers.

Research shows the effects of class size reduction are maximized when several conditions are met:

  • Start in kindergarten or first grade; early intervention is crucial
  • The ideal class size is 13-17
  • If resources are scarce, target at-risk students first
  • To maintain intensity, students should experience small classes all day, everyday
  • Small classes should last at least two years, and three to four years for the longest-lasting benefits.

The Wisconsin SAGE study showed that class size reductions produced sustained increases student achievement as well as:

  • Greater benefits for African American students
  • A Narrowing of the achievement gap between African American and white students
  • Compensating for poor attendance.

==========================
Not unfair limit on free speech, board argues

Teachers have no right to criticize class sizes during parent interviews, lawyer tells court

Janet Steffenhagen

Vancouver Sun
Thursday, April 21, 2005

Teachers have no more right to criticize class-size increases during parent-teacher interviews than Air Canada pilots do to complain to passengers that government isn’t giving their airline enough money, the B.C. Court of Appeal was told Wednesday.

Both are examples of employees with unusual access to captive audiences by virtue of their employment, and employer limits on what they say under those circumstances is not an unfair restriction on freedom of speech, lawyer Keith Murray argued on behalf of the B.C. Public School Employers’ Association.

“The intent of parent-teacher interviews is to focus on the child’s progress in the system,” Murray said. “It’s not to be turned into a political platform.”

But the lawyer for the B.C. Teachers’ Federation rejected the suggestion that parents attending such interviews are “captive audiences” and noted there are no rules about what may be discussed.

“It’s not automatic that you only talk about the student,” John Rogers told a three-judge panel hearing an appeal of an arbitrator’s ruling in 2004 that said teachers have a constitutional right to express their views about education.

The matter arose in 2002 after the Liberal government reduced the BCTF contract by eliminating provisions restricting class size and composition. The union subsequently sent a communique urging members to tell parents about the impact of those changes.

Specifically, teachers were asked to raise their concerns during parent-teacher interviews and give parents “report cards” showing the average class size in their school, advising that the increase was hurting students, and casting blame at the Liberal government.

“Teachers have the legal right to provide factual information to parents,” the union said in material distributed province-wide. “It has always been part of our professional responsibility to communicate with parents and inform them of what is necessary for their child’s success.”

The union also asked members to post similar material — with titles such as Our Children’s Education is Threatened and What’s at Stake for B.C. Students — on teacher bulletin boards, including those that could be viewed by students and parents.

Several school boards ordered teachers to stop disseminating the information and the union filed a grievance, which resulted in the ruling by arbitrator Don Munroe last year.

jsteffenhagen@png.canwest.com